Key takeaways
- Compare six recording mixers for studio tracking and mixing, from analog desks with multitrack USB to a digital console with motorized faders and full recall.
A studio desk has to capture clean multitrack audio, feed cue mixes without fuss, and stay out of the way while you mix. This guide compares six recording mixers for studio work using only the specs their makers publish, from analog boards with USB multitrack recording to one digital console with full recall.
Quick verdict
The short answer depends on how you record. The TASCAM Model 2400 and Mackie Onyx24 lead on multitrack capture, the PreSonus StudioLive AR16c suits smaller rooms, the SSL BiG SiX is a mixdown desk, the Soundcraft Signature 16 covers stereo-mix recording, and the Allen & Heath Qu-5 adds digital recall.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TASCAM Model 2400 | Analog console with SD recorder and USB interface | Full-band tracking without a computer | 24-track SD recording, 24 in / 22 out USB | USB audio stops at 48 kHz |
| Mackie Onyx24 | Analog mixer with multitrack USB | High sample rate DAW tracking | 24-bit / 96 kHz multitrack USB, 18 mic preamps | Only two aux sends for cue mixes |
| PreSonus StudioLive AR16c | Hybrid analog mixer and interface | Small studios and project rooms | 18×4 USB at 24-bit / 96 kHz, 12 XMAX preamps | SD recorder captures the main mix only |
| Solid State Logic BiG SiX | Analog summing and hybrid mixdown desk | Mixing stems through analog circuitry | 16-channel USB interface, G-Series bus compressor | Only four mic preamps, no onboard recorder |
| Soundcraft Signature 16 | Analog mixer with stereo USB | Rooms that record the stereo mix | 12 Ghost preamps, 4-band EQ, Lexicon effects | USB carries two channels in and out |
| Allen & Heath Qu-5 | Digital mixer with motorized faders | Studios that need scene recall | 32×32 USB-C interface, SD multitrack recording | 16 physical mic inputs on the surface |
How we selected
Each pick had to earn its place from published information alone. We read maker and full listing pages, then kept only models whose own pages state a recording path: multitrack USB, an onboard recorder, or both. Every number here traces back to one of those pages.
The six desks split into three camps. Two are analog consoles built around multitrack capture, the TASCAM and the Mackie. Two are smaller hybrid boards, the PreSonus and the Soundcraft, that trade track count for size. The SSL is a summing and mixdown desk, and the Allen & Heath is the lone digital console, included because studio buyers weigh recall against analog simplicity.
Channel counts follow each maker’s own wording. Where a maker counts stereo channels inside a headline figure, the product section says so, because a 24-channel desk with five stereo pairs does not offer 24 microphone inputs. Anything a page did not state is left out rather than filled in from general knowledge.
Recording mixers for studio work: the six picks in detail
Read these sections in order of how you work. Trackers who record whole bands should start with the TASCAM and Mackie. Producers who mix more than they record should weigh the SSL and the Qu-5. The PreSonus and Soundcraft fit rooms where the desk also handles rehearsals, writing sessions, and small ensemble work between booked sessions.
TASCAM Model 2400
TASCAM calls the Model 2400 a 24-track flagship analog recording console and live mixer with an audio interface, and the spec sheet backs the recording claim from two directions at once: a 24-track multitrack recorder writing to SDXC cards, and a 24 in / 22 out USB audio interface for a computer.
The input side lists 22 analog channel modules with 16 XLR mic preamps using the maker’s Ultra HDDA preamp design. Channels 1-12 carry one-knob compressors and insert points, so outboard gear can sit on the channels that usually need it most. A 3-band EQ with a sweepable mid serves channels 1-12, a 100 Hz low-cut filter handles rumble, and phantom power at +48V switches in groups of four channels. Five aux sends, four of them plus the internal effects feed, and four stereo subgroups give enough routing for cue mixes and parallel groups.
Recording to card needs no computer at all. The maker lists SDXC support up to 512 GB, WAV recording at 44.1 or 48 kHz in 16 or 24 bit, and punch-in and punch-out on the recorder. The USB path runs at 24-bit and 48 kHz, and the console adds DAW transport control over HUI and MCU plus MIDI in and out. Sixteen onboard effects, Bluetooth input, and 100 mm faders finish the surface. The desk measures 680.5 by 132.5 by 568.0 mm and weighs 14.0 kg, so it wants a permanent home.
- Pros: records 24 tracks to a card with no computer; 16 mic preamps; inserts on 12 channels; subgroups and five aux sends
- Cons: USB audio stops at 48 kHz; large footprint; compressors only on channels 1-12
Buy if you track full bands and want the desk itself to be the recorder. Skip if your sessions depend on 96 kHz recording over USB, or if the desk must move between rooms every week.
