Key takeaways
- Find air filters that fit Maytag furnace cabinets, with the right size and MERV rating for your home. Compare seven pleated and media filters and sizing tips.
A Maytag furnace only works well with a filter that matches its cabinet, so the wrong size or a rating the blower cannot handle can leave gaps and weak airflow. The best air filters for Maytag furnace owners pair a listed Maytag size with a MERV rating suited to the home, and this guide compares seven such filters.
Quick verdict
For most Maytag furnace owners, the Filterbuy 16x25x5 MERV 11 gives the most useful middle ground, with a listed Maytag cabinet size and a rating that covers dust, pollen, and pet dander. Homes that need lighter airflow can step down to a MERV 8 model, while a MERV 13 model suits homes that want finer capture.
Start with size, then pick a MERV rating. A filter that does not sit squarely in the slot lets air pass around the media. The picks below cover the common Maytag cabinet sizes of 16x22x5, 16x25x5, 20x20x5, 20x25x5, and 24x25x5, plus 1-inch slot sizes for homes with a standard return.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Filterbuy 20x20x5 MERV 8 Dust Defense | Pleated 5-inch | Basic dust control | MERV 8, traps 90 percent of dust particles | Lightest capture in this set |
| Filterbuy 20x20x5 MERV 13 Health Defense | Pleated 5-inch | Finer particle capture | MERV 13, traps 98 percent of dust particles | Highest airflow demand here |
| Filterbuy 16x25x5 MERV 11 Pet and Allergy Defense | Pleated 5-inch | Pets and everyday allergens | MERV 11, traps 95 percent of dust particles | Actual size varies by cabinet variant |
| Filtrete 16x25x1 MPR 1500 MERV 12 | Pleated 1-inch | Standard 1-inch slots | MERV 12, MPR 1500, 3-month filter life | Shorter life than 5-inch media filters |
| Nordic Pure 16x25x1 MERV 12 | Pleated 1-inch | Standard 1-inch slots | MERV 12, change every 3 to 6 months | Actual size not stated on the page read |
| Honeywell Home FC100A1029 MERV 11 | Media cabinet filter | Honeywell 16×25 media cabinets | MERV 11, lasts up to 1 year | Fits a media cabinet, not a bare slot |
| Filterbuy 24x25x5 MERV 8 Dust and Allergy Defense | Pleated 5-inch | Large cabinets, basic dust control | MERV 8, traps 90 percent of dust particles | Lightest capture in this set |
How we selected the best air filters for Maytag furnace systems
Selection started from the sizes listed for Maytag cabinets on the maker page for Maytag replacement filters, then matched each size to a filter with a stated MERV rating and actual size. Only filters with published specifications on pages read during research were kept in the set.
The set covers the full range of needs rather than a single rating. MERV 8 models cover basic dust control, MERV 11 and MERV 12 models cover the middle ground for homes with pets, and MERV 13 models cover finer capture. Both 1-inch pleated filters and 5-inch media filters were included, because Maytag systems appear with both kinds of housing. A media cabinet filter was included for homes whose Maytag furnace is paired with a Honeywell 16×25 media air cleaner cabinet.
Claims in this guide are quoted as maker descriptions, not as independent findings. Where a maker states a capture figure, the figure is given with the maker as the source of the claim. Where a page does not state a fact, such as an actual size, the guide says so instead of filling in a number. No filter here is described as made by Maytag or approved by Maytag, because no opened page states that.
Seven filters that fit Maytag furnace systems
Each filter below is listed with the size it fits, the MERV rating the maker states, and the limits that matter most in daily use. Read the size on your old filter first, then compare it with the actual size given for each pick, since nominal sizes on the box are rounded and actual sizes run smaller.
Filterbuy 20x20x5 MERV 8 Dust Defense
This Filterbuy model is a pleated 5-inch filter in a size the maker lists for Maytag cabinets, and it suits homes that want basic dust control without adding much airflow demand. Its MERV 8 synthetic media is the lightest rating in this set, which makes it a sensible starting point for older systems and for homes without pets.
The maker lists the nominal size as 20x20x5 and the actual size as 20.25 inches by 20.75 inches by 5.25 inches. The maker describes the MERV 8 synthetic media as comparable with Clean Living Dust Defense MPR 700 and FPR 5, and states that it can trap 90 percent of dust particles while guarding the home from lint, pollen, mold, dander, and other debris. It is sold as a 2-pack. Note that the maker page for Maytag filters lists a 20x20x5 size with a different actual size for another cabinet variant, so read the frame of the old filter before ordering.
