Key takeaways
- Compare six indoor smokeless grills for steaks with infrared heat, fan extraction and water trays, 446 to 500 degrees and 108 to 121 square inches of grate.
Steak night indoors works when the grill handles fat before it burns. The indoor smokeless grills for steaks below use infrared heat, extractor fans, cool-air zones and water trays to cut smoke, and they reach 446 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, hot enough to sear a ribeye with real grill marks on both sides.
The 6 picks at a glance
The table lines up the six grills by the design each maker uses to hold smoke down, the top heat on the maker page and the rated power. Two reach a stated 500 or 446 degrees for hard searing, and the rest trade peak heat for fans, water trays or a lighter build.
| Product | Smoke-control design | Top heat | Power |
|---|---|---|---|
| Philips Smoke-less Indoor Grill HD6371/94 | Infrared heat, reflectors, cool grease tray | 446 degrees Fahrenheit, constant | 1660 watts |
| Ninja Foodi Smart XL Grill DG551 | Splatter shield and cool-air zone | 500 degrees Fahrenheit | 1760 watts |
| PowerXL Smokeless Grill Pro PG-1500FDR | Built-in fan, water collection pan | 450 degrees Fahrenheit | 1500 watts |
| PowerXL Smokeless Grill Elite SMG-01 | Built-in fan, water tray | 450 degrees Fahrenheit | 1500 watts |
| Gotham Steel Smokeless Grill 1618 | Drip tray cools grease | Four dial settings | 1500 watts |
| Chefman Electric Smokeless Indoor Grill RJ23-SG | Water tray cools grease | Warm to Sear dial | 1120 watts |
No design on this page makes a fatty steak cook with literally no smoke at all, and the makers do not claim that either. What the designs do is attack the cause: fat that lands on a hot surface and burns. Keep fat away from the hottest parts, cool it fast or pull the vapor away with a fan, and the kitchen stays far clearer than it would over an open pan.
How the indoor smokeless grills for steaks here cut smoke
Smoke at the grill comes from one event repeated many times: rendered fat dripping onto a surface hot enough to burn it. Every model in this list interrupts that event in a different place, and the interruption point decides how the grill cooks, how it cleans and what it asks of the cook standing over it.
The Philips works before the drip. Its reflectors aim infrared heat up at the grid while the grease tray below stays cool, so fat that falls through lands on a cool surface instead of a hot one. The two PowerXL models work after the drip and in the air: a water-filled tray catches the fat, and a built-in fan pulls vapor away from the cooking surface while a sealed glass lid holds splatter in. The Ninja works at the surface itself, pairing a temperature-controlled grate with a splatter shield and a zone of cool air above the food. The Gotham Steel and the Chefman use the simplest version of the idea, a tray of cool water or a cooling drip pan under an open grate.
- Cool-tray designs (Philips, Gotham Steel, Chefman): fat lands on a cool surface and never burns, so there is little vapor to manage.
- Fan designs (both PowerXL models): an extractor fan draws vapor away while water in the tray cools the drippings.
- Shield designs (Ninja): a splatter shield and cool-air zone keep fat off the heating element and dilute what vapor forms.
- Lid designs (Ninja, both PowerXL models): a closed lid holds splatter and vapor inside the unit instead of the room.
Steak is the hardest test for these designs, because a well-marbled ribeye renders fat steadily for the whole cook instead of dripping briefly and stopping. The longer fat renders, the more chances it has to reach a surface hot enough to burn, which is why tray temperature and fan strength matter more for steak than for almost any other food cooked indoors.
Fat content still matters. The Philips sheet says plainly that beef and chicken produce hardly any smoke on its grid while pork and lamb can produce slightly more, though much less than on a conventional grill. A well-marbled ribeye will test any of these designs harder than a lean sirloin, and trimming loose external fat before cooking helps every model on the list.
The best indoor smokeless grills for steaks, in detail
The six detailed sections below run from the infrared Philips through the fan-driven PowerXL pair to the two open water-tray grills. Each section sticks to the numbers on the maker page or manual: rated watts, stated temperatures, surface sizes where the maker publishes them, and the exact smoke-control parts each design uses.
