Key takeaways
- Compare six blenders for making smoothies with ice on motor power, smoothie programs, jar sizes and blade design, plus pros, cons, a full buying guide and FAQ.
Making a smoothie with ice asks more of a blender than fresh fruit does: cubes have to be pulled down, broken and kept moving until the texture turns even. This guide compares the best blenders for making smoothies with ice on the figures makers publish for that job, from motor ratings to smoothie programs and jar design.
Quick verdict
The short answer is that full-size pitchers are the natural home for icy smoothies, and all six machines here are built around one. Each maker publishes a smoothie route and an ice route, whether that is a named program, a crushing blade design, or both, so the differences sit in power, capacity and how much the machine does by itself.
The Vitamix Explorian E310 is the manual-control pick, with ten variable speeds, a pulse and a 2 HP motor behind a 1.4-litre container. Blendtec answers twice: the Classic 575 with a dedicated smoothie cycle and five speeds, and the Designer 650 with six cycles including smoothie and ice crush under an eight-year warranty. The Breville Super Q brings the highest motor rating here at 1800 watts plus two smoothie programs and a personal attachment. The KitchenAid K400 is the preset recipe model, with ice crush, icy drinks and smoothie programs on a five-speed dial, and the Cleanblend Commercial is the straightforward high-power option at 3 HP and 1800 watts with a 64 oz container.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vitamix Explorian E310 | Full-size pitcher | Manual speed control for icy blends | 2 HP motor, 1.4-litre container, 10 variable speeds | No preset smoothie program |
| Blendtec Classic 575 | Full-size pitcher | One-touch smoothie cycle | 1560 watt motor, WildSide+ jar, 5 speeds plus pulse | Shortest warranty in this group at 2 years |
| Breville the Super Q (BBL920) | Full-size jug plus personal attachment | Highest power and two smoothie programs | 1800 watt motor, 68 oz jug, 12 speed settings | Largest and heaviest machine here |
| KitchenAid K400 | Full-size jar | Preset recipes for ice and smoothies | 1.5 peak HP motor, 3 preset recipe programs | Jar size not stated in ounces by the maker |
| Blendtec Designer 650 | Full-size pitcher | Programs plus an eight-year warranty | 1560 watt motor, 6 preprogrammed cycles, 8 speeds | Touch interface instead of a dial |
| Cleanblend Commercial Blender | Full-size container | Simple high-power blending | 3 HP, 1800 watts, 64 oz container, 5-year warranty | Container not listed for dishwasher cleaning |
How we selected
Selection for this keyword favored full-size machines, because making smoothies with ice is usually a pitcher job: cubes need room to circulate and fall back into the blades. A model only belongs here if its maker publishes both a smoothie route and an ice statement, as a program name, a blade description or a stated recommended use.
Within that filter, the comparison rests on published figures: motor watts or horsepower as each maker states them, container size, the names of smoothie and ice programs, speed counts, blade and jar design notes, and warranty length. Where a maker describes what its jar or blade does for frozen ingredients, that description is reported as the maker’s own wording, not as a measured result.
Each product below is currently listed for sale by its maker or an established seller, and every figure in its section comes from that maker’s published product information. No model is credited with a capability its maker does not state.
Six blenders for making smoothies with ice
The six machines below all make smoothies with ice as a headline job, but they divide by control style. Two lean on manual speeds and pulse work, two lean on preprogrammed cycles, one mixes presets with a dial, and one keeps things deliberately simple with raw power and a big container doing the talking.
Vitamix Explorian E310
The E310 is the driver’s pick of this group: ten variable speeds and a pulse, with no preset programs between you and the blend. Vitamix fits a 2 HP motor and a 1.4-litre container sized for medium batches and small family meals, and includes a mini-tamper for pushing thick or frozen mixtures down toward the blades.
For icy smoothies, