Key takeaways
- Find a filter for your Coleman furnace with seven pleated options in 16x25x1 and 20x25x1, rated MERV 8 to MERV 13, with sizes, media, and fit checks explained.
Finding the best furnace filters for coleman furnace systems starts with the size printed on your old filter, because a close fit matters more than a higher rating alone. This guide compares seven pleated filters in 16x25x1 and 20x25x1, with MERV ratings from 8 to 13, and explains how each one fits, what the maker lists, and where it falls short.
Quick verdict
For most Coleman furnace homes with a 16x25x1 slot, the Filtrete 16x25x1 MERV 11 MPR 1000 air filter gives a balanced mix of finer capture and a three month change cycle. For a larger 20x25x1 slot, the Filtrete 20x25x1 MERV 11 MPR 1000 air filter follows the same pattern in the larger size.
If airflow is the main concern, or if the furnace manual calls for a lower rating, the Filterbuy 16x25x1 MERV 8 Dust and Allergy Defense air filter and the Filterbuy 20x25x1 MERV 8 Dust Defense air filter use MERV 8 media, which the maker lists as trapping 90 percent of dust particles. For finer capture in a 16x25x1 slot, the Nordic Pure 16x25x1 MERV 12 pleated air filter and the Filtrete 16x25x1 MERV 13 MPR 1900 air filter sit at the higher end of this guide, and both need a careful check of the furnace manual before use, because higher ratings can add resistance as a filter loads.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Filtrete 16x25x1 MERV 11 MPR 1000 air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Balanced 16x25x1 use | MERV 11, MPR 1000, 3 month life | Actual size not stated on the opened page |
| Filterbuy 16x25x1 MERV 8 Dust and Allergy Defense air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Airflow first 16x25x1 use | MERV 8, 90 percent dust capture, 14 pleats per foot | Lower capture than MERV 11 and MERV 12 picks |
| Nordic Pure 16x25x1 MERV 12 pleated air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Finer capture in 16x25x1 | MERV 12, particles as small as 0.3 microns | Higher rating needs a manual check |
| Filtrete 20x25x1 MERV 11 MPR 1000 air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Balanced 20x25x1 use | MERV 11, MPR 1000, 3 month life | Fits only a 20x25x1 slot |
| Filterbuy 20x25x1 MERV 8 Dust Defense air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Airflow first 20x25x1 use | MERV 8, 90 percent dust capture | Lower capture than MERV 11 picks |
| Filtrete 16x25x1 MERV 13 MPR 1900 air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Finest capture in 16x25x1 | MERV 13, MPR 1900, 3 month life | Highest rating here, needs a manual check |
| Filterbuy 16x25x1 MERV 11 Pet and Allergy Defense air filter | Pleated electrostatic | Pet homes with 16x25x1 | MERV 11, 95 percent dust capture, 14 pleats per foot | Same size limits as other 16x25x1 picks |
How we selected
Selection started with size, because Coleman furnace models use different filter slots, and a filter that does not match leaves gaps or will not slide in. The picks cover 16x25x1 and 20x25x1, the two nominal sizes used below, and each product was read from a maker or listing page that was opened.
From those pages, the guide compared MERV rating, MPR rating where the maker lists one, pleated electrostatic media, frame material, actual size where stated, pack count, and the change interval the maker lists. A higher MERV rating was not treated as better on its own, because a rating that is too high for a given furnace can add resistance, so the set spans MERV 8 to MERV 13 and pairs each rating with its size, media, and limits.
Furnace filters for Coleman furnaces
The seven filters below are all pleated furnace filters in 16x25x1 or 20x25x1, and each one is described from the page that was opened for it. Compare the size, rating, and change interval for each pick, and keep the size printed on your current filter close by while you read.
Filtrete 16x25x1 MERV 11 MPR 1000 air filter
This Filtrete filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 16x25x1 slot that wants a step up from basic dust capture without moving to the highest rating in this guide. The maker lists MERV 11 and MPR 1000, with pleated electrostatic media and a cardboard frame, and describes the filter for furnace, air conditioner, and HVAC use.
The maker lists a 3 month pleated filter life and advises changing the filter at least every 90 days for best performance, and the listing is for a 1 pack with manufacturer number 9801-4. The maker describes the media as pulling in and trapping microparticles such as pet dander, smoke, and smog, and also lists large particles such as lint, pollen, and household dust.
- Pros: MERV 11 and MPR 1000 in a common 16x25x1 size, with a clear 90 day change interval from the maker.
- Pros: Pleated electrostatic media, with a cardboard frame and a 3 month life stated by the maker.