Philips Smoke-less Indoor Grill HD6371/94: infrared heat at one constant temperature
The Philips takes the opposite path from every dial-driven grill here: it has no temperature settings to choose. Its infrared elements hold the grid at a constant 446 degrees Fahrenheit, the heat the maker picked for searing meat, and a keep-warm function holds finished food until the rest of the meal is ready to serve.
The specification sheet rates the grill at 1660 watts on 120 volts and lists a product weight of 5.6 kilograms. Special reflectors guide the heat toward the grid while the grease tray underneath stays cool, which is the whole smoke strategy: fat collects in the extra-large tray without burning. Philips states up to 80 percent less smoke from this arrangement, a maker figure quoted here as the brand presents it. The grid itself is die-cast aluminum with a non-stick finish, shaped to leave barbecue-style marks, and the unit is only two parts, grid and tray, so setup takes under a minute by the sheet. Detachable parts are listed by the maker for dishwasher cleaning. For a cook who wants one correct steak temperature with nothing to adjust, this is the most direct design in the group.
Ninja Foodi Smart XL Grill DG551: 500 degrees and a thermometer probe
The Ninja is the heat leader here. Its cyclonic grilling technology pairs 500 degree Fahrenheit circulating air with a grill grate that also reaches 500 degrees, and the listing rates the unit at 1760 watts. The ceramic-coated grate measures 9 by 12 inches, 108 square inches of cooking surface, and the maker says it fits up to 6 steaks at once.
Smoke control here is a named system with three parts: a temperature-controlled grill grate, a splatter shield and a cool-air zone, which together reduce smoke and keep it out of the kitchen in the maker’s wording. Steak doneness is handled by the Foodi Smart Thermometer, with 4 protein settings and 9 customizable doneness levels from rare to well done. Beyond grilling, the unit air fries, roasts, bakes, broils and dehydrates, and the removable grate, crisper basket and cooking pot are listed by the maker for dishwasher cleaning. The body measures 15.7 by 11.1 by 16 inches and the listing carries a 1 year limited warranty. The maker copy also credits the grill with taking foods from frozen to char-grilled in under 25 minutes. Kitchens that grill for a family and want the probe to call doneness get the most complete package here.
PowerXL Smokeless Grill Pro PG-1500FDR: fan extraction with a glass lid
The Pro version of the PowerXL pairs a built-in extractor fan with a water-filled collection pan. The manual rates the unit at 1500 watts on 120 volts and gives a temperature range of 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, set with buttons rather than a dial, with the 200 to 250 degree band suggested for keeping food warm after cooking.
Before cooking, about 2 cups of water go into the collection pan, where dripping fat lands and cools. The fan is meant to run through the whole cooking session, drawing vapor away from the plate, and the silicone-sealed hinged glass lid holds heat and splatter in while still letting the cook watch the food. The maker’s own summary is measured: the unit is designed and engineered to reduce the smoke and visible vapors of grilling to a minimum. The nonstick grill plate can be swapped for a griddle plate on versions that include one, and the manual lists the grill plate, drip tray, collection pan and glass lid for the bottom rack of a dishwasher or for hand washing. The manual cooking chart gives steak 3 to 9 minutes per side, the widest steak window in this group. The control panel lights an indicator when the fan is running, so the cook can confirm the extraction is on before the first steak goes down.
PowerXL Smokeless Grill Elite SMG-01: the larger fan model with cross-hatch plate
The Elite shares the Pro’s formula, fan plus water tray, in a bigger body. The manual rates it at 1500 watts on 120 volts with the same 200 to 450 degree Fahrenheit range, and it lists the appliance dimensions at 21.02 by 11.65 by 6.61 inches, the longest footprint of any grill in this article.
