Key takeaways
- Compare six natural gas grills that also cook over charcoal, from tray conversions to side-by-side hybrids, with BTU, cooking area, and tray details stated.
A plumbed gas line ends the tank run, but it also locks a cook into one fuel. Natural gas grills with charcol option builds break that lock: some take a charcoal tray over the burners, some park a charcoal firebox beside the gas side, and one runs charcoal in trays across the whole surface. Six models below state both fuels on their pages.
Quick verdict
The Napoleon Prestige PRO 500 is the easy route in: a natural gas grill that takes an optional cast iron charcoal tray. The Fire Magic Aurora A830i and Coyote Centaur are side-by-side hybrids with their own charcoal zones. The AMG Encore 36 spreads charcoal across every burner, and two more Napoleons trade size for the same tray trick.
| Product | Charcoal route | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Napoleon Prestige PRO 500 RSIB, natural gas | Optional cast iron charcoal tray | Cart grill owners who want both fuels | 80,000 BTU total output | Tray is an accessory, not included |
| Napoleon Prestige 500, natural gas (P500NK-3) | Optional cast iron charcoal tray | Smaller patios, folding shelves | 48,000 BTU, 760 sq in total area | Warranty terms conflict on the listing |
| Coyote Centaur 50 in built-in hybrid (C3HY50NG) | Own charcoal side, crank tray | Built-in kitchens, one cutout | 40,000 BTU gas side, 50 in wide | Built-in only in this form |
| Fire Magic Aurora A830i, natural gas (A830I-7EAN-CB) | Own charcoal side, gas-lit tray | Cooks who run both fuels at once | 828 sq in main area, split by fuel | Two gas burners only |
| American Made Grills Encore 36, natural gas (ENC36-NG) | Multi-fuel trays over all burners | Whole-surface charcoal or wood | 110,000 BTU, 1,106 sq in | Largest and heaviest design here |
| Napoleon Prestige PRO 665 Elite, natural gas | Charcoal mode, accessory tray | Big cooks plus smart controls | 94,000 BTU, 1,141 sq in total | Charcoal tray sold separately |
How we selected
Every grill below had to clear two bars on its own product pages: the page states natural gas as the fuel, and the page states a charcoal route, whether that is an optional charcoal tray, a charcoal firebox, or a multi-fuel tray system. Models sold only for propane were left out.
Gas grills with no maker-stated charcoal path were also left out, no matter how strong the rest of the spec sheet looked.
The charcoal routes fall into three designs. A drop-in tray swaps over the sear plates of a gas grill and lights from the burners below. A side-by-side hybrid gives charcoal its own firebox, hood, and grate, so both fuels can cook at once. A multi-fuel tray system spreads trays over every burner, so the whole surface can run on gas, charcoal, wood, or a mix. Each design changes the work involved, the cleaning load, and how much charcoal cooking you actually get.
Specs below come only from the pages opened for each model: output in BTU, cooking area, tray design, dimensions, and the warranty terms the page prints. Where a page left a fact unstated or printed two versions of it, the entry says so instead of picking the friendlier number. Availability was read from the same pages, and each model showed as orderable in its natural gas form.
Natural gas grills with charcol option, model by model
The six grills below run from cart models that convert with a tray to built-in hybrids designed around two fuels from the start. Each entry states how the charcoal side works, what the gas side offers on its own, and where the design asks the owner to compromise.
Napoleon Prestige PRO 500 RSIB, natural gas
The listing page names this model a natural gas grill in its title and highlights, and its feature list includes the route to charcoal: a cast iron charcoal tray, marked optional, that the maker says turns the grill into a charcoal BBQ, lit by the gas burners with wood chips added for smoke. That is the tray design in its simplest form.
As a gas grill it is fully loaded. Total output is 80,000 BTU from four 12,000 BTU main burners, an 18,000 BTU rear infrared rotisserie burner, and a 14,000 BTU infrared side burner in the SIZZLE ZONE, which the page rates at 1800 degrees for searing. The cooking area is 17.75 by 28 inches, listed as room for 31 burgers, over 9.5 mm stainless WAVE cooking grids. The grill measures 25.5 by 66.5 by 51.75 inches and weighs 241 lb.
