Key takeaways
- Five fresh menthol and mint bottled e-liquids not used in earlier guides: two spearmint salts, a lemon menthol, a watermelon ice and a wintergreen freebase.
Menthol is the most crowded flavour shelf in bottled e-liquid, so this guide to vape juice for menthol smokers sticks to five fresh bottles: two spearmint salts from different makers, a lemon menthol, a watermelon ice in two formats, and a wintergreen mint freebase sold as a twin pack for sub ohm tanks.
Quick verdict
Three of the five are 10ml bottles blended at 50/50 for pods and mouth to lung kits, and two are larger format freebase bottles for bigger tanks. Cooling styles differ as much as formats: spearmint leads two bottles, menthol finishes a lemon and a watermelon, and wintergreen stands in as the mildest mint of the group.
| Product | Bottle | Printed strengths (mg) | Ratio | Flavour notes as printed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IVG Spearmint Nic Salt | 10ml | 10, 20 salt | 50VG/50PG | Spearmint, bubblegum |
| Hale Minted Lemon Menthol | 10ml | 3, 6, 12, 18 | 50VG/50PG | Lemon, menthol |
| Dinner Lady Spearmint Menthol Nic Salt | 10ml | 5, 10, 20 salt | 50VG/50PG | Spearmint, menthol, light citrus |
| Soulsome Frosted Melon | 60mL freebase / 30mL salt | 0, 3, 6, 12, 18 freebase; 20, 30, 50 salt | 65VG/35PG freebase | Watermelon candy, menthol |
| Mints Vape Co. Wintergreen | 2 x 60mL | 3, 6 freebase | 70VG/30PG | Wintergreen mint |
The two spearmint salts are easy to confuse at a glance, since both are UK made 10ml salts at 50/50, but they are different makers with different recipes: one sweetens spearmint with bubblegum, the other sharpens it with menthol and a light citrus edge, and their strength ladders do not match either.
Format is the other dividing line in the table. The three 10ml bottles belong with small refillable kits, the Frosted Melon page splits its flavour across a pod salt and a tank freebase, and the wintergreen twin pack is a bulk freebase for sub ohm hardware, so a reader can sort the list by the device already in hand before comparing flavours at all.
How we selected this vape juice for menthol smokers
The first rule for this list was freshness of selection: menthol roundups repeat the same famous bottles, so any liquid already covered in a standard menthol guide format was set aside in favour of bottles with their own current product pages. Each entry below is a distinct product from a distinct recipe, not a rebadged variant.
The second rule was a printed cooling identity. A bottle qualified only if its page names the cooling element directly, menthol, spearmint or wintergreen, in the flavour list itself. Fruit liquids with a vague cold finish and no named mint or menthol in the printed profile were left out, because a menthol reader deserves to know what does the cooling.
The third rule covered formats. The group deliberately spans the formats menthol buyers actually meet: 10ml salts for pods, a 10ml conventional bottled range, a dual format bottle sold as freebase and salt on one page, and a high VG freebase twin pack for sub ohm tanks. Ratio and hardware notes are reported exactly as each page prints them.
Finally, every page had to be a live sales page for the bottle at the time of reading, with strengths selectable or listed as the range on offer. Two well known menthol bottles failed that test in this round, one through a clearance listing marked out of stock and one through having no single product page with a full ladder, and both were excluded.
Menthol also attracts more flavour hybrids than any other family, so the shortlist was balanced on purpose: two mint led salts, one citrus led menthol, one fruit led menthol and one pure mint freebase. A reader can therefore compare cooling styles across the group instead of reading five versions of the same spearmint recipe with different labels.
The five bottles of vape juice for menthol smokers in detail
Each entry follows the same order: the flavour build in the maker’s own terms, the bottle and ratio as printed, and the ladder as printed. One honesty note applies to the last entry: wintergreen is a mint rather than menthol itself, and it is included as the mint family option, described exactly the way its maker prints it.
