Key takeaways
- Compare six analog mixers with FX on published specs: Lexicon, SPX, GigFX+, and KLARK TEKNIK engines, preset counts from 12 to 100, direct outs, and limits.
An analog mixer with built-in FX keeps reverb and delay where your hands already are, on the desk. This guide compares analog mixers with fx whose makers state the effects engine on the product page itself, from 12 editable presets to a 100-preset library, so the FX section can be judged beside channels, EQ, and routing.
Quick verdict
Six analog desks make the cut, and they split by how each one handles effects. The Soundcraft FX16ii and EFX8 build around Lexicon processors with storable settings, the Samson MXP144FX carries the largest library at 100 presets, and the Mackie ProFX12v3+ carries the smallest at 12, but edits and saves each one on a color screen.
Choose the Yamaha MG20XU for the most channels with SPX effects and group routing. Choose the Behringer Xenyx QX1832USB for its graphic EQ and feedback detection beside a 32-preset KLARK TEKNIK engine. The FX16ii is the recording-leaning pick with a direct output on every channel, while the EFX8 is the compact pick for small groups that still want Lexicon reverb on a dedicated FX bus.
| Product | Inputs | FX engine | Presets | Best for | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yamaha MG20XU | 20 (max 16 mic) | SPX | Count not stated on listing page | Full bands, larger rooms | Program count not published on the page |
| Mackie ProFX12v3+ | 12 | GigFX+ | 12, editable and savable | Streaming and recording | Smallest preset library here |
| Behringer Xenyx QX1832USB | 18 | KLARK TEKNIK | 32 | Live rooms, feedback control | No per-channel direct outputs |
| Soundcraft FX16ii | 26 (16 mic channels) | Lexicon | 32, editable and storable | Live plus multitrack recording | No USB connection |
| Samson MixPad MXP144FX | 14 | Digital FX | 100 | Rehearsals, clubs, worship | USB figures not published by maker |
| Soundcraft EFX8 | 8 + 2 stereo | Lexicon | 32, storable and recallable | Small groups, compact rigs | Fewest mic channels here |
How we selected
Selection started from the corrected keyword itself: an analog mixer whose own published product page states a built-in effects processor or engine. Boards that reach effects only through a computer, a phone app, or an external unit were left out, and so were digital consoles, since the keyword asks for analog desks with FX onboard.
Every figure below comes from the published page for that exact model: preset counts, parameter controls, channel layouts, EQ bands, and routing are quoted from those pages, and anything a page does not state is left out rather than filled in. Where dealer pages disagreed on a figure, the manufacturer’s own product copy decided the number used here.
Six analog mixers with FX, model by model
The six desks below all state an onboard effects engine on their own product pages. They range from a compact 8-channel frame to a 26-input recording console, and the FX sections differ as much as the channel counts: some edit deeply, some store settings, and one simply gives you a hundred presets and a big display to pick from.
Yamaha MG20XU
The MG20XU is the largest desk in this group, a 20-channel analogue console for a working band, a small venue, or a worship team that has outgrown a smaller board. Twelve mono mic and line channels plus four mono or stereo channels take up to 16 microphones and 20 line sources at once.
Sixteen D-PRE preamps carry +48V phantom power and pad switches, with a peak LED that lights when the post-EQ signal comes within 3 dB of clipping. The 3-band EQ gives plus or minus 15 dB per band: a 10 kHz shelving high band, a 100 Hz shelving low band, and a mid band that sweeps from 250 Hz to 5 kHz on mono channels. Eight one-knob compressors ride gain, threshold, and ratio together, with threshold moving from +22 dBu to -8 dBu and ratio from 1:1 to 4:1.
The SPX effects processor is fed from one of the four aux sends and returned to the mix, and an optional footswitch toggles the effect return so a singer can drop the reverb between songs. The listing page names reverb and delay among the SPX programs but does not print a program count. Four group buses, a monitor output, twin 12-segment LED meters, and a USB connection moving two channels each way at up to 24-bit/192 kHz complete the desk. The chassis is metal, a rack-mount kit is included, and the weight is 7.1 kg.
