Key takeaways
- Six mixers for makers mark that suit a rounded bourbon: a cola built for whiskey, two ginger pours, sweet tea, cherry cola and lemonade, with the label facts.
Bourbon highballs live or die on the mixer, because the spirit brings the richness and the mixer decides whether the glass turns spiced, fruity, or sharp. The best mixers for makers mark lean sweet and warm rather than bitter: cola, ginger in two forms, tea, cherry, and lemon. Each was read from an opened page.
Quick verdict
Start with the Fever-Tree Distillers Cola. It is the only bottle in this set designed for whiskey by name, with a bourbon serve printed by its own maker, and it flatters a bourbon cola the way the standard colas never quite manage to do. If only one bottle comes home, it should be that one.
The two ginger pours split by style. Bundaberg is the brewed, cane sugar bottle with a soft, round spice, while the Bruce Cost ale is unfiltered fresh ginger with a rawer bite. Pure Leaf sweet tea makes the tall, easy highball, Coca-Cola Cherry turns the cola serve fruity, and Simply Lemonade is the bright, still option for drinkers who want citrus without any fizz at all.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec per serving | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bundaberg Ginger Beer | Brewed ginger beer | A long, spiced highball | 170 calories, 40 g sugars per 12.7 fl oz bottle | Sweetest ginger pour here |
| Fever-Tree Distillers Cola | Cola for dark spirits | The whiskey cola | 70 calories, 18 g sugars per 6.8 fl oz bottle | One small bottle per drink |
| Pure Leaf Sweet Tea | Brewed sweet tea | A tall tea highball | 160 calories, 42 g sugars per 18.5 fl oz bottle | Caffeine in every pour |
| Bruce Cost Ginger Ale | Unfiltered ginger ale | A ginger-forward ale serve | 160 calories, 37 g sugars per 12 fl oz | Strong raw ginger bite |
| Coca-Cola Cherry | Cherry cola | A fruit-led cola serve | 150 calories, 42 g sugars per 12 fl oz can | Sweetest cola in the set |
| Simply Lemonade | Lemonade | The bourbon lemonade | 120 calories, 28 g sugars per 8 fl oz | No fizz; fridge bottle |
How we selected
Each product was read from an opened maker page, brand release, or label listing, and each had to bring a different register to the bourbon: spice, cola depth, tea, fruit, or citrus. The set also had to stay apart from the whiskey lists already published in this project, so the colas and teas used there stay there.
Sweetness is the honest theme of this shelf. The lightest pour, the Distillers Cola, still carries 18 g of sugar in a small bottle, and the sweet tea and cherry cola top the set at 42 g. That is the nature of bourbon mixing: the classic partners are sweet, and the labels below let a drinker choose where on that scale each glass lands.
Caffeine draws the second line through the set. The tea, the cherry cola, and the whiskey cola all carry some, in amounts their makers print, while the two ginger pours and the lemonade carry none. A shelf stocked for evening drinking has to know which side of that line each bottle sits on, and the sections below mark it for every product.
Six mixers for makers mark, compared
The order runs from the spiced pours to the fruit and citrus. Two ginger drinks open the set because ginger and bourbon is the serve most often poured, then the cola built for whiskey, then tea, cherry cola, and lemonade for the drinkers who want the glass softer still.
Bundaberg Ginger Beer
Most ginger beers are flavored sodas; this one is brewed, with yeast in the ingredient list beside the ginger root and cane sugar. Brewing gives it a rounder, softer spice than the sharp ginger ales, and that roundness sits comfortably against a rich bourbon pour.
The maker’s panel for the 375 ml bottle lists 40.1 g total carbohydrate and 39.8 g sugars, with sodium at 42 mg and fat and protein each under 1 g; US labels for the same 12.7 fl oz bottle work out at about 170 calories and 40 g of sugars. The ingredients are carbonated water, cane sugar, ginger root, natural flavors, citric acid, yeast, preservatives, and ascorbic acid as antioxidant.