Cooling strength is described in words on these pages rather than measured in figures, so this guide repeats the makers’ own comparisons where they exist: one mint is called milder than menthol by its own maker, one menthol is staged as a finish, and two spearmints are staged as leads. Those printed comparisons are the fairest intensity guide available without inventing a scale.
IVG Spearmint Nic Salt
IVG’s spearmint salt blends crisp spearmint with a subtle bubblegum sweetness, a combination the listing describes as a fresh mint vape juice with a gentle sweet twist. The bottle is a 10ml at 50VG/50PG in 10 and 20 mg salt strengths, made in the UK, with a childproof cap, a tamper evident seal and a TPD compliant bottle.
The flavour staging on the page runs spearmint first, with a clean minty freshness on the inhale, then the bubblegum softening the mint, and a cool, smooth exhale with a fresh spearmint aftertaste. For a menthol smoker who finds straight menthol one note, that candy layer is the point of difference here.
The maker’s salt range covers fruit, menthol, candy, dessert and drink inspired flavours in the same 10ml format, and this bottle is its spearmint entry. The listing names pod kits, vape pens, starter kits and mouth to lung tanks as the hardware match for the 50/50 blend, which is the standard pairing for a salt at these strengths.
Spearmint is the softest of the common mints, sweeter and less sharp than peppermint, and the bubblegum note leans into that softness rather than fighting it. Readers moving from menthol cigarettes often land on spearmint for daily use precisely because it reads as mint flavoured rather than cold, and this bottle is built squarely in that direction.
Hale Minted Lemon Menthol
Hale is an Irish brand, and its Minted collection pairs fruit with menthol across several flavours; the lemon entry combines the sharp, lively character of lemon with a cooling menthol finish. The bottle is a 10ml at 50VG/50PG, ready to use, with documented strengths of 3, 6, 12 and 18 mg, listed as subject to stock availability.
The page is unusually careful about what it does not claim: no nicotine free version is documented for this flavour, and the nicotine formulation is left to the individual bottle label, with the Minted line described as the brand’s conventional bottled collection, separate from its Hale Pro Salt range. This guide reports it the same way.
The flavour build centres on lemon zest rather than lemonade sweetness, with light citrus sweetness behind the tartness and a menthol led finish. The maker also reports that its ingredients come from certified European Union suppliers and that it holds ISO 9001:2015 quality management accreditation, both stated on the page as manufacturing facts.
The same Minted collection includes an apple menthol and a blueberry menthol, which the page sets against this one directly: apple is the orchard option, blueberry the rounded sweet option, and lemon the sharp citrus option. That kind of within range comparison is printed by the maker itself, and it makes the lemon bottle easy to place for readers who already know the range.
Dinner Lady Spearmint Menthol Nic Salt
Dinner Lady’s entry pairs the same headline mint as the IVG bottle with a different build: sweet spearmint on the inhale, cooling menthol developing alongside it, and a subtle citrus note adding brightness to the finish. It is a 10ml salt at 50VG/50PG in 5, 10 and 20 mg, made in the UK, ready to vape with no mixing required.
The bottle carries an integrated dripper tip and a tamper evident seal, and the listing names refillable pod kits, vape pens and lower powered mouth to lung devices as the match. The 5 mg step at the bottom of the ladder is uncommon among salts in this group and gives the range a wider printed span than the two step ladders.
Side by side with the IVG spearmint, the differences are recipe and ladder: bubblegum sweetness against citrus sharpness, two strengths against three. A reader choosing between them is choosing a flavour direction first, since the format, ratio and bottle size are identical, which is exactly the kind of comparison a printed flavour list makes possible.
Dinner Lady built its name on dessert flavours, and its menthol salts sit apart from that catalogue as the fresh end of the range. The spearmint menthol keeps one foot in each world: a sweet opening from the spearmint, then a colder menthol layer that the dessert side of the brand never uses, finished with the citrus edge that stops it reading as a sweet.
