Key takeaways
- Compare six tobacco menthol e juices on printed specs only: bottle size, PG and VG ratio, nicotine format and listed strengths, from freebase to hybrid salt.
A tobacco menthol liquid has two jobs at once: keep the tobacco base recognizable and lay a cool edge over it without wiping the tobacco out. This guide compares six tobacco menthol e juice for smokers listings on printed specs only: bottle size, the PG and VG split, nicotine format and the strengths each maker lists.
Quick verdict
Five of the six picks are 10ml ready-to-use bottles and one is a 100ml shortfill. Two are freebase liquids, three are nicotine salts and one is a hybrid that mixes freebase and salt nicotine in one bottle. Listed strengths run from 0 mg up to 20 mg, and the ratios run from 60PG/40VG to 70 percent VG.
The split that matters most is format. The two freebase bottles, from Vampire Vape and Vapemate, list the widest strength ladders, five options each including 0 mg. The three salt bottles list three strengths each, and the Riot Squad hybrid sits between the two formats on paper, with a 50 percent VG ratio and strengths of 5 mg, 10 mg and 20 mg. The Cosmic Fog shortfill is the outlier on size and ratio: 100ml of 0 mg liquid at 70 percent VG, built to take nicotine shots.
| Product | Format | Bottle | Ratio | Strengths listed | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Menthol Tobacco by Vampire Vape | Freebase | 10ml | 60PG/40VG, or 50/50 at 3 mg | 0, 3, 6, 12, 18 mg | Ratio changes with strength |
| Tobacco Menthol by Vapemate Classic | Freebase | 10ml | 50VG/50PG | 0, 3, 6, 12, 18 mg | One ratio across the range |
| Tobacco Menthol Hybrid Salt by Riot Squad | Hybrid salt | 10ml | 50 percent VG | 5, 10, 20 mg | Listed as one flavor in a menthol range |
| Menthol Tobacco Nic Salt by Pod Salt Origin | Nicotine salt | 10ml | 50/50 VG/PG | 5, 11, 20 mg | Three strengths only |
| Chill’d Tobacco Shortfill by Cosmic Fog | Shortfill | 100ml in a 120ml bottle | 70 percent VG | 0 mg as sold | Needs nicotine shots to contain nicotine |
| Mint Tobacco Nic Salt by Elf Bar Elfliq | Nicotine salt | 10ml | 50 percent VG | 5, 10, 20 mg | 10ml bottle size only |
How we selected
Each liquid here had to pass three tests on a product page that was opened and read: the page shows the liquid on sale, the liquid pairs a tobacco base with menthol or mint in its listed flavor profile, and the page prints the core figures used in this guide, meaning bottle size, ratio, nicotine format and the strength ladder.
The tobacco menthol shelf overlaps heavily with plain menthol and plain tobacco ranges, so the filter was the pairing itself. A liquid counted only when its own listing names both sides, tobacco and a cool note, in one product. That rule kept out straight menthol bottles and straight tobacco bottles, even from the same makers. Every figure below is quoted from the page read for that liquid, and where a page does not state a figure, the gap is noted rather than filled in.
- Every product page read for this guide showed the liquid on sale.
- Every liquid pairs tobacco with menthol or mint on its own listing.
- Bottle size, ratio, format and strengths are quoted only where the page states them.
- No liquid is presented as a way to stop smoking; no page read is quoted that way here.
- One further tobacco menthol liquid was left out because its page showed it out of stock.
Tobacco menthol e juice for smokers picks compared
The six liquids below are ordered by format: the two freebase bottles first, then the hybrid, then the two remaining salts, and the shortfill last because its bottle and ratio put it in a different device class. Read the ratio line against your hardware, since it decides which of these a small pod kit can run as listed.
Menthol Tobacco by Vampire Vape
The Vampire Vape listing describes this 10ml freebase liquid as a traditional tobacco taste with a refreshing menthol twist. It is the only bottle here whose ratio changes with strength: the 0 mg, 6 mg, 12 mg and 18 mg options are listed at 60PG/40VG, while the 3 mg option is listed at 50PG/50VG.
That split gives the range two different behaviours in one product name. The 60PG side is the thinner mix, and the single 50/50 option sits in the middle of the strength ladder rather than at the top or bottom. The bottle is listed as child-proof and the liquid as manufactured in the UK. Five strengths is the joint widest ladder in this guide, and it includes a 0 mg option, which only one other pick here matches.
