Key takeaways
- Compare cast iron and porcelain-enameled cooking grates for gas grills by fit, dimensions and material, from Weber and Char-Broil fitments to a universal grid.
The factory grates on many gas grills are thin coated steel, and they are often the first part to rust, flake or warp. This guide compares cooking grates for gas grills in cast iron and porcelain-enameled cast iron, matched by fit and dimensions, so a worn grill cooks like a heavier one. One universal grid covers grills that no brand list names.
Quick verdict
Start with fit, then pick the material. Exact fit cast iron sets for Weber and Char-Broil grills are the straightforward path, Broil King sells its reversible grid one piece at a time, a universal adjustable grid covers grills with no listed fitment, and a cast iron griddle insert adds a flat top option.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| QuliMetal 17.5 inch Grill Grates | Cast iron set | Weber Spirit and Genesis fit | 17.5 inch, replaces 7638/7639 | Thin spec sheet |
| Uniflasy 15 inch Cast Iron Grates | Cast iron pair | Older Spirit 200 grills | 15 x 11-1/4 inches each | Side control models only |
| BBQMall Cast Iron Cooking Grates | Porcelain coated cast iron | Char-Broil 4 burner grills | 16-7/8 x 9-5/16 inches each | Model list must match |
| Broil King 11229 Cast Iron Cooking Grill | Reversible cast iron grid | Regal and Imperial owners | 19.25 x 6 inches, sold singly | Buy each grid separately |
| Mustang Cast Iron Grid Universal | Adjustable universal grid | Grills with no listed fit | Depth adjusts 35 to 45.5 cm | One grid size only |
| Napoleon Cast Iron Reversible Griddle 56425 | Porcelain coated griddle insert | Flat top cooking on a Rogue 425 | 11 5/8 x 17 3/4 inches | Replaces one grid section |
How we selected
Every grate below comes from a maker or listing page that states its material and its dimensions or fit list. Cast iron and porcelain-enameled cast iron lead this list on purpose: they hold heat at the surface, mark food well, and cover the most common replacement sizes for Weber, Char-Broil and Broil King grills.
- Fit first: each set names the grill models or part numbers it replaces.
- Dimensions stated on the page for five of the six picks, so you can measure before buying.
- No stainless rod grates here, to keep this list distinct from plain replacement sets.
- One universal adjustable grid and one griddle insert for grills the fit lists miss.
One boundary is worth stating: this guide does not repeat the stainless rod grate comparison from other grate coverage on the site. Stainless has its own strengths, but owners asking about cast iron usually want surface mass and sear marks, so every pick here is iron, enamel over iron, or an iron insert.
The best cooking grates for gas grills, pick by pick
Read the picks by the grill you own. Weber owners get two cast iron options split by grill generation, Char-Broil owners get a porcelain coated set with a long model list, and Broil King owners get a reversible grid. The last two picks solve the cases the brand lists leave out.
QuliMetal 17.5 inch Grill Grates
This cast iron set covers the largest group of Weber owners: the listing names the Spirit 300 and 400 series, the Spirit II 300 series, the Spirit 700, and the Genesis Silver and Gold B and C lines plus Genesis 1000-3500 grills. It is sold as the cast iron part for Weber numbers 7638 and 7639.
The size class is 17.5 inches, matching the standard Weber three burner layout of two grates side by side. Cast iron brings the mass that thin factory rods lack, so the surface holds heat when cold food lands on it. The trade off is spec depth: the listing page states the fit and the material, but no per grate dimensions or weight.
- Material: cast iron
- Size class: 17.5 inches
- Fits: Spirit 300/400, Spirit II 300, Spirit 700, Genesis Silver/Gold B and C, Genesis 1000-3500
- Replaces: Weber 7638 and 7639
Pros: a very wide Weber fit list and a true cast iron surface. Cons: the listing gives no exact per grate measurements, so comparing against your old grates is essential, and cast iron needs oiling to stay rust free.
