Key takeaways
- Compare grills for smoking cheese that keep heat near zero: two low-temperature electric smokers, three cold smoke generators and one slow smoker attachment.
Cheese softens and slumps long before it cooks, so grills for smoking cheese succeed or fail on one point: how much heat reaches the rack along with the smoke. This guide compares two low-temperature electric smokers, three add-on cold smoke generators and one slow smoker attachment, each picked for low stated heat and long smoke times.
Quick verdict
For most people, the Smoke Chief generator is the simplest route in this group: it attaches to a grill or smoker you already own and, in the maker’s words, cold-smokes with 0 degrees F of heat added. Cooks who want a dedicated box should start with the Little Chief, and Masterbuilt owners get the longest unattended smoke run from the Slow Smoker.
The two Smokehouse electric smokers hold a steady 165 degrees F, the lowest fixed temperature in this comparison, and the maker’s own cheese guide uses them for cheddar, gouda and brie. The three generators take a different approach: the burn stays outside the cooking chamber, so the cheese sits in smoke while the fire stays elsewhere. The Big Kahuna burns chips and chunks in short loads, the Magnum P.I.G. stretches a load further in big cabinets, and the Masterbuilt Slow Smoker feeds chips on its own for up to 6 hours. Every pick below earned its place from a stated temperature, a stated smoke time or a stated cold smoke feature on its maker or listing page.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smokehouse Products Little Chief Front Load Electric Smoker | Electric smoker | A dedicated cheese box | Steady 165 degrees F from a 250 watt element | One fixed temperature, no dial |
| Smokehouse Products Big Chief Front Load Electric Smoker | Electric smoker | Bigger batches of cheese | 50 pound capacity at a steady 165 degrees F | One fixed temperature, wider body |
| Smokehouse Products Smoke Chief Cold Smoke Generator | Cold smoke generator | Any grill or smoker you own | Up to 3 hours of smoke from 1 cup of pellets | Smoke tube needs regular cleaning |
| Smoke Daddy Big Kahuna Cold Smoke Generator | Cold smoke generator | Chips and chunks, strong smoke | Up to 45 minutes of burn time per load | Mounting needs a drilled 1-1/8 inch hole |
| Smoke Daddy Magnum P.I.G. Cold Smoke Generator | Cold smoke generator | Large smokers and cabinets | Up to 2.5 hours of smoke per full load | Built for smokers of 6 cubic feet and up |
| Masterbuilt Slow Smoker | Smoker attachment | Masterbuilt electric smoker owners | Up to 6 hours of continuous smoke | Fits Masterbuilt smokers only |
How we selected
Cheese sets a hard filter that most grills fail: the smoke source has to run for an hour or more while the chamber stays cool enough that blocks hold their shape. Each pick below shows a stated cold smoke feature, a stated low operating temperature or a burn chamber that sits outside the food space on its maker or listing page.
The shortlist favors separation between fire and food. Two picks are electric smokers whose only heat setting is a low 165 degrees F, low enough that the maker’s cheese guide uses them with the door cracked open to shed heat. Three picks are generators that burn pellets, chips or chunks in their own housing and pipe the smoke in. The last pick is an attachment that feeds chips automatically while the host smoker’s heating element stays off, which its manual describes as the way to cold smoke cheese. Models with no stated low-temperature or cold smoke claim were left out, however good they are at ribs or brisket.
Six grills for smoking cheese and cold smoke setups
The six picks split into two camps. The Little Chief and Big Chief are full smokers with racks, drip pans and one low heat setting. The Smoke Chief, Big Kahuna and Magnum P.I.G. are generators that turn a grill or cabinet you own into a cold smoker. The Masterbuilt Slow Smoker sits between the camps as a powered attachment.
Smokehouse Products Little Chief Front Load Electric Smoker
The Little Chief is the dedicated cheese box in this group: a small aluminum electric smoker that holds one steady temperature of 165 degrees F and nothing higher. The maker’s cheese guide smokes cheddar, gouda, brie and cream cheese in this unit, which is exactly the workload most home cheese smokers start with.