Mackie Onyx24
The Onyx24 is a 24-channel analog mixer built around high-rate multitrack USB. The listing spec table counts 24 input channels as 14 mono and 5 stereo, with 18 Onyx mic preamps offering up to 60 dB of gain, and it states full multitrack recording into a DAW at up to 24-bit / 96 kHz over USB.
Channel processing follows the maker’s Perkins EQ design: a 3-band EQ with a hard bypass switch per channel, with the mono channels sweeping the mid band from 100 Hz to 8 kHz between shelves at 80 Hz and 12 kHz, each band moving plus or minus 15 dB. A 100 Hz high-pass filter sits on the input channels, phantom power at +48V applies across the inputs, and the surface uses 60 mm faders. Bluetooth streaming is built in for reference playback from a phone, and the spec table lists SD media support alongside the USB recording path.
Outputs cover a stereo master on XLR and TRS, a control room pair, two mono aux sends, one mono effects send, and a headphone output. That aux count is the honest weakness here: two sends means two independent cue mixes unless you split sends or lean on the control room feed. For a studio that records one or two performers at a time, the trade is easy to accept for 96 kHz multitrack capture and 18 preamps.
- Pros: 24-bit / 96 kHz multitrack USB; 18 preamps with 60 dB of gain; sweepable mid EQ with hard bypass; Bluetooth playback
- Cons: two aux sends limit cue mixes; analog surface means settings are recalled by hand
Buy if your studio records at 96 kHz and wants an analog front end with many preamps. Skip if your sessions need three or four separate headphone mixes from the desk.
PreSonus StudioLive AR16c
PreSonus describes the StudioLive AR16c as an 18-channel analog mixer, a USB-C compatible audio interface, and a stereo SD recorder in one unit. The interface runs 18×4 at 24-bit and up to 96 kHz over USB 2.0 on a USB-C connection, and the maker states it records every channel plus the main mix.
Twelve balanced microphone inputs carry Class A XMAX preamps with a gain range of +12 to +55 dB, joined by two instrument inputs, 16 balanced line inputs, and two insert points. Channels carry a 3-band semi-parametric EQ, and the Super Channel on channels 17 and 18 gathers Bluetooth 5.0, RCA inputs, a 1/8-inch stereo input, and switchable SD or USB playback. A stereo effects processor holds 16 presets. The 2×2 SD recorder captures the main mix to SD or SDHC cards up to 32 GB, covering rehearsal tapes without opening a session.
The unit is compact for its channel count: 18.9 inches wide, 15.56 inches deep, 3.5 inches high, and 14.1 lbs. Phantom power is +48 VDC, supported sample rates run 44.1, 48, 88.2, and 96 kHz, and the headphone output is rated at 150 mW per channel at 60 ohms. For a project studio tracking small groups, this is the balanced middle pick.
- Pros: multitrack USB plus a main-mix SD recorder; 12 XMAX preamps; compact and light; Super Channel handles playback sources
- Cons: SD recording is stereo only; 12 mic inputs cap full-band work; USB returns are four channels
Buy if your room tracks small lineups and wants one desk for tracking, rehearsal capture, and playback duties. Skip if you regularly mic a full drum kit plus a whole band at once.
Solid State Logic BiG SiX
The BiG SiX comes at studio work from the mix side. SSL lists four SuperAnalogue mic preamps with line and Hi-Z inputs, 48V phantom power, a high-pass filter, and a polarity switch, plus four stereo line inputs with dual mono switching, summing up to 18 inputs at mixdown.
Processing is the draw. Every channel carries a 3-band EQ drawn from the maker’s E-Series designs, with shelving at 3.5 kHz and 60 Hz, a fixed mid control at 700 Hz, and plus or minus 15 dB of range. Channel compressors run a gentle 2:1 ratio with program-dependent attack from 8 to 30 ms and release around 300 ms. Across the mix bus sits the G-Series bus compressor with a fixed 4:1 ratio, 30 ms attack, 100 ms release, and the Auto release setting. A Listen Mic Compressor, two stereo cue feeds, and dual headphone outputs round out the surface.
The built-in USB interface carries 16 channels at 96 kHz and 24 bit in both directions, with routing that can switch the first 12 channels pre or post fader. There is no onboard recorder, so capture depends on a computer. As a tracking desk it is limited by its four mic preamps; as a hybrid mixdown desk that prints stems through analog summing and bus compression, it has no direct rival in this group.
- Pros: G-Series bus compressor on the mix bus; E-Series style EQ on every channel; 18-input analog summing; dual cue feeds
- Cons: four mic preamps only; no onboard recording; USB is the only capture path
Buy if your studio mixes more than it tracks and you want analog summing with console dynamics. Skip if you need to record a drum kit or a full band from the desk alone.
