Key takeaways
- Compare grills for smoking and grilling across pellet, gravity charcoal and kamado designs, with verified temperature ranges, cooking areas and smoke features.
Many backyards hold two cookers because one handles low-and-slow smoke and the other handles weeknight grilling. This guide compares best grills for smoking and grilling that do both jobs in a single unit, judged on published temperature ranges, smoke features and searing hardware from pages opened for this guide.
Quick verdict
The six cookers below split into three camps. Pellet models hold low temperatures for hours and grill up to about 500 to 600 degrees F, charcoal gravity and kamado models reach higher searing heat, and one pellet grill adds a separate smoke box so wood chunks or charcoal deepen the smoke while pellets hold the temperature.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traeger Timberline | Pellet | Connected smoking and grilling | 880 square inches, max 500 degrees F | Top heat capped at 500 degrees F |
| Weber Searwood XL 600 | Pellet | Wide range plus direct flame | 180 to 600 degrees F range | Smoking output is pellet only |
| Masterbuilt Gravity Series 1050 | Gravity charcoal | Charcoal smoke with digital control | Sear up to 700 degrees F | 1-year warranty |
| Pit Boss Navigator 1150 | Pellet | Direct flame searing on pellets | 1,158 square inches total area | No app control on this model |
| Camp Chef Woodwind Pro 36 | Pellet plus smoke box | Strongest smoke flavor control | Smoke Box burns chunks or charcoal | Top heat 500 degrees F |
| Kamado Joe Classic Joe III | Ceramic charcoal | Manual charcoal, smoke and sear | SloRoller insert included | No digital temperature control |
How we selected
Each model here had to show both halves of the job on its own product page: a low range or a named smoke feature for smoking, and a top temperature or searing feature for grilling. Cookers that only smoked or only grilled were left out, and every figure in this guide comes from a page opened during research.
The list also mixes fuel types on purpose. Four models burn wood pellets with digital controllers, one feeds charcoal by gravity into a digitally fanned fire, and one is a ceramic charcoal kamado with manual vent control. That spread matters because the smoke source, the heat-up routine and the cleaning job differ more by fuel than by brand.
Smoke claims were read carefully. A smoke mode name on a controller is not the same thing as a second smoke fuel, so the guide separates models that only burn pellets from the one model that burns chunks or charcoal in its own box, and from charcoal models where the fuel itself makes the smoke. Where a maker states a figure, the figure is used; where a page stays silent, the guide says so.
The best grills for smoking and grilling, model by model
Read the six profiles in fuel order: pellets first, then gravity-fed charcoal, then ceramic charcoal. Each profile covers who the cooker suits, the smoke feature that earns its place here, the grilling ceiling from the maker’s own figures, and the limit most likely to matter after the first few cooks.
Traeger Timberline
The Timberline is Traeger’s flagship pellet grill, built around Smart Combustion technology and WiFIRE connectivity. For smoking, it pairs a Downdraft Exhaust system with a Super Smoke Mode, and the maker notes that food cooked between 165 and 225 degrees F produces more smoke flavor than food cooked at higher temperatures.
Cooking space is 880 square inches across 3 tiers of stainless steel grates, split by the maker into racks of 396, 242 and 242 square inches. Capacity is rated at 9 chickens, 8 rib racks or 6 pork butts. The hopper holds 22 pounds of pellets, the maximum temperature is 500 degrees F, and the total weight is 238 pounds, so this is a fixed-position grill once assembled.
Grilling hardware includes a Traeger Induction cooktop on the side, which the maker describes as great for searing, alongside the main grates. A touchscreen display, a P.A.L. Pop-And-Lock accessory rail and an EZ-Clean Grease and Ash Keg that collects grease and ash in one container round out the package, and the warranty is a 10-year limited warranty.
The limit is the 500 degrees F ceiling: fine for burgers, chicken and most steaks, short of the hardest sear. Buy the Timberline if you want the most connected pellet cooker here, with insulated dual-wall construction for cold-weather smoking. Skip it if high-heat charcoal searing is your priority.
