Key takeaways
- Five cookers compared for a competition chicken turn-in, on printed specs only: cooking area, fuel capacity, burn time, airflow control, and stated weight.
Competition chicken is a short, hot cook judged on uniform pieces, so the best chicken smokers for competition bbq are the ones whose printed specs support steady heat and repeatable timing. This guide compares five cookers on the specs their makers and sellers print: cooking area, fuel load, burn time, airflow hardware, and weight.
Quick verdict
The five cookers split into two camps. The Gateway Straight Up 55G, the Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Pro, and the Weber Smokey Mountain 22 are charcoal cookers run by hand on dampers and intake pipes, while the Backwoods G3 Chubby adds insulation and a water pan, and the Camp Chef Woodwind Pro 36 runs on pellets with a controller.
Gateway Charcoal Drum Smoker Straight Up 55G
The Gateway is the hot and fast entry: a 55-gallon steel drum with a 22 inch stainless grate, 462 square inches of cooking area, two welded intake pipes, and a fire basket rated by the seller at up to 14 hours. Its own listing describes it as built for backyard cooks, competitors, and enthusiasts, which matches the drum’s competition role.
Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Pro Drum Smoker
The Bronco Pro is the maker’s competition drum: 366 square inches on a 21.5 inch surface, a 17 pound fuel capacity, an oversized basket the maker rates at over 15 hours of smoking, a gasketed hinged lid, and wagon-style wheels. Oklahoma Joe’s describes it as designed for competition-level performance.
Backwoods G3 Chubby Charcoal Smoker
The G3 Chubby is the insulated cabinet: four stainless racks measuring 22 by 15.5 inches inside a chamber with 2 inches of insulation, a printed temperature range of 180 to 300 degrees Fahrenheit, and a water pan. The selling page positions it for competitors practicing at home, and its rack layout suits batches of smaller pieces laid out in rows.
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22 Inch
The Smokey Mountain 22 is the bullet cooker: 726 square inches across two plated steel grates, a porcelain-enameled water pan, four aluminum dampers, and a built-in lid thermometer, at a listed weight of 68 pounds. It is the lightest cooker here by a wide margin, which matters when a team loads and unloads at every event.
Camp Chef Woodwind Pro 36 Pellet Grill
The Woodwind Pro 36 is the pellet entry: 1,236 square inches of total rack area, a 22 pound hopper, a WiFi controller with four probe ports, and a Smoke Box that burns wood chunks, chips, or charcoal beside the pellets. Its Smoke Number setting, printed as 1 to 10, lets the cook set smoke output from the controller instead of the fire.
The five cookers side by side
The table collects the headline printed specs for all five cookers in one place. Cooking area figures are each maker’s own published totals, and burn times are maker or seller statements, so read them as label claims to compare formats, not as measured results from a single test day.
| Cooker | Fuel | Cooking area | Fuel capacity | Printed burn time | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gateway Straight Up 55G | Charcoal | 462 sq in | 8 to 10 lb basket | Up to 14 hours | 150 lb |
| Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Pro | Charcoal | 366 sq in | 17 lb | Over 15 hours | 162 lb |
| Backwoods G3 Chubby | Charcoal | 4 racks, 22 x 15.5 in | 6 to 10 lb | 6 to 8 hours | 150 lb |
| Weber Smokey Mountain 22 | Charcoal | 726 sq in | Not stated | Not stated | 68 lb |
| Camp Chef Woodwind Pro 36 | Wood pellets | 1,236 sq in | 22 lb hopper | Not stated | 183 lb |
Two patterns stand out. The charcoal drums and the bullet all manage heat with manual airflow hardware, while the pellet grill manages it with a controller and probe ports. The cabinet and the pellet grill print the largest food capacity figures, while the drums print the longest single-load burn times.
The cookers in detail
Each cooker below is covered the same way: the format and the printed numbers first, then the hardware that controls the fire, then the details that matter when the cook is chicken on a competition schedule rather than a long brisket at home. Nothing here rests on a maker’s headline alone; every figure traces to a spec list.
