Key takeaways
- Compare six replacement cooking grids for gas grills by exact fit, material and panel size, from Char-Broil and Broil King grids to Weber-fit iron and steel.
Old grids rust, flake and cook unevenly long before the burners give up, and a grid that almost fits still rocks, gaps and drops food. This guide compares six cooking grids for gas grills by exact model fit, panel size and material, so you can match a replacement set to the grill you already own instead of guessing by burner count alone.
Quick verdict
Start with fit, then material. Char-Broil Performance owners get the widest coverage from the three-piece Direct Store DC151 set, while older Char-Broil and Thermos grills match the FORYEYC G08 set. Weber Spirit 300 owners split between cast iron and 7 mm stainless from DcYourHome, and Broil King owners buy single 11241 grids one at a time.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Direct Store DC151 | Matte cast iron, 3 pieces | Char-Broil Performance 4 and 5 burner grills | 18 x 25 inches total coverage | Char-Broil fitment only |
| FORYEYC G08 | Matte coated cast iron, 3 pieces | Older Char-Broil, Thermos, Kenmore grills | Each grid 16-7/8 x 9-5/16 inches | Older model list only |
| DcYourHome 7639SS-2 | 304 stainless steel rod, 2 pieces | Weber Spirit 300 owners avoiding cast iron care | 7 mm rod thickness | No grid dimensions in the listing fields |
| Hestia Industrial porcelain-enameled set | Porcelain-enameled cast iron, 2 pieces | Weber Spirit II 300, 2013 and newer | 17.5 x 23.8 inches, 15.56 pounds | Front-control Spirit fitment only |
| Stanbroil G023-CS | Cast iron, 2 pieces | Weber Genesis II 300 owners | Replaces Weber part 66095 | Listing omits individual grid size |
| Broil King 11241 | Cast iron, single grid | Baron, Crown, Rebel and Patriot owners | 6 1/8 x 17 3/8 inches per grid | Sold one grid at a time |
How we selected
Every grid here was taken from a listing page that names the grill models or original part numbers it replaces, and each page states the grid material and at least one hard measurement. Sets that only showed a photo, a burner count or a vague universal claim were left out, and special-order parts were excluded in favor of grids listed in stock.
Fit came first: a cooking grid is a model-specific part, so each pick below is tied to named grill families such as Char-Broil Performance, Weber Spirit 300 or Broil King Baron. Material came second, because cast iron, porcelain-enameled cast iron and stainless rod behave differently over years of heat. Panel count and total footprint came third, since a three-piece set and a single narrow grid solve different replacement jobs.
Cooking grids for gas grills, picked by grill brand
The six sets below cover the three grill brands that dominate replacement-grid searches. Read the fitment line before the material line: the best grid on this page is worthless on the wrong grill, and each entry states plainly which models it covers, which part number it replaces, and where its published information runs out.
Direct Store DC151 Cast Iron Cooking Grates
The DC151 is a three-piece matte cast iron set built for Char-Broil Performance grills. The maker lists one grid at 18 x 6.5 inches and two at 18 x 9.3 inches, for 18 x 25 inches of total coverage, and names the Performance 5 Burner 463347519 plus the 4 burner 463377017, 463347017, 463376117 and 463377117 as the fitment list.
This is the set for a Performance owner whose original grids have rusted through in patches. Cast iron holds heat across the whole panel, so the surface recovers faster after the lid opens than thin stamped steel does. The maker lists the set weight at 6.74 kilograms, which is real heft spread across three panels, and lists no nonstick coating, so the surface is bare matte iron that takes seasoning like a skillet.
The three-panel layout is the practical advantage: you can lift out one section to reach the burners or to run a partial load without stripping the whole cooking surface. The limit is brand lock-in. Nothing in the listing suggests these panels fit anything outside the named Char-Broil Performance models, and the mixed panel widths mean the set only works as a complete layout, not as single spares.
- Pros: three panels cover 18 x 25 inches; named fitment for five Performance models; bare cast iron seasons with use
- Cons: Char-Broil only; mixed panel sizes must be used as a set; cast iron needs oiling after wet cooks
Buy it if your Char-Broil Performance model number is on the fitment list and the full grid row needs replacing. Skip it if you run any other brand, or if only one narrow section of your current set is damaged and a single-grid part exists for your grill.