The warranty terms on the page are strong: a bumper to bumper lifetime warranty on major components including the hood, cooking grids, and tube burners, with sear plates and other parts covered for 15 years. The compromise is the tray itself. Charcoal cooking covers part of the surface rather than all of it, and the tray is an extra purchase, so the charcoal mode is an occasional setting on a gas grill rather than a second full grill.
- Pros: 80,000 BTU with infrared side and rear burners; tray lights from the gas burners; lifetime warranty terms
- Cons: charcoal tray sold separately; charcoal zone is partial surface
- Buy if: you want one cart grill that does both fuels well
- Skip if: you want to run gas and charcoal side by side at full size
Napoleon Prestige 500, natural gas (P500NK-3)
The Prestige 500 page states the same pairing in plainer form: a natural gas grill that can turn into a charcoal BBQ with the optional cast iron charcoal tray. The tray swaps in over the sear plates, the burners light the charcoal, and the same firebox then cooks over coals, which keeps the conversion to a few minutes of handling.
Output is 48,000 BTU, and the cooking area is 17.75 by 28 inches for the main surface, listed at 31 burgers, with total cooking area given as 760 sq in once the warming rack is counted. The grids are 7.5 mm stainless WAVE cooking grids. The cart has folding side shelves and interior cabinet storage in a pedestal base, and the grill measures 66.25 inches wide with shelves up, 26.50 inches deep, and 50.25 inches tall, so it suits patios where the PRO model’s fixed shelves would crowd the space.
One flag belongs in the open: the listing prints two warranty figures, 1 year in one line and lifetime in the spec table. Buyers should confirm the current terms with the maker before purchase rather than rely on either figure. On the cooking side, the trade-offs mirror its larger sibling: the charcoal mode is a tray conversion over part of the grill, and the tray costs extra.
- Pros: folding shelves suit tight patios; same tray conversion as the PRO line; 760 sq in total area
- Cons: warranty figures conflict on the listing; tray sold separately
- Buy if: you want the Napoleon tray system in a smaller cart
- Skip if: you need warranty terms settled before you buy
Coyote Centaur 50-inch built-in hybrid (C3HY50NG)
The Centaur takes the side-by-side route. The maker’s spec sheet titles it a 50 inch built-in charcoal and gas grill, and its model table lists the C3HY50NG version as natural gas at 40,000 BTU. One side cooks on gas burners, the other over a height adjustable charcoal tray, so the two fuels run at the same time under one 50 inch body.
The sheet lists 304 stainless steel construction, a double walled hood, adjustable dampers on the charcoal side, an integrated wind guard, and flame thrower ignition. A dealer page for the model describes the layout as two burners paired with a hand-crank tray and a pull-out drawer, and its variant table shows the natural gas version as available. Overall size is 25 3/8 inches high by 50 inches wide by 25.5 inches deep, and the cutout is 13 by 47 3/4 by 20.5 inches.
Because each fuel gets only its half, neither side matches a dedicated 50 inch grill for space. The gas side’s 40,000 BTU is also the lowest output in this group, so this is a grill for cooks who value running both fuels in one cutout over raw power. In return, the charcoal side is a real charcoal grill with damper control, not a tray conversion, and the crank tray sets coal height without opening the hood.
- Pros: true side-by-side layout in one cutout; crank adjustable charcoal tray; dampers for airflow control
- Cons: 40,000 BTU gas side; each fuel gets half the body
- Buy if: your island has room for one grill and you cook both fuels weekly
- Skip if: you need a freestanding cart model
Fire Magic Aurora A830i, natural gas (A830I-7EAN-CB)
The A830i is the other side-by-side design, and its pages are the most detailed here. The natural gas version carries its own model number, and the spec pages state the fuel pairing directly: natural gas or propane in separate versions, plus charcoal or wood chunks. Each fuel gets its own double-walled hood over one welded firebox.
The numbers split cleanly by fuel. Main cooking area is 828 sq in, with 432 sq in on the gas side and 396 sq in on the charcoal side, plus 360 sq in of warming racks for 1,188 sq in total. The gas side runs two cast stainless steel E-burners at 50,000 BTU. The charcoal side holds a hand-crank adjustable tray over a dedicated 26,000 BTU burner that lights the coals, so no chimney starter is needed. The grill measures 52.25 by 30 by 25.125 inches, weighs 300 lb, and needs a cutout of 50.25 by 19.5 by 11.5 inches.
