Updated Nov 16, 2026· 13 min read

Key takeaways

  • Six freebase menthol e-liquids compared on flavor build, VG PG ratio, bottle size and nicotine strengths, from maker and listing pages opened for this guide.

Menthol smokers who move to bottled liquid usually want the cold note without a salt formula. This guide to e juice flavors for menthol smokers compares six regular freebase bottles on flavor build, ratio, bottle size and the nicotine strengths printed on each opened page, and on what each maker says the flavor is built from.

Quick verdict

For menthol over real tobacco, Black Note Special Blend Menthol is the standout entry, built on naturally extracted sun-cured Oriental leaf. For the strongest straight menthol in a big bottle, Halo SubZero is the classic pick. For a small cheap bottle to test the category, Vampire Vape Ice Menthol and IVG Iced Mint both come in 10 ml.

The six split into three styles. SubZero and Ice Menthol are menthol on its own. Special Blend Menthol layers mint over tobacco extract. Naked 100 Melon puts menthol in a melon-led fruit blend in a high-VG bottle. Dinner Lady Ice Menthol adds a mint note with a cooling agent in a 50:50 bottle. Every bottle here is a freebase formula; the salt versions these brands also sell are separate products and are not the subject of this guide.

How we selected

Each flavor had to be a menthol e-liquid in a regular freebase bottle, shown on an opened maker or listing page with its ratio, bottle size and strengths printed. Salt versions were excluded even where the same flavor name exists in both forms, because the keyword sits next to a salt-specific guide in this series.

Pages were read in full, and where a brand sells one flavor in several formulations, the freebase figures are the ones quoted. Two checks mattered beyond the flavor name: that the page showed the bottle on sale, and that the strengths formed a normal freebase ladder rather than the high numbers typical of salts. Flavor descriptions are the makers’ own words, shortened where needed, and no flavor is described as matching any cigarette brand.

E juice flavors for menthol smokers in freebase bottles

The six bottles below cover menthol alone, menthol over tobacco, and menthol under fruit, in bottle sizes from 10 ml to 60 ml and ratios from 50:50 up to 70 percent VG. Strength ladders are quoted as printed; none of them is a recommendation, and no page read promises any outcome from any strength.

Halo SubZero

SubZero is Halo’s straight menthol: the listing describes it as a strong and pure menthol flavored vape juice and a classic menthol flavor. The classic bottled version is a freebase formula in a 60 ml bottle at 50 percent VG and 50 percent PG, made in the USA, with variant strengths listed at 3, 6, 12, 18 and 24 mg.

Halo sells the same flavor name in a separate nicotine salt line, and a page read for this guide spells out the split: the classic version uses freebase nicotine, while the Ultra version contains nicotine salts in 10 ml bottles at 10 and 20 mg. The bottle in this guide is the classic 60 ml freebase version. There is no fruit, tobacco or dessert note in the profile; the flavor is menthol itself, which is why it anchors the straight-menthol end of this list.

The listing also points to a 0 mg version of the Halo line, so the full printed ladder for the classic bottle runs from nicotine-free up to 24 mg. That spread is unusual in this guide and worth reading carefully at order time, because the same product name covers every step of it. The page describes the flavor in the plainest terms used anywhere in this list: strong, pure and classic are its three adjectives, and no secondary flavor is named at all.

  • Pros: 60 ml bottle; widest strength ladder here, up to 24 mg; pure menthol with nothing else in the profile.
  • Cons: 50:50 ratio suits mouth-to-lung devices rather than high-power tanks; some listed strengths were out of stock on the page read.
  • Buy if: you want menthol alone, in a large bottle, with strength choice.
  • Skip if: you want tobacco or fruit under the menthol.

Black Note Special Blend Menthol

Special Blend Menthol puts mint over real tobacco. The maker describes crisp, pulegone-free mint from Mentha arvensis laid over naturally extracted sun-cured Oriental leaf, and an extra distillation and micro-filtration step that the maker says leaves less residue on a coil.