FORYEYC G08 Cooking Grates, 16-7/8 inch set of 3
FORYEYC sells this set under model number G08: three matte coated cast iron grids, each 16-7/8 x 9-5/16 inches, covering 16-7/8 x 27-15/16 inches together. The listing ties it to Char-Broil models 463420508, 463420509, 463420511, 463436213, 463436214 and 463436215, plus Thermos 461442114, and names Master Chef and Kenmore among the brands it fits.
Older Char-Broil grills are exactly where replacement grids get hard to source, because the original part numbers have rolled through several revisions. This listing answers that problem directly by naming the original parts it replaces: 80008076, 80018559, G432-1800-W1, G432-0002-W1, G432-4300-01 and G432-001N-W1. If one of those numbers is stamped on your old grid or printed in your manual, the match is documented rather than guessed.
The matte coating sits over cast iron, so you get iron heat retention with a coated face that is less demanding than bare iron during the first season. The trade-off is that coatings eventually wear at the rod edges, and the fitment list stops at older model families. Current Performance grills use different panels, so measure before assuming a Char-Broil badge means a match.
- Pros: replaces six named original part numbers; three equal panels simplify layout; fits several older Char-Broil and Thermos models
- Cons: no current-model Char-Broil fitment; coating wear is a long-term concern; panel size is one fixed width
Buy it if your grill or manual shows one of the listed model or part numbers. Skip it if your Char-Broil is a current Performance model, since the DC151 above is the documented fit for those grills instead.
DcYourHome 7639SS-2 Stainless Steel Grill Grates
DcYourHome builds this two-piece set from 304 stainless steel rods at 7 mm thick, listed as a replacement for Weber part numbers 7638, 7639, 7526, 7011, 7527, 7586, 64812 and 67023. Fitment covers the Weber Spirit 300 series, the Spirit II 300 series and the Genesis Silver, Gold and Platinum B and C lines, including the Genesis 1000 to 5000 range.
Stainless rod is the low-maintenance path: no seasoning, no coating to chip, and surface rust that stays cosmetic far longer than on iron. The maker lists a cooking surface area of 395.04 square inches and a set weight of 4.83 kilograms, noticeably lighter than the cast iron sets on this page. The 7 mm rod figure matters because thin rods flex and sag over years of heat cycles; 7 mm is a stout rod for this grill class.
One gap to know about: the listing fields carry a placeholder dimension entry, so the maker does not publish a clean per-grid measurement on the page. The fitment is stated by model and part number instead, which is the more reliable match method for Weber parts, but it means you should confirm your grill’s model badge rather than measuring your old grids and matching numbers.
- Pros: 7 mm 304 stainless rods; replaces eight Weber part numbers; no seasoning or coating care
- Cons: lighter rods hold less heat than cast iron; per-grid dimensions not stated in listing fields; sear marks are softer than on iron
Buy it if you own a listed Spirit or Genesis model and want a grid set you can brush, scrape and ignore. Skip it if deep cast iron sear marks are the whole point of the replacement, or if your grill is not a Weber.
Hestia Industrial Porcelain-Enameled Cast Iron Cooking Grates
Hestia Industrial makes this porcelain-enameled cast iron set for the Weber GS4 Spirit II 300 series from 2013 onward, naming the Spirit E and S 310, 320 and 330 front-control models. The set measures 17.5 x 23.8 inches in total and the maker lists the item weight at 15.56 pounds, the heaviest set on this page, with model number 7536-7508-7658.
That weight is the story: thick cast iron under a porcelain enamel coat gives strong heat retention and hard sear marks, while the enamel face resists the rust bloom that bare iron shows after a rainy week under a cover. For Spirit II owners who grill several nights a week, this is the closest match to the grids the grill shipped with, since it replaces the Weber 7638 layout the GS4 grills use.
The limits are fitment discipline and enamel care. The set is listed for front-control Spirit II 300 models from 2013 onward, not the older side-control Spirit generation, and porcelain enamel can chip if a grid is dropped on concrete or pried with a metal tool while cold. Treat it like the coated iron it is and it holds up; treat it like bare iron and the chips become rust points.
