Key takeaways
- Compare five analog mixers for live sound: 14 to 22 channels, swept-mid EQ, subgroups, built-in effects and USB recording for bands and venues of most sizes.
Live sound rewards a board that an engineer can run by touch in a dark room: real faders, honest preamps and enough sends for monitors. These analog mixers for live sound cover 14 to 22 channels, most pair swept-mid EQ with subgroups, and they add effects or USB recording where the format allows it best.
Quick verdict: analog mixers for live sound
The Allen & Heath ZED-22FX is the strongest all-round live board here, with 16 preamps, long faders and tap-tempo effects. The Yamaha MG20XU matches it on inputs and adds the best USB spec, the Mackie 1604VLZ4 is the purist 4-bus choice, and the Peavey PV 14 BT packs Bluetooth and media playback.
| Model | Channels | Mic preamps | Bus structure | Effects | USB audio | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allen & Heath ZED-22FX | 22 | 16 DuoPre | 4 aux sends | 16 built-in effects | USB stereo in/out | 23.1 lb |
| Yamaha MG20XU | 20 | Up to 16 D-PRE | 4 group buses, 4 AUX | SPX, 24 programs | 2-in/2-out, 24-bit/192 kHz | 15.7 lb (7.1 kg) |
| Behringer Xenyx X2222USB | 22 | 8 XENYX | 2 subgroups, 3 aux sends | 16 editable presets | 2-in/2-out, 16-bit/48 kHz | 11.2 lb (5.1 kg) |
| Mackie 1604VLZ4 | 16 | 16 Onyx | 4 subgroups, 8 direct outputs | None built in | None | 20.0 lb |
| Peavey PV 14 BT | 14 | 8 combo inputs | 1 pre-fader aux send | Digital effects with LCD | USB-B streaming, 16-bit/48 kHz | Not stated |
The honest split in this group is philosophy. Three boards build effects and USB into the desk, the Mackie leaves both out and spends everything on preamps and routing, and the Peavey aims at small stages that need playback and streaming more than they need a second monitor mix.
How we selected these analog boards
Every board here was verified on an opened product or maker page, and every figure in the entries below comes from those pages. We required a minimum of eight microphone inputs on most models, channel inserts or subgroups for real live routing, and at least one monitor send, because those are the features a working band actually uses.
EQ quality drove much of the shortlist. A swept or semi-parametric mid band is the tool that fixes a boxy vocal or a ringing guitar in a live room, so boards offering one ranked ahead of fixed three-band designs. We also recorded preamp gain range and noise figures where the pages state them, since a quiet stage with dynamic microphones exposes weak preamps quickly.
We treated headline channel counts with suspicion. A 22-channel board with eight mic preamps is an eight-microphone mixer for band purposes, so the table lists the true preamp count for every model. Stereo channels still matter for keyboards and playback, but they do not help a singer, and the entries say which is which.
Effects and USB were scored as live tools, not studio features. Tap tempo matters when a delay has to follow the band, a footswitch input matters when the singer runs the desk, and a stereo USB feed matters for recording the show or playing walk-in music from a laptop. Boards that skip those extras had to win on routing or preamps instead.
The mixers in detail
Five analog boards follow, from the largest live desks down to the compact media-friendly option. Each entry states who it suits, the specifications that matter on a stage, and the limits a buyer accepts, drawn only from the pages opened for this guide and the notes recorded with them during research.
Allen & Heath ZED-22FX: the most complete live board here
The ZED-22FX suits a band or venue that wants one analog desk to cover almost everything: 16 microphone inputs, long-throw faders, a proper effects section and inserts on every mono channel. It is the board in this group that a guest engineer can walk up to and run without a manual or a learning period.
The mixer has 22 channels: 16 mono mic/line channels and 3 dual stereo channels. Sixteen DuoPre preamps offer a 69 dB gain range, the widest stated here. Mono channels carry a 3-band EQ with swept mid, stereo channels a 2-band EQ. Sixteen built-in effects include delay, reverb, ping-pong delay, flanger and chorus, five with tap tempo and adjustable parameters, and four aux sends cover monitors and effects.