Its water tray takes about three quarters of a cup of water, less than the Pro asks for, and its grill plate carries a cross-hatch pattern that leaves a crisscross mark on steaks. The fan runs from its own button on the control panel, the hinged glass lid is silicone-sealed, and the manual describes the same design goal as the Pro: smoke and visible vapors reduced to a minimum rather than erased. The manual lists parts for dishwasher cleaning. Between the two PowerXL models, the choice is mostly size and plate pattern: the Elite suits a long counter and cooks who like the cross-hatch finish, while the Pro is the smaller footprint of the pair. The manual lists a cord of 35.43 inches, a detail worth checking against where the outlets sit along the counter.
Gotham Steel Smokeless Grill 1618: the lightest open grill here
The Gotham Steel is the open-grate traditionalist of the group. The listing rates it at 1.5 kilowatts with 4 power levels on a removable temperature control, gives a cooking surface of 120.75 square inches and a weight of just 4.9 pounds, the lightest figure here by a wide margin, inside a body measuring 17.32 by 14 by 3.94 inches.
Its smoke control is a single idea, executed in the drip tray: the tray is designed to cool grease quickly as it falls, and the maker states that this reduces virtually all hot smoke. The cooking surface carries the brand’s ceramic and titanium reinforced nonstick coating, applied in three layers by the listing, and the heating element spreads across the full surface for even heat. The grill plate is listed by the maker for dishwasher cleaning, and the listing carries a 10 year warranty, the longest coverage figure in this article. The listing describes the coating as holding up to metal spatulas, spoons and whisks, and the aluminum exterior as dense and wear-resistant. There is no lid and no fan, so splatter control rests on the cook, but for a small kitchen that wants an open grill that stores flat and weighs under 5 pounds, nothing else here comes close.
Chefman Electric Smokeless Indoor Grill RJ23-SG: heat zones from warm to sear
The Chefman is the gentlest grill in the group at 1120 watts on 120 volts, and it leans on water and layout rather than force. Its removable water tray must be filled between the minimum and maximum lines before cooking; the water cools falling grease on contact, which the maker credits for the reduced smoke and for easier cleanup afterward.
The control is a single knob that runs from Warm to Sear with no degree markings, and the surface is built with heat zones that vary across the grill, so a steak can sit over the hot zone while vegetables rest in a gentler one. The body measures 20.5 by 10.5 by 3.5 inches and weighs 5.3 pounds. The grill top and the water tray both come off and are listed by the maker for dishwasher cleaning, and the manual notes cool-touch handles and overheat auto shut-off among its features. The manual gives a preheat of about 5 to 10 minutes before the indicator light signals that the grill is ready. Chefman backs the grill with a 1-year assurance. For mixed plates of steak and vegetables cooked at once, the zoned surface is the practical draw here.
How to choose indoor smokeless grills for steaks
Start with the smoke design that fits the kitchen, then check heat. A fan model needs its fan run for the whole session and suits cooks who grill fatty cuts often. A cool-tray model asks almost nothing of the cook but gives up the lid, and a shield model sits between the two in both effort and parts count.
Peak heat decides the crust
A steak crust forms when the surface stays hot, and the stated top temperatures here run from the Philips constant 446 degrees to the Ninja at 500 degrees, with both PowerXL models at 450. The Gotham Steel and Chefman use dial settings without published degree figures, so their searing strength is judged by wattage and plate build instead.
Wattage supports the same ranking. The Ninja at 1760 watts and the Philips at 1660 watts carry the strongest ratings, the PowerXL pair and the Gotham Steel sit at 1500 watts, and the Chefman at 1120 watts is built for gentler, zoned cooking. High watts alone do not brown a steak, but they help the plate recover heat after a cold steak lands on it.
Surface size and steak count
Published surfaces run from the Ninja grate at 108 square inches to the Gotham Steel at 120.75 square inches, and the Ninja listing states its grate fits up to 6 steaks at once. The Philips and the PowerXL models publish no surface area on the pages opened for this article, so judge their fit from the body dimensions in the detailed sections.