Buy it if you want a freebase tobacco menthol with a strength ladder that reaches both 0 mg and 18 mg. Skip it if you need one fixed ratio across strengths, because the 3 mg bottle is blended differently from the rest of its own range.
- Pros: five listed strengths; two ratios in one range; child-proof bottle; made in the UK as listed.
- Cons: ratio changes at 3 mg; 10ml bottle only; freebase format only.
Tobacco Menthol by Vapemate Classic
The Vapemate Classic listing keeps things simpler: one 10ml freebase bottle at 50VG/50PG across all five listed strengths, 0 mg, 3 mg, 6 mg, 12 mg and 18 mg. The listing describes the flavor as cool mint over earthy tobacco, and lists a childproof bottle made in the UK.
Against the Vampire Vape bottle above, the trade is plain. Vapemate holds the ratio constant and lets only the strength change, so a reader moving up or down the ladder keeps the same liquid thickness. The mint wording also differs: this listing says mint rather than menthol in its flavor description, though the product name carries menthol. Both bottles are 10ml, both are freebase, and both list the same five strengths, so the ratio policy and the flavor wording are the real separators.
Buy it if you want one 50/50 blend that stays the same at every strength. Skip it if you want a thinner high-PG option at the top strengths, because this range does not list one.
- Pros: five listed strengths including 0 mg; fixed 50/50 ratio; childproof bottle; made in the UK as listed.
- Cons: one ratio only; 10ml bottle only; flavor described as mint rather than a menthol blast.
Tobacco Menthol Hybrid Salt by Riot Squad
Riot Squad lists this 10ml liquid as the Tobacco flavor inside its Menthol Hybrid Salt range. The format is the point of difference: hybrid nicotine, which the range page describes as a mix of freebase nicotine and nicotine salt in one bottle, at a 50 percent VG ratio and in 5 mg, 10 mg and 20 mg strengths.
None of the other five picks blends the two nicotine formats. The freebase bottles list longer strength ladders but no salt content, and the salt bottles list no freebase content. The hybrid therefore stands as a third format rather than a variant of either. The range page lists the flavor options side by side, Cherry Menthol, Lemon Cucumber, Melon Menthol, Menthol Ice and Tobacco, so the tobacco version is one option in a menthol-led range rather than a standalone tobacco line.
Buy it if you want the only hybrid format in this guide and a 50 percent VG salt-side bottle. Skip it if you want a 0 mg option or a strength below 5 mg, because the listed ladder starts at 5 mg.
- Pros: only hybrid nicotine format here; 50 percent VG; three strengths up to 20 mg.
- Cons: no 0 mg option; ladder starts at 5 mg; one flavor inside a wider menthol range.
Menthol Tobacco Nic Salt by Pod Salt Origin
The Pod Salt Origin listing is a 10ml nicotine salt at a 50/50 VG/PG ratio, in 5 mg, 11 mg and 20 mg strengths. The 11 mg middle step is the only one of its kind in this guide: every other ladder here moves in the more common 5, 10 and 20 mg or 0 to 18 mg patterns.
The listing positions the liquid for mouth-to-lung refillable pod and starter kits, which matches its 50/50 ratio and salt format. It is also the plainest presentation in the group: no flavor notes beyond the tobacco menthol pairing in the name are quoted on the page read, and no bottle features such as seals or caps are listed there. What is stated is the format, the ratio, the three strengths and the device class the maker aims it at.
Buy it if you want a salt liquid with an 11 mg middle option for a small pod kit. Skip it if you want detailed flavor notes or bottle features on the listing, because this page keeps its description short.
- Pros: 11 mg middle strength; 50/50 ratio for pod kits; salt format in a 10ml bottle.
- Cons: three strengths only; short listing with few stated details; no 0 mg option.
Mint Tobacco Nic Salt by Elf Bar Elfliq
The Elfliq listing describes this 10ml salt liquid as earthy tobacco with botanical mint, woody and cool. It is listed at 50 percent VG in 5 mg, 10 mg and 20 mg strengths, with salt nicotine, a childproof cap, a tamper evident seal and a recyclable bottle, and the page states it is made in China.
This is the most fully specified small bottle in the guide. The page even prints the bottle dimensions, 7.3 cm tall and 1.9 cm in diameter, which no other 10ml listing here does. The flavor wording is also the most layered: tobacco first, then mint described as botanical, with woody and cool notes behind it. Against the Pod Salt Origin bottle, which shares the 50 percent VG class and two of the three strengths, the Elfliq page simply states more.