- Pros: most mic inputs here; sweepable mid EQ; SPX effects with footswitch control of the return
- Cons: SPX program count is not printed on the listing page; the heaviest desk in this group
- Buy if: a full band needs effects, groups, and monitors from one analog desk
- Skip if: you want a published preset count and deep FX editing
Mackie ProFX12v3+
The ProFX12v3+ takes the opposite approach to effects: a short list, deeply editable. Its GigFX+ engine holds 12 presets, and each one can be edited and saved on the fly from a full-color LCD screen, so the reverb you tune at soundcheck is the reverb you recall at the show.
Seven Onyx mic preamps provide up to 60 dB of gain. All channels carry 3-band EQ, channels 1 to 4 add one-knob compression, and every mic channel has a Hi-Z switch, a 100 Hz low-cut filter, and 48V phantom power. A stereo 1/8-inch input sits on channel 11/12, and separate FX, monitor, and subgroup buses handle routing. The headphone output has its own level and blend controls.
The USB-C interface records two channels in and four out at 24-bit/192 kHz, with three modes that matter for FX: Standard records the full mix with effects, Interface records channels 1 and 2 without effects processing, and Loopback adds computer audio for streaming. A bi-directional Bluetooth channel brings in phone calls or backing tracks. Waveform OEM software is included, and the chassis is solid steel.
- Pros: presets you can edit and save on a color screen; record with or without FX; Bluetooth channel
- Cons: 12 presets is the smallest library here; dimensions and weight are not published on the maker page
- Buy if: you would rather tune a few effects well than browse a long list
- Skip if: you want dozens of ready-made presets for different songs
Behringer Xenyx QX1832USB
The QX1832USB is an 18-input, 3/2-bus analog mixer whose FX engine is one part of a wider live-sound toolkit. Its KLARK TEKNIK multi-FX processor is a 24-bit design with 32 presets covering reverb, chorus, flanger, delay, pitch shifting, and multi-effects, with dual addressable parameters, a Tap function, and storable user settings.
Six XENYX mic preamps state a dynamic range of 130 dB, and six one-knob compressors with threshold LEDs cover the mic channels. Channel EQ is British-style 3-band with a semi-parametric mid band. Above the channels sits a 9-band stereo graphic EQ that can be assigned to the main mix or the monitor bus, and the FBQ Feedback Detection system lights the corresponding EQ fader LED when a feedback frequency appears, pointing at the band to pull down.
Two more processors ride along: an XPQ 3D stereo surround effect and a Voice Canceller for karaoke-style playback work. A bidirectional stereo USB interface records to a computer, the desk is wireless-ready for Behringer ULM microphone receivers, and the faders are 60 mm logarithmic-taper types. The maker lists a weight of 4.6 kg and a footprint of 430 x 355 mm.
- Pros: graphic EQ with feedback detection beside the FX engine; dual-parameter preset editing; wireless mic option
- Cons: USB resolution is not published on the listing page; no rack mounting
- Buy if: feedback control and room tuning matter as much as effects
- Skip if: you need direct outputs or multitrack recording
Soundcraft FX16ii
The FX16ii is the recording-leaning desk in this group: a 26-input analog console with 16 mono microphone channels, four stereo returns, and a direct output on every channel. Each direct output switches individually between pre-fader and post-fader, which is the layout a 16-track recording system wants.
The built-in effects processor is a 24-bit Lexicon design using the AudioDNA processor found in Lexicon outboard gear, including the MX400. It offers 32 editable effects with tap tempo, three parameter adjust rotaries, a store function for user settings, and an effects clip LED. The 4-bus architecture routes subgroups to the mix, and two sub-group outputs plus a separate mono sum output widen the options for live feeds.
Channel hardware stays classic: 3-band EQ with a swept mid-band, a stereo 18 dB per octave 100 Hz high-pass filter, inserts on all mono channels and on the stereo mix output, channel mutes, and dual global +48V phantom power split between channels 1 to 8 and 9 to 16. Metering is a 10-segment tri-coloured display. There is no USB connection on this model, and the maker page does not state dimensions or weight. An integral universal power supply is built in, and a rotating connector pod allows rack mounting in a 10U space.
