Key takeaways
- Six griddles for gas cooktops compared on size, material and weight, from a reversible cast iron classic plate to a 51-pound steel flat top for a 30-inch range.
A good stovetop griddle turns two gas burners into one wide, even cooking surface for pancakes, eggs and burgers. This guide compares the best griddles for gas cooktops on the specs that decide daily use: cooking area, material, thickness, weight, handles and the care each plate asks for week after week.
Quick verdict
Five of these six plates are two-burner griddles in cast iron or carbon steel, and one is a full-range steel flat top that changes how a 30-inch range cooks. The cast iron models win on heat retention and ease of entry in effort, while the carbon steel and flat top plates win on size and response.
For most gas cooktops, the Lodge Double Play LDP3 is the straightforward pick: reversible, pre-seasoned and sized for two burners. The Victoria reversible griddle adds the best handles here, and the Made In carbon steel griddle is the pick for cooks who want a lighter-feeling plate that reacts faster to flame changes.
The Steelmade PRO Series Flat Top is the specialist: a 51-pound steel surface that covers a whole 30-inch range. The two other Lodge plates, the wide LPGI3 Pro Grid and the low-sided LCDRG Chef Collection model, fill the gaps for cooks who want maximum width or easy spatula access.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lodge Double Play LDP3 | Cast iron, reversible | Everyday two-burner cooking | 16.75 x 9.5 in; 9.35 lb | Hand wash care only |
| Lodge Pro Grid LPGI3 | Cast iron, reversible | Widest cast iron plate | About 20 x 10.5 in across two burners | Weight not stated by the maker |
| Made In Carbon Steel Griddle | Carbon steel | Fast heat changes | 24 in long; 4 mm steel; 9.9 lb | Maker width figures conflict |
| Victoria Rectangular Reversible Griddle | Cast iron, reversible | Grip and flaxseed seasoning | 18.5 x 10 in; 9.8 lb | Inner cooking surface is 13 x 8.5 in |
| Steelmade PRO Series Flat Top | Steel flat top | Full-range cooking surface | 26.5 x 18.25 in; 51 lb | Not for glass ceramic cooktops |
| Lodge Chef Collection LCDRG | Cast iron, reversible | Low sides, lifted handles | 19.5 x 10 in; 10.56 lb | Hand wash care only |
How we selected
Every plate here was picked for gas cooktop use first: it has to sit flat across two burners on a grate, hold heat from an open flame without warping under normal cooking, and come from a maker page or listing with real dimensions and materials printed on it.
Cast iron dominates the list because it suits gas heat well, storing energy from the flame and giving it back steadily when cold food lands. One carbon steel plate and one thick mild steel flat top broaden the set for cooks who want faster response or a full-range surface. A popular outdoor griddle plate was left out because its maker sells it for gas grills, not for stovetops, and this keyword is about cooking on the range you already own.
Specs below come from the maker pages and listings behind each model. Where a maker’s own pages disagree, as they do on one griddle’s width, the article prints only the figure both pages support and flags the gap rather than choosing a number on the reader’s behalf.
Griddles for gas cooktops: the six plates compared
Size is the first sort: four plates cluster around 17 to 20 inches long for two burners, one stretches to 24 inches, and one covers the whole range. Material is the second sort, because cast iron, carbon steel and thick plate steel each ask for different care and give back different cooking behavior over a gas flame.
Lodge Double Play Reversible Cast Iron Grill and Griddle LDP3
The Lodge Double Play LDP3 is the reference two-burner griddle: 16.75 by 9.5 inches of cast iron, one smooth face for pancakes and eggs, one ribbed face for burgers and chops, and a low 0.62-inch profile that stores in a cabinet or hangs flat without eating shelf space.
It arrives pre-seasoned with 100 percent vegetable oil, and the maker notes the finish improves with use as more cooking oils bake into the surface. At 9.35 lb it is heavy enough to sit steady on the grates and spread flame heat, but light enough to move with one hand and a mitt. The listing states it spans two burners, which is exactly how it should be used on gas: one burner under each end, both set alike.
Care is classic cast iron: the spec table lists no dishwasher use, so it washes by hand, dries on the stove and takes a thin wipe of oil. The maker also lists it for ovens, grills and campfires, and it is crafted in the USA. Buy it as the default two-burner griddle. Skip it if you want handles with real grip clearance, because its edge handles sit close to the plate.