- Cons: Actual size is not stated on the opened page, so fit needs a direct check against the old filter.
- Cons: A 1 pack covers one change only, so a home that changes filters often needs more than one pack.
Buy if your slot is 16x25x1, your manual allows MERV 11, and you want a mid range pleated filter with a stated 90 day cycle. Skip if your slot is a different size, if your manual calls for a lower rating, or if you want a multi pack in a single order.
Filterbuy 16x25x1 MERV 8 Dust and Allergy Defense air filter
This Filterbuy filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 16x25x1 slot that puts steady airflow first and wants a straightforward MERV 8 pleated filter. The maker lists an actual size of 15.50 by 24.50 by 0.75 inches, MERV 8 synthetic media, and a 12 pack with model AFB16x25x1M8pk12.
The maker lists the media as trapping 90 percent of dust particles, with electrostatically charged media at 14 pleats per foot, and describes the media as lasting 3 times longer than fiberglass models, with replacement every 90 days for best results. The frame is industrial grade beverage board with dual wire backing, and the maker lists an ability to endure temperatures up to 200 degrees Fahrenheit and to withstand exposure to moisture.
- Pros: Clear actual size, MERV 8 media, and a 12 pack that covers several changes.
- Pros: Beverage board frame with dual wire backing, rated by the maker to 200 degrees Fahrenheit.
- Cons: MERV 8 captures less fine material than the MERV 11 and MERV 12 picks in this guide.
- Cons: The actual size is smaller than the nominal size, so a loose slot can leave a small gap.
Buy if your slot is 16x25x1, you want MERV 8, and you want a larger pack with a stated 90 day cycle. Skip if you want finer capture, or if your manual calls for a higher rating for dust and pet dander in your home.
Nordic Pure 16x25x1 MERV 12 pleated air filter
This Nordic Pure filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 16x25x1 slot that wants finer capture than MERV 8 or MERV 11, and the maker lists MERV 12 with an actual size of 15.5 by 24.5 by 0.75 inches. The listing is a 6 pack with part number 16x25x1M12-6, and the maker lists the media as electrostatically charged synthetic pleated media.
The maker lists MERV 12 as comparable to MPR 1500-1900, and states that a MERV 12 Nordic Pure air filter captures airborne particles as small as 0.3 microns. The frame is a heavy duty, moisture resistant beverage board frame, and the maker recommends changing the filter every 1 to 3 months, depending on the home environment, with more frequent changes for homes with pets or allergy concerns.
- Pros: MERV 12 rating with a stated 0.3 micron capture point and a 6 pack.
- Pros: Heavy duty moisture resistant beverage board frame and electrostatic pleated media.
- Cons: The higher rating can add resistance, so the furnace manual needs a check first.
- Cons: The 1 to 3 month change range means the cycle is less fixed than a single 90 day point.
Buy if your slot is 16x25x1, your manual allows MERV 12, and you want finer capture in a 6 pack. Skip if your furnace is older, if your manual limits the rating, or if you want the lowest resistance option in this guide.
Filtrete 20x25x1 MERV 11 MPR 1000 air filter
This Filtrete filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 20x25x1 slot that wants the same MERV 11 and MPR 1000 pattern as the 16x25x1 Filtrete pick, in the larger face size. The maker lists MERV 11 and MPR 1000, with pleated electrostatic media and a cardboard frame, for furnace, air conditioner, and HVAC use.
The maker lists an actual size of 19-2/3 by 24-2/3 by 5/6 inch, a 3 month pleated filter life, and a change at least every 90 days for best performance, and the listing is for a 1 pack with manufacturer number 9803-4. The maker describes the media as pulling in and trapping microparticles such as pet dander, smoke, and smog, and also lists large particles such as lint, pollen, and household dust.
- Pros: MERV 11 and MPR 1000 in a 20x25x1 size, with a clear actual size and a 90 day cycle.
- Pros: Pleated electrostatic media with a cardboard frame, from the same line as the 16x25x1 pick.
- Cons: A 1 pack covers one change only, and the filter fits no other nominal size.
- Cons: The actual size is smaller than the nominal size, so a worn slot can leave a small gap.
Buy if your slot is 20x25x1, your manual allows MERV 11, and you want a mid range pleated filter in the larger size. Skip if your slot is 16x25x1, or if you want a multi pack in a single order.
Filterbuy 20x25x1 MERV 8 Dust Defense air filter
This Filterbuy filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 20x25x1 slot that wants MERV 8 media and a simple two filter pack. The maker lists an actual size of 19.50 by 24.50 by 0.75 inches, MERV 8 synthetic media, and a 2 pack in a pleated electrostatic form.