- Pros: direct output on every channel; Lexicon effects with three parameter controls and stored settings; subgroup and mono sum outputs
- Cons: no USB; dimensions and weight are not published on the maker page
- Buy if: you record to a separate multitrack system and mix live from the same desk
- Skip if: computer recording over USB is part of the plan
Samson MixPad MXP144FX
The MXP144FX is a 14-input analog stereo mixer for rehearsals, clubs, and houses of worship, and it carries the largest effects library here: 100 presets of 24-bit digital effects. The maker’s manual describes the set as delays, chorus, flanging, and reverbs, which is the working core most small rigs use nightly.
Six Class A MDR mic preamps lead the input side, four of them with single-knob compressors. Every channel has 3-band EQ at plus or minus 15 dB per band, gain trim, a high-pass filter, and a mute switch, all worked by 60 mm faders. Each channel also carries two aux sends: a pre-fader send for the monitor mix and a post-fader send for routing to external effects, which sits comfortably beside the internal engine. Four TRS inserts add more outboard options.
A bidirectional USB interface records a mix or brings computer audio into the desk, and the USB and tape inputs can be assigned to the main mix or to the Mix 2 and phones outputs. Outputs cover the main mix on XLR and 1/4-inch jacks, a Mix 2 output, phones, and an RCA tape out. The maker lists frequency response of 20 Hz to 30 kHz, distortion under 0.03 percent, maximum mic-to-main gain of 70 dB, dimensions of 391 x 370 x 100 mm, and a weight of 3.8 kg, the lightest desk in this group.
- Pros: 100 presets; pre- and post-fader aux sends on every channel; light for its size
- Cons: USB channel count and sample rate are not stated by the maker; no subgroup buses
- Buy if: you want the biggest preset library with simple, physical controls
- Skip if: you need published USB recording figures or subgroup routing
Soundcraft EFX8
The EFX8 is the compact pick: an 8+2 channel analog mixer with eight mono inputs and two stereo channels, sized for small groups who do not want to carry a separate effects unit. Its GB30 mic preamps were designed by Graham Blythe and are shared with the maker’s larger professional consoles.
The built-in 24-bit Lexicon effects processor offers 32 presets on a dedicated FX bus, with reverbs and delay named on the maker’s store page. The presets are storable and recallable, tap tempo sets delay times, three parameter controls adjust each effect, and a user setting store facility keeps your tuned versions. An effects send sits on each channel, and the FX channel adds a clip LED and a mute function.
Channel EQ is 3-band, with a swept mid band running from 150 Hz to 3.5 kHz at Q of 0.8 on mono inputs and a fixed 720 Hz mid on stereo inputs, all at plus or minus 15 dB. Inserts sit on every mono input, one aux send is configurable, and metering is a ten-segment LED output display with a peak LED on each channel. The maker lists noise of -126.5 dBu with a 150 ohm source, distortion of 0.02 percent at 1 kHz, frequency response within +0/-1.5 dB from 20 Hz to 20 kHz, power consumption under 35 W, and a weight of 4.6 kg.
- Pros: Lexicon effects with stored settings in a compact frame; swept mid EQ; inserts on every mono input
- Cons: eight mic channels is the fewest here; no USB connection
- Buy if: a small group wants Lexicon reverb and delay without extra boxes
- Skip if: you need more mic channels or computer recording
Buying guide
An FX badge on an analog mixer can mean anything from a single reverb knob to a storable, editable processor, so the badge alone tells you little. The points below read past it: how many presets you get, what you can change, whether your settings survive the trip home, and how the effect reaches monitors and recordings.
How to compare analog mixers with FX engines
Start with the engine’s origin and structure. The two Soundcraft desks use Lexicon processors with dedicated parameter controls, the Yamaha uses its SPX family, the Mackie uses GigFX+, the Behringer uses a KLARK TEKNIK design, and the Samson uses its own digital engine.
Named engines with published preset lists are easier to judge than a bare effects claim. The Samson’s engine carries the largest library here, while the Lexicon desks lean on a shorter list with deeper controls, so origin and structure together tell you more than either fact alone.
Preset count versus editing depth
The counts here run from 12 to 100, and the right end of that range depends on your habits. A hundred presets suit a player who switches sounds song by song. Twelve editable presets suit an engineer who builds one reverb and one delay carefully in practice.