Buy it if you want a salt tobacco mint with the fullest stated bottle details in this guide. Skip it if you want a strength below 5 mg or a freebase option, because this range lists neither.
- Pros: three strengths; childproof cap and tamper evident seal listed; bottle dimensions stated; recyclable bottle.
- Cons: ladder starts at 5 mg; 10ml bottle only; salt format only.
Chill’d Tobacco Shortfill by Cosmic Fog
The Cosmic Fog listing is the big-bottle outlier: 100ml of 0 mg liquid in a 120ml bottle, at 70 percent VG and 30 percent PG. The flavor notes are listed as tobacco, chocolate and peppermint, and the page describes dark tobacco and chocolate lifted by fresh peppermint with a frosty finish.
The shortfill format explains the spare 20ml of bottle space. The listing states there is room for two 10ml nicotine shots, and that two 18 mg shots bring the bottle to 120ml of 3 mg liquid. As sold, the bottle contains no nicotine, which makes it the only pick here that arrives nicotine free by design rather than by choosing a 0 mg option. The page also lists a childproof cap, a tamper evident seal, a recyclable bottle and manufacture in the USA. Its 70 percent VG ratio is the thickest mix in the guide and points it at larger devices rather than small pod kits.
Buy it if you want a large bottle, a high VG ratio and a tobacco profile with chocolate behind the peppermint. Skip it if you want nicotine in the bottle as sold, or a liquid blended for a small pod kit.
- Pros: 100ml bottle; 70 percent VG; shot space and resulting strength stated on the listing; made in the USA as listed.
- Cons: 0 mg as sold; ratio points away from small pods; only one strength outcome listed for the shot mix.
Buying guide
The six listings divide along four lines: nicotine format, ratio, bottle size and how the cool note is built. The sections below work through each line using only the figures the pages print, so the comparison stays on what a buyer can read on a label before choosing a bottle.
Freebase, salt and hybrid formats
Three nicotine formats appear in this guide. Freebase is the format of the Vampire Vape and Vapemate bottles, salt is the format of the Pod Salt Origin, Elfliq and, in part, the Riot Squad bottle, and hybrid is the Riot Squad format on its own, listed as freebase and salt nicotine combined in one liquid.
The listings tie format to strength range in a consistent way. The freebase ladders run 0 mg to 18 mg in five steps, the salt ladders run 5 mg to 20 mg in three steps, and the hybrid matches the salt pattern at 5 mg, 10 mg and 20 mg. No page read for this guide presents any format as better than another; the formats are simply sold in different strength shapes, and the shape of the ladder is a printed fact a buyer can compare directly.
PG and VG ratios in a tobacco menthol e juice for smokers list
Ratios here run from 60PG/40VG at the thin end to 70 percent VG at the thick end. The Vampire Vape range holds both ends of the small-bottle spread by itself, 60/40 at most strengths and 50/50 at 3 mg. Vapemate, Pod Salt Origin, Riot Squad and Elfliq all sit at or near 50/50, and the Cosmic Fog shortfill stands alone at 70 percent VG.
Ratio is the figure that connects a bottle to a device class. The one listing that names a device class, Pod Salt Origin, pairs its 50/50 ratio with mouth-to-lung pod and starter kits. The shortfill pairs the thickest ratio with the largest bottle and a shot-based format. A buyer comparing bottles can therefore read ratio and bottle size together: the 10ml bottles cluster at 50/50 or thinner, and the one big bottle is the one thick mix.
Bottle size and the shortfill format
Five picks are 10ml bottles sold ready to use at the stated strength. The sixth, the Cosmic Fog shortfill, is 100ml of 0 mg liquid in a 120ml bottle, and its strength exists only after shots are added: the listing works the sum out as two 10ml shots of 18 mg giving 120ml at 3 mg.
That makes the shortfill a different kind of purchase. The 10ml bottles state their strength on the label and need nothing added. The shortfill states a starting point of 0 mg and one listed outcome after mixing. A buyer who wants a stated strength above 3 mg, or a bottle that is finished as sold, is reading the wrong format in the shortfill, and a buyer who wants volume in one bottle is reading the wrong format in the 10ml range.
How the cool side is built
The listings build the cool note four ways. Vampire Vape describes a menthol twist over traditional tobacco. Vapemate describes cool mint over earthy tobacco. Elfliq describes botanical mint with woody and cool notes over earthy tobacco. Cosmic Fog uses peppermint, set against tobacco and chocolate, with a frosty finish in the description.