Soulsome Frosted Melon
Frosted Melon is the watermelon ice of the group, sold by Black Note under its Soulsome line: sweet watermelon candy with a menthol finish, the watermelon leading on the inhale and the menthol arriving on the exhale. The maker calls it the only iced flavour in the Soulsome line, and it is made in small batches.
One page carries both formats: a 60mL freebase bottle at 65VG/35PG in 0, 3, 6, 12 and 18 mg for sub ohm tanks, and a 30mL salt bottle in 20, 30 and 50 mg for pod systems. The nicotine is naturally extracted rather than synthetic, and the liquid is made without diacetyl, acetyl propionyl, sucralose, alcohol or synthetic nicotine.
The absence of sucralose is the detail the maker leans on: without the high intensity sweetener, the candy watermelon reads less syrupy and leaves less sticky residue on a coil than heavily sweetened liquids, in the maker’s own account. Menthol here is a finish rather than the main event, which suits readers who want fruit first and cooling second.
The dual format also makes this the flexible bottle of the group for households with two kinds of kit: the same flavour can be ordered as a thinner salt for a pod or a thicker freebase for a tank, with the ratio of the salt version following the maker’s standard salt blend. Few menthol pages print both formats side by side, and the comparison table on the page lays the two out line by line.
Mints Vape Co. Wintergreen
Wintergreen closes the group as the big bottle option: two 60mL unicorn bottles, 120mL in total, at 70VG/30PG, in 3 and 6 mg freebase strengths, made in the USA with tobacco free nicotine. The maker states plainly that it is built for sub ohm devices only, and the bottles carry child resistant caps.
The flavour is the classic wintergreen mint of gum and lozenges, described as a lightly sweet, herbaceous mint with a smooth, chilling finish, and the maker’s own comparison is honest about intensity: it is less intense than menthol and milder than peppermint or spearmint. That makes it the gentle end of this list, not the cold end.
The brand behind the bottle makes mint and only mint, with peppermint, spearmint and wintergreen as its classic trio, so wintergreen here is a specialism rather than a side flavour. Readers who smoked menthol but now find strong menthol tiring over a long day may find this milder mint profile the easier bottle to live with.
The twin bottle format suits that daily use pattern: one bottle in service and one still sealed, in a high VG blend that the maker restricts to sub ohm hardware. It is the only entry here whose nicotine is tobacco free by design, printed as TFN on the page, which some buyers actively look for and others avoid, another fact worth reading before ordering.
Buying guide
Menthol buying is mostly about cooling style and format, since strengths and ratios overlap heavily across brands. The sections below use only what the five pages print: the named cooling ingredient, the flavour staging, the format and ratio, and the bottle details that come with each range.
Spearmint, menthol and wintergreen are different cools
The five bottles show three distinct cooling ingredients: spearmint, a sweet soft mint; menthol, the sharper cooling note in the lemon and watermelon bottles; and wintergreen, the mildest of the three by its maker’s own description. Reading which one a bottle names is the fastest way to predict how a flavour will feel before any other detail.
Check what leads and what finishes
Listings stage their flavours, and the order matters: spearmint leads both salt bottles, lemon leads its menthol, watermelon leads its menthol, and wintergreen stands alone. A menthol smoker who wants cooling first should look for bottles where the mint or menthol is named as the lead note, not the finish, on the printed profile.
Match the format to the kit you own
Three bottles here are 10ml at 50/50 for pods, pens and mouth to lung tanks, one page offers a 65VG freebase or a salt for two different hardware classes, and one twin pack is 70VG and sub ohm only by its maker’s instruction. The ratio printed on the page is the maker’s own hardware guidance, and it deserves more weight than habit.
Putting a thick 70VG freebase through a small pod coil, or a high strength salt through a sub ohm tank, is the mismatch the Frosted Melon page itself warns about when it explains its two formats. The warning generalises across this list: format first, flavour second, because the wrong pairing spoils a good liquid.