The sweetness is the trade. At roughly 40 g of sugar a bottle, this is a dessert-leaning highball mixer, and a long pour over bourbon tastes closer to a ginger snap than to a dry refresher. Drinkers who like their bourbon drinks soft and spiced will call that a feature; everyone else should pour it shorter.
- Pros: brewed with yeast for a round spice; cane sugar; single bottle servings
- Cons: about 40 g sugars per bottle; soft carbonation fades in a long drink; imported bottle format
- Buy if: your bourbon highball should taste spiced and mellow
- Skip if: you want a dry, sharp ginger pour
Fever-Tree Distillers Cola
This cola was built for the exact job on this page. The maker says it was designed for mixing with rums and whiskeys, and prints its own Whiskey Cola serve: three parts cola to one part bourbon whiskey, finished with a curl of lemon rind over ice. It reached the market in 2021 with exactly this job in mind.
Per 6.8 fl oz bottle, the label lists 70 calories, 0 g total fat, 0 mg sodium, 18 g total carbohydrate, 18 g sugars, and 0 g protein. The ingredients are carbonated spring water, sugar, natural flavoring, roast malt extract, citric acid, caffeine, and natural kola flavoring. The recipe behind the flavoring runs to Caribbean kola nuts, Tahitian limes, Jamaican pimento berries, Madagascan vanilla, and Sicilian lemons.
The maker states the cola carries 18 percent less sugar than conventional colas and contains no high fructose corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, colors, or GMO ingredients. In the glass that restraint is the point: the maker says the lime, spice, and vanilla are tuned to complement the butterscotch and charred oak notes of whiskey rather than cover them.
- Pros: designed for whiskey, with a printed bourbon serve; real kola nut; less sugar than standard colas
- Cons: small bottle, one per drink; caffeine from the kola nut; craft pricing tier
- Buy if: the bourbon cola is your serve and you want the whiskey to stay in front
- Skip if: you pour cola drinks by the pitcher
Pure Leaf Sweet Tea
Sweet tea and bourbon is a pairing with deep Southern roots, and this bottle is the straightforward way to pour it: real brewed black tea, sugar, and nothing else on the label. Poured long over bourbon and ice, it makes the easiest highball in this set.
The 18.5 fl oz bottle lists 160 calories, 5 mg sodium, and 42 g sugars, with caffeine at 69 mg per bottle. The ingredients are brewed black tea, sugar, and citric acid, and the maker notes the tea leaves carry Rainforest Alliance certification. The brand copy stresses the method: brewed from real tea leaves, never from powder or concentrate, with no artificial sweeteners and no artificial flavors.
Two facts govern this pick. The first is the caffeine, 69 mg in a bottle, which makes the tea highball a daytime and early evening drink for most people. The second is the sugar, 42 g, level with the cherry cola as the sweetest in the set. The directions ask for the fridge after opening, and the big bottle is best finished within days.
- Pros: three ingredient label; real brewed tea; no artificial sweeteners or flavors
- Cons: 69 mg caffeine per bottle; 42 g sugars; needs refrigeration after opening
- Buy if: a tall tea highball is your warm weather bourbon serve
- Skip if: you pour bourbon drinks in the late evening
Bruce Cost Ginger Ale
Where the Bundaberg above is brewed and round, this ginger ale is raw and direct. The name on the label says unfiltered, the ingredient list leads with 100 percent fresh ginger, and the pour carries the heat and texture of the root itself rather than a ginger flavoring.
Per 12 fl oz, the label record lists 160 calories, 0 g total fat, 0 mg sodium, 40 g total carbohydrate, 37 g total sugars, and 0 g protein, with iron at 2 mg. The ingredients are four items long: carbonated water, pure cane sugar, 100 percent fresh ginger, and citric acid. No colors, no preservatives, and no flavoring line at all.
Unfiltered means the bottle carries sediment, so a gentle roll before pouring is part of serving it, and the ginger bite is strong enough to push back against a rich bourbon. That is the appeal for ginger drinkers, and the warning for everyone else: this is the most assertive pour in the set, and it will not sit quietly behind the spirit.