Soundcraft Signature 16
The Signature 16 is a 16-channel analog mixer whose recording path is deliberately simple: a 2-in / 2-out USB connection that records and plays back at 24-bit and 48 kHz. It will not multitrack a band, and this guide will not pretend otherwise; what it offers instead is a strong analog channel strip count for rooms that record the stereo mix.
Twelve Ghost mic preamps feed channels with a 4-band Sapphyre EQ that includes two sweepable mid bands, high-pass filters, and 48V phantom power on all channels, plus switchable Hi-Z inputs for instruments. A Lexicon effects engine provides the onboard effects, dbx limiters sit on input channels, and routing runs through three aux buses, one aux and effects bus with pre and post switching, and four mono or two stereo subgroups with dedicated outputs. The surface uses 100 mm faders, and the maker bundles a recording software download with the mixer.
For a studio built around two-track capture, singer and accompanist sessions, or a rehearsal room that archives every run-through, the Signature 16 covers the job with more preamps and better EQ than most stereo-USB boards. Buyers who need separate tracks for each microphone should look at the TASCAM, Mackie, or PreSonus instead, because no setting on this desk splits its USB feed into multitrack audio.
- Pros: 12 Ghost preamps; 4-band EQ with two swept mids; Lexicon effects and dbx limiters; flexible subgroup routing
- Cons: USB records only the stereo mix; no onboard recorder; fewer aux buses than the TASCAM
Buy if your sessions end as a stereo recording and channel quality matters more than track count. Skip if you need to edit individual microphones after the session.
Allen & Heath Qu-5
The Qu-5 is the digital entry in this group: a compact mixer with 38 inputs to mix, built on a 96 kHz XCVI processing core. Sixteen XLR and jack combi sockets provide the physical mic and line inputs, with 12 XLR outputs, and the maker counts 12 mixes plus four matrix outputs in the mix architecture.
Recording runs three ways. A USB-C audio interface carries 32×32 channels for multitrack recording and playback with a computer. An SD card slot records multichannel audio at 16×16 at 96 kHz or 32×32 at 48 kHz. A USB-A port handles stereo recording and playback. Seventeen 100 mm motorized faders across four layers, a 7-inch capacitive touchscreen, and eight SoftKeys drive the surface, and settings store and recall as scenes, which no analog desk in this group can match.
Assistive tools set it apart for busy rooms: a Gain Assistant that sets and watches channel gain, a Feedback Assistant with up to 16 filters per output, and a 32-channel Automatic Mic Mixer for speech work. An SLink port connects stage boxes with 128×128 channels of patching, and the desk mounts in a 19-inch rack with an optional kit. The trade is workflow: menus and layers replace one knob per function, and expanding past 16 inputs means adding remote I/O.
- Pros: full scene recall with motorized faders; 32×32 USB-C and SD multitrack; 96 kHz processing; SLink expansion
- Cons: 16 physical mic inputs before expansion; layered digital workflow; Dante belongs to the Qu-5D variant
Buy if your studio shares the desk across engineers, classes, or a live room and needs instant recall. Skip if you want every control on the surface at all times with no screens.
Buying guide: choosing recording mixers for studio sessions
A studio mixer purchase turns on five questions: how many microphones you record at once, whether the desk must multitrack, how cue mixes reach the performers, whether it records without a computer, and how it fits the room. The sections below work through each question using the six desks above as the reference points.
Count mic inputs, not headline channels
Headline channel counts mix mono, stereo, and playback channels together, so the microphone figure is the one that decides what a desk can record. In this group the spread runs from four mic preamps on the SSL BiG SiX to 18 on the Mackie Onyx24, with the TASCAM at 16 and the PreSonus and Soundcraft at 12 each.
Count your largest regular session. A full drum kit with overheads, a bass input, two guitars, and a vocal can pass ten microphones before room mics enter the picture. Desks with stereo line inputs still help, since keyboards and playback sources do not need preamps, but they cannot rescue a session that runs out of mic inputs. Leave at least two spare preamps above your normal count for guests and extra room microphones.
Multitrack USB versus stereo USB
The single biggest split in this group is what the USB connection carries. Multitrack desks send each channel to the computer separately: the TASCAM at 24 in / 22 out, the Mackie with multitrack recording at 24-bit / 96 kHz, the PreSonus at 18×4, the SSL at 16 channels, and the Qu-5 at 32×32.
Stereo USB, as on the Soundcraft Signature 16, sends only the main mix. That is fine for archiving a rehearsal or recording a podcast-style session, and it keeps the workflow simple, but every balance decision is printed at record time. If you plan to mix after the session, or to fix one loud source without re-recording the group, multitrack is not a luxury feature; it is the whole point of the desk.
Cue mixes and aux sends
Performers record better when they hear themselves clearly, and separate headphone mixes come from aux sends. The TASCAM lists five aux sends, the Soundcraft three aux buses plus an aux and effects bus, and the Mackie two mono aux sends plus an effects send, which is the tightest allowance in this group.