The maker lists the media as trapping 90 percent of dust particles, and describes the filter for furnace, air conditioner, heat pump, and HVAC use. The maker does not state a pleat count or a change interval on the page that was opened for this size, so those points are not listed here for this product.
- Pros: Clear actual size in 20x25x1, MERV 8 media, and a 2 pack for two changes.
- Pros: Pleated electrostatic media with a stated 90 percent dust capture point from the maker.
- Cons: MERV 8 captures less fine material than the MERV 11 picks in this guide.
- Cons: Pleat count and change interval are not stated on the opened page for this size.
Buy if your slot is 20x25x1, you want MERV 8, and a 2 pack fits your change routine. Skip if you want finer capture, or if you want a larger pack or a stated change interval on the same page.
Filtrete 16x25x1 MERV 13 MPR 1900 air filter
This Filtrete filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 16x25x1 slot that wants the finest capture in this guide, with MERV 13 and MPR 1900 listed by the maker. The listing is a 4 pack with model UA01-4CA, and the maker lists a 3 month pleated 1 inch filter with a change at least every 90 days.
The maker describes the filter with 3-in-1 technology, including MPR 1900 and MERV 13, and lists microparticles such as pet dander, smoke, bacteria, and viruses, along with large particles such as mold spores, pollen, lint, and household dust. The maker also describes this filter as having the highest airflow among MERV 13 filters, based on California Energy Commission claimed data as of 1/29/2025, as stated on the opened page.
- Pros: MERV 13 and MPR 1900 in 16x25x1, with a 4 pack and a 90 day cycle.
- Pros: Maker described airflow claim for a MERV 13 filter, with 3-in-1 technology listed.
- Cons: The highest rating here, so the furnace manual needs a check before use.
- Cons: Limited availability was listed on the opened page, so stock needs a fresh check.
Buy if your slot is 16x25x1, your manual allows MERV 13, and you want the finest capture in this guide. Skip if your manual limits the rating, if your furnace is older, or if you want the lowest resistance option.
Filterbuy 16x25x1 MERV 11 Pet and Allergy Defense air filter
This Filterbuy filter suits a Coleman furnace home with a 16x25x1 slot and pets, where the maker lists MERV 11 media for pet and allergy defense. The maker lists an actual size of 15.50 by 24.50 by 0.75 inches, MERV 11 synthetic media, and a 2 pack with model AFB16x25x1M11pk2.
The maker lists the media as trapping 95 percent of dust particles, with electrostatically charged media at 14 pleats per foot, and describes the media as lasting 3 times longer than fiberglass models, with replacement every 90 days for best results. The frame is industrial grade beverage board with dual wire backing, and the maker lists an ability to endure temperatures up to 200 degrees Fahrenheit and to withstand exposure to moisture.
- Pros: MERV 11 media with 95 percent dust capture, 14 pleats per foot, and a 2 pack.
- Pros: Beverage board frame with dual wire backing, rated by the maker to 200 degrees Fahrenheit.
- Cons: A 2 pack covers two changes only, so frequent changers need more packs.
- Cons: The actual size is smaller than the nominal size, so fit needs a direct check.
Buy if your slot is 16x25x1, you have pets, and you want MERV 11 with a stated 90 day cycle. Skip if your slot is a different size, or if you want MERV 8 for lower resistance or MERV 13 for finer capture.
Buying guide
Use this guide to match a filter to your Coleman furnace in order, starting with size, then rating, then media and frame, then change timing. Work through the checks in order, and use the size and rating from your furnace manual as the firm limits for the choice.
Match the size to your Coleman furnace in the best furnace filters for coleman furnace
Start with the size printed on the edge of your current filter, and compare it with the size listed in your furnace manual before you order a replacement. The picks in this guide use 16x25x1 and 20x25x1, and those two nominal sizes are not interchangeable.
Nominal size is the rounded size on the box, while actual size is the measured size of the filter, and the makers in this guide list actual sizes that are smaller than the nominal size by a small amount. Measure the slot with a tape measure if the old filter is missing or if the print on its edge is worn, and write down length, width, and depth in inches.
Choose a MERV rating for a Coleman furnace
MERV rating describes how fine the particles are that a filter media is rated to capture, with a higher number pointing to finer capture. The picks span MERV 8 to MERV 13, with MERV 8 for basic dust capture, MERV 11 for a mid range step up, and MERV 12 and MERV 13 for finer capture where the manual allows it.
Check your furnace manual for a rating limit before you move up, because a higher rating can add resistance as the filter loads, and an older blower can show that change sooner than a newer one. If the manual does not state a limit, start with MERV 8 or MERV 11, watch how the filter looks at the next change, and ask a qualified technician if airflow seems weak or if the furnace cycles in an odd way.