The freebase versions come in 60 ml bottles at 50VG/50PG and at 70VG/30PG, in 0, 3, 6, 12 and 18 mg. The maker states there are no sweeteners in it, and rates a coil at up to 35 ml of this liquid before replacement. A salt version exists in a 30 ml bottle, but the freebase bottles are the subject here. This is the one entry in the guide where tobacco is part of the recipe rather than a separate flavor category, which makes it the natural first read for a menthol cigarette smoker comparing bottled options.

The ingredient list the maker prints is short: real sun-cured Oriental tobacco extract, natural mint extract, vegetable glycerin, propylene glycol, purified water, and nicotine when a nicotine version is selected. The maker also keeps a fuller original, Menthol Tobacco, in the same line, and describes Special Blend Menthol as the crisper, coil-friendly version of it. Readers who want the menthol further forward are pointed by the maker to that original; readers who want the lighter residue on coils are pointed here.

  • Pros: real tobacco extract under the mint; two freebase ratios; no sweeteners per the maker.
  • Cons: balanced rather than heavy menthol, by the maker’s own description; 60 ml is the only freebase bottle size.
  • Buy if: you want menthol and tobacco in one bottle.
  • Skip if: you want the coldest menthol in this guide.

Naked 100 Melon (Menthol)

Melon is the menthol fruit entry in the Naked 100 line, sold on the page read as a flavor option in the maker’s menthol collection alongside Crisp Menthol. The line’s stated format is a 60 ml bottle at 70 percent VG and 30 percent PG, with nicotine options listed at 0, 3, 6 and 12 mg, made in the USA.

The menthol collection pairs the cooling note with fruit rather than tobacco. Melon is the melon-led option in that collection, and the 70 percent VG ratio makes this the bottle in the guide aimed at larger tanks and higher-power devices rather than small pods. Readers who found 50:50 menthol bottles too sharp in a big tank will find the format here built for the other end of the hardware range.

The same listing page shows the width of the line’s menthol shelf: Apple, Berry and Strawberry Pom appear as menthol options next to Melon and Crisp Menthol, all under the same 60 ml, 70:30 format. That matters for a fruit-menthol reader, because the flavor can be changed without changing bottle size, ratio or strength ladder. Melon is the pick here because its profile is the melon blend the collection is known for, with the menthol as the cooling layer rather than the headline.

  • Pros: high-VG 70:30 format in a 60 ml bottle; menthol with fruit instead of tobacco; 0 mg option listed.
  • Cons: thick liquid is a poor match for small pod coils; the flavor is fruit-led, so the menthol sits in the background.
  • Buy if: you run a sub-ohm tank and want menthol under melon fruit.
  • Skip if: you use a small mouth-to-lung pod kit.

Vampire Vape Ice Menthol

Ice Menthol is the small-bottle straight menthol from Vampire Vape: the listing describes a refreshingly cool and minty e-liquid with an intense menthol flavor and a crisp aftertaste. It comes in a 10 ml bottle, made in the UK, with a childproof cap and a tamper evident seal.

Strengths run 0, 3, 6, 12 and 18 mg. The ratio depends on the strength: 60PG/40VG for most of the range, with the 3 mg version in a 50PG/50VG blend, per the listing page. That high-PG format is built for pod devices and mouth-to-lung kits. As a 10 ml bottle at the sharp end of the menthol scale, it works as the low-commitment way to find out whether straight menthol, rather than menthol tobacco, is the flavor you actually want.

The bottle itself is a recyclable 10 ml format, per the same listing. Vampire Vape sells this flavor inside a large 10 ml range from the same maker, and the listing groups it with the brand’s regular freebase bottles rather than its salt lines, which matches the strength ladder printed for it. Of the two straight menthols in this guide, this is the pocket format and SubZero is the bulk format; the flavor intent, menthol with a mint edge and nothing else, is the same.

  • Pros: full strength ladder in a 10 ml bottle; high-PG format for small kits; UK made.
  • Cons: 10 ml runs out fast in daily use; ratio changes with strength, so read the bottle.
  • Buy if: you want a small, strong menthol bottle for a pod kit.
  • Skip if: you want a large bottle or a high-VG blend.