Think about how many different mixes your sessions need. A singer and a drummer rarely want the same balance. If the desk runs short, options include splitting one send to two listeners who accept the same mix, or using the control room feed as an extra cue path. The SSL instead provides two stereo cue feeds for headphone mixes, suiting its mixdown focus.
Recording without a computer
Three of these desks can capture audio with no computer attached at all. The TASCAM records 24 tracks to SDXC cards, the Qu-5 records multichannel audio to SD and stereo to USB-A media, and the PreSonus records its main mix to SD or SDHC cards up to 32 GB.
Card recording changes how a room works. Rehearsals get archived without opening a session, live-in-the-studio takes survive a computer crash, and the desk can travel to a hall or rehearsal space and still record. Check the card format and ceiling before you buy: the TASCAM accepts SDXC cards up to 512 GB, while the PreSonus stops at 32 GB SDHC cards, which fills far sooner at session lengths.
Sample rates and what they change
Sample rate ceilings differ across this group of desks. The Mackie, PreSonus, and SSL record at up to 96 kHz, the Qu-5 processes at 96 kHz with SD recording at 16×16 at that rate or 32×32 at 48 kHz, and the TASCAM and Soundcraft record at 44.1 or 48 kHz.
Higher rates matter most when your delivery chain asks for them, or when you record sources with strong content at the top of the spectrum and plan heavy pitch or time processing later. For most band tracking, 48 kHz multitrack with clean preamps beats a higher rate with fewer inputs. Match the desk to the work you actually deliver rather than the largest number on the box.
Recall, size, and the room itself
Analog desks remember nothing: every session starts from the knobs exactly as the last engineer left them, which many engineers prefer for speed and touch. The Qu-5 stores scenes and moves its own faders, which pays off when several people share one room or a desk splits duties.
Physical fit matters too. The TASCAM measures 680.5 mm wide and weighs 14.0 kg, the PreSonus measures 18.9 inches wide and weighs 14.1 lbs, and the Qu-5 mounts in a 19-inch rack with an optional kit. Measure your desk space and leave room for cable runs behind the rear panel before the mixer arrives, not after.
FAQ
These answers stick to what the makers publish about the six desks above. Where a maker does not state a figure, the answer says so plainly instead of estimating, and general recording practice is kept separate from the product claims made by each maker.
How many channels do recording mixers for studio tracking really need?
Start from microphones, not channels. Most small-studio band sessions use between eight and sixteen mic inputs once drums, amplifiers, and vocals are counted, which is why the desks here carry between 12 and 18 preamps, apart from the four-preamp SSL that is built for mixdown rather than tracking.
Stereo channels still earn their place for keyboards, playback, and effects returns. The Mackie counts five stereo pairs inside its 24 channels, so read the input breakdown in the spec table before comparing headline numbers between brands.
Can these mixers record every channel separately?
Five of the six can. The TASCAM records 24 tracks to a card or over USB, the Mackie records multitrack over USB at up to 96 kHz, the PreSonus records every channel plus the main mix over USB, the SSL streams 16 channels over USB, and the Qu-5 records 32×32 over USB-C or to SD.
The Soundcraft Signature 16 is the exception: its USB connection carries two channels in and two out, so it records the stereo mix only. It has no onboard recorder either. If separate tracks matter to your workflow, treat that as the deciding line and choose from the other five.
Do I still need a separate audio interface with a USB mixer?
For recording into a computer, no. Each desk here includes a built-in USB audio interface: 24 in / 22 out on the TASCAM, multitrack on the Mackie, 18×4 on the PreSonus, 16 channels on the SSL, stereo on the Soundcraft, and 32×32 over USB-C on the Qu-5.
An interface can still earn its place for very low-latency monitoring setups, extra digital I/O formats, or a second room. The maker pages for these desks do not publish latency figures, so any claim about monitoring delay would be a guess; judge that in your own room with your own buffer settings if it decides the purchase.
Which pick suits a room that records and mixes in equal measure?
The TASCAM Model 2400 is the most even split: 16 preamps, inserts on 12 channels, subgroups, and a 24-track recorder for tracking days, with a full analog mix path for mixdown days. The Qu-5 matches it on flexibility and adds recall, at the price of a screen-driven workflow.
The SSL BiG SiX tilts the other way: it is the strongest mixing desk here and the weakest tracking desk, with four preamps. Rooms that track elsewhere and mix at home should rank it first; rooms that record full bands should rank it last and treat it as a later addition beside a tracking desk.
Conclusion
For most studios, the TASCAM Model 2400 is the strongest center of the room: it records 24 tracks with or without a computer and mixes on a full analog surface. Choose the Mackie Onyx24 for 96 kHz multitrack, the Qu-5 for recall, the AR16c for a smaller room, and the BiG SiX when mixdown matters most.