Key takeaways
- Compare six audio mixers for studios on preamps, channel counts, USB recording, EQ and effects, from a compact analog desk to a 48-channel digital console.
A studio desk has to capture clean tracks, feed headphones, and shape a mix without slowing the session down. This guide compares audio mixers for studios across analog and digital designs, using only specs the makers publish, so each pick is tied to a stated channel count, preamp set, and recording path.
Quick verdict
For pure analog tone with real console processing, the BiG SiX leads this group. The Model 24 is the pick when recording has to happen without a computer, while the SQ-5 and StudioLive 32SC cover studios that also mix live rooms or larger sessions on a regular basis.
The six consoles fall into two camps. The Solid State Logic BiG SiX, TASCAM Model 24, Mackie Onyx16, and Yamaha MG16XU are analog desks with digital recording paths of different depths. The PreSonus StudioLive 32SC and Allen & Heath SQ-5 are digital consoles with motorized faders, full recall, and networking. None of them is the right answer for every room, so the verdict depends on how you record.
- Best analog processing: Solid State Logic BiG SiX, with per-channel EQ and compression plus a G Series bus compressor.
- Best for recording without a computer: TASCAM Model 24, with a 24-track recorder writing to SD card.
- Best compact multitrack USB desk: Mackie Onyx16, with 18×4 USB recording at up to 24-bit/96 kHz.
- Best for studios that also run live sessions: PreSonus StudioLive 32SC and Allen & Heath SQ-5.
- Best simple stereo workflow: Yamaha MG16XU, with one-knob compressors and a 2-in/2-out USB connection.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solid State Logic BiG SiX | Analog with USB interface | Analog tracking and mixdown | 16-channel USB at 96 kHz, G Series bus compressor | Only 4 mic preamps |
| TASCAM Model 24 | Analog with multitrack recorder | Band sessions without a computer | 24-track SD recording, 16 mic preamps | Recording tops out at 48 kHz |
| Mackie Onyx16 | Analog with multitrack USB | Compact project studios | 18×4 USB at 24-bit/96 kHz, 12 preamps | Two aux sends plus FX send |
| PreSonus StudioLive 32SC | Digital console | Studios that also run live sessions | 64×64 USB recording, 34-track SD recorder | 16 local mic preamps |
| Allen & Heath SQ-5 | Digital console | Large ensembles and monitor mixing | 48 channels at 96 kHz, 12 stereo mixes | Expansion needed for 48 mic inputs |
| Yamaha MG16XU | Analog with stereo USB | Simple stereo recording | 24-bit/192 kHz stereo USB, SPX effects | No multitrack recording path |
How we selected
Every console here was chosen from its maker’s published specification: channel and preamp counts, the recording path over USB or card, EQ and dynamics per channel, and the outputs a studio actually patches. Models with unclear current availability were left out.
The shortlist favors desks that can sit at the center of a working studio for years. That means enough mic preamps for a drum kit or a small ensemble, a recording path that captures separate tracks rather than only a stereo mix where the format allows it, and monitor outputs that can feed control room speakers and headphone mixes at the same time. Analog and digital designs are judged on the same points, because a studio buys results, not a technology label.
One model was dropped during research: a well-known 22-input analog multitrack desk whose current listings carried discontinued and out-of-stock signals. It is named in the project notes rather than recommended here, because a studio console has to be buyable, serviceable, and supported when it goes into daily use.
Audio mixers for studios: the six consoles in detail
The six consoles split into analog desks with USB interfaces and digital systems with full recall. Read each entry for who it suits, the specs that matter in a studio, and the limits that should rule it out before the strengths talk you into the wrong desk.
Solid State Logic BiG SiX
The BiG SiX is built for producers who track a handful of sources at a time and mix through real analog circuitry. It suits project studios that value channel processing and bus compression over raw input count, and that already own outboard gear to patch in.
The maker lists four SuperAnalogue mic preamps with +72 dB of gain, individually switched +48V phantom power, a high-pass filter, and a polarity switch, plus four stereo line inputs with dual mono switching, for up to 18 inputs at mixdown. Every channel carries a 3-band E-Series EQ, with shelving bands at 3.5 kHz and 60 Hz, a fixed mid band at 700 Hz, and plus or minus 15 dB of range. The mono channels add a one-knob style channel compressor with a gentle 2:1 ratio, and the mix bus carries the G Series Bus Compressor at a fixed 4:1 ratio with an Auto release setting.