The listing page lists a 250 watt heating element, 4 easy-slide chrome-plated grills and room for up to 25 pounds of meat or fish, far more than a batch of cheese blocks needs. The body measures 24.5 inches high by 11.5 inches wide by 11.5 inches deep and weighs 12.2 pounds, so it stores on a shelf between sessions. A removable wood flavor pan lets you change chips without opening the door, and the box includes a drip pan, an electric cord and a bag of Smokehouse wood chips. For cheese, the maker’s guide props the loading door open about 1.5 inches to circulate smoke and shed heat.
The fixed temperature is the trade: there is no dial to turn down on a warm day, so the door trick and cool weather do the regulating. The maker also suggests freezing cheese for an hour or two before smoking so the outside takes smoke before the block softens.
- Pros: lowest fixed temperature here; maker publishes a full cheese guide for it; light and compact
- Cons: no temperature adjustment; small racks suit blocks and wheels, not large trays
- Buy if: you want one small smoker that lives at cheese temperature
- Skip if: you need a smoker that also cooks ribs and brisket at higher heat
Smokehouse Products Big Chief Front Load Electric Smoker
The Big Chief is the Little Chief scaled up for people who smoke cheese in quantity: the same steady 165 degrees F heat in a wider aluminum body that the maker rates for up to 50 pounds of meat or fish. Holiday batches, gifts and club-sized cheese orders are its home ground.
The listing page gives dimensions of 24.5 inches high by 18 inches wide by 12 inches deep and a weight of 17.6 pounds, with easy-slide chrome-plated grills that load from the front like an oven. Like its smaller sibling it runs a single heat setting from a standard household outlet, uses a removable wood flavor pan you can service without opening the door, and ships with a drip pan, a recipe and instruction booklet and a bag of wood chips. The maker’s cheese guide covers the Big Chief alongside the Little Chief, with the same smoking times per cheese.
Nothing about the bigger box lowers the temperature, so warm-day cheese still calls for the propped door and a cool, shaded spot. What the size buys is rack room: more blocks per load, spaced so smoke reaches every face instead of crowding onto two levels.
- Pros: double the stated capacity of the Little Chief; same low fixed heat; front-loading racks
- Cons: no temperature dial; wider body takes more storage room
- Buy if: you smoke several pounds of cheese at a time
- Skip if: a few blocks a month is your whole output
Smokehouse Products Smoke Chief Cold Smoke Generator
The Smoke Chief is a powered generator that hangs on the outside of a grill or smoker and pumps pellet smoke in through a short tube. The maker’s cheese guide describes cold-smoking with the Smoke Chief as adding 0 degrees F of heat, which is the cleanest answer to the cheese problem in this whole comparison.
The review pages list model 9500-000-0000 at 9.5 by 4 by 12.13 inches and 7 pounds, running on 110VAC household power or 12VDC from a vehicle outlet. One cup of wood pellets gives up to 3 hours of smoke, which covers the maker’s longest cheese times without a refill. The maker lists it for use with gas grills, pellet grills, charcoal grills and smokers, and the box includes a hanger, a clean-out tool and an 8 ounce measuring jar. Because the element is electric, there is no flame to light or tend.
The narrow smoke tube is the upkeep item: review pages note it builds up residue and needs cleaning about every hour to keep flowing. Output also depends on how well the tube seals into your grill’s opening, so some fitting work is part of ownership.
- Pros: no added heat per the maker; 3 hours per cup of pellets; works with most grills
- Cons: tube needs frequent cleaning; needs a power outlet near the grill
- Buy if: you already own a grill with room for cheese racks
- Skip if: you want a self-contained smoker with its own racks
Smoke Daddy Big Kahuna Cold Smoke Generator
The Big Kahuna is the heavy burner of the generator group: a stainless steel and aluminum unit with an 8 inch cylinder that smolders wood chips or chunks under an adjustable air pump. It suits cooks who want dense smoke and already burn chips or chunks for their regular smoker.
Review pages list dimensions of 10 by 8 by 5 inches and a weight of 5 pounds, with a threaded outlet tube and a 3 foot silicone hose that shoots the smoke across into the chamber. Each load of chips or chunks burns for up to 45 minutes, and the pump’s airflow sets how hard it smolders. The housing is machined aluminum and stainless steel, made in the USA, and it attaches to any smoker or grill once a 1-1/8 inch hole is drilled low on the side, using the supplied washers and lock nuts.