The breadth of the fit list is the practical story: one set covers three burner Spirits, the older Genesis Silver and Gold lines, and the Genesis 1000-3500 family, which are the grills most often kept alive with new parts. If your grill has passed between owners, the part number route is the surest check, since badges and series names blur over the years.
Buy if your Weber matches the fit list and you want cast iron mass. Skip if your grill is a two burner Spirit, because this set is sized for the larger fireboxes.
Uniflasy 15 inch Cast Iron Grates
Older two burner Weber grills need a different size, and this pair covers them. The maker lists heavy duty cast iron, two grates per package, and a fit list of Spirit E210, E200, S200 and S210 from 2009-2012, the Genesis Silver A, and the Spirit 500, with side mounted controls as the layout.
Each grate measures 15 x 11-1/4 inches, and the pair spans 15 x 22-1/2 inches. The set replaces Weber part numbers 7522, 7523, 7521, 65904 and 65905. The maker also prints its care routine on the page: scrape after each use, brush with oil after each use, and cover the grill when it stands idle.
- Material: heavy duty cast iron
- Size: 15 x 11-1/4 inches each, 15 x 22-1/2 inches per pair
- Fits: Spirit E210, E200, S200, S210 (2009-2012), Genesis Silver A, Spirit 500
- Replaces: Weber 7522, 7523, 7521, 65904, 65905
Pros: exact dimensions are stated, the fit covers grills that newer sets skip, and care steps come from the maker. Cons: it fits side control models only, and bare cast iron asks for regular oiling.
There is an ownership angle here too: these older two burner grills are light, simple and cheap to keep, and a fresh pair of heavy grates is often the only part standing between one and several more seasons. The maker’s warning to double check dimensions and model before purchasing is worth following, because this generation spans several similar sizes.
Buy if you run an older side control Spirit and want to keep it cooking. Skip if your controls sit on the front panel, because the fit list does not cover those grills.
BBQMall Cast Iron Cooking Grates for Char-Broil
Char-Broil owners get the porcelain version of the same idea. The maker describes high quality porcelain coated cast iron, which pairs an iron core with an enamel surface, and lists a long run of Char-Broil models across the Advantage, Classic, Traditional and Performance 4 burner lines, plus Thermos 461442114.
Each unit measures 16-7/8 x 9-5/16 inches, and three units span 16-7/8 x 27-15/16 inches. The set replaces original part numbers including G432-1800-W1 and G432-0002-W1. Porcelain coating changes the care routine versus bare iron: the surface wipes clean more easily, but hard drops and metal scraping can chip enamel.
- Material: porcelain coated cast iron
- Size: 16-7/8 x 9-5/16 inches each, 16-7/8 x 27-15/16 inches for three
- Fits: Char-Broil Advantage, Classic, Traditional, Performance 4 burner models listed by the maker
- Replaces: G432-1800-W1, G432-0002-W1 and related numbers
Pros: enamel over iron, exact dimensions, and a deep model list. Cons: the model list is long and specific, so a near match is not a match, and enamel needs gentler tools than bare cast iron.
The three unit layout matters in daily use: with three narrower sections, one section can come out for cleaning or for a griddle swap without stripping the whole cooking surface. The maker also describes the grates as heating evenly and holding heat well enough to produce clear sear marks, which is the porcelain coated iron pitch in one line.
Buy if your Char-Broil model number appears on the maker’s list. Skip if it does not, even when the dimensions look close, because ledge fit decides whether a grate sits flat.
Broil King 11229 Replacement Cast Iron Cooking Grill
Broil King sells this grid the way its grills are built: one section at a time. Each grid measures 19.25 x 6 inches, and the maker lists heavy duty cast iron made for maximum heat retention. The fit covers the Regal series from 2010 and the Imperial series from 2009, and the grid replaces part 11229 among others.
The design point is the reversible face. One side is pointed and the maker says it gives excellent sear marks; the other side carries grease channels that run drippings to the end of the grid, and the maker suggests that side for chicken, fish and other juicy foods. Sold individually, it also suits owners replacing one damaged section.