- Pros: listed Maytag size, low airflow demand, deep 5-inch media.
- Cons: lightest capture in this set, actual size varies by cabinet variant.
- Buy if: the home needs basic dust control and the system runs best with a light filter.
- Skip if: the home has heavy pet dander or the owner wants finer capture.
Filterbuy 20x20x5 MERV 13 Health Defense
This Filterbuy model uses the same 20x20x5 cabinet size as the MERV 8 model above, but with the highest rating in this set, so it suits homes that want the finest capture a pleated 5-inch filter can offer. The deep media gives the higher rating more surface area than a 1-inch filter, which helps it hold dust over a longer service life.
The maker lists the nominal size as 20x20x5 and the actual size as 20.25 inches by 20.75 inches by 5.25 inches. The maker describes the MERV 13 synthetic media as comparable with MPR 1900 and FPR 10, and states that it can trap 98 percent of dust particles. It is sold as a 3-pack. A MERV 13 filter adds more resistance than a MERV 8 filter, so read the furnace manual and the blower setting before moving up to this rating.
- Pros: finest capture in this set, same Maytag cabinet size as the MERV 8 model, deep media.
- Cons: highest airflow demand here, needs a system that can handle a MERV 13 rating.
- Buy if: the home wants the finest capture and the system is rated for MERV 13 filters.
- Skip if: the furnace is older or the manual calls for a lower MERV rating.
Filterbuy 16x25x5 MERV 11 Pet and Allergy Defense
This Filterbuy model is the middle rating in the Maytag cabinet range, and it suits homes with pets or everyday airborne particles that a MERV 8 filter would miss. It is a 5-inch pleated filter, so it carries far more media than a 1-inch filter in the same cabinet opening, and the maker lists it in the size most often linked with Maytag cabinets.
The maker lists the Maytag cabinet version at a nominal size of 16x25x5 and an actual size of 15 and 3 eighths inches by 25 and 1 half inches by 5 and 1 quarter inches, and states that it is designed to fit the M1-1056 cabinet. The maker describes the MERV 11 media as filtering pollen, dust mites, mold, auto emissions, and large particles like milled flour. The maker also states that the MERV 11 media can trap 95 percent of dust particles, uses 8 pleats per foot, and should be replaced every 90 days for best results, with frames that endure temperatures up to 200 degrees Fahrenheit. It is sold as a 2-pack.
- Pros: middle rating for most homes, listed Maytag cabinet fit, deep media, strong frame.
- Cons: actual size differs between cabinet variants, 90-day change routine.
- Buy if: the home has pets and the cabinet takes a 16x25x5 filter.
- Skip if: the cabinet takes a different size or the system needs a lighter rating.
Filtrete 16x25x1 MPR 1500 MERV 12
This Filtrete model is a 1-inch pleated filter for homes whose Maytag furnace uses a standard 1-inch slot rather than a media cabinet. It suits owners who want a higher rating in a slim filter, and its MERV 12 rating sits just below the MERV 13 models while keeping the familiar 1-inch form that most return grilles accept.
The maker lists the nominal size as 16x25x1, with an overall thickness of 1 inch, and describes the filter as a 3-month pleated 1-inch home HVAC filter. The maker states a MERV rating of 12 and an MPR rating of 1500, and describes the filter as built with exclusive Filtrete 3-in-1 technology from 3M. The maker states 54 percent small particle capture for bacteria and particles that carry viruses, based on ASHRAE 52.2 testing for 0.3 to 1 micron particles, and states that the filter should be changed at least every 90 days, with a filter life of 3 months. The maker does not state the actual size on the pages read, so measure the old filter before ordering.
- Pros: high rating in a 1-inch filter, widely sold size, clear 90-day change routine.
- Cons: shorter life than 5-inch media filters, actual size not stated on the pages read.
- Buy if: the furnace takes a 1-inch filter and the owner wants MERV 12 capture.
- Skip if: the home has a 5-inch media cabinet or the system needs a lighter rating.
Nordic Pure 16x25x1 MERV 12
This Nordic Pure model is another 1-inch pleated filter in the common 16x25x1 size, and it suits homes that want a MERV 12 rating with a longer change window than the Filtrete model above. Its frame and support grid are built for repeated handling, which matters when a filter sits in a return grille that gets opened every few months.
The maker lists the nominal size as 16x25x1 and the MERV rating as 12. The maker describes the filter as made with MERV rated synthetic poly blend pleated media and electrostatically charged synthetic materials, with a heavy-duty, moisture-resistant beverage board frame and a metal mesh support grid. The maker states that the filter is made in the USA and recommends changing it every 3 to 6 months to help maximize performance. The maker describes the MERV 12 media as designed to capture dust, pollen, mold spores, pet dander, and finer particles like smoke and smog. It is sold as a 4-pack.