These are flavor descriptions as printed, not measured intensities, and no page read ranks its own cool note against another brand. What a buyer can take from the wording is structure: which note leads, whether chocolate or wood sits behind it, and whether the cool element is named as menthol, mint or peppermint. The Riot Squad and Pod Salt Origin listings, by contrast, state the pairing in the product name and print little flavor prose, so their structure is the least described of the six.
Strength ladders as listed
Across the six listings, the stated strengths are 0 mg, 3 mg, 5 mg, 6 mg, 10 mg, 11 mg, 12 mg, 18 mg and 20 mg, plus the shortfill outcome of 3 mg after shots. The freebase bottles hold the low end and the only 0 mg options sold ready to use. The salt and hybrid bottles hold the top end at 20 mg.
This guide reports the ladders as specifications and nothing more. No page read for this guide ties a strength to a pattern of smoking, and no strength is presented here as right for any reader. The useful comparison is availability: a reader who wants a stated 0 mg bottle has two freebase options and the shortfill, and a reader who wants 20 mg has three salt or hybrid options, all in 10ml bottles.
FAQ
The questions below settle the points the six listings raise most often: which strengths are actually on offer, whether the shortfill contains nicotine as sold, which ratio the pod kit listing uses, which bottles list a 0 mg option, and what the pages state about where the liquids are made.
What strengths do tobacco menthol e juice for smokers listings offer?
The two freebase bottles list 0 mg, 3 mg, 6 mg, 12 mg and 18 mg. The salt and hybrid bottles list 5 mg, 10 mg and 20 mg, except Pod Salt Origin, which lists 5 mg, 11 mg and 20 mg. The Cosmic Fog shortfill is 0 mg as sold, with a listed outcome of 3 mg after two 18 mg shots are added.
Those ladders are the whole stated range across the six pages read. No listing here offers a ready bottle between 12 mg and 18 mg on the freebase side, and no salt listing goes below 5 mg, so the ladders, rather than any single strength, are what separate the formats.
Does the shortfill contain nicotine as sold?
No. The Cosmic Fog listing states 100ml of 0 mg liquid in a 120ml bottle, with room left for two 10ml nicotine shots. The shots are the nicotine source, and the listing states that two 18 mg shots bring the mixed bottle to 120ml of 3 mg liquid. The headroom in the bottle is there for exactly that mixing step.
That is the only pick in this guide sold without nicotine in the bottle. The Vampire Vape and Vapemate ranges also list 0 mg options, but those are ready bottles at 0 mg, not a base liquid waiting for shots to be added.
Which ratio suits a small pod kit, on these listings?
The one listing that names a device class is Pod Salt Origin, which positions its 50/50 VG/PG salt liquid for mouth-to-lung refillable pod and starter kits. Vapemate, Riot Squad and Elfliq also list ratios at or near 50 percent VG, though their pages do not name a device class.
At the other end, the Cosmic Fog shortfill lists 70 percent VG, the thickest mix here, in a 100ml bottle. The listings therefore put the small-bottle, pod-side liquids at 50/50 and the one large shortfill at high VG, and a buyer can match the ratio on the label to the class of device they own.
Which of these liquids list a 0 mg option?
Three of the six. The Vampire Vape range lists 0 mg at its 60PG/40VG ratio, the Vapemate Classic range lists 0 mg at 50/50, and the Cosmic Fog shortfill is 0 mg as sold across the whole bottle. The two remaining salt bottles and the hybrid list no 0 mg option; their ladders start at 5 mg.
The distinction inside that answer matters. The two freebase 0 mg bottles are finished liquids at that strength. The shortfill is a 0 mg base that the listing expects shots to be added to, so its 0 mg state is a starting point rather than the finished product.
Where are these liquids made, as listed?
Four pages state an origin. Vampire Vape lists manufacture in the UK, Vapemate lists its bottle as made in the UK, Cosmic Fog lists manufacture in the USA, and the Elfliq page states made in China. That is four stated origins across the six listings, two of them in the UK.
The Riot Squad and Pod Salt Origin pages read for this guide do not state a country of origin, so none is quoted for them here. Origin is a label fact only; no page read connects where a liquid is made to how it tastes or how strong its cool note is.
Conclusion
On printed specs, the Vampire Vape and Vapemate bottles offer the widest ladders at 0 mg to 18 mg, the Riot Squad bottle is the only hybrid format, Pod Salt Origin holds the only 11 mg step, Elfliq prints the fullest bottle details, and the Cosmic Fog shortfill stands alone on size, on ratio and on its chocolate-backed flavor build.