Channel inserts on channels 1-16 accept outboard compressors or gates, a high-pass filter and global 48V phantom power cover the input stage, and the configurable USB stereo in/out can send from the LR mix or the aux buses for recording. Main outputs are 2 x XLR plus a mono TRS. The board measures 25.4 x 18.3 x 3.9 inches and weighs 23.1 lb, the heaviest here, and Cakewalk SONAR LE is bundled.
The 100 mm faders are the working detail that matters at a show. Small rides on a vocal stay smooth instead of jumpy, and the swept mid lets the engineer notch the one frequency a room keeps feeding back. The trade is size: at over 25 inches wide this is a desk for a fixed booth or a serious band trailer, not a carry-on rig.
- Pros: 16 preamps with 69 dB gain range; 100 mm faders; inserts on all mono channels; tap-tempo effects
- Cons: heaviest board here; USB is stereo only; stereo channels get 2-band EQ
- Buy if: one desk must handle full bands, guest engineers and regular recording
- Skip if: the rig has to travel light every night
Yamaha MG20XU: sixteen inputs and the best USB spec
The MG20XU fits a venue or band that records as seriously as it performs. It matches the ZED on microphone count, adds group buses and one-knob compression, and its USB interface runs at 24-bit/192 kHz, the strongest recording specification in this group by a clear margin on paper.
Yamaha lists 20 channels with a maximum of 16 mic and 20 line inputs: 12 mono combo XLR/TRS channels plus 4 stereo channels that each carry an XLR mic input. D-PRE Class-A preamps use an inverted Darlington circuit, with gain trim from +20 dB to +64 dB, a 26 dB PAD on channels 1-12 and +48V phantom power. Equivalent input noise is -128 dBu. Four group buses and one stereo bus organize the mix, with 4 AUX sends, the fourth shared with the effects.
The SPX effects section holds 24 programs with a PARAMETER knob and an FC5 foot switch input. Mono channels carry a 3-band EQ with sweepable mid from 250 Hz to 5 kHz, an 80 Hz high-pass filter, and 1-knob compressors on channels 1-8. Cubase AI is included by download and a rack-mount kit comes in the box. Dimensions are 444 x 130 x 500 mm, weight is 15.7 lb (7.1 kg), and the internal supply draws 36 W.
For a working band the group buses earn their place: drums on one group, backing vocals on another, and the lead vocal straight to the mains gives the engineer three faders that shape the whole show balance. The shared AUX 4 and effects send is the compromise to plan around when the band wants three wedge mixes and reverb at once.
- Pros: 16 mic inputs; 24-bit/192 kHz USB; group buses; compressors on 8 channels
- Cons: fourth aux is shared with effects; no channel inserts listed; stereo channels share the mic inputs
- Buy if: the show gets recorded every night and the band is mid-sized
- Skip if: you need inserts on every channel for outboard dynamics
Behringer Xenyx X2222USB: twenty-two inputs, eight preamps
The X2222USB is the value route to a big channel count: 22 inputs for bands with several stereo keyboards, playback rigs and guest spots. Eight microphone channels with one-knob compressors cover the core band, and two subgroups keep the mix manageable for one engineer running a busy stage.
Behringer lists 8 mono and 4 stereo channels, with 8 XENYX mic preamps offering +10 to +60 dB of gain, +48V phantom power and a stated 130 dB dynamic range. Mono channels carry a 3-band British EQ with a semi-parametric mid sweeping 100 Hz to 8 kHz, low at 80 Hz and high at 12 kHz, plus channel inserts. Stereo channels carry a 4-band EQ. Three aux sends per channel split into one pre fader, one pre/post switchable and one post fader.
The 24-bit Multi-FX processor holds 16 editable presets covering reverb, chorus, flanger, delay, pitch shifter and multi-effects, with a tap function. Three stereo aux returns bring effects back without eating channels. The USB interface is 2-in/2-out at 16-bit/48 kHz, main outputs are XLR and 1/4 inch, and 60 mm faders run the desk. It measures 16.9 x 3.5 x 14 inches, weighs 11.2 lb (5.1 kg) and includes rackmount brackets.