That 45 minute load is short next to the pellet units, so long cheese sessions mean reloads. The drilled hole is also permanent: this is a fit-once accessory for a cooker you plan to keep, not a clip-on for a borrowed grill.
- Pros: burns chips and chunks, not just pellets; adjustable air pump; metal build
- Cons: shortest burn per load here; installation needs drilling
- Buy if: your smoker already runs on chips or chunks
- Skip if: you cannot drill into your grill or smoker
Smoke Daddy Magnum P.I.G. Cold Smoke Generator
The Magnum P.I.G. is Smoke Daddy’s large-chamber generator, built for smokers of 6 cubic feet and larger. Review pages credit it with holding smoking temperatures under 100 degrees F, the kind of number cheese needs, while a full load of wood chips runs up to 2.5 hours.
Its 11.5 inch cylinder is machined from heavy gauge SCH 40 6061 aluminum, and the listed dimensions are 12.1 by 9.4 by 5.9 inches at 6.4 pounds. Like the Big Kahuna it mounts through a drilled 1-1/8 inch hole with washers and lock nuts, feeds smoke through a 3 foot silicone hose, and uses an adjustable air pump with a spring baffle. The outlet tube sits above the fuel source to resist clogging, and the end cap removes so chips can be lit with a torch.
Size is the filter: on a small kettle or a compact cabinet this generator is more hardware than the chamber needs, and its smoke output can overwhelm a tight space. It earns its place when the smoker is big and the cheese load fills racks rather than a single tray.
- Pros: longest chip burn in this group; stated sub-100 degree smoking; heavy machined build
- Cons: oversized for small smokers; installation needs drilling
- Buy if: your smoker cabinet is 6 cubic feet or larger
- Skip if: your cooker is a small kettle or tabletop unit
Masterbuilt Slow Smoker
The Slow Smoker is a powered attachment that bolts onto the wood chip loading port of a Masterbuilt digital electric smoker and feeds chips on its own. Its manual gives the cheese method directly: for cold smoking applications such as cheese, leave the main smoker’s heating element off and let the attachment make the smoke.
The maker lists model MB20100112 with a continuous wood feed system that provides up to 6 hours of uninterrupted smoke, the longest run in this comparison, plus an automatic chip heating element that starts with a button press. The manual rates it for cold or hot smoking applications up to 275 degrees F. The unit measures 8.1 by 9.8 by 16.8 inches, weighs 9.95 pounds, has an alloy steel body and a removable ash tray for cleanup. Compatibility covers all Masterbuilt digital electric smokers, per the maker.
The brand lock is the obvious limit: this attachment does nothing for a Weber, Traeger or Smokehouse owner. The host smoker also has to sit idle as a cold box, so it cannot smoke cheese and cook dinner at the same time.
- Pros: up to 6 hours of unattended smoke; maker documents the cheese method; ash tray cleanup
- Cons: Masterbuilt smokers only; ties up the host smoker as a cold box
- Buy if: you own a Masterbuilt digital electric smoker
- Skip if: your smoker is any other brand
Buying guide
Buying for cheese is mostly buying heat control. The sections below walk through the decisions that matter: how the temperature stays down, whether the smoke source stands alone or bolts on, how long a fill of fuel lasts, which woods suit cheese, and how much rack room a batch really needs.
Heat control on grills for smoking cheese
Cheese gives up its shape early, so the working target is a chamber that stays as cool as the day allows. The Smoke Chief’s maker describes its cold smoke as adding 0 degrees F of heat, and a review page credits the Magnum P.I.G. with smoking temperatures under 100 degrees F. Those two statements frame the goal: smoke in, heat out.
The electric Chiefs take the other route, holding 165 degrees F inside the box. That is warm for cheese, which is why the maker’s guide props the door open about 1.5 inches and leans on cool weather. Judge any cooker by the coolest honest number its maker or listing page states, not by how low its dial markings go.
Standalone smoker or add-on generator
A standalone electric smoker brings its own racks, drip pan and door, and it works the day it arrives. A generator brings none of that: it needs a host chamber with racks and a way in for the smoke tube or hose, and two of the three generators here need a drilled hole before they work at all.