Gateway Charcoal Drum Smoker Straight Up 55G
The Straight Up 55G is a 55-gallon steel drum in the maker’s smoking configuration, rather than its direct-heat grilling layout. The seller lists a cooking area of 462 square inches on a 22 inch stainless steel grate with three height positions, expandable to three grates, and calls the model a full-size drum for hot and fast barbecue.
The seller’s page adds the ownership basics: minimal assembly required, a user guide in the box, no electrical connection at any point, and a powder-coated exterior finish whose color options vary by model. The page files the model under smoking as its usage, with a fit described as beginner-friendly to intermediate, even though the hardware is the same drum format that competition teams run for fast chicken cooks.
Fire control on the Gateway
Temperature is manual: two welded, air-adjusting intake pipes and one adjustable exhaust pipe, read on a fixed, center-mounted 3 inch custom dial thermometer scaled from 50 to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. The removable fire basket holds 8 to 10 pounds of charcoal, and the seller rates burn time at up to 14 hours, far beyond a chicken cook’s needs.
Gateway details for a contest site
The drum ships with a removable caster wheel kit and welded handles, weighs 150 pounds, and carries a powder-coated finish the seller rates to withstand 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit. For chicken, the useful points are the grate height positions and the hot and fast design brief, built around the higher temperatures a thigh cook uses.
Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Pro Drum Smoker
The Bronco Pro is Oklahoma Joe’s larger drum, model 19202099, with a primary and total cooking area of 366 square inches on a 21.5 inch cooking surface. The maker describes it as a heavy-duty barrel smoker built for competition, with a sealed cooking chamber, an airflow control system, and extended fuel capacity.
The maker’s own question section describes the Bronco Pro as a heavy-duty barrel smoker built for competition, with the cooking capacity for handling massive meats, and notes that barrel smokers are a popular choice for competition cooks because of their mobility and their ability to maintain temperatures over long periods with less supervision. That positioning is the maker’s, printed on the product page itself.
Fire control on the Bronco Pro
The oversized charcoal basket holds 17 pounds of fuel, and the maker rates it at over 15 hours of uninterrupted smoking. Airflow runs through the maker’s purpose-built intake system, temperature reads on a barrel-mounted gauge, and the hinged lid carries a gasket that the maker says creates a tight seal to hold smoke and heat.
Bronco Pro details for a contest site
The box includes the cooking grate, a heat diffuser, 3 meat hangers, and 9 meat hooks, plus an integrated side shelf and large wagon-style wheels. The maker lists 162 pounds, assembled dimensions of 28.75 by 40 by 48 inches, porcelain-coated steel grates, a large ash pan with a drain cap, and a 2-year warranty on all parts.
Backwoods G3 Chubby Charcoal Smoker
The G3 Chubby is an insulated vertical cabinet smoker. The selling page lists four stainless steel racks measuring 22 by 15.5 inches with 3 inch spacing, a cooking chamber 23 inches deep, 13 inches tall, and 16 inches wide, and 2 inches of insulation in the cabinet walls, with a gasketed stainless steel door.
The same page prints the design labels a buyer can check in person: a reverse air flow system, vertical airflow through the cabinet, a heat diverter for improved heat distribution, and stainless steel door construction. It also files the model as designed for competition or catering environments, and prints outside dimensions of 26 inches deep, 29 inches tall, and 20 inches wide, with an added allowance for the thermometer and latches.
Fire control on the G3 Chubby
The printed temperature range is 180 to 300 degrees Fahrenheit, managed by manual airflow control with a water pan the page describes as assisting heat stability. The firebox holds 6 to 10 pounds of charcoal for a listed burn time of 6 to 8 hours, and the page notes the smoker usually comes with a Tel-Tru thermometer.
G3 Chubby details for a contest site
The page prints food capacity estimates of roughly 10 to 12 slabs of baby back ribs, 4 to 6 briskets, or 4 to 6 Boston butts across the racks. It weighs 150 pounds, stands 29 inches tall and 20 inches wide outside, and sits on 3 inch feet with pre-drilled caster bolt patterns. Four flat racks suit a turn-in batch of thighs arranged in even rows.