Weber Searwood XL 600
The Searwood XL 600 is Weber’s current pellet grill, with the widest range of the pellet models here: the maker states a full temperature range of 180 to 600 degrees F. A SmokeBoost setting holds the grill at its lowest setting to optimize smoke absorption, and a DirectFlame system removes the large diffuser sheet found in many pellet grills.
Two cooking levels carry the capacity, and Weber’s stated design goal is plain: smoke, sear, bake and roast on the same barbecue. The included Weber Crafted frame kit and sear grate widen the grilling side further, with a griddle, pizza stone and rotisserie offered as add-ons, so the grill half of the brief can grow without replacing the cooker.
That DirectFlame layout creates a full-grill sear zone, so the whole main grate sears instead of one small area. The Rapid React PID controller reaches smoke, roast and sear temperatures in 15 minutes or less by the maker’s lab-based figure, and recovers heat quickly after the lid opens. Cooking runs on two levels, and the deep top rack fits a brisket or lifts out for tall roasts and whole poultry.
Running gear is practical: a side hopper fits a standard 20 pound bag of pellets with a release handle for swapping flavors, the maker rates smooth pellet flow for up to 20 hours of cooking, and a pull-and-clean grease and ash system sits at the front. Two food probes are included, the controller is a Weber Connect digital LCD with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, and the warranty is a 5-year limited warranty.
The limit is smoke depth: pellets are the only fuel, so smoke flavor depends on the SmokeBoost setting and pellet choice rather than chunks of wood. Buy the Searwood XL 600 if you want one pellet grill that genuinely covers low smoking and 600 degrees F grilling. Skip it if you want to burn charcoal or wood chunks as well.
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 1050
The Gravity Series 1050, model MB20041220, burns charcoal with digital control. Its GravityFed hopper holds up to 10 pounds of lump charcoal or 16 pounds of briquettes and feeds the fire by gravity, while a DigitalFan moves air from the hopper to the cooking chamber to hold the set temperature automatically.
The maker states the two ends of the range plainly: smoke at 225 degrees F or sear up to 700 degrees F. Heat-up is fast for charcoal, reaching 225 degrees F in 8 minutes and 700 degrees F in 15 minutes by the maker’s figures. Cooking space is 1,050 square inches, the hopper supports up to 10 hours of uninterrupted cooking, and the grill connects to the Masterbuilt app with tracking for up to 4 meat probes.
Smoke control has a charcoal cook’s touch: the maker’s own guide describes adding 1 or 2 wood chunks to the ash bin for on-demand smoke lasting about 2 to 3 hours, or layering chunks through the charcoal for controlled smoke. Reversible cast iron grates, porcelain-coated warming racks, a removable ash bucket and a grease tray cover the hardware, and a pizza oven, rotisserie and griddle are sold separately.
The warranty is the weak point at 1 year, the shortest in this guide, and charcoal ash management is a bigger routine than pellet ash. Buy the Gravity Series 1050 if you want real charcoal smoke and a 700 degrees F sear with push-button temperature holding. Skip it if you want set-and-forget pellet feeding and a longer warranty.
Pit Boss Navigator 1150
The Navigator 1150, model PB1150G, answers the pellet grill’s usual searing weakness with hardware: a Flame Broiler slide plate with an external control lever. Slide the plate open and the fire pot flame reaches the food for direct flame searing rated up to 1,000 degrees F; slide it closed and the grill cooks indirectly for smoking.
The maker’s specification sheet gives a temperature range of 180 to 500 degrees F and a total cooking area of 1,158 square inches, split into 711 square inches on the main grid and 447 square inches on the upper rack. The main grid is porcelain coated cast iron, the upper rack is porcelain coated steel, and 2 meat probes are included with the dial-in digital control and LCD screen.
The hopper is one of the largest here at 32 pounds, with a cleanout door and a sight glass window for checking fuel level. Grease management is a bucket system, the body is heavy-duty steel with a high temp powder coat finish, and the assembled grill weighs 185.2 pounds on two in-line wheels and two locking casters.