The trade is flexibility. One Smoke Chief can serve a kettle this weekend and a cabinet smoker next month, while a Little Chief is always a cheese and fish box and never competes for space with dinner. Count what you already own before choosing which camp to join.
Smoke time per fill
Cheese sessions run longer than most people expect: the maker’s guide gives cheddar 1.5 to 2 hours and mozzarella several hours. A generator that quits at 45 minutes per load, like the Big Kahuna, asks you to reload mid-session, while the Masterbuilt Slow Smoker’s 6 hour feed covers any cheese on the maker’s chart.
Match the fuel clock to your longest cheese, not your average one. Refilling a hot generator is doable, but every opening dumps smoke and restarts the smolder, so a fill that outlasts the session is worth more than a slightly larger chamber.
Wood choices for cheese
The Smokehouse cheese guide leans on fruit woods and mild hardwoods: apple and cherry recur across its cheese list, alder pairs with gouda and brie, and hickory shows up for cheddar and goat cheese. The same guide warns that mesquite turned parmesan and provolone harsh and bitter, which is useful direction from the maker itself.
Fuel form matters as much as species. The Chiefs burn chips, the Smoke Chief and the Masterbuilt tower take pellets or chips, and the Smoke Daddy units burn chips and chunks. Buy the form your unit lists, in the mildest flavor on the shelf, for a first batch.
Chamber size and rack layout
Cheese needs spacing more than raw area: blocks should sit apart so smoke reaches every face, and soft cheeses need a rack they cannot slump through. The Little Chief’s 4 grills and the Big Chief’s 50 pound stated capacity mark the two ends of the standalone range in this group.
With a generator, the host chamber sets the layout. A kettle fits a ring of blocks around the edge away from the inlet; a cabinet stacks trays. Measure your largest planned batch in pounds of blocks, then check it against the stated rack count rather than a headline area figure.
FAQ
Cheese raises questions that brisket never does, mostly about temperature and timing. The answers below stick to what the makers and listing pages behind this guide actually state, from the Smokehouse cheese chart to the Masterbuilt manual’s cold smoking section.
What temperature should cheese stay under while smoking?
The makers frame it as low as possible rather than one magic number. Smokehouse describes its Smoke Chief as adding 0 degrees F of heat for cold-smoking, a review page credits the Magnum P.I.G. with smoking temperatures under 100 degrees F, and the maker’s own brie note says to cold-smoke with no heat or keep the heat as low as possible.
Do grills for smoking cheese work in summer?
They work, but summer is the hard season, because the chamber cannot go below the temperature of the air around it. Cold smoking practice leans on shade, the cool hours of the day and sometimes a tray of ice inside the chamber, and the Smokehouse guide’s door-propping trick exists for the same reason: warm air is the enemy on a cheese day.
How long does cheese stay in the smoke?
The Smokehouse guide gives times by cheese: Baby Bel rounds and cream cheese take 45 to 60 minutes, provolone 30 to 45 minutes with apple wood, gouda and Swiss about 1 hour, cheddar 1.5 to 2 hours, parmesan 2 hours or more, and mozzarella several hours because its low-moisture body takes smoke slowly.
Can a pellet grill cold smoke cheese on its own?
A pellet grill’s fire pot makes heat as well as smoke, so on its own it cooks rather than cold smokes. That is why the generators in this guide exist: the Smoke Chief’s maker lists pellet grills among its hosts, with the burn happening in the generator outside the chamber while the grill itself stays off and acts as the smoke box.
Should cheese be cold before it goes in the smoker?
Yes, according to the Smokehouse guide, which suggests putting cheeses in the freezer for an hour or two before smoking so the outside layer takes smoke before the block warms through. The same guide is blunt about soft cheeses: cream cheese that goes in warm can end as a puddle, so the freezer step matters most for the softest blocks.
Conclusion
For cheese, the winning spec is the heat a unit does not make. Pick the Smoke Chief for heat-free smoke on a grill you own, a Chief electric smoker for a dedicated low-temperature box, or the Masterbuilt Slow Smoker for the longest unattended run. Keep the chamber cool, the wood mild and the blocks spaced, and the smoke does the rest.