The light weight is the touring argument: at about half the ZED-22FX’s weight it rides in a rack or a gig bag far more easily, and the rack brackets make a permanent small-venue install tidy. The shorter 60 mm faders and the 16-bit USB are where the savings show, so engineers who ride vocals all night should weigh that trade honestly.
- Pros: 22 inputs; lightest full-size board here; semi-parametric mid EQ; subgroups with separate outputs
- Cons: only eight mic preamps; USB audio is 16-bit; 60 mm faders
- Buy if: stereo sources multiply and the budget is firm
- Skip if: the band needs more than eight microphones
Mackie 1604VLZ4: the purist four-bus workhorse
The 1604VLZ4 is the board for an engineer who owns outboard gear and trusts it more than built-in extras. There are no effects and no USB here at all. What the money buys instead is sixteen full Onyx preamp channels, four subgroups, eight direct outputs and a control room matrix built for serious routing.
All 16 channels carry an Onyx mic preamp, a line input and a balanced insert. The preamps offer a 60 dB gain range, 128.5 dB dynamic range and an EIN of -128.5 dBu with a 150 ohm termination, with distortion under 0.0007 percent from mic in to insert send. Every channel has a 3-band EQ: high shelf at 12 kHz, a mid peak sweeping 100 Hz to 8 kHz, and a low shelf at 80 Hz, each plus or minus 15 dB, plus an 18 dB/octave 75 Hz low-cut filter.
Routing is the point of this desk: 4 subgroups with group outputs, 8 direct outputs on channels 1-8 for multitrack recording to an external interface, 4 stereo returns, and a control room and phones source matrix. Phantom power is available on all channels. The steel chassis is rack-mountable with sealed rotary controls, dimensions are 17 x 17.3 x 5.1 inches, and weight is 20.0 lb.
For a venue with a house outboard rack, this layout is still hard to beat: compressors patch into the inserts, the house effects return on the stereo returns, and the direct outputs feed a recording rig without touching the live mix. Buyers starting from zero should note the real system cost, because the effects and interface the other boards include must be bought separately here.
- Pros: 16 full preamp channels; direct outputs for multitrack; inserts everywhere; strong noise figures
- Cons: no built-in effects; no USB; aux-send count not stated on the opened listing page
- Buy if: outboard gear and multitrack recording are already part of the rig
- Skip if: you want effects and recording inside the desk
Peavey PV 14 BT: playback and streaming for small stages
The PV 14 BT aims at the small stage that plays tracks as often as it plays live: Bluetooth streaming, USB media playback and a Hi-Z guitar input sit alongside eight microphone channels. It is the compact, media-first option in this group, built for solo acts, duos and small rooms rather than full bands.
Peavey lists 14 channels with 8 combination XLR/1/4 inch low-noise mic preamps. A selectable high-pass filter covers the first 8 inputs, a 3-band EQ covers all channels, MidMorph EQ shapes 8 channels, and an EQ bypass is available per channel. Four channels carry built-in compression. Individual channel mutes and Listen/Solo, LED clip and signal indication, and 8 direct outputs round out the channel section.
Channel 9/10 is a stereo input on 1/4 inch, RCA or 3.5 mm, and the media section adds Bluetooth 3.0 with A2DP, USB-A playback of MP3 and WAV files, and stereo USB-B streaming audio in and out at 16-bit up to 48 kHz. Built-in digital effects show on an LCD display, KOSMOS processing adds bass and treble enhancement, and the main stereo outputs sit on 1/4 inch unbalanced and balanced XLR. One pre-fader AUX send feeds a monitor, 60 mm faders run the desk, and a tablet cradle is built in.
The single aux send is the hard limit: one monitor mix is all the stage gets, so a band that needs separate wedges should look at the other four boards. Dimensions are 16.1875 inches wide, 17.3 deep and 2.1875 high. The opened page states only a packed weight, so the unit weight is left unstated here rather than guessed.