Recording runs over a built-in 16-channel USB interface at 96 kHz and 24-bit, wired into the analog signal chain, so tracks printed to the computer carry the channel EQ and dynamics with them. Two stereo cue feeds and dual headphone outputs with a source matrix handle performer mixes, and 100 mm faders keep mix moves precise. The desk draws 70 watts from an external supply.
- Pros: full analog channel processing, bus compressor on the stereo mix, 16-channel USB at 96 kHz.
- Cons: only four mic preamps, no onboard recorder, external power supply.
Buy it if you track vocals, guitars, and keys a few at a time and want to mix through analog summing with real compression on the bus. Skip it if you record full drum kits or bands live off the floor, because four mic inputs run out fast.
TASCAM Model 24
The Model 24 is a 22-channel analog console with a multitrack recorder and a USB interface in one box. It fits studios and rehearsal rooms that want to capture a full band in one pass, then mix down on the same surface without moving the session to a laptop first.
TASCAM lists 22 inputs, with 16 microphone preamps in total and Ultra-HDDA preamps on channels 1 to 12. The onboard recorder writes up to 24 tracks of WAV audio at 48 kHz and 24-bit to SD, SDHC, or SDXC cards, and can punch in and out on eight tracks at once. As a USB audio interface it sends 24 channels to the computer and returns 22, so the same session can be finished in a DAW. Channels 1 to 12 carry a 3-band EQ with a sweepable mid band and a 100 Hz low-cut filter, and the master section adds a 7-band graphic EQ and 16 preset effects.
The surface is built for hands-on work: 100 mm long-throw faders, three aux outputs for monitors and effects, one-knob compressors on selected channels, and Bluetooth input for rehearsal playback. It measures 576 x 112.5 x 513 mm and weighs 22.49 lb, so it needs a proper desk or stand rather than a shelf.
- Pros: records 24 tracks with no computer, 16 mic preamps, full analog channel strips.
- Cons: USB and recording top out at 48 kHz, large footprint, stereo-only Bluetooth input.
Buy it if your studio records bands, rehearsals, or live sets and you want the capture to happen on the desk itself. Skip it if you need sample rates above 48 kHz or a compact desktop footprint.
Mackie Onyx16
The Onyx16 is a compact analog mixer for studios that record to a computer and want a stereo backup copy on card. It suits singer-songwriters, small ensembles, and podcast rooms that need a dozen mic inputs, a built-in effects engine, and simple multitrack USB.
Mackie lists an 18×4 analog mixer with 12 Onyx mic preamps providing up to 60 dB of gain. USB recording runs at up to 24-bit/96 kHz with 18 inputs and 4 returns, and the desk also records a stereo mix directly to an SD card. Each channel carries a 3-band Perkins EQ with a hard bypass switch, and the comparison chart on the maker page lists 13 line inputs, five of them stereo, plus two aux sends and a separate FX send.
A full-color LCD with the Studio Command interface controls the built-in effects engine and SD card management, and Bluetooth streaming can feed any channel for reference tracks or walk-in music. Switchable hi-Z inputs take guitars and bass directly, and the included Waveform OEM software bundle gives the desk a recording program out of the box.
- Pros: 12 preamps in a compact frame, 96 kHz multitrack USB, SD stereo recording as backup.
- Cons: only two aux sends plus the FX send, no per-channel dynamics, stereo-only card recording.
Buy it if you want an analog front end that multitracks a small band or a multi-mic podcast straight into your DAW. Skip it if you need several separate headphone mixes, because the aux count is the ceiling here.
PreSonus StudioLive 32SC
The StudioLive 32SC is a rack-mountable digital console for studios that also run live sessions, rehearsals, or a small stage. It fits engineers who want motorized faders, scene recall, networked stage boxes, and multitrack recording over USB and SD card together.
PreSonus lists 32 channels with 40 mixing channels and 26 buses, driven by 16 recallable XMAX preamps across eight XLR inputs and eight XLR and quarter-inch combo inputs. Seventeen touch-sensitive motorized faders and a full-color touchscreen run the surface. Every input channel carries delay, a high-pass filter, a gate, a compressor, a limiter, and a parametric 4-band EQ, and a four-slot FLEX FX processor handles reverbs and delays on dedicated effects buses.
Recording is the strong suit: the onboard SD recorder captures 34 tracks, 32 channels plus the stereo mix, while USB streams 128 channels, 64 in each direction, to a Mac or Windows computer, and both can run at the same time. Built-in AVB networking connects stage boxes and personal monitor mixers, and DAW control covers Studio One directly, with MCU emulation for Logic Pro and HUI emulation for Pro Tools.
- Pros: huge recording channel count, redundant USB and SD recording, AVB expansion, DAW control.