- Pros: 100 percent fresh ginger; four ingredient label; zero sodium
- Cons: raw ginger heat is strong; sediment in the bottle; 37 g sugars per pour
- Buy if: you want the ginger to argue with the bourbon, pleasantly
- Skip if: you prefer a smooth, filtered ginger ale
Coca-Cola Cherry
Cherry and bourbon meet in classic cocktails built on fruit, and this can brings that pairing to the simple highball. It is the maker’s long running cherry cola, on sale since 1985, with the cherry carried in the natural flavors rather than in any juice.
Per 12 fl oz can, the maker’s page lists 150 calories, 0 g total fat, 35 mg sodium, 42 g total carbohydrate, and 42 g total sugars, all of it added, with caffeine at 34 mg per can. The ingredients are carbonated water, high fructose corn syrup, caramel color, phosphoric acid, and natural flavors, plus the caffeine. The maker also notes the drink contains no Red 40.
The honest limit is sweetness. At 42 g of sugar, this ties the sweet tea as the sweetest pour here, and the cherry reads as confectionery rather than orchard fruit. Poured over a generous measure of bourbon with plenty of ice, that sweetness is the style of the drink; poured warm or short, it takes over the glass.
- Pros: cherry cola profile suits bourbon; cans everywhere in several sizes; caffeine listed by the maker
- Cons: 42 g added sugars per can; corn syrup sweetened; cherry is flavoring, not juice
- Buy if: your bourbon highball should lean fruity and sweet
- Skip if: you are watching added sugar
Simply Lemonade
The lemonade is the still pour of the set, and the simplest label: filtered water, lemon juice, cane sugar, and natural flavors. Bourbon lemonade is a porch drink by tradition, tart enough to cut the spirit’s richness and sweet enough to stay easy. The same bottle also anchors the non-alcoholic side of the table without any extra buying.
Per 8 fl oz serving, the label record for the 52 fl oz bottle lists 120 calories, 0 g total fat, 14 mg sodium, 30 g total carbohydrate, 28 g total sugars, and 0 g protein. The sugar is cane sugar, and the lemon is present as lemon juice, the second ingredient, rather than as a flavoring at the end of the list.
Without carbonation, this is the mixer that asks for the coldest serve and the most ice, because nothing lifts the drink once it warms. It is also the most flexible bottle here at breakfast-adjacent hours, since a lemonade highball at low strength is a long, mild drink. Keep the bottle refrigerated and shake it before pouring.
- Pros: lemon juice is the second ingredient; cane sugar; no caffeine, no fizz to lose
- Cons: 28 g sugars per small serving; flat pours need plenty of ice; fridge space for a big bottle
- Buy if: bourbon lemonade is the house summer drink
- Skip if: you want bubbles in every highball
Buying guide
Bourbon mixing is mostly a sweetness decision. Every classic partner on this page is sweetened, so the useful skill is choosing how sweet, and in which flavor direction, rather than hunting for a dry mixer that the tradition never really produced. The four sections below take those decisions in order.
How sweet should mixers for makers mark run?
The set spans 18 g of sugar in the small Distillers Cola bottle to 42 g in the sweet tea and the cherry cola, and the pour size matters as much as the number. A highball built at three parts mixer to one part bourbon drinks the whole bottle, so the label figure is the glass figure.
A practical approach is to keep two registers on the shelf: a restrained bottle like the Distillers Cola for neat-leaning drinkers, and one full-sweet bottle like the Bundaberg or the sweet tea for everyone else. The same bourbon then pours two very different drinks, and nobody at the table has to compromise.
Ginger beer or ginger ale with bourbon?
The two ginger pours here answer different tastes. The brewed Bundaberg is round and soft, its spice folded into cane sugar sweetness, and it makes the gentler highball. The unfiltered Bruce Cost ale is raw ginger with sediment and heat, and it makes the louder one.