- Pros: Bluetooth and USB media playback; compression on 4 channels; direct outputs; tablet cradle
- Cons: one aux send only; unit weight not stated on the opened page; smallest channel count here
- Buy if: tracks, streaming and a guitar plug straight into the desk
- Skip if: the band needs two or more monitor mixes
Buying guide: picking analog mixers for live sound
Start with the stage plot, not the brochure: count microphones, stereo sources and monitor mixes on your busiest night. The sections below turn those counts into the five decisions that separate these boards, from preamp counts to the fader length your hands will live with for years.
Mic preamps decide the real size
The ZED-22FX and MG20XU each take 16 microphones, the 1604VLZ4 takes 16 with inserts on all of them, while the X2222USB and PV 14 BT take 8. A board’s headline channel count includes stereo line channels that cannot help a singer. Match the preamp count to your largest lineup, then add one spare for a guest or a failure.
Aux sends are monitor mixes
Every distinct wedge or in-ear mix needs its own pre-fader aux send. The ZED-22FX offers 4 aux sends and the MG20XU offers 4 AUX sends with one shared with effects, while the PV 14 BT offers a single pre-fader send. Bands where the drummer and the lead singer want different worlds need at least two, and three is comfortable.
Swept mids fix live rooms
A fixed mid band guesses; a swept mid finds the problem. The ZED-22FX sweeps its mono mids, the MG20XU sweeps from 250 Hz to 5 kHz, the 1604VLZ4 sweeps from 100 Hz to 8 kHz, and the X2222USB uses a semi-parametric mid over the same wide range. In rooms with hard walls, that single control does more for clarity than any effect.
Effects: built in or outboard
Built-in effects travel with the desk and recall with it: 16 presets on the ZED-22FX and X2222USB, 24 SPX programs on the MG20XU. The 1604VLZ4 takes the other path, offering inserts and returns so a house rack does the work. Choose built-in for a portable rig, outboard for a fixed venue that already owns the gear.
USB recording, honestly assessed
Every USB link here is stereo, so all of them record the main mix, not separate tracks. The MG20XU records at 24-bit/192 kHz, the X2222USB and PV 14 BT at 16-bit/48 kHz, and the ZED-22FX sends a configurable stereo feed. For true multitrack, the 1604VLZ4’s eight direct outputs into a separate interface are the only route in this group.
FAQ: analog mixers for live sound questions
Buyers comparing analog boards ask the same handful of questions: whether analog still makes sense beside digital desks, how many aux sends a band really needs, what subgroups do at a show, and whether a stereo USB feed is enough for recording a live performance.
Is analog still a sensible choice for live sound?
For a fixed band or venue, yes. An analog desk boots instantly, every control is visible at a glance, and a guest engineer needs no scene files or app. What you give up is recall: settings live where the knobs sit. The five boards here trade that recall for direct control, and three of them add effects and USB to close the gap.
How many aux sends does a band need?
One per monitor mix, plus one if effects are sent from an aux. A four-piece sharing one wedge mix can live with the PV 14 BT’s single send, but most bands land on two or three monitor mixes, which points to the ZED-22FX or MG20XU with four sends each. In-ear systems count the same way: a stereo in-ear mix still starts as aux sends.
What do subgroups actually do at a show?
They gather related channels under one fader: drums, backing vocals, or the whole band against the lead vocal. The MG20XU and 1604VLZ4 each provide four subgroups, the X2222USB provides two with separate outputs. During a show, one group fader move rebalances the band in a second, which is far calmer than chasing eight channel faders.
Can these boards record a full show?
As a stereo mix, yes: the MG20XU, X2222USB, ZED-22FX and PV 14 BT all send the main mix to a computer or, on the Peavey, stream and play media directly. As separate tracks, only the 1604VLZ4 helps, through its eight direct outputs into an interface you supply. Decide which kind of recording you mean before choosing.
Conclusion
The ZED-22FX is the most complete analog live board here, the MG20XU is its match for venues that record, and the 1604VLZ4 remains the purist routing desk. The X2222USB stretches a budget across 22 inputs, while the PV 14 BT serves small stages built around playback. Match preamps and sends to your stage, and the choice makes itself.