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 22 Inch
The Smokey Mountain 22, model 731001, is Weber’s largest bullet cooker. The maker’s spec sheet lists a total cooking area of 726 square inches on two plated steel cooking grates, a porcelain-enameled bowl, lid, and water pan, and a steel charcoal grate, in a cooker 48.5 inches tall, 23 inches wide, and 24 inches deep.
Fire control on the Smokey Mountain
Heat is set with four rust-resistant aluminum dampers, and the spec sheet lists a built-in lid thermometer and a silicone temperature grommet for probe cables. A rust-resistant aluminum fuel door lets the cook add charcoal during a session without lifting the midsection, and a premium-grade cover is included in the box.
The spec sheet rounds out the build list with two glass-reinforced nylon lid handles and an owner’s guide in the box, and the selling listing describes the porcelain-enameled lid, bowl, and center section as retaining heat without rusting or peeling. The same listing notes that the silicone temperature grommet monitors the smoker’s internal temperature during a cook.
Smokey Mountain details for a contest site
The selling listing puts the weight at 68 pounds, less than half of any other cooker here, and lists a 10-year limited warranty. The two-grate layout gives a chicken cook a full second level for a practice batch or a holding level, and the water pan format is the one many teams learn first before moving to drums or cabinets.
Camp Chef Woodwind Pro 36 Pellet Grill
The Woodwind Pro 36, model PG36WWSB, is the pellet grill of the five. The listing prints a lower rack of 663 square inches and an upper rack of 573, for 1,236 square inches of total rack area, a chamber size of 7,000 cubic inches, and a 22 pound hopper, in a grill listed at 62 by 26 by 45 inches and 183 pounds.
Fire control on the Woodwind Pro 36
A WiFi controller runs the cook, with the Camp Chef Connect app, four temperature probe ports, and a Smoke Number setting from 1 to 10 that adjusts smoke output. The grill’s listed high temperature is 500 degrees Fahrenheit, and a Fan Only mode supports cold smoking. An ash cleanout empties into a removable cup with a side pull.
The selling pages add the supporting detail: a Down and Out ventilation design that pushes smoke and heat up the sides of the grill and out the rear exhaust, high-grade stainless steel components inside, compatibility with the maker’s Sidekick flat top and sear accessories, and a 3-year warranty on materials and workmanship with the finish excluded. The grill’s main cooking grid measures 34 by 19 inches.
Woodwind Pro 36 details for a contest site
The distinguishing hardware is the Smoke Box: a separate chamber that burns wood pellets, chunks, or chips, and even charcoal, with a damper to adjust its output while the pellet fire holds the temperature. For chicken, that means smoke flavor can be raised for a short cook without changing the set temperature on the controller.
More printed detail worth weighing
Beyond the headline numbers, the five pages print a second layer of hardware detail that separates these cookers in daily use: how the fire breathes, whether a water pan or diverter sits over it, and how the cook reads the temperature while a turn-in clock is running.
Fuel and fire hardware, as printed
All four charcoal cookers burn charcoal with wood chunks for smoke, and each page says so. The Gateway seller lists lump charcoal as the common fuel with chunks added for flavor and no electrical connection required. The Bronco Pro burns charcoal only, with no water pan in its spec list. The Woodwind Pro burns pellets as its main fuel.
The fire hardware differs more than the fuel. The Gateway basket lifts out of the drum. The Bronco Pro basket is oversized and paired with a heat diffuser. The Backwoods firebox is described as a commercial-grade fire grate and ash pan under a heat diverter. The Weber uses a steel charcoal grate under a porcelain-enameled charcoal chamber, per its spec sheet.
Water pans, diverters, and seals
Three of the five designs put something between the fire and the food. The Backwoods runs a water pan the page calls permanent, with a removable pan option over a heat diverter. The Weber’s porcelain-enameled water pan is part of its spec sheet cooking system. The Bronco Pro instead lists a heat diffuser and no water pan at all.