IVG Iced Mint

Iced Mint blends mint into the menthol: the listing describes mint-infused menthol bringing a cool wave of freshness with an icy backdrop on the exhale. It is a 10 ml bottle in a 50 percent VG and 50 percent PG blend, manufactured in the UK with a tamper-evident seal.

The page states the range uses standard nicotine, which is the freebase form, in 0, 3, 6, 12 and 18 mg. The 50:50 ratio and the strength ladder make it a direct counterpart to the Vampire Vape bottle above, with the difference in the flavor build: mint forward rather than menthol alone. The listing notes the format suits smaller devices, including pens and pods, and produces smaller clouds with more flavor concentration, in the seller’s words.

The bottle has an integrated dripper tip, per the listing, which is a small practical point in its favor for filling narrow pod openings. IVG is a UK manufacturer with a large fruit-led catalogue, and Iced Mint is its mint-menthol entry in the 50:50 line rather than a standalone range. For a reader choosing between the two UK 10 ml bottles in this guide, the decision is the flavor build alone: mint-infused menthol here, straight menthol in the Vampire Vape bottle.

  • Pros: mint and menthol together; 50:50 suits almost any small kit; strengths from 0 to 18 mg.
  • Cons: 10 ml only; mint softens the menthol edge some readers want.
  • Buy if: you want the cold note rounded off with mint.
  • Skip if: you want menthol with no mint flavor at all.

Dinner Lady Ice Menthol

Ice Menthol sits in Dinner Lady’s menthol range, which the maker’s own shop page lists alongside Spearmint and Fresh Menthol. The same page documents the range’s 50:50 format: 10 ml bottles combining even measures of PG and VG, in strengths from 3 to 18 mg, and notes that traditional e-liquids of this kind use freebase nicotine.

The maker’s wider description of its menthol line pairs cooling menthol with fresh mint across the range. The 50:50 Ice Menthol bottle is the mouth-to-lung entry of that range, aimed by the maker at low wattage devices with higher ohm coils, such as pen devices and refillable pod kits. The brand also sells this flavor family in salt and shortfill forms; the 50:50 freebase bottle is the one compared here.

  • Pros: balanced 50:50 in the standard 3 to 18 mg freebase ladder; part of a wide menthol range from one maker.
  • Cons: the maker page covers the range rather than one bottle, so confirm the exact bottle and strength on the listing at order time.
  • Buy if: you want a mainstream 50:50 menthol from a large UK range.
  • Skip if: you want a 60 ml bottle.

Buying guide

Freebase menthol bottles differ on four printed facts: the flavor build, the VG and PG ratio, the bottle size, and the strength ladder. Work through them in that order and the right bottle in this list usually picks itself, because each of the six wins on a different one of the four.

Choosing e juice flavors for menthol smokers by build

There are three builds here. Menthol alone: Halo SubZero and Vampire Vape Ice Menthol. Menthol over tobacco: Black Note Special Blend Menthol. Menthol with something else on top: Naked 100 Melon with fruit, IVG Iced Mint with mint, and Dinner Lady Ice Menthol with mint and a cooling note.

A menthol cigarette smoker comparing bottles should start with the tobacco build, because it is the only one where tobacco is in the recipe. Readers who discover they prefer the cold note by itself can move to the straight menthols at the next bottle; the 10 ml sizes make that test cheap in volume terms.

Ratio: 50:50, high PG and high VG

Ratio decides which device the bottle suits. The 50:50 bottles, SubZero, Iced Mint, Ice Menthol and the 50VG/50PG version of Special Blend Menthol, are the all-rounders for pods and mouth-to-lung tanks. Vampire Vape Ice Menthol leans further toward PG at 60PG/40VG in most strengths, for small kits.

At the other end, Naked 100 Melon at 70 percent VG and the 70VG/30PG version of Special Blend Menthol are thicker liquids for larger tanks and higher power. Putting a high-VG bottle in a small pod usually ends in weak wicking and a burnt taste; putting a high-PG bottle in a big tank can feel harsh. Match the printed ratio to the device you own.