Warranty terms are printed in tiers: lifetime cover on the cast stainless burners, cooking grids, and housing, 15 years on valves and manifold, 5 years on flavor grids, 3 years on other parts, and 1 year on ignition and electronics. The limits are structural. Two gas burners is few for a grill this size, the unit is built-in only, and it needs a 120V outlet for ignition and lights, plus an insulating liner if the island is combustible.
- Pros: separate hood per fuel; 26,000 BTU burner lights the charcoal; detailed printed warranty tiers
- Cons: only two gas burners; built-in only; needs household power
- Buy if: you run gas on weeknights and charcoal on weekends, at the same time
- Skip if: you want four or more gas burners
American Made Grills Encore 36, natural gas (ENC36-NG)
The Encore rejects the split layout entirely. Its product page, listed under the natural gas SKU, says the grill puts natural gas, propane, charcoal, lump charcoal, wood chunks, and hardwood pellets under the cook’s control, alone or in any combination, through a patented multi-fuel tray system that spans the burners.
Power is the headline: four 22,000 BTU main burners plus a rotisserie back burner give 110,000 BTU total across 1,106 sq in of cooking surface, the largest output and area in this group. The grates are 9-gauge reversible stainless V-grates, one face for open-flame grilling and the other for cooking over solid fuel. A drop-in infrared sear burner, a rotisserie kit, a stainless griddle, and a starter fuel kit with wood and charcoal are listed in the box. The page describes full 304 stainless construction and a maker warranty named the Gold Standard Lifetime Warranty.
The compromises are size, weight, and commitment. This is a 36 inch built-in head, also sold with a cart, and the tray system means every cook involves handling trays whether the fuel is charcoal or not. Cooks who only light charcoal twice a year carry a lot of hardware for the privilege. Cooks who move between gas, lump, and wood chunks in a single session get a design nothing else here matches.
- Pros: 110,000 BTU and 1,106 sq in; charcoal or wood over any burner; sear burner and griddle included
- Cons: tray handling on every cook; large, heavy built-in format
- Buy if: you mix fuels within a single cook
- Skip if: charcoal is a rare event in your cooking
Napoleon Prestige PRO 665 Elite, natural gas
The largest Napoleon adds electronics to the same two-fuel idea. Its listing states natural gas as the fuel type, and its feature list counts eight cooking modes that include cooking over charcoal, with a note that some accessories are sold separately; the charcoal mode runs on the maker’s optional charcoal tray, as on the other Prestige models.
The gas side is the biggest in the Napoleon set: 94,000 BTU across 5 main burners, a main cooking area of 37 by 18 inches listed at 41 burgers, and 1,141 sq in of total cooking area. A built-in electric smoker box adds wood smoke without opening the lid, with up to 45 minutes of burn time, and the infrared SIZZLE ZONE side burner is listed as heating to 1800 degrees F in under 30 seconds. The grill measures 76.50 inches wide, 26.50 inches deep, and 52.75 inches tall, carries a rotisserie kit, and the page states a lifetime limited warranty.
The charcoal side is the modest part of this grill. It depends on an accessory tray rather than a built-in firebox, so a buyer paying for the smart features should count the tray as part of the purchase. In exchange, the gas side adds app control, probe support, and automatic flame monitoring that none of the other five offer, which suits a cook whose charcoal use is occasional but whose gas cooking is frequent and large.
- Pros: 94,000 BTU and 1,141 sq in; electric smoker box built in; smart controls and probes
- Cons: charcoal tray is a separate accessory; widest footprint in the group
- Buy if: you host large gas cooks and want charcoal as a bonus mode
- Skip if: charcoal is your main fuel, not the bonus
Buying guide: picking among natural gas grills with charcol option
The right choice turns on how the charcoal side is built, because that decides how much charcoal cooking you get and how much work it takes. Output, area, and install format then narrow the field. The checks below follow the order that matters: charcoal design first, then the gas side you will use on the nights charcoal stays in the bag.