- Material: heavy duty cast iron
- Size: 19.25 x 6 inches per grid
- Fits: Broil King Regal (2010 and newer), Imperial (2009 and newer)
- Design: reversible, pointed side and grease channel side
Pros: two cooking faces in one grid, sold singly for partial replacement, and an in stock listing. Cons: a full set costs several single purchases, and the narrow 6 inch width means layout planning when you mix old and new grids.
The reversible design also changes cleanup: the channel side gathers drippings and runs them to the end of the grid, so fatty cooks leave less grease baked across the whole surface. Flip to the pointed side for steaks and the same casting gives narrow, dark marks, which is why this grid reads as two products in one part number.
Buy if one or all of your Regal or Imperial grids have failed. Skip if your Broil King is an older Signet or Crown, because this part number does not list them.
Mustang Cast Iron Grid Universal
Some grills appear on no fit list at all, and this grid is built for them. The maker calls it a universal cast iron grid: the width is 30 cm, and the depth adjusts between 35 and 45.5 cm, so one grid covers a range of firebox depths that fixed grates cannot. The grid weighs 5.06 kg and carries product code 641509.
An adjustable grid trades exact fit for coverage. It will not lock into brand specific ledges the way a model matched set does, and one grid may not span a wide firebox alone. In return, owners of house brands, older imports and mixed part grills get a cast iron surface that fixed catalogs leave out.
- Material: cast iron
- Size: 30 cm wide, depth adjusts from 35 to 45.5 cm
- Weight: 5.06 kg
- Product code: 641509
Pros: adjustable depth, honest universal fit, and cast iron mass. Cons: sizing is in centimeters, the width is fixed at 30 cm, and wide grills may need two grids side by side.
At 5.06 kg, the grid has real iron weight for its size, which is what you want from a universal piece: it stays where you set it instead of sliding when a spatula presses down. The black finish and plain bar layout keep it neutral, so it suits the mixed fleet of grills that gather at cabins, rentals and second homes.
Buy if your grill matches no brand list and its firebox falls inside the stated range. Skip if an exact fit set exists for your model, because a matched set always sits better.
Napoleon Cast Iron Reversible Griddle 56425
The last pick is not a rod grate at all: it is a porcelain coated cast iron griddle that replaces one cooking grid section on a Napoleon Rogue 425, or sits on top of the grids. The maker lists a surface of 11 5/8 x 17 3/4 inches, a weight of 10 lbs and a height of 0.5 inch.
Napoleon states the griddle can replace the original cooking grids or rest on top of them, and the listing notes integrated holes that direct grease away from food. The maker warrants this product against defects in material and workmanship for two years. As a flat surface it handles eggs, onions and smash burgers that would fall through any rod grate.
- Material: porcelain coated cast iron
- Surface: 11 5/8 x 17 3/4 inches
- Weight: 10 lbs
- Fits: Napoleon Rogue 425 series
Pros: a true flat top on a gas grill, grid replacement or overlay use, and a stated two year warranty from the maker. Cons: it covers one section only, so the rest of the grill still needs sound grates, and it fits one Napoleon series.
Think of it as a section swap rather than a repair: pull one rod grid, drop the griddle in, and the grill gains a breakfast station while the remaining grids keep searing. The porcelain coating seasons like a cast iron pan according to the maker, and the listing notes the coating is non-stick in character, which suits eggs and other delicate foods.
Buy if breakfast and flat top cooking are what your Rogue 425 misses. Skip if you need full width rod grates, because this insert is a section, not a set.
Buying guide: cooking grates for gas grills
Replacement grates fail in two ways: they do not fit, or they fit and then rust, chip or warp within a season or two. The checks below attack both problems in order: measure the firebox, confirm the part number, choose the material for your care habits, and plan how many sections you need.
Measure before you match models
Model lists are long and grill generations overlap, so the tape measure settles arguments. Measure each old grate front to back and side to side, count the sections, and compare against the stated sizes here: 15 x 11-1/4 inches, 16-7/8 x 9-5/16 inches, 19.25 x 6 inches. A grate that is even slightly wide can rock on its ledges and cook unevenly.