Freebase and salt are different products

Several flavors in this guide share a name with a salt product from the same brand. Halo sells SubZero as a classic freebase bottle and as an Ultra salt bottle; Black Note sells Special Blend Menthol in freebase and salt forms; Dinner Lady sells its menthol range in both forms as well.

The giveaway is the strength ladder and bottle. Freebase bottles here run from 0 to 24 mg in 10 ml or 60 ml bottles. Salt versions cluster at 10 and 20 mg, or at 20, 30 and 50 mg for Black Note, in 10 ml or 30 ml bottles. Check the form printed on the listing before ordering, because the same flavor name covers both.

Bottle size and the 10 ml test

The 10 ml bottles, Ice Menthol from Vampire Vape, Iced Mint and Dinner Lady Ice Menthol, are the test format: a full strength ladder in a bottle that lasts days rather than weeks. The 60 ml bottles, SubZero, Special Blend Menthol and Naked 100 Melon, are the restock format once a flavor is settled.

A sensible order for a new reader is one 10 ml straight menthol and one 10 ml menthol tobacco or mint blend, then a 60 ml of whichever build wins. That sequence uses the small bottles for what they are good at and avoids a large bottle of a flavor that turns out to be wrong.

Reading the strength ladder on the bottle

Freebase ladders in this guide run in even steps: 0, 3, 6, 12 and 18 mg for most of these brands, with Halo SubZero adding a 24 mg step. The number is a concentration, milligrams per milliliter, printed on the bottle and the listing. It is not a measure of how much nicotine a reader absorbs, which depends on the device and the pattern of use.

Two cautions follow from the pages read. First, the same flavor name can sit on two ladders, the freebase ladder and a salt ladder with different numbers, so the form matters as much as the figure. Second, no maker page in this guide ties a strength to a number of cigarettes in a way this guide can repeat as fact; where a maker offers a starting suggestion, it is that maker’s suggestion, and it is labeled as such in the product sections above.

FAQ

Most questions about this keyword are really about form: freebase against salt, ratio against device, and whether any bottle tastes like a menthol cigarette. The answers below use the maker and listing pages read for this guide and say plainly where no page makes a claim.

Are e juice flavors for menthol smokers only sold as salts?

No. All six bottles in this guide are freebase formulas, and most of these brands sell a salt version of the same flavor as a separate product. The freebase versions carry the wider, lower strength ladders, from 0 mg up to 18 or 24 mg depending on the brand, in 10 ml and 60 ml bottles.

Which of these tastes closest to a menthol cigarette?

No page read for this guide promises a match to a cigarette brand. The closest build on paper is Black Note Special Blend Menthol, because its recipe is mint over naturally extracted tobacco. The maker describes it as reading like a fresh menthol cigarette rather than a dessert, and that is the maker’s description, quoted as such.

What ratio should a pod kit use?

On the pages read, the 50:50 bottles and the high-PG Vampire Vape blend are the ones their makers aim at pods and mouth-to-lung kits. The 70 percent VG bottles, Naked 100 Melon and the 70VG/30PG Special Blend Menthol, are aimed at sub-ohm tanks. Your device maker’s stated liquid range is the deciding document.

What nicotine strength should a menthol smoker pick?

This guide does not recommend a strength. The ladders printed on the pages run from 0 mg to 18 mg for most of these bottles and to 24 mg for Halo SubZero. Black Note’s page suggests starting points by smoking pattern, but that is the maker’s suggestion on its own page, and no strength is presented here as right for any reader.

Do these flavors help you quit smoking?

No page read for this guide claims that, and this guide does not claim it. These are nicotine products for adults, compared on flavor build, ratio, bottle size and printed strengths. Anyone who wants to stop smoking should ask a doctor or pharmacist about approved support.

Conclusion

For menthol over tobacco, Special Blend Menthol is the bottle built for this keyword. For menthol alone, SubZero in 60 ml or Ice Menthol in 10 ml cover both ends. Iced Mint softens the edge with mint, Melon takes menthol into high-VG fruit, and Dinner Lady Ice Menthol covers the balanced 50:50 middle ground.

A
admin88
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.