- Cons: only 16 local mic preamps for a 32-channel frame, menu-driven workflow, deep feature set to learn.
Buy it if your studio doubles as a live room and you want one console to record everything both ways at once. Skip it if you prefer one knob per function, because most processing lives behind the touchscreen.
Allen & Heath SQ-5
The SQ-5 is a 48-channel digital mixer that runs at 96 kHz and packs a full live console into a rack-mountable frame. It suits studios that record larger ensembles, mix monitors for performers, or need expansion over digital networking as the room grows.
The maker lists a 96 kHz XCVI FPGA engine with 48 input channels, 17 onboard preamps, and 17 motorized faders across six layers. Each input carries a high-pass filter, a gate with sidechain and filter, a 4-band parametric EQ with real-time analysis, and a Peak/RMS compressor. Twelve stereo mixes plus the main LR and three stereo matrix mixes cover monitor duty, and eight stereo FX engines with dedicated returns draw on the RackExtra library.
For recording, the built-in USB interface moves 32×32 channels at 96 kHz, and SQ-Drive records 16 channels at 96 kHz or 32 channels at 48 kHz straight to a USB drive with no computer attached. The SLink port expands the system to 48 mic inputs with remote stage boxes, and a 64×64 I/O port accepts networking cards for Dante, Waves, MADI, or SLink. A 7-inch capacitive touchscreen and eight assignable SoftKeys run the surface.
- Pros: 48 channels at 96 kHz, deep monitor mixing, strong expansion path, direct-to-drive recording.
- Cons: 17 local preamps means stage boxes for big sessions, layered fader workflow, no analog summing character.
Buy it if the studio records choirs, orchestras, or full bands and needs monitor mixes to match. Skip it if your sessions stay under a dozen inputs, because much of its capacity would sit idle.
Yamaha MG16XU
The MG16XU is the straightforward analog option in this group: a 16-channel console with one-knob compression and a stereo USB connection. It suits small studios, schools, and rehearsal spaces that record a stereo mix rather than separate multitracks.
Yamaha lists a maximum of 10 mic and 16 line inputs across eight mono and four stereo channels. The D-PRE mic preamps use an inverted Darlington circuit, and mono channels carry 1-knob compressors, a 26 dB pad switch, an 80 Hz high-pass filter, and a 3-band EQ with a sweepable mid band from 250 Hz to 5 kHz. The SPX effects engine offers 24 programs, and routing covers four group buses, a stereo bus, and four aux sends including the effects send.
The USB connection is 2-in/2-out at 24-bit and up to 192 kHz, so it records the stereo mix at high resolution but cannot separate the channels afterward. Yamaha includes a Cubase AI download, a rack mount kit, and an internal universal power supply. The metal chassis measures 444 x 130 x 500 mm, weighs 15.0 lb, and draws 30 watts.
- Pros: simple and durable, good preamps and effects for the format, high-resolution stereo USB.
- Cons: stereo-only recording, no multitrack path, fewer mic inputs than its channel count suggests.
Buy it if your studio work is demos, rehearsals, lessons, and stereo captures that need to sound clean with little setup. Skip it if you plan to mix tracks individually later, because the USB path locks you into the stereo mix.
Buying guide
Choosing between these consoles comes down to how you record, not how many knobs a desk has on its panel. Work through the five points below in order, and the right type, analog or digital, usually becomes obvious before you compare individual models in this group.
Count mic preamps, not just channels
A channel count includes line inputs, stereo returns, and digital channels that cannot take a microphone on their own. For studio work, the mic preamp count is the number that decides how many microphones you can record at once, so compare that figure first.
A drum kit alone can use eight or more microphones, and a live band session adds vocals, amps, and room mics on top. The Model 24 offers 16 preamps and the Onyx16 offers 12, while the BiG SiX offers four very well-equipped ones. Digital consoles split the difference: the SQ-5 has 17 onboard preamps behind 48 channels, and the StudioLive 32SC has 16 behind 32 channels, with stage boxes adding more over a network cable.
Decide how multitrack recording should happen
Multitrack recording means each source lands on its own track for later mixing. Some desks send tracks to a computer over USB, some record to a card inside the mixer, and some do both at once, which gives you a backup when a session cannot be repeated.
The BiG SiX sends 16 channels over USB, the Onyx16 sends 18, and the SQ-5 sends 32 at 96 kHz. The Model 24 records 24 tracks to SD card and also works as a 24-in/22-out USB interface. The StudioLive 32SC goes furthest, with a 34-track SD recorder and 64 channels each way over USB running together. The MG16XU sits at the other end: its USB path is stereo only, which is fine for demos and lessons but final at mixdown.