Cast iron versus porcelain-enameled cast iron
Bare cast iron, like the Uniflasy and Broil King grids, holds heat hard and marks food deeply, and it asks for scraping and oiling after cooks. Porcelain-enameled cast iron, like the BBQMall set and the Napoleon insert, wipes clean faster and resists rust on the surface, but the enamel can chip if a grate is dropped or scraped with metal tools.
Rod layout and reversible faces
The cooking face shapes the result as much as the material. Pointed rods mark steaks with narrow lines, flat or channeled faces move grease away from the flame, and the Broil King grid puts one face on each side of the same casting. Match the face to your food: channels for fatty chicken, points for steaks, a flat insert for eggs and onions.
Sections, sets and partial replacement
Grills divide their cooking area into sections, and makers sell them both ways. The Weber and Char-Broil picks come as full sets, while Broil King sells the 11229 one grid at a time. Partial replacement saves money when one section fails early, but mixing a new heavy grid with worn thin ones can leave an uneven surface across the grill.
Care that keeps iron alive
Seasoning deserves one clarification: on bare cast iron, a thin coat of oil heated on the grate builds the dark layer that food releases from, and the first few cooks on a new set may stick a little until that layer forms. Preheating fully and oiling the food, not just the grate, carries most cooks through that break in period without trouble.
Iron grates die from neglect more than from heat. The Uniflasy maker prints the routine plainly: scrape the grates after each use, season them by brushing with oil after each use, and cover the grill when it is not in use. Add one habit for enamel: let coated grates cool before washing, so the coating is not shocked by cold water.
FAQ
These answers cover the questions that come up when factory grates wear out: how to confirm fit, how long cast iron lasts, and how a griddle insert compares with a full grate set. Each answer stays with the figures and fit lists the makers state for the products above.
How do I know a grate set fits my grill?
Match three things: the model name, the part number it replaces, and the measured size of your old grates. The sets here replace named numbers, from Weber 7638 and 7522 to Char-Broil G432-1800-W1 and Broil King 11229. When all three agree, fit is as certain as replacement parts get; when any one disagrees, keep looking.
Start by taking the old grates out and reading any stamped numbers on the frame or in the grill manual, because those numbers outrank series names. Badges fade and series names repeat across decades, but a part number points at one firebox size and one ledge layout.
Are cooking grates for gas grills worth upgrading to cast iron?
For most owners, yes. Cast iron adds surface mass, so the grate stays hot when food lands and marks it instead of steaming it. The cost is care: iron needs oil and a covered grill. Porcelain-enameled cast iron splits the difference, keeping most of the mass while asking less after each cook.
Can one damaged section be replaced alone?
Sometimes. Broil King sells the 11229 grid individually for exactly that case, and the Napoleon griddle replaces a single grid section on the Rogue 425. Set based grills are less flexible: the Weber and Char-Broil picks here are sold as matched sets, so one failed grate usually means replacing the set.
How long do cast iron grates last?
Cast iron is the longest lived grate material in this guide when it is kept oiled and dry, because the metal itself does not wear out in home use; rust and neglect end more iron grates than heat does. Porcelain enamel shifts the weak point from the metal to the coating on top of it.
The iron under enamel can outlast the enamel by years, so gentle tools and no sudden cold water on a hot grate are the habits that stretch its life. With bare iron, the routine is the one the Uniflasy maker prints: scrape after each use, brush with oil, and keep the grill covered between cooks.
What size is a universal grate?
Universal grates adjust instead of matching one model. The Mustang grid in this guide is 30 cm wide with a depth that adjusts between 35 and 45.5 cm. Measure your firebox depth before ordering: inside that range the grid adapts, and outside it no adjustment will make the fit right.
Conclusion
Match the fit list first and the material second: QuliMetal or Uniflasy for Weber grills by generation, BBQMall for Char-Broil, Broil King 11229 for Regal and Imperial grids, Mustang when no list names your grill, and the Napoleon insert for flat top cooking. Measure your old grates before ordering any of them, because fit decides everything here.