Pleated media, frame, and airflow
All seven picks use pleated electrostatic media, which folds the media to give more surface area in the same face size than a flat panel. The makers list electrostatic charge as a way to draw small particles to the media, and pleated media holds more dust than a flat panel before it needs a change.
Frame material matters because a weak frame can bend in a warm slot, and the makers in this guide list beverage board frames, with Filterbuy adding dual wire backing and a temperature point of 200 degrees Fahrenheit.
Change timing and seasonal checks
Change timing is the part of filter care that most homes can control. Filtrete and Filterbuy list a change at least every 90 days for the picks that state a cycle, and Nordic Pure recommends a change every 1 to 3 months, depending on the home environment, with more frequent changes for homes with pets.
Set a reminder for the next change when you install a new filter, and look at the filter at that time rather than leaving it in place through a full heating season.
Common fit mistakes to avoid
The most common mistake is ordering by nominal size alone and skipping the actual size, because the actual size is smaller than the nominal size for the filters in this guide. A second mistake is using a filter from a different slot size, which will not fit or will leave gaps.
A third mistake is installing the filter backward, so check the airflow arrow on the frame and point it toward the blower before you slide the filter in. A fourth mistake is leaving a filter in place for too long, which lets dust build up and adds resistance, so follow the 90 day cycle or the 1 to 3 month range the maker lists.
FAQ
These answers cover the size, rating, change timing, and fit questions that come up most often for Coleman furnace homes. Each answer draws on the sizes and ratings in this guide, and the manual for your own furnace model stays the final point of reference.
What size filter does a furnace use?
There is no single size for every Coleman furnace, because models use different slots, so the size printed on your current filter and the size listed in your furnace manual are the two points to trust. The picks in this guide cover 16x25x1 and 20x25x1, and those sizes match the products that were opened for this guide, not every Coleman model.
Measure the slot if the old filter is missing, and compare the nominal size with the actual size the maker lists, because the actual size is smaller than the nominal size. For the Filterbuy picks, the actual size is 15.50 by 24.50 by 0.75 inches for 16x25x1 and 19.50 by 24.50 by 0.75 inches for 20x25x1, while the Filtrete 20x25x1 MERV 11 pick lists an actual size of 19-2/3 by 24-2/3 by 5/6 inch.
Is MERV 11 too high for a Coleman furnace?
MERV 11 is a mid range rating in this guide, and it is not too high on its own, but the right answer depends on your furnace manual and on how the filter loads in your home. The Filtrete and Filterbuy MERV 11 picks in this guide list a 90 day change cycle, and the makers list MERV 11 media for homes with pets and dust concerns.
Check the manual for a rating limit, and if no limit is stated, start with MERV 11 only if airflow stays steady and the filter is changed on time.
How often should I change a furnace filter?
Filtrete and Filterbuy list a change at least every 90 days for the picks in this guide that state a cycle, and Nordic Pure recommends a change every 1 to 3 months, depending on the home environment. Those points give a clear starting cycle for most homes, and the exact timing can shift with pets, dust, and how long the furnace runs.
Set a reminder when you install a new filter, and check the filter at the next change date. If the media looks loaded with dust, if the pleats are bent, or if the frame is damp or torn, change the filter at that point, even if the calendar date is still ahead.
Can I use a 20x25x1 filter in place of a 16x25x1 filter?
No, a 20x25x1 filter will not fit a 16x25x1 slot, because the face size is larger in one direction, and a filter that is too large can bend or fail to slide in. A smaller filter in a larger slot is also a poor match, because it leaves gaps where air can pass around the media instead of through it.
Use the exact nominal size for your slot, and confirm the actual size the maker lists for that product.
Do pleated filters restrict airflow more than fiberglass filters?
Pleated filters can add more resistance than a flat fiberglass panel, because the media is denser and captures finer particles, but the pleats also give more surface area, which helps the filter hold dust without loading as fast. The Filterbuy makers list their pleated media as lasting 3 times longer than fiberglass models.
The rating matters more than the pleat form alone, so a MERV 8 pleated filter will usually add less resistance than a MERV 13 pleated filter in the same size.
Conclusion
Start with the size on your old filter, match it to a 16x25x1 or 20x25x1 pick in this guide, and choose MERV 8 for airflow first, MERV 11 for a balanced step up, or MERV 12 and MERV 13 only if your manual allows the higher rating. Change the filter on the cycle the maker lists, and keep a note of the size and rating that worked for your home.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!