The limit is control: this Navigator uses a dial-in board without the app connectivity the other pellet models here include, and the barrel range tops out at 500 degrees F away from the open flame zone. Buy the Navigator 1150 if direct flame searing on a pellet grill matters most. Skip it if you want phone control and monitoring.
Camp Chef Woodwind Pro 36
The Woodwind Pro 36 has the most flexible smoke setup in this guide. Alongside its pellet fire, a built-in Smoke Box burns wood chunks, wood chips, charcoal or pellets, with a damper that controls heat and flavor, so the smoke fuel can be changed without changing how the grill holds temperature.
The controller is a PID unit with a full-color display, Wi-Fi and the Camp Chef Connect app, 4 temperature probe ports, and a Smoke Number setting that raises or lowers smoke output from the controller. A Fan Only mode supports cold smoking with the Smoke Box. The listing states a high temperature of 500 degrees F, hot enough for grilling and searing in the maker’s own FAQ answer.
Construction details from the listing: the interior uses 430 stainless steel, the butterfly valve, gasket and burn cup use 304 stainless steel, and an ash cleanout knob drops ash into a removable cup. The grill measures 62 inches wide, 26 inches deep and 44.5 inches high, weighs 220 pounds, and carries a 3-year warranty. The main cooking grid measures 34 x 19 inches.
The limit is that deep smoke takes a second routine: the Smoke Box fuel burns down and needs refilling on long cooks, and the top temperature matches the pellet pack rather than beating it. Buy the Woodwind Pro 36 if smoke flavor control is the whole point of the purchase. Skip it if you want the simplest possible single-fuel cooker.
Kamado Joe Classic Joe III
The Classic Joe III, model KJ15040921, is the manual entry: an 18-inch ceramic charcoal grill on a heavy-duty powder coated steel cart. Its smoking hardware is the SloRoller hyperbolic insert, which the maker says instantly turns the grill into a smoker by rolling heat and smoke around the food in the chamber.
The 3-Tier Divide and Conquer Flexible Cooking System stacks cooking levels so different foods sit at different heights and temperatures, and the maker lists 250 square inches of maximum cooking space for the main configuration. A stainless steel charcoal basket, an AMP Firebox and a double-thick wire mesh fiberglass gasket support the fire and the seal, and a Kontrol Tower top vent holds its air setting while the dome opens and closes.
For grilling, the deflectors come out and food cooks over direct charcoal heat on stainless steel cooking grates; an Air Lift hinge reduces the dome weight at the handle, and folding aluminum side shelves, a built-in thermometer and an ash tool are included. Kamado Joe backs the grill with a limited lifetime warranty, shown on the product page.
The limits are effort and feedback: temperature is managed by vents and experience rather than a controller, and the maker’s page does not state a temperature range figure, so none is claimed here. Buy the Classic Joe III if you enjoy running a fire and want charcoal smoke with a dedicated smoker insert. Skip it if you want app alerts and automatic temperature holding.
One ownership note applies to every ceramic kamado: the shell is heavy and the grill is happiest in a permanent spot on the cart, rolled short distances on its locking wheels rather than hauled to events. In exchange, the thick ceramic walls hold heat with very little charcoal, which is why kamado owners often smoke on a single load of fuel that would not last the same cook in a thin steel cooker.
Buying guide
Dual-purpose cookers compromise somewhere, and the buying decision is choosing which compromise fits your cooking. The sections below break the choice into fuel, temperature range, smoke control and upkeep, using the figures published for the six models above rather than general claims about whole product categories.
Fuel decides the daily routine
Pellets feed automatically and hold a set temperature, which suits overnight smoking and busy weeknight grilling. Charcoal asks more of the cook: loading, lighting and ash removal, in exchange for charcoal flavor and higher searing heat. The gravity model sits between the two, feeding charcoal automatically while a fan holds the set temperature.
Fuel also decides running cost and storage in a plain, practical way. Pellets come in measured bags and pour from a hopper; charcoal comes in larger bags and leaves more ash per cook. Neither fact favors one cooker for every household, but the household that grills three weeknights a week usually feels fuel handling more than the household that smokes one brisket a month.