- Pros: MERV 12 rating, sturdy frame and mesh grid, 3 to 6 month change window.
- Cons: actual size not stated on the page read, 1-inch depth holds less dust than 5-inch media.
- Buy if: the furnace takes a 1-inch filter and the owner wants a longer change window.
- Skip if: the home has a 5-inch media cabinet or the system needs a lighter rating.
Honeywell Home FC100A1029 MERV 11
This Honeywell Home model is a media cabinet filter rather than a slot filter, and it suits homes whose Maytag furnace is paired with a Honeywell 16×25 media air cleaner cabinet. It is the pick for owners who already have that cabinet and want a genuine replacement part with a known part number, instead of guessing at a generic size.
The maker lists the model as FC100A1029, with a MERV rating of 11 and a nominal size of 16x25x4, and notes that some stores call the same filter a 16x25x5 because the actual depth is more than 4 inches. The actual size is 15 and 15 sixteenths inches by 24 and 7 eighths inches by 4 and 3 eighths inches. The maker states that it is made for Honeywell 16×25 F100 and F200 media air cleaners, that each filter can last up to a year, and that it is sold as 5 filters per box. The maker describes it as catching household dust, pollen, pet dander, mould spores, and dust mite debris, and notes an airflow arrow on the side that shows the direction of air travel toward the furnace or blower.
- Pros: genuine replacement part number, MERV 11 rating, lasts up to 1 year.
- Cons: fits a media cabinet only, nominal size naming varies by store.
- Buy if: the home has a Honeywell 16×25 F100 or F200 media cabinet on a Maytag furnace.
- Skip if: the furnace has a bare 1-inch slot or a different cabinet size.
Filterbuy 24x25x5 MERV 8 Dust and Allergy Defense
This Filterbuy model is the largest cabinet size in this set, and it suits homes with a big Maytag furnace cabinet that takes a 24x25x5 filter. It is a basic MERV 8 pleated filter, so it keeps airflow demand low while the deep 5-inch media gives it far more surface area than a 1-inch filter of the same face size.
The maker lists the nominal size as 24x25x5 and the actual size as 23.63 inches by 24.69 inches by 4.25 inches. The maker describes the MERV 8 synthetic media as comparable with Clean Living Dust Defense MPR 700 and FPR 5, and states that it can trap 90 percent of dust particles while guarding the home from lint, pollen, mold, dander, and other debris. The maker also states that the filter uses 8 pleats per foot, should be replaced every 90 days for best results, and has beverage board frames with dual wire backings that endure temperatures up to 200 degrees Fahrenheit. The maker lists Maytag among the compatible models for this filter. It is sold as a 1-pack.
- Pros: listed Maytag compatibility, large deep media, low airflow demand.
- Cons: lightest capture in this set, sold as a single filter, needs a large cabinet.
- Buy if: the cabinet takes a 24x25x5 filter and the home needs basic dust control.
- Skip if: the cabinet is smaller or the owner wants finer particle capture.
Buying guide: best air filters for Maytag furnace fit
A good filter choice starts with the cabinet, not with the rating. The size on the old filter frame, the depth of the slot, and the blower rating in the furnace manual decide which filters are even in play, and only then does the MERV rating narrow the field.
Match the size printed on your old filter
The surest way to get the right size is to pull the old filter out and read the numbers printed on its frame, since the nominal size on the box is rounded and the actual size runs smaller. A nominal 20x20x5 filter lists an actual size of 20.25 inches by 20.75 inches by 5.25 inches on one maker page.
Measure the old filter with a tape measure if the print is worn or hard to read, and write down all three numbers: width, height, and depth. Compare those numbers with the actual size stated for the new filter, not just the nominal size, since two filters with the same nominal size can differ in actual size by cabinet variant. A filter that is too small leaves gaps at the edges, and air that passes around the media does no good at all.
Choose a MERV rating your system can handle
MERV stands for Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value, and the scale runs from low numbers that catch large dust to high numbers that catch finer particles. A MERV 8 filter covers basic dust, lint, and pollen, a MERV 11 or MERV 12 filter adds finer particles such as pet dander and mold spores, and a MERV 13 filter adds the finest capture in this set.
Read the furnace manual or the label inside the cabinet before moving up a rating, since some systems list a maximum MERV rating and older blowers can struggle with dense media. A 5-inch media filter handles a high rating more easily than a 1-inch filter, because the deeper pleats give the air more surface area to pass through.