Choose the charcoal design before the brand
Three designs appear above. A drop-in tray, as on the three Napoleons, converts part of a gas grill and lights from the burners. A side-by-side firebox, as on the Centaur and the A830i, gives charcoal its own hood and grate. Multi-fuel trays, as on the Encore 36, spread solid fuel over every burner.
Match the design to how often charcoal actually gets lit at your house. A household that lights charcoal monthly needs a different grill than one that lights it twice a year and mostly wants the option to exist.
Check whether the tray is included or separate
On all three Napoleon models the charcoal tray is an accessory: the PRO 500 page marks it optional, the PRO 665 Elite page notes that some accessories are sold separately, and the Prestige 500 page calls it optional as well. On the Centaur, A830i, and Encore, the charcoal hardware is part of the grill.
A tray bought later is a small added purchase, but it decides whether the grill cooks over charcoal on day one.
Compare gas output and area per fuel
Totals flatter split grills, so read the per-fuel figures. The A830i lists 828 sq in of main area but only 432 sq in of it is gas, over two burners at 50,000 BTU. The Centaur’s gas side is 40,000 BTU. The Encore 36 puts 110,000 BTU under the full 1,106 sq in, and the PRO 665 Elite lists 94,000 BTU with a 37 by 18 inch main area.
Size the gas side for your weeknight cooking first. A big total number means little if the zone you use nightly is the small one.
Confirm the natural gas version before ordering
These grills are fuel-specific. The A830i sells natural gas and propane as separate versions, the Centaur’s spec sheet lists separate model numbers for each fuel, and the Encore page lists its natural gas SKU directly. Napoleon states on its pages that its freestanding grills cannot be converted between fuels later.
Order the version that matches your line, and have a licensed installer make the connection.
Plan the install: cutout, power, and clearance
Built-in models live or die on dimensions. The Centaur needs a cutout 47 3/4 inches wide, the A830i one of 50.25 by 19.5 by 11.5 inches, and the A830i also needs a 120V outlet and an insulating liner in a combustible island. Cart models ask less of the patio.
The PRO 500 measures 66.5 inches wide and the PRO 665 Elite 76.50 inches, so measure the patio run before falling for the largest grill.
FAQ
Most questions about this category are really one question: how real is the charcoal side? The answers below use the designs and figures stated on the six product pages above, from tray swaps to dedicated fireboxes, so the differences between designs stay concrete.
Are natural gas grills with charcol option as good as a separate charcoal grill?
It depends on the design. The side-by-side models give charcoal its own firebox, hood, and grate: the A830i lists 396 sq in of charcoal area with a crank tray, and the Centaur lists a height adjustable tray with dampers. Tray conversions on the Napoleon models cook over real charcoal too, but on part of the surface.
For full charcoal sessions, the dedicated firebox designs sit closest to a standalone grill.
How does a charcoal tray light without lighter fluid?
The burners do the work. On the Napoleon tray, the page says to light the charcoal with the gas burners, then turn them off once the coals catch. The A830i builds the idea in, with a dedicated 26,000 BTU burner under its charcoal tray. The Encore lights its trays from the main burners.
In each design the gas side acts as the starter, which removes the chimney and the fluid from the routine.
Can I convert a propane grill to natural gas later?
For these models, plan on no. Napoleon states that its freestanding grills are not convertible and offers no conversion kits for them, and the built-in brands here sell natural gas and propane as separate versions with different model numbers. The Encore lists its natural gas SKU on the product page.
Choose the fuel at purchase, and treat a later fuel change as a new grill, not a kit.
Can gas and charcoal cook at the same time?
On the side-by-side designs, yes: the Centaur and the A830i run both fuels at once under separate hoods, which is their main reason to exist. The Encore 36 can mix fuels across its trays in one cook, with some zones on gas and others over charcoal or wood.
On the tray-conversion Napoleons, the tray occupies part of the firebox, so the remaining burners can still run, but the charcoal zone itself is one setting at a time.
Conclusion
For most buyers, the Napoleon Prestige PRO 500 is the balanced pick: full gas power, a tray that adds real charcoal, and lifetime warranty terms. Choose the A830i or the Encore 36 if charcoal is a weekly habit. Any of these natural gas grills with charcol option ends the tank run without giving up coals.