- Pros: reversible smooth and ribbed faces; pre-seasoned; slim 0.62-inch profile; made in the USA
- Cons: hand wash care; short edge handles; cooking width is the narrowest here at 9.5 inches
Lodge Cast Iron Reversible Pro Grid Griddle LPGI3
The Lodge LPGI3 Pro Grid is the wide Lodge: 51 by 26.5 cm on the page, about 20 by 10.5 inches, which makes it the largest one-piece cast iron plate in this set. That extra length over the Double Play buys room for a third row of pancakes or a full strip of bacon without crowding.
One side is a flat griddle and the flip side is a grill pan, seasoned cast iron through and through, factory seasoned with vegetable oil baked on at high temperature per the care text on the page. The same care text places it on gas, electric, ceramic and induction cooktops, in the oven, on the grill and over a campfire, so it earns its keep beyond the gas range.
Care follows the standard Lodge routine on the page: hand wash, dry right away and rub with a light coat of vegetable oil. The opened page does not state a weight or a height, so neither figure is printed here; expect a two-hand lift, as with any cast iron plate of this size. It is made in the USA. Buy it if width is your first requirement in cast iron. Skip it if published weight matters for a bad back or a high storage shelf.
- Pros: widest cast iron cooking surface here; reversible griddle and grill faces; factory seasoned; made in the USA
- Cons: weight and height not published on the page; hand wash care; two-hand handling
Made In Carbon Steel Griddle
The Made In griddle takes the carbon steel route: a 4 mm plate of Dutch carbon steel, heat-treated and seasoned twice before shipping with a blend of coconut oil and shea nut oil, so it arrives ready to cook rather than ready to season. Carbon steel answers flame changes faster than cast iron, which suits gas cooking well.
The maker describes 24 inches of carbon steel across two burners on a standard home range, the longest plate in this set, and lists it for gas, electric and induction cooktops plus outdoor grills and open flame. It weighs 9.9 lb, similar to the cast iron plates here despite the extra length, because the 4 mm sheet is thinner than a cast plate. The maker’s comparison table lists a maximum heat of 1200 degrees F for this griddle.
One honest gap: the maker’s own pages give two different widths for this griddle, so only the 24-inch length and two-burner span that both pages agree on are stated here. Care is hand wash only, dry right away and oil lightly, and the maker lists a lifetime warranty. Buy it for length and fast response over gas. Skip it if you want the set-and-forget heat storage of thick cast iron.
- Pros: longest plate at 24 inches; pre-seasoned twice; maker lists heat up to 1200 degrees F; lifetime warranty listed
- Cons: hand wash only; maker width figures conflict; thinner plate stores less heat than cast iron
Victoria Rectangular Cast Iron Reversible Griddle
The Victoria reversible griddle is the handle pick. Its wider loop handles give a mitt or potholder real room to grip, a small detail that matters every time a 9.8 lb plate of hot cast iron has to move from burner to trivet. The plate measures 18.5 by 10 inches and stands 0.8 inches high.
The iron is preseasoned with three layers of flaxseed oil, and the maker lists the seasoning as non-GMO and kosher-certified. One face is smooth for pancakes, eggs and tortillas; the ridged face handles steaks, burgers, corn and fajitas per the maker’s list. The maker also gives the cooking surface inside the handles as 13 by 8.5 inches, a useful honesty check: the working area is smaller than the outer dimensions suggest.
The maker lists use on gas, electric, ceramic and induction heat, in the oven and broiler, on a barbecue and over open fire, and gives a cooking tip worth repeating: preheat slowly over low to medium heat rather than blasting the plate with full flame. Care is hand wash with warm water only, never the dishwasher. It is made in Colombia. Buy it for grip and a well-documented seasoning. Skip it if you need the largest possible flat area, since the inner surface runs small.
- Pros: wide loop handles; three-layer flaxseed oil seasoning; reversible faces; maker publishes the true inner cooking size
- Cons: inner cooking surface is only 13 x 8.5 inches; hand wash with warm water only
Steelmade PRO Series Flat Top for 30-Inch Gas Ranges
The Steelmade PRO Series Flat Top is a different tool from the other five: a 5/16-inch American mild steel plate with a cooking surface of 26.5 by 18.25 inches that covers most of a standard 30-inch range, turning the whole top into one flat cooking field for smash burgers, cheesesteaks and big breakfast runs.