Crowding matters more than raw area. Steaks packed edge to edge steam in their own juices and brown poorly on any grill, whatever the brochure capacity says. Leaving a gap between steaks keeps the surface hot and the marks defined, so a household that grills four thick steaks at once should read every capacity figure in this article as a ceiling, not a plan.
Doneness help: probes, charts and guesswork
Only the Ninja offers a built-in answer to doneness, with its thermometer probe and 9 doneness levels. The PowerXL Pro manual answers with a cooking chart, 3 to 9 minutes per side for steak. The Philips removes the question by holding one searing temperature, and the dial models leave timing to the cook and a separate thermometer.
What does not change between listings is the parts list: count the trays, lids and plates a design asks the household to wash and store, and weigh that count against how often steak night actually happens in the kitchen.
Buying guide: fat, lids and cleanup
Three ownership details separate these grills after the first week: where the fat ends up, whether a lid holds splatter in, and how many parts need washing. The sections below use only design facts from the maker pages, because those are the details that decide whether a grill gets used weekly or stored away.
Where the fat goes
Every model here gives fat a cool destination. The Philips collects it in an extra-large grease tray under a cool zone, the PowerXL pair and the Chefman float it on tray water, the Gotham Steel cools it in its drip tray, and the Ninja keeps it off the heating element behind a splatter shield.
Water trays need refilling on long sessions and emptying while the water is greasy, so cooks who grill in long stretches may prefer the Philips dry tray or the Gotham Steel pan.
Lids, splatter and counter mess
The Ninja and both PowerXL models cook under lids, which hold splatter inside the unit and keep the counter cleaner around the grill. The Philips, Gotham Steel and Chefman are open grills: simpler, lighter and easier to store, but a fatty steak will throw some fine splatter onto the surrounding counter.
Open designs also let the cook see and turn food without lifting anything, which some steak cooks prefer for judging the crust as it forms.
Cleanup part count
The Philips has the shortest wash list, a grid and a tray. The Chefman asks for its grill top and water tray, both listed for dishwasher cleaning. The PowerXL models add a glass lid and a collection pan to the plate and tray, and the Ninja adds a crisper basket and cooking pot to its grate.
Every one of those parts is listed by its maker for dishwasher cleaning, so the real difference is sink time and storage space for the parts, not the method.
Questions, answered
The answers below stick to what the maker pages state about smoke, heat and care. Where a maker gives a figure, the answer quotes the figure as the brand presents it, and where the pages are silent, the answer says so rather than filling the gap with a guess or a number from another model.
Do smokeless grills make no smoke at all?
No maker here promises that. Philips states up to 80 percent less smoke, PowerXL describes smoke and visible vapors reduced to a minimum, and Ninja describes a system that reduces smoke. Fatty cuts still produce some vapor on any hot surface, so a window open or a range hood on low remains a sensible partner for steak night on every model here.
Which of these grills sears hardest?
On stated figures, the Ninja reaches the most heat, with 500 degree air and a 500 degree grate, followed by the Philips at a constant 446 degrees. The PowerXL pair top out at 450 degrees. The Gotham Steel and Chefman publish dial settings rather than degrees, so their peak heat cannot be ranked from the maker pages opened here.
What keeps smoke down most: fan, water or infrared?
Each method attacks a different point in the same chain. Infrared heat with a cool tray stops fat from burning in the first place. Water trays cool fat the moment it lands. Fans pull away whatever vapor still forms, and splatter shields keep fat off the heating element.
The makers publish no shared test that ranks the methods against each other, so the honest answer is that all four work on the same cause, and the best fit depends on the kitchen and the cuts cooked most often.
For most steak cooks, the Ninja DG551 is the strongest all-round pick here, with the highest stated heat, a thermometer probe and room for 6 steaks. The Philips is the purist choice, one constant searing temperature and the fewest parts to wash.
The two PowerXL models suit cooks who grill fatty cuts often and want a fan doing the air work. The Gotham Steel suits small kitchens that prize light weight and a long warranty, and the Chefman suits mixed plates that use its heat zones. Match the smoke design to the kitchen first, and the steak results follow from there.