Editing depth shows in the controls: three parameter rotaries on the Soundcraft desks, dual parameters on the Behringer, and full screen editing on the Mackie. A preset you cannot adjust is a preset you work around; a preset you can tune becomes part of your sound.
Storing your settings between shows
A tuned effect is worth keeping. The FX16ii and the EFX8 both store user settings, the Behringer stores user parameter settings, and the Mackie saves edited presets from its screen, so the work you do at soundcheck survives to the show and to the next venue.
Without storage, the desk returns to factory presets at power-up, and your soundcheck work starts over. If the mixer lives in one room, storage matters less; if it travels between venues, it matters a great deal.
Tap tempo and footswitch control
Delay effects live or die by their timing. Tap tempo, offered on the Behringer and both Soundcraft desks, sets repeats against the song from a button, so the echo follows the band instead of fighting it. That single button does more for a live delay sound than a page of millisecond figures.
Footswitch control works the other end of the problem: the Yamaha’s optional footswitch toggles the whole effect return, so a singer or a player can mute reverb between songs without leaving the microphone or the instrument.
Where the FX send sits in the routing
An internal engine still needs a path. A dedicated FX bus, as on the EFX8, keeps effect levels separate from monitor sends. An aux-fed engine, as on the Yamaha, shares the aux structure, which is flexible but asks for care with monitor mixes on stage.
The Samson adds a post-fader aux send per channel for external effects, so its internal engine and an outside unit can work at the same time. Read the send layout before you buy; it decides how the engine behaves on a busy night.
FAQ
Questions about analog mixers with built-in effects tend to circle the same ground: how the sharing works, what reaches a recording, and whether an external unit still has a place. The answers below stick to what these six makers publish about their engines, routing, and connections.
Can analog mixers with FX record to a computer?
Four of the six here can. The Yamaha, Mackie, Behringer, and Samson each include a USB connection for recording a stereo mix or streaming it to an audience, with the Mackie adding a 2-in, 4-out layout and modes that record with or without effects at this size.
The two Soundcraft desks take the other route: the FX16ii feeds a separate multitrack recorder from its direct outputs, and the EFX8 has no computer connection. Neither approach is wrong; they serve different rigs.
Can two channels use different effects at the same time?
On these desks, one engine is shared. Each channel sends its own amount to the engine, but the whole board hears the selected program. That is the normal layout for a single-engine analog mixer, and it covers most live work without strain on a normal night.
The way around it is an external processor on a spare aux send, which the Samson’s post-fader send and the FX16ii’s routing both support, or a larger dual-engine console.
What does an FX parameter control actually change?
It changes the character of the selected effect rather than its level. Depending on the engine, the controls adjust reverb decay, room size, delay regeneration, or modulation depth, which is the difference between a small room and a hall on the same program.
The Soundcraft desks give three parameter rotaries, the Behringer gives two addressable parameters per preset, and the Mackie opens the editing on its LCD screen. Level is set separately by the send and return controls.
Are built-in effects good enough to skip an external unit?
For the standard live toolkit of reverb, delay, chorus, and flanger, yes: every engine here covers that ground, and two of them carry Lexicon processing drawn from outboard gear. The built-in route also skips the extra cables, boxes, and setup steps.
An external unit still earns its place for unusual effects, for a second simultaneous effect, or for studio-grade editing. These desks plan for that day with inserts and spare sends.
Do the effects work on monitor mixes too?
It depends on the routing of that particular desk. Where the engine is fed from a post-fader aux or a dedicated FX bus, the effect usually lands in the main mix, and monitor sends stay dry unless the design routes the return there as well for the performers.
A singer who wants reverb in the wedges should look at how the return can be assigned; the Yamaha returns its SPX feed to the mix from an aux structure, which gives the engineer options.
Conclusion
For most bands, the Yamaha MG20XU is the complete analog FX desk: SPX effects, eight compressors, group buses, and room for 16 microphones. The Soundcraft FX16ii is the pick for recording with direct outputs and Lexicon processing, the Samson MXP144FX for a 100-preset library, and the Mackie ProFX12v3+ for editable presets and streaming.
Every desk in this guide states its effects engine in its own published specifications, so the real differences are visible before you buy: preset count, editing depth, stored settings, and the path the effect takes through the board. Match those four points to your band, your room, and your recording habits, and the choice makes itself.