It weighs 51 lb, and the maker is blunt about the consequence: that weight exceeds the limit for glass ceramic stoves, so this model is for gas or electric coil ranges only, which is exactly the fit this keyword asks for. The steel is 67 percent thicker than the maker’s standard models, the front edge carries a lip with a 5-degree break, and a stainless steel drip tray sits below the drain holes to catch grease; on gas the tray sits under the grate.
The maker lists a maximum temperature of 750 degrees F, a lifetime warranty, and a finish that builds as baking oil seasons into the metal toward a natural easy-release surface. The maker lists dishwasher cleaning for the drip tray; the plate itself is seasoned steel care, scrape, heat, oil. It is made in the USA. Buy it if you cook for a crowd on a 30-inch gas range. Skip it for any glass-top stove, and skip it if a 51-pound plate sounds like a storage problem.
- Pros: largest cooking surface here by far; thick 5/16-inch steel; drip tray included; lifetime warranty listed; made in the USA
- Cons: 51 lb; gas and coil ranges only, never glass ceramic; takes over the whole cooktop
Lodge Chef Collection Double Burner Reversible Griddle LCDRG
The Lodge LCDRG from the Chef Collection is the spatula-friendly cast iron plate: 19.5 by 10 inches with low, easy-access sides, so a spatula slides under pancakes and eggs without fighting a tall rim. It stands 0.75 inches high and weighs 10.56 lb, the heaviest of the two-burner cast iron plates here.
The iron is foundry-seasoned and ready to use, one face flat and the other carrying grill lines the maker designs for a seared finish. Ergonomic lifted handles on both ends give grip and control when the plate needs lifting or rotating on the grates, a step up from the flush edge handles on the standard Double Play.
The spec sheet lists use on the stove, in the oven, on the grill and over a campfire, with care by hand washing, prompt drying and a rub of oil. It is made in the USA by Lodge in South Pittsburg, Tennessee, per the sheet. Buy it if you flip a lot of food and want low sides and real handles. Skip it if storage height is tight, since the lifted handles add bulk the flatter Lodge plates avoid.
- Pros: low sides for easy spatula work; lifted handles; foundry-seasoned; generous 19.5-inch length
- Cons: heaviest two-burner cast iron here; hand wash care; handles add storage bulk
Buying guide
Choosing among these plates comes down to five things: the span of your burners, the material you want to maintain, how the seasoning story starts, how you will move a hot plate, and where a heavy piece of iron or steel will live between cooks. None of them needs a special gas connection or any change to the stove.
Sizing griddles for gas cooktops to your burners
A two-burner griddle works when each end of the plate sits over its own burner, so measure the distance between your front and back burner centers, or your two side burners, before ordering. The plates here run from 16.75 to 24 inches long, and a plate much longer than the burner span wastes its ends over cold grate.
Width matters for food, not fit. A 9.5 to 10.5 inch width takes two rows of pancakes or a row of burgers with room to flip. Remember the Victoria lesson: outer dimensions include handles, and its true inner cooking surface is 13 by 8.5 inches. Compare inner cooking area where the maker publishes it, and treat outer size as a storage measurement.
Cast iron, carbon steel or plate steel
Cast iron, in four of these six plates, stores heat deeply. Once the plate is hot, a pile of cold burgers drops its temperature less, and the surface recovers steadily from the flame below. The trade is weight, slow preheats and rust care: dry it, oil it, every time.
Carbon steel, in the Made In plate, heats and cools faster, which gives a gas cook quick corrections when a flame is too hot. Thick plate steel, in the Steelmade, behaves like a diner flat top: huge heat storage across a huge area, at 51 lb. Pick by cooking style: steady batch cooking favors iron, responsive saute work favors carbon steel, and crowd cooking favors the flat top.
Seasoning and daily care
Every plate here arrives seasoned: vegetable oil on the Lodge plates, flaxseed oil in three layers on the Victoria, and a coconut and shea nut oil blend applied twice on the Made In. Seasoning is not a coating to baby; it is a working surface that improves as you cook fatty foods and maintain it after each use.
The routine is the same across the iron and steel plates: wash by hand, dry fully with heat, and wipe on a thin layer of oil before storing. None of the griddle plates here is listed for dishwasher cleaning; only the Steelmade drip tray carries that listing. Five minutes of care after cooking is the real trade-off of a cast iron griddle, and cooks who hate that routine should know it before buying.
Handles, lips and grease management
Handles decide how a hot griddle moves. The Victoria wide loops and the Lodge LCDRG lifted handles give mitts real clearance, while the flatter Lodge plates and the Made In rely on edge grips that sit closer to the heat. If you move the plate mid-cook to rest food, handle clearance is worth more than an extra inch of width.