What audio mixers for studios need for headphone mixes
Performers play better when they hear themselves clearly, and every separate headphone mix needs its own aux send or mix bus. Count the sends before you buy, because this is the spec that most often limits a growing studio in daily practice and rehearsal work.
Analog desks offer a handful: the Model 24 has three aux outputs, the Onyx16 has two aux sends plus an FX send, and the MG16XU has four aux sends. The BiG SiX takes a different route with two stereo cue feeds and dual headphone outputs. Digital consoles scale much further, since the SQ-5 provides 12 stereo mixes and the StudioLive 32SC provides 16 FlexMixes that can serve as auxes, subgroups, or matrix mixes.
Analog summing or digital recall
Analog desks process sound in circuitry and leave every knob where you set it, which makes them fast for a resident engineer and slow to reset between clients. Digital desks store every setting in scenes, so a session can be recalled exactly, days or months later.
Choose analog if one person runs the room and likes shaping sound with channel EQ, compression, and outboard gear patched in, as the BiG SiX and Model 24 encourage. Choose digital if several engineers share the room, if you mix live events between sessions, or if repeatability matters more than the analog path, as with the SQ-5 and StudioLive 32SC.
Plan outputs for monitors and outboard gear
A studio desk feeds more than the main speakers. Control room monitors, a second pair of reference speakers, headphone amps, external recorders, and outboard processors all need outputs, and balanced connections keep long cable runs quiet in a working room.
Check the main, monitor, group, and direct outputs against your patch list. The MG16XU provides group outputs and monitor outputs on top of its stereo outs, the Model 24 adds sub outputs on XLR and RCA, and the digital consoles offer assignable XLR outputs that can be patched per session. If you own hardware compressors or reverbs, insert points or spare send and return pairs matter as much as the headline channel count.
FAQ
Short answers to the questions studio buyers ask most often, drawn from the published specs of the six consoles covered above and from general studio practice that applies to any desk of this size, format, and class of equipment in daily use by working engineers.
Can one mixer handle both tracking and mixing?
Yes, and that is the normal studio pattern. You track through the preamps and recording path, then mix either on the same surface, in the DAW, or by routing DAW tracks back through the desk, as the Model 24 and BiG SiX are designed to do in one surface.
The real question is how the desk behaves in each role. Analog consoles mix with the same channel strips you tracked through, while digital consoles add scene recall so the mix setup from last week returns exactly. Both approaches work; the choice follows how your studio schedules its sessions.
Are audio mixers for studios a good fit for podcasting?
They can be, especially for multi-host shows recorded in a treated room. A desk like the Onyx16 gives you a mic input per host, hardware EQ and effects, and a multitrack USB feed, so each voice lands on its own track for editing afterward and later mixing.
For a single host, a mixer is more hardware than the job needs, and a small interface is easier to run. The mixer earns its place when several microphones, a phone or video-call guest feed, and music playback all have to be balanced live by one operator.
Do analog mixers record to a computer?
Many current analog mixers include a USB audio interface, but the channel count varies widely. The BiG SiX moves 16 channels each way, the Onyx16 moves 18 in and 4 back, and the MG16XU moves only the stereo mix, all from their published specs in each case.
Before buying, confirm whether the USB feed is taken before or after the channel EQ and fader if that matters to your workflow, and check the highest sample rate the interface supports. A desk that records only the stereo bus is not a defect, but it does decide your mixing method on day one.
How many aux sends does a studio mixer need?
At minimum, one send per separate headphone mix plus one for a shared effects feed. A solo artist working alone needs one or two; a band tracking together usually needs three or four so the drummer, singer, and rhythm section hear different balances.
If your sessions involve several performers wearing headphones at once, treat aux and mix count as a first-order spec, equal to preamps. It is the main reason growing studios move from compact analog desks to digital consoles like the SQ-5, which offers 12 stereo mixes from one surface.
Is a digital mixer better for a small studio?
Not automatically. A digital mixer gives you recall, more processing per channel, and far more monitor mixes, which helps when several people share the room. An analog mixer gives you direct controls and a simpler signal path, which helps when one person does everything.
For a small studio, the deciding factors are session turnover and headphone mixes. If every day starts from a blank setup, analog speed wins. If you return to the same projects across weeks, digital recall wins. Both types record equally well when the interface spec matches your track count.
Conclusion
Pick the console that matches your recording path first and your channel count second. The BiG SiX and Model 24 reward hands-on analog work, the Onyx16 and MG16XU keep small rooms simple, and the SQ-5 and StudioLive 32SC add recall and scale when sessions grow beyond a few sources at a time in the room.