Salt ladders come in different shapes
The salt ladders in this group run two, three and three steps respectively, at 10 to 20 mg, 5 to 20 mg and 20 to 50 mg across the two formats of one bottle. There is no standard salt ladder, so the printed range of the exact bottle in front of you is the only reliable guide, and comparing headline strengths alone misleads.
Sweetness is a printed choice too
Two bottles here sweeten their mint, one with bubblegum and one as a candy watermelon, while one maker makes a point of leaving sweetener out entirely and another keeps its lemon tart. For a flavour vaped all day, that printed sweetness level decides how cloying a bottle becomes by the third refill, so it is worth reading before the strength.
Seals, caps and storage
The 10ml bottles in this group list childproof caps and tamper evident seals among their printed features, and the twin pack lists child resistant caps. Nicotine liquids should be stored closed, upright and out of reach of children and pets, and a bottle whose seal arrives broken should go back rather than into a tank.
Storage also protects the flavour the buyer paid for: menthol and mint notes are volatile, and a bottle left open or in heat loses its top notes first, which for this flavour family is the whole point of the liquid. Keeping the cap on between refills is a small habit with an outsized effect on mint liquids in particular.
FAQ
These answers stay with what the five product pages print: flavour ingredients, ladders, ratios, formats and bottle details. Nothing here advises a strength or a ratio for any individual reader; the listings leave those choices to the buyer, and so does this guide.
Are the two spearmint salts the same product?
No. They are different makers with different recipes in the same format: the IVG bottle blends spearmint with bubblegum in 10 and 20 mg, while the Dinner Lady bottle blends spearmint with menthol and light citrus in 5, 10 and 20 mg. Both are UK made 10ml salts at 50VG/50PG, which is where the similarity ends.
The distinction is worth spelling out because spearmint salts are often sold side by side under similar names. Checking the maker name on the bottle, not just the flavour name, is what keeps a repeat order consistent, since the two recipes stage their sweetness and cooling in opposite orders.
Is wintergreen the same as menthol?
Not as its maker describes it: wintergreen is a mint profile of its own, similar to traditional wintergreen gum or lozenges, and the page states it is less intense than menthol and milder than peppermint or spearmint. It is included here as the mint family entry for readers who want cooling without menthol’s sharper edge.
Which bottles are tobacco free in flavour?
All five flavour profiles are built without tobacco notes: two spearmints, a lemon menthol, a watermelon candy menthol and a wintergreen mint. One bottle, the Mints Vape Co. freebase, uses tobacco free nicotine as its nicotine source, which is a separate point from flavour and is printed on its page as TFN.
That split matters when reading labels: a tobacco flavour describes what the liquid tastes like, while a tobacco free nicotine note describes where the nicotine itself came from. The five pages here keep the two ideas separate, and buyers who care about either point can find it stated in plain terms on the relevant page.
Do any of these come in a nicotine free version?
One does as printed: the Frosted Melon freebase ladder starts at 0 mg. The Hale page documents no nicotine free version of Lemon Menthol, and the two spearmint salts and the wintergreen freebase print ladders that start at 5, 10 and 3 mg respectively, so a 0 mg option should not be assumed for them.
What sizes do menthol bottles come in here?
The group spans three formats: 10ml bottles for the two spearmint salts and the lemon menthol, a 60mL freebase and 30mL salt pairing on the Frosted Melon page, and a twin pack of 60mL bottles for the wintergreen freebase. Size follows format and hardware class on these pages, not flavour, so the kit decides the bottle.
Which of these is closest to a menthol cigarette profile?
None of the five is a tobacco menthol; that shelf was covered by other bottles in this project. The closest in spirit is the lemon menthol, whose maker builds the flavour as a sharp lead note with a menthol led finish and no sweetness beyond a light citrus balance, while the spearmint salts read as mint confectionery by comparison.
Conclusion
Menthol smokers are spoiled for choice, and the useful skill is reading the printed build: which mint or menthol leads, what sweetens it, and which format carries it. These five bottles answer those questions in full, from a bubblegum spearmint salt to a mild wintergreen twin pack, each described exactly as its maker prints it.