Grease needs a plan too. Reversible plates hold grease in their channels until you pour it off, the Victoria and Lodge plates included. The Steelmade answers with drain holes and a drip tray under the front edge. On gas grates there is no flat surface to catch drips, so a plate with a lip or a tray keeps the cooktop, and the burners under it, far cleaner.
Weight and storage
Weights here run from 9.35 lb for the Lodge Double Play to 51 lb for the Steelmade flat top, and that spread changes where the plate can live. A 10-pound plate hangs on a hook or slides into a cabinet. A 51-pound plate realistically stays on the range or in a low drawer, and lifting it to a high shelf is a poor idea.
Match the plate to the cook. Anyone with wrist or back limits should stay with the lighter plates and the best handles, which points to the Victoria or the Double Play. Strong cooks feeding a crowd can treat the Steelmade as a semi-permanent range top. Storage honesty up front beats a heavy plate that never gets used.
FAQ
Gas griddle questions usually come down to seasoning, heat behavior across two flames and what else the plate can cook on. The answers below rest on the maker pages behind these six models, plus the plain physics of a metal plate sitting over two burners.
How do I season griddles for gas cooktops?
These plates arrive seasoned, so seasoning means maintenance, not a from-scratch project. After cooking, wash the plate by hand, dry it on a warm burner until every drop is gone, then wipe on a very thin layer of cooking oil while the metal is still warm. That thin layer is the whole routine.
If the surface ever looks dull or food starts to stick, cook a few fatty meals and repeat the oil wipe after each one; the finish rebuilds in layers. The makers here season with vegetable oil, flaxseed oil or a coconut and shea blend at the factory, and ordinary cooking oil at home keeps any of them in shape.
Can a stovetop griddle also go in the oven?
For these six, yes, within the makers’ own listings. The Lodge pages list oven use for the Double Play, the Pro Grid and the Chef Collection plate, the Victoria lists oven and broiler use, and the Made In lists oven-adjacent heat sources including grills and open flame alongside cooktops.
Oven use is handy for finishing thick burgers or keeping pancakes warm while the next batch cooks. Keep the heat within the maker’s stated limits where one is published: the Made In table lists 1200 degrees F and the Steelmade lists 750 degrees F, both far above home oven settings, so the practical limit is your recipe, not the plate.
Why does a griddle heat unevenly over two burners?
Because the plate can only spread the heat it is given. If one burner runs hotter than the other, or one end of the plate hangs past its burner, that end cooks slower. Set both burners to the same level, center the plate so each end sits over its flame, and give iron and steel time to even out before food goes down.
Material helps or hurts here. Thick cast iron and the 5/16-inch Steelmade steel smooth out small differences between burners once they are fully heated. The thinner carbon steel plate answers faster but shows burner differences sooner. A longer preheat at medium flame beats a short blast at high flame for even results on any of them.
Can I use one of these griddles on other heat sources?
Mostly yes. The Lodge plates list stovetop, oven, grill and campfire use. The Victoria lists gas, electric, ceramic and induction heat plus barbecue and open fire. The Made In lists gas, electric and induction cooktops plus outdoor grills and open flame. A gas griddle is rarely a one-stove tool.
The exception is the Steelmade flat top, which the maker restricts to gas and electric coil ranges and warns away from glass ceramic cooktops because of its 51-pound weight. Always follow the individual maker’s list rather than assuming a plate that works on gas belongs on every surface in the house.
How do I keep food from sticking to cast iron?
Preheat the plate fully at medium heat, add a thin film of oil or fat, and let food sit until it releases on its own. Most sticking on seasoned iron is a timing problem: food lifted too early, or a plate that was still cold in the middle when the food went down. The Victoria maker adds a related tip, to preheat slowly over low to medium heat.
Keeping the seasoning healthy matters just as much. Dry the plate with heat after washing and oil it lightly, every time, and the surface grows more release-friendly with use, as the Lodge listing notes about its own finish. A plate that is washed and left wet will rust, and rust undoes seasoning faster than any cooking mistake.
Conclusion
Buy the Lodge Double Play LDP3 as the default two-burner griddle, the Victoria for handles and seasoning, the Made In for length and fast response, the LPGI3 for width, the LCDRG for low sides, or the Steelmade PRO flat top to convert a whole 30-inch gas range. Match plate to burners and the cooking takes care of itself.