Read the change interval and set a reminder
Every filter in this guide states a change interval, and the interval varies widely by depth and rating. A 1-inch pleated filter lists a life of 3 months, with a change at least every 90 days, while a Nordic Pure 1-inch model lists a change every 3 to 6 months, and a Honeywell media cabinet filter lists a life of up to 1 year.
Set a reminder on the day a new filter goes in, and write the install date on the frame if the filter has a space for it. Homes with pets, renovation dust, or heavy system use fill a filter sooner, so a quick look at the media each month is worth the effort.
Look at pleat count and frame build
Pleats give a filter its surface area, and more pleats per foot means more media packed into the same frame. The Filterbuy models in this guide list 8 pleats per foot, with electrostatically charged synthetic media that the maker describes as trapping more particles than plain fiberglass.
Look for a beverage board frame with a wire backing, which the makers in this guide describe as stronger than plain cardboard and able to endure temperatures up to 200 degrees Fahrenheit while resisting moisture. A metal mesh support grid, as listed on the Nordic Pure model, adds the same kind of stiffness.
Plan for pets, dust, and heavy use
Homes with pets, heavy foot traffic, or dusty work nearby load a filter faster than a quiet home with no pets, so the change routine should match the home rather than the box alone. A MERV 11 or MERV 12 filter is a common middle step for pet owners, since the maker descriptions for those ratings cover pet dander along with dust and pollen.
Keep a spare filter on the shelf so a dirty one can be swapped the same day it is found, and buy the next pack before the last spare goes in. A multi-pack, such as a 2-pack, 3-pack, 4-pack, or 5-pack, makes this easy and keeps the size and rating consistent from change to change.
FAQ: best air filters for Maytag furnace
These questions cover the sizing, rating, and change routine issues that come up most often when buying a filter for a Maytag furnace. Each answer sticks to the sizes and ratings stated on the pages read for this guide, and to general practice where no maker states a figure.
What size filter does a Maytag furnace use?
There is no single size for every Maytag furnace, since the cabinet size varies by model and by the filter housing fitted with it. The maker page for Maytag replacement filters lists 16x22x5, 16x25x5, 20x20x5, 20x25x5, and 24x25x5 sizes, with MERV 8, MERV 11, and MERV 13 options.
Pull the old filter and read the size printed on its frame, then match the actual size stated for the new filter.
Can I use a thicker filter in a 1-inch slot?
No, a 5-inch filter does not fit a 1-inch slot, and a 1-inch filter does not fill a 5-inch media cabinet correctly. The depth of the slot or cabinet decides the thickness, and the filter must sit flat with its frame sealed against the housing on all four sides.
Homes with a 1-inch slot should use a 1-inch pleated filter in the right face size, such as 16x25x1, while homes with a media cabinet should use the media filter made for that cabinet, such as a 16x25x5 or a 16x25x4 cabinet filter.
What does MERV mean on a furnace filter?
MERV stands for Minimum Efficiency Reporting Value, a scale that rates how well a filter captures particles of different sizes. Low numbers cover large dust and lint, middle numbers add pollen, pet dander, and mold spores, and high numbers add finer particles such as smoke and bacteria-sized particles.
The filters in this guide run from MERV 8 to MERV 13, with MERV 11 and MERV 12 in the middle. A higher MERV number means finer capture, but it also means more resistance to airflow, so the rating should be matched to what the furnace manual allows.
How often should I change a furnace filter?
The interval depends on the filter depth and the home, and the makers in this guide give a spread of answers. A 1-inch pleated filter lists a life of 3 months, with a change at least every 90 days, a Nordic Pure 1-inch model lists a change every 3 to 6 months, and a Honeywell media cabinet filter lists a life of up to 1 year.
Check the media monthly and change the filter when it looks loaded, even if the calendar says it has time left.
Does a higher MERV rating always work better?
No, a higher MERV rating only works better when the system can move air through it without strain. A MERV 13 filter captures finer particles than a MERV 8 filter, but it also adds resistance, and an older blower or a small return can struggle with that extra load.
The best rating is the highest one the furnace manual allows for the filter depth in use. A 5-inch media filter handles a high rating more easily than a 1-inch filter, since the deep pleats spread the air over more surface area.
Conclusion
Start with the size on the old filter, pick a MERV rating the furnace can handle, and favor a deep media filter when the cabinet allows it. For most Maytag furnace owners, the Filterbuy 16x25x5 MERV 11 is the sound middle pick for most homes, with MERV 8 and MERV 13 models covering lighter and finer needs.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!