Sealing is the other printed theme. The Bronco Pro’s hinged lid carries a gasket for a tight seal, the Backwoods door system is gasketed stainless steel, and the Gateway drum is a single steel shell with welded intake pipes. The Woodwind Pro lists a gasket among its 304 stainless steel components, alongside the butterfly valve and burn cup.
Gauges, probes, and controllers
Temperature feedback ranges from a single dial to a connected controller. The Gateway reads on its fixed 3 inch dial thermometer, the Bronco Pro on a barrel-mounted gauge, and the Backwoods usually ships with a Tel-Tru thermometer per its page. The Weber lists a built-in lid thermometer plus a silicone grommet sized for probe cables.
The Woodwind Pro sits at the other end: a WiFi controller with a full-color display, four temperature probe ports, app monitoring through Camp Chef Connect, and push notifications per the selling pages. For a chicken cook, the practical difference is whether doneness checks happen at the cooker or from a phone across the contest site.
How to choose chicken smokers for competition bbq
Start from the chicken cook itself, then match the printed specs to it. A competition chicken entry is a short cook at moderate to high heat, judged on pieces that look and bite alike, so grate layout, heat response, and a repeatable fire matter more than the overnight burn times that dominate brisket shopping.
Match the grate layout to the turn-in batch
Chicken pieces are small and numerous, so rack shape decides how evenly a batch fits. The Backwoods offers four flat racks of 22 by 15.5 inches, the Weber two round grates totaling 726 square inches, the Gateway a single 22 inch grate expandable to three levels, and the Woodwind Pro the largest printed total at 1,236 square inches across two racks.
Decide how the fire gets managed
Manual airflow cookers, the two drums, the cabinet, and the bullet, ask the cook to read a dial gauge and work dampers or intake pipes. The pellet grill replaces that work with a controller, probe ports, and a smoke setting. Neither approach is printed as better; the choice is whether the team’s routine is built around tending a charcoal fire.
Check weight and wheels before anything else
Competition cooking is travel, so the printed weight and the rolling hardware are working specs. The Weber lists 68 pounds, the Gateway and Backwoods 150 pounds each, the Bronco Pro 162 pounds on wagon-style wheels, and the Woodwind Pro 183 pounds. Caster kits and caster-ready feet exist because these cookers move constantly.
Use burn time as a schedule margin, not a headline
Every charcoal cooker here prints a single-load burn time far longer than a chicken cook: up to 14 hours for the Gateway, over 15 for the Bronco Pro, and 6 to 8 for the G3 Chubby. Read those figures as margin for a full contest day with several categories running, not as a requirement for the chicken entry itself.
Questions buyers ask about chicken smokers for competition bbq
Three questions come up whenever a team picks a cooker around the chicken category. Each answer below stays with what the makers and sellers print about these five models, rather than with general contest advice that no label here supports or repeats.
Do any of these cookers print a chicken capacity?
None of the five pages opened for this guide prints a chicken piece count. The Backwoods page prints capacity in ribs, briskets, and butts, and the other makers print area and fuel figures only. A buyer comparing batch size should work from grate dimensions and rack counts, which every page here does print.
Which cookers here are built to travel?
All five print mobility hardware or a portable weight. The Gateway lists a removable caster wheel kit, the Bronco Pro large wagon-style wheels, the Backwoods pre-drilled caster patterns in its feet, the Weber a 68 pound listed weight, and the Kamado-style cart format is absent here. The pellet grill is the heaviest at a listed 183 pounds.
Can the pellet grill match charcoal smoke on a short cook?
The Woodwind Pro’s answer on its own page is the Smoke Box: a separate chamber for chunks, chips, or charcoal with its own damper, plus a Smoke Number setting from 1 to 10. Those are the printed tools for raising smoke inside a short chicken cook. Whether the result matches a drum is a judging question no spec sheet settles.
Conclusion
For a competition chicken turn-in, the printed specs point to format first: drums for hot and fast charcoal work, the insulated Backwoods cabinet for racked batches, the Weber bullet for the lightest travel weight, and the Woodwind Pro for controller-run consistency. Match the grate layout and fire routine to the team’s day.