Read both ends of the temperature range
For smoking and grilling in one unit, the low end matters as much as the high end. A grill that holds 180 to 225 degrees F smokes gently; a ceiling of 600 to 700 degrees F sears hard. Compare the stated ranges above, and note the difference between a barrel temperature and a direct flame figure, which covers the fire zone, not the whole grate.
Stability at the low end deserves as much attention as the numbers themselves. Insulated walls, gasketed lids and fan-driven controllers, all present on models in this guide, exist to keep a 225 degrees F setting from wandering during a long smoke. A wide stated range on a thin, leaky cooker is worth less than a narrower range the cooker can hold for eight hours without help.
Smoke control on grills for smoking and grilling
Smoke features come in three levels. Mildest is a controller mode that changes how pellets burn at low temperatures. Stronger is a smoke setting paired with a low holding temperature. Strongest is a second fuel: chunks or charcoal in a smoke box, or charcoal as the main fuel, where the smoke source itself can be changed by hand.
Capacity and rack layout
Total area figures count every rack, so check the split before comparing. A large main grid suits grilling for a group, while tall multi-rack layouts suit smoking several cuts at once. The profiles above list main and upper areas separately where the maker publishes them, and that split better predicts how a cooker will actually be loaded.
Cleaning and ash handling
Smoke cooking is dirty cooking. Pellet models collect ash in the fire pot and grease in a tray or keg; charcoal models add ash volume and grate scraping. Look for cleanout doors, removable ash cups and front-access grease systems, all present on models above, because a dual-purpose cooker that is annoying to clean ends up used for one job only.
FAQ
Shoppers comparing these cookers usually ask the same few questions about heat, smoke strength and fuel. The answers below stick to what the makers publish for the models in this guide and to general cooking knowledge that does not depend on any single product’s figures.
Can one grill really smoke and grill well?
Yes, within the limits of its fuel. Every model here holds smoking temperatures for hours and reaches grilling temperatures on the same grate, which covers most backyard cooking. The compromises show at the extremes: pellet models sear less hard than charcoal, and charcoal models need more attention during long smokes than a pellet controller does.
What temperature range should I look for?
A low end near 180 to 225 degrees F covers smoking, and a top end of at least 500 degrees F covers grilling, with 600 to 700 degrees F giving a harder sear. All six models here meet the smoking end by their published figures; they differ at the top, from 500 degrees F pellet ceilings to 700 degrees F on charcoal and the 1,000 degrees F flame zone.
Do pellet grills make enough smoke?
Pellet smoke is real but gentler than charcoal or chunk smoke, and strongest at low temperatures, which is why makers add smoke modes for the low range. If smoke depth is the priority, the model with a smoke box, or a charcoal model, gives more control than settings alone. Pellet choice matters too: stronger woods read more clearly in the food.
Time is the other variable. A short grill session takes little smoke no matter the cooker, while hours at low temperature let even mild pellet smoke build a clear ring and bark. Cooks who mostly grill fast and smoke rarely are usually satisfied with a smoke mode; cooks who chase brisket flavor usually end up at the smoke box or charcoal end of this list.
Are grills for smoking and grilling hard to clean?
They collect more grease and ash than a grill used one way, because smoking coats the chamber and grilling burns drippings onto grates. The routine is still simple: empty ash after long cooks, scrape grates while warm, and clear the grease path before it builds up. Models with cleanout systems, several profiled above, shorten each of those jobs.
A shop vacuum, a stiff brush and a putty knife handle nearly all of it. The one habit that matters most is clearing the grease path before a high-heat grilling session that follows a long fatty smoke, because old grease plus a 600 degrees F grate is where most dual-purpose cookers get into trouble.
Conclusion
Pick by fuel first, then by range. Pellet models hold smoke temperatures with the least effort, charcoal models sear hardest, and the smoke box design gives the deepest smoke control of the pellet group. Match the stated range and rack layout to your cooking, and one cooker can honestly cover both jobs.