- Pros: heaviest set here at 15.56 pounds; enamel face over cast iron; documented Spirit II fitment from 2013 onward
- Cons: front-control models only; enamel can chip from drops or prying; heavier panels to lift for cleaning
Buy it if your Spirit II 300 has front controls and you want iron performance with a coated face. Skip it if your Spirit is an older side-control model, since the panel layout and control position changed between generations.
Stanbroil G023-CS Cast Iron Cooking Grate, set of 2
Stanbroil’s G023-CS is a two-piece cast iron set made for the Weber Genesis II and Genesis II LX 300 series, listed as a replacement for Weber part 66095. The maker lists the set weight at 7.94 kilograms, which puts solid iron mass under the food, and the included components are stated plainly as two cast iron cooking grid grates.
Genesis II owners face a split in the Weber line: the Genesis II 300 uses a different grid layout than the older Genesis 300, and parts from one generation do not drop into the other. This set is aimed squarely at the newer generation, so the fitment question is simple. If your grill is a Genesis II or Genesis II LX 300 and your manual lists part 66095, this is the documented cast iron replacement.
The honest gap is measurement data. The opened listing gives parcel dimensions for shipping, which say nothing about the grids themselves, and does not state each grid’s length and width. Cast iron also asks for the usual care: light oil after cooking while the grids are warm, and no cold-water shock on a hot grid. Buyers who need a tape-measure confirmation before ordering will find this listing thin.
- Pros: exact Genesis II generation fitment; replaces Weber part 66095; heavy cast iron at 7.94 kilograms per set
- Cons: individual grid dimensions not stated on the listing; cast iron care routine required; Genesis II models only
Buy it if your Genesis II 300 manual names part 66095 and you want cast iron rather than the stainless route. Skip it if your grill is a first-generation Genesis 300, which uses a different grid layout entirely.
Broil King 11241 Cooking Grid
Broil King sells the 11241 as a single cast iron cooking grid, 6 1/8 x 17 3/8 inches, for the Baron, Crown, Rebel and Patriot lines, and the listing ties it to 228 grill models. It replaces the older part 52005-281, and the listing notes that some grills use grids twice this width, so two 11241 grids are needed to replace one wide original.
Single-grid sales suit Broil King owners better than full sets, because Baron-class grills often lose one grid to rust while the rest of the row is still sound. The listing also flags a detail that decides fit on the spot: the grid must have a notch on each end for the mounting screw. If your old grid has those notches, the 11241 pattern matches; if it does not, this is the wrong part no matter what the model badge says.
Cast iron care applies here as with every iron grid on this page, and the per-grid format means a full-row replacement on a wide grill can take several pieces. The listing does not publish a grid weight, so there is no heft figure to compare against the sets above. What it does publish is the dimension that matters most for this brand: width per grid.
- Pros: replace only the damaged grid; exact 6 1/8 x 17 3/8 inch size stated; fits 228 listed Broil King models
- Cons: full-row replacement needs multiple grids; weight not stated on the listing; notch pattern must match
Buy it if one Baron, Crown, Rebel or Patriot grid has failed and the rest of the row is sound. Skip it if your grill’s grids lack the end notches, or if the whole row is rusted and a multi-piece set works out simpler.
Buying guide
A replacement grid is a fitment part first and a material choice second. The checks below run in the order that avoids returns: confirm the model, confirm the part number, measure the old grid, then choose between cast iron, coated iron and stainless rod for how you actually cook and clean.
How to measure cooking grids for gas grills before ordering
Pull the old grids out and measure each panel’s length and width with a tape, then count the panels and note how they sit side by side. Record the total footprint too, because sets reach the same coverage with different panel splits, and a set that matches on total size can still fail panel by panel when the splits differ.
The DC151 set totals 18 x 25 inches from three unequal panels, while the FORYEYC set totals 16-7/8 x 27-15/16 inches from three equal ones. Same grill family, different math, so panel-by-panel numbers are the ones that count.
Match the part number, not just the brand
Brand badges span decades of layouts. The reliable match is the part number in your manual or stamped on the old part: when a listing names your number, fit is documented, and when it only names your brand, keep looking and measure before you commit to an order.
The DcYourHome set replaces eight Weber numbers including 7638 and 7639, the FORYEYC set replaces six Char-Broil numbers, and the Broil King 11241 replaces 52005-281.