Sugar separates them less than texture does: about 40 g in the Bundaberg bottle against 37 g in the Bruce Cost. Choose on the ginger itself. Drinkers who order ginger drinks for the burn should start with the ale; drinkers who want spice as background should start with the brewed beer.
Mind the caffeine in evening pours
Three bottles in this set carry caffeine, and the amounts differ enough to matter. The sweet tea leads at 69 mg per bottle, the cherry cola follows at 34 mg per can, and the Distillers Cola contains caffeine from its kola nut without a printed milligram figure on the label record.
For late pours, the ginger beer, the ginger ale, and the lemonade are the caffeine-free side of the shelf, and none of their labels list caffeine at all. Bourbon is an evening spirit for many households, so checking this one line before stocking saves the midnight wide-awake surprise.
Bottle sizes and the three to one habit
Highball math runs through every format here. The Distillers Cola bottle is a single drink at the maker’s three to one serve, the Bundaberg bottle is one long pour, and the tea and lemonade bottles hold several drinks each. Buying by the drink count, not the bottle count, keeps the shelf honest.
Carbonation argues for small formats: the cola and ginger pours are at their best freshly opened, while the tea and lemonade keep in the fridge for days of shorter pours. A mixed shelf, small bottles of the fizzy mixers and one big bottle of a still one, matches how the drinks are actually made.
FAQ
Most questions about bourbon mixers come down to the same three things: which bottle the maker aimed at whiskey, how the two ginger styles differ, and where the caffeine and sugar hide. The answers below use only the labels and maker pages behind this list.
Which mixers for makers mark add caffeine?
Three of the six. The sweet tea carries the most, at 69 mg per 18.5 fl oz bottle, because it is brewed black tea. The cherry cola lists 34 mg per 12 fl oz can on the maker’s page. The Distillers Cola lists caffeine in its ingredients, from the kola nut, without a milligram figure.
The ginger beer, the ginger ale, and the lemonade list no caffeine on their labels. Bourbon drinks are often evening drinks, so a household that pours after dinner can build the whole serve from those three and never think about the question again.
Why is there a cola designed for whiskey?
Because standard cola is built to be the whole flavor of the glass, and a good bourbon does not need the help. The maker of the Distillers Cola says it restrained the sweetness, 18 percent less sugar than conventional colas, and layered in lime, spice, and vanilla so the whiskey’s own notes stay audible.
The printed serve makes the intent plain: three parts cola to one part bourbon, with lemon rind over the top. Whether it earns its shelf place is a taste question, but the design brief is stated by the maker rather than guessed at, which is why the bottle leads this list.
Can sweet tea really carry a bourbon drink?
Yes, and it is one of the oldest pairings in American drinking, tea and whiskey having shared glasses for a very long time. The tannin in brewed black tea gives the drink a structure that fruit sodas lack, so the highball tastes like a composed drink rather than a spiked soda.
The Pure Leaf bottle is the simple route in: brewed tea, sugar, citric acid, and no artificial sweeteners or flavors. Pour it long over ice with the bourbon, and remember the 69 mg of caffeine and 42 g of sugar in the bottle when you plan the second round.
What is the lightest pour in this set?
The Distillers Cola, by a wide margin: 70 calories and 18 g of sugar in its 6.8 fl oz bottle, against 120 calories and 28 g of sugar in even the lemonade’s smaller 8 fl oz serving. The gap comes from the format as much as the recipe, since the cola bottle is one modest drink.
Per ounce the picture tightens, and the honest summary is that every mixer here is sweetened. Bourbon’s classic partners are sweet drinks, and this set reflects that. Drinkers who want the spirit with almost nothing added are better served by the soda and seltzer lists elsewhere in this project.
Conclusion
For a bourbon shelf, buy the cola that was designed for whiskey and one ginger in the style you prefer, brewed and round or unfiltered and hot. Add sweet tea for tall summer pours and lemonade for still ones, and the cherry cola when the table wants fruit. Each figure here came from a label or a maker’s page.