Key takeaways
- Five side-by-side refrigerators with ice makers compared on total capacity, daily ice output, dispenser style, dimensions and energy use, from maker pages.
A side-by-side puts fresh and frozen food at eye level, but models differ widely in how much ice they make and where the ice maker sits. This guide compares five current side by side refrigerator with ice makers, using the capacity, ice output, dispenser and dimension figures each maker publishes, so the choice rests on printed numbers.
Quick verdict
The five models split along two lines: where the ice maker lives, and how much the maker prints about ice output. The Samsung and KitchenAid keep their ice in a door, the LG runs two ice makers at once, and the Frigidaire and Whirlpool use a freezer-mounted maker with a door dispenser. Only the LG prints a daily production figure.
For sheer room, the Samsung RS70H27SDRAA leads at 27.4 cu. ft. total, with a 17.9 cu. ft. fresh side, and it adds slow-melting Sphere Ice beside its in-door maker. The LG LRSOS2706S is close behind at 27.1 cu. ft. and is the pick for households that go through ice in two forms, because its SpacePlus door maker handles cubed and crushed while a second maker produces Craft Ice spheres. The Frigidaire FRSS2623AS at 25.6 cu. ft. is the straightforward mid-size option with an external dispenser and a sealed crisper system.
The Whirlpool WRS325SDHZ and the KitchenAid KRSF705HPS sit at the smaller end, 24.5 and 24.8 cu. ft., and they differ in approach: the Whirlpool is a plain, full-depth box with a freezer icemaker and dual dispenser pads, while the KitchenAid moves the ice bin into the refrigerator door and adds measured water dispensing. None of the five is a counter-depth model, so every one needs a full-depth alcove. The sections below give the printed figures model by model.
| Model | Total capacity | Ice maker setup | Dispenser | Standout figure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Samsung RS70H27SDRAA | 27.4 cu. ft. | In-door ice maker, Sphere Ice | External water and ice | 17.9 cu. ft. fresh side |
| LG LRSOS2706S | 27.1 cu. ft. | Dual ice: SpacePlus door maker plus Craft Ice | Smooth Touch with UVnano | 2.3 lb daily output, 3.5 lb storage |
| Frigidaire FRSS2623AS | 25.6 cu. ft. | Automatic ice maker | External water and ice | Cubed or crushed through the door |
| Whirlpool WRS325SDHZ | 24.5 cu. ft. | Factory-installed icemaker in freezer | Exterior ice and water | EveryDrop filtration, dual pads |
| KitchenAid KRSF705HPS | 24.8 cu. ft. | In-Door-Ice bin on the refrigerator door | Exterior ice and water | Measured fill in ounces, cups, liters |
How we selected these models
Every model had to pass two tests on its maker or listing page: the page names the layout as side-by-side, and it states an ice maker for that exact model, whether a door dispenser, an in-door bin or a factory-installed freezer icemaker. Models that leave the ice maker as an optional kit, and models the maker lists as discontinued, were left out.
The figures compared here are the ones makers actually print for this category: total capacity and the fresh and freezer split, the ice maker type and location, daily ice production and ice storage where a maker states them, dispenser style, outside dimensions, and energy certification or annual energy use where published. Where a maker prints no daily output figure, the entry says so instead of estimating one from bin size.
The five survivors give a fair spread of the current market: two large 27 cu. ft. models with door ice systems, one mid-size 25.6 cu. ft. dispenser model, and two models under 25 cu. ft. that take opposite routes, one plain and one feature-led. All five are full-depth, freestanding, 36-inch-class boxes, so the comparison stays honest about the alcove they need.
Side by side refrigerator with ice makers, model by model
The five entries below run from the largest cabinet to the smallest, and each sticks to what the maker or listing page states for that model: capacity split, ice maker type and placement, dispenser form, dimensions, and energy figures where printed. Limits are stated as plainly as strengths, including figures a maker does not publish.
Samsung Bespoke AI 27 cu. ft. Side-by-Side Refrigerator RS70H27SDRAA
The Samsung is the capacity leader: 27.4 cu. ft., split 17.9 cu. ft. fresh and 9.5 cu. ft. freezer, in a body 35 7/8 inches wide and 70 1/16 inches tall. Its ice maker sits in the door, which the maker says produces ice at a high capacity while saving shelf space for frozen food, and the dispenser serves filtered water with curved or crushed ice.
The second ice form is the talking point. Beside the regular supply, the maker lists Sphere Ice, slow-melting rounded ice that the maker says keeps drinks colder longer, which suits households that pour long drinks in the evening but still need crushed ice for daytime use. Control runs through the SmartThings app, which the maker says can monitor and manage the refrigerator and its power use, and the controls are placed to meet ADA reach standards, a detail worth noting for households that need lower, easier controls.
The limits are about depth and unknowns. At full depth, this is not the box for a shallow alcove, and the maker page used here prints no daily ice production figure in pounds, so heavy ice users have to judge output by the in-door design rather than a number. Pros: largest total and fresh capacity here; two ice forms; app control; compressor listed with a 10 year warranty. Cons: no printed daily output figure; full-depth body. Buy if: you want the biggest fresh side and two kinds of ice. Skip if: your alcove is shallow or you want a published pounds-per-day figure before buying.
LG 27 cu. ft. Side-by-Side InstaView Refrigerator LRSOS2706S
The LG runs two ice makers in one cabinet. The SpacePlus maker sits in the freezer door and dispenses cubed ice, with crushed ice at the same dispenser, while the Craft Ice maker automatically makes batches of three or six slow-melting Craft Ice per day. Total capacity is 27.1 cu. ft., split 17.50 cu. ft. fresh and 9.60 cu. ft. freezer.
This is also the only entry whose maker prints the full ice arithmetic: daily ice production of 2.3 lbs, rising to 3.0 lbs with the IcePlus setting, Craft Ice production of 0.8 lbs a day, and ice storage of 3.5 lbs. Those numbers let a buyer plan around real use instead of guessing. The dispenser is a Smooth Touch unit with UVnano, and the maker states the dispenser light system addresses the nozzle on a daily cycle. Cooling runs through Door Cooling+ and Linear Cooling, which the maker says holds temperatures stable within 1 degree F, behind an edge-to-edge InstaView panel.
The body measures 35 7/8 inches wide, 70 1/2 inches to the top of the hinge and 33 1/2 inches deep with handles, and the unit weighs 295.6 lbs. The maker lists energy use at 694 kWh per year with ENERGY STAR qualification, the LT1000P water filter, and warranty cover of 1 year parts and labor with 5 years on the sealed system and compressor. Pros: two ice makers; the only full set of printed output and storage figures; large capacity. Cons: the heaviest style of feature list to learn; Craft Ice output is under a pound a day. Buy if: ice output numbers matter and the household uses both cubed and round ice. Skip if: a single, simple dispenser is all the kitchen needs.
Frigidaire 25.6 Cu. Ft. Side-By-Side Refrigerator FRSS2623AS
The Frigidaire is the middle path: 25.6 cu. ft. total, split 16.6 cu. ft. fresh and 9 cu. ft. freezer, with an automatic ice maker feeding an external water and ice dispenser in the left door. The dispenser offers cubed or crushed ice, and the water runs through the maker’s PurePour filter.
Cooling is the maker’s EvenTemp system, described as reacting quickly to temperature changes and circulating cold air through both compartments, which is the feature the maker leans on for even temperatures from top to bottom. For the filter, the maker says the PurePour design reduces up to 99 percent of contaminants, and the listing page names NSF and WQA certification for it.
Storage is practical rather than showy: four adjustable door bins, a dairy bin, four shelves of which three adjust, two wire shelves and a pull-out basket in the freezer, and sealed Fresh Storage Crispers for produce. Bright LED lighting is listed across the interior.
The cabinet stands about 69.88 inches tall with hinges, about 36.13 inches wide and 35 inches deep with handles, the deepest body in this group, so the alcove check matters. The model is ENERGY STAR certified and carries a 1 year parts and labor warranty as listed. Pros: honest mid-size capacity; cubed and crushed ice through the door; flexible door bins. Cons: deepest cabinet here; no daily ice output figure printed on the page used. Buy if: you want a mainstream dispenser model with room to organize tall items. Skip if: depth is tight or a second ice form is on the list.
Whirlpool 25 cu. ft. Side-by-Side Refrigerator WRS325SDHZ
The Whirlpool is the plainest box in the guide, and that is its appeal. The maker lists total volume at 24.5 cu. ft., split 15.44 cu. ft. fresh and 9.11 cu. ft. freezer, with a factory-installed icemaker in the freezer and an exterior dispenser using dual pads, serving crushed or cubed ice and filtered water through EveryDrop filtration.
The dispenser options listed include filtered water, an ice dispenser lock and a night light. Inside, the layout is built around loading flexibility: frameless glass shelves, a deli drawer, adjustable gallon door bins, humidity-controlled crispers and an in-door can caddy that frees shelf space.
Controls are electronic and sit at the dispenser, the hinges are hidden, and the finish is listed as fingerprint resistant. The cabinet measures 35-1/2 inches wide, 69-5/8 inches tall and 33-5/8 inches deep, and at 251 lbs it is the lightest model in this group by a clear margin.
Two honest limits stand out. The maker page lists this model as not ENERGY STAR certified, the only one of the five to say so, and no daily ice production figure is printed, so output has to be judged on the freezer icemaker design alone. Pros: lightest cabinet here; simple dual-pad dispenser; flexible door storage. Cons: no energy certification; smallest fresh capacity in the group. Buy if: you want a straightforward dispenser refrigerator without connected features. Skip if: energy certification is a requirement or the household needs maximum fresh room.
KitchenAid 24.8 cu. ft. Side-by-Side Refrigerator KRSF705HPS
The KitchenAid takes the door-ice idea further than the Samsung: its In-Door-Ice system mounts the ice bin on the inside of the left refrigerator door, which the maker says keeps the ice maker out of the fresh compartment and frees shelf space. Total capacity is 24.8 cu. ft., split 15.90 fresh and 8.90 freezer.
The dispenser adds a feature none of the other four lists: Measured Water Fill, which displays and dispenses water in ounces, cups or liters, so a coffee pot or a recipe quantity can be filled to a set amount. Food care is the maker’s Preserva system, described as two independent cooling systems, one for fresh food and one for frozen, with a FreshFlow air filter and a produce preserver the maker says delays over-ripening in the crisper drawers. The stainless exterior carries the maker’s PrintShield finish, which the maker says resists smudges and fingerprints.
The body measures 35.75 inches wide, 69 inches to the top of the hinge and 34.75 inches deep with handles, and it is ENERGY STAR certified with a 1 year parts and labor warranty. Pros: ice bin in the refrigerator door; measured water dispensing; two cooling systems. Cons: smallest freezer capacity here; no daily ice output figure printed. Buy if: measured water and fresh-food care rank above freezer room. Skip if: the freezer does heavy duty for a large household.
Buying guide: choosing a side by side refrigerator with ice makers
Five checks decide most purchases in this category: the alcove, the capacity split, where the ice maker sits, what the maker prints about output, and the energy figures behind the certification label. Each check below uses figures from the five models in this guide, so the advice stays tied to numbers a buyer can verify on a listing page.
Start with the alcove: width, height and depth with handles
All five models are 36-inch-class, full-depth cabinets, and their depths with handles run from 33 1/2 inches on the LG to 35 inches on the Frigidaire. That spread decides whether the doors clear the counter edge and whether the box stands proud of the run, so depth with handles, not case depth, is the figure to measure against the kitchen.
Height matters just as much: the group runs from 69 inches at the hinge on the KitchenAid to 70 1/2 inches on the LG, and a tall cabinet under low bulkheads can fail by half an inch. Widths cluster at 35-1/2 to about 36.13 inches. Take the three printed dimensions from the maker page of the exact model, add the maker’s stated clearance, and compare against the alcove before comparing any feature.
Read the capacity split, not just the total
The Samsung pairs the biggest total, 27.4 cu. ft., with the biggest fresh side at 17.9 cu. ft., while the KitchenAid’s 24.8 cu. ft. total leaves only 8.90 cu. ft. for the freezer because its ice bin lives in the fresh door. Read the freezer figure first if the household freezes in bulk; read the fresh figure first if it shops fresh.
The split also shapes daily use. Side-by-side columns are narrow, so wide trays and large joints depend on shelf width rather than total volume. Where a maker lists shelf and bin counts, as the Frigidaire and Whirlpool pages do, those counts tell more about real loading than the headline total. Match the split to the shopping pattern, then check the door bins for gallon storage if milk and juice live on the door.
Decide where the ice maker should live
Placement changes both space and service. A freezer-mounted maker, as on the Frigidaire and Whirlpool, is the traditional layout: simple, and it gives up a block of freezer room to the bin. An in-door system, as on the Samsung and KitchenAid, moves the bin into a door and hands shelf space back.
The LG shows the third option: keep the dispenser maker in the freezer door and add a second maker for a specialty form. Households that serve both crushed ice for drinks and slow-melting rounds for spirits get both from one cabinet. The trade-off is complexity and one more system to maintain. Choose placement by which compartment can spare the room, not by novelty.
Daily output and storage are two different numbers
Output is how fast a machine makes ice across a day; storage is how much sits ready in the bin. The LG is the only model whose maker prints both: 2.3 lbs a day of production, 3.0 lbs with its boost setting, and 3.5 lbs of storage. The other four makers describe their ice makers without a pounds-per-day figure on the pages used.
For a household that fills a cooler every weekend, storage size and a removable bin matter more than a production rate, because the bin can be emptied into the cooler and refilled. For a household that serves drinks all evening, production rate matters more. Where a maker prints neither figure, treat output claims in advertising with care and judge by bin placement and dispenser design instead.
Check the filter, the certification and the warranty together
Every model here filters its dispenser water, and the makers name their systems: PurePour on the Frigidaire, EveryDrop on the Whirlpool, and a named LT1000P cartridge on the LG. A named filter is easier to reorder than a generic one, and the Whirlpool page lists a filter indicator and reset, which takes the guesswork out of timing.
Certification splits the group cleanly: the LG, Frigidaire and KitchenAid pages state ENERGY STAR certification, the Whirlpool page states the opposite, and the LG prints a full annual figure of 694 kWh. Warranty terms are printed for three models, 1 year parts and labor as the base, with the LG adding 5 years on the sealed system and compressor and Samsung listing 10 years on its compressor. Read those three lines together and the energy picture is complete.
FAQ
Five questions cover the points buyers raise most: how much ice these machines make, how the two ice maker layouts differ, what plumbing they need, whether any fit a shallow kitchen, and which carry energy certification. Each answer rests on the maker and listing pages behind the five models above, and says so where a page leaves a figure unstated.
How much ice does a side by side refrigerator with ice makers produce each day?
Only one maker prints the figure. The LG LRSOS2706S lists production of 2.3 lbs from its door maker, 3.0 lbs with the IcePlus setting, plus 0.8 lbs a day of Craft Ice, with 3.5 lbs of storage. The Samsung, Frigidaire, Whirlpool and KitchenAid pages describe their ice makers without a pounds-per-day figure, so no ranking can be built for them.
What is the difference between an in-door ice maker and a freezer ice maker?
An in-door system mounts the bin in a door. Samsung places its maker in the freezer door; KitchenAid mounts the bin inside the refrigerator door, freeing shelf space in the fresh compartment. A freezer ice maker, as on the Frigidaire and Whirlpool, sits in the freezer and gives up a block of that space to the bin.
Do these refrigerators need a water line?
Yes. Every model serves water and ice through a door dispenser, and a dispenser runs on a plumbed supply with a filter cartridge in the path. None of the five is a tank-fed design. A kitchen without a supply line at the alcove needs one added before these models can dispense.
Are any of these models counter depth?
No. All five pages state counter depth as No, and their depths with handles run from 33 1/2 to 35 inches, beyond counter depth. They will stand proud of a standard counter run. A buyer who needs a flush fit should look at the counter-depth side-by-side class instead, and expect less capacity than the 24.5 to 27.4 cu. ft. range here.
Which of these models are ENERGY STAR certified?
Three pages state it directly: the LG, Frigidaire and KitchenAid are listed as ENERGY STAR certified or qualified, and the LG prints annual use of 694 kWh. The Whirlpool page states the opposite, listing Energy Star as No. The Samsung listing page states neither, so confirm it on the maker’s model page before purchase.
Conclusion
For most households the LG LRSOS2706S is the strongest pick: two ice makers, the only printed output and storage figures, and 27.1 cu. ft. of room. The Samsung answers with the largest fresh side and Sphere Ice, the KitchenAid with door ice and measured water, while the Frigidaire and Whirlpool cover the mid-size and no-frills routes.