Cast iron, coated iron or stainless rod
Cast iron stores the most heat and marks food hardest, at the cost of seasoning and rust care. Porcelain-enameled cast iron keeps most of that heat with an easier face, but the coat can chip. Stainless rod asks the least care and gives back the least sear.
The Hestia set shows the coated iron route and the 7 mm DcYourHome set the rod route. Pick by your habits: daily grillers tolerate iron care, weekend grillers often prefer rod.
Count panels and check how they are sold
Sets on this page range from the Broil King 11241, sold as one 6 1/8 inch wide grid, to three-piece Char-Broil layouts. A single-grid format costs less when one panel fails and turns wasteful when the whole row is gone, so the right count depends on how much of your current row is actually damaged and how the original row was built.
Check whether a wide original grid is actually two narrow grids side by side, as the Broil King listing warns, before deciding how many pieces your grill really needs.
Plan care around the material you choose
Iron grids want a hot brush-down after cooking and a thin coat of cooking oil while warm, then dry storage under the lid or a cover. Enamel grids want a nylon or brass brush rather than aggressive steel scraping on a cold surface, and they should cool on the grill instead of being lifted hot and set on cold stone or concrete.
Stainless rod tolerates the harshest brushing of the three. None of this is difficult, but it is daily, so choose the routine you will actually keep.
FAQ
Most replacement-grid questions come down to fitment across model years, whether a grid from one brand can serve another, and how long each material lasts. The answers below stick to what the listings and general grill practice support, and they point back to the model and part-number checks that settle most doubts.
Are cooking grids for gas grills interchangeable between brands?
No. Grid panels are cut for one firebox layout, with ledges, notches and panel widths that differ by brand and generation. A Weber Spirit grid does not sit correctly in a Char-Broil Performance firebox, and a grid that almost fits still rocks on its ledges, cooks unevenly and can drop small food straight onto the burners.
Even within one brand the older Genesis 300 and newer Genesis II 300 use different layouts. The listings on this page name models and part numbers precisely because brand-level swapping does not work.
How do I know which grid my grill takes?
Find the model number on the grill’s rating label, usually inside the cabinet door or on the back panel, then check the manual’s parts list for the grid part number. Match that number against the listing’s replacement list, and check the model year too, since brands changed layouts mid-generation.
If the manual is gone, measure each old panel and count them, then compare against stated panel sizes such as the 6 1/8 x 17 3/8 inch Broil King grid.
Is cast iron or stainless steel better for a replacement grid?
Cast iron holds more heat per panel and leaves darker sear marks, which suits steak-heavy cooking. Stainless rod heats and cools faster, resists rust with far less attention, and suits grills that sit outdoors between weekend cooks, especially in wet or coastal air where bare iron needs constant oiling to stay ahead of rust.
The Hestia and Stanbroil sets show the iron end of the range, while the DcYourHome 7 mm stainless set shows the low-care end. Neither is wrong; they serve different routines.
When should a cooking grid be replaced instead of cleaned?
Replace a grid when the coating flakes into food, when rust pits the rods deeply enough that a brush leaves orange dust after oiling, or when a panel warps and rocks on its ledges. A grid that has worn through to thin, sharp rod edges is also done, because it flexes under a spatula and marks food unevenly.
Surface rust on cast iron usually scrubs back and re-seasons. A cracked cast iron panel, a common failure after a drop onto concrete, cannot be repaired and should be swapped for the matching part number.
Do new grids need seasoning before the first cook?
Bare cast iron does: wash, dry fully, coat thinly with a high-heat cooking oil and heat the grill until the oil sets, then repeat once. Porcelain-enameled and matte coated grids do not need seasoning on the coated face, though a light coat of oil before the first cook still helps food release while the surface is new and the grill settles in.
Stainless rod needs only a wash and a preheat. The Hestia set and the FORYEYC set both fall in the coated group. When a maker states a preparation step on the listing, follow the maker’s version.
Conclusion
Match the part number first and the material second. Char-Broil owners are covered by the DC151 and FORYEYC G08 sets, Weber owners by the DcYourHome, Hestia and Stanbroil picks, and Broil King owners by the single 11241 grid. Measure your old panels, confirm the number, and the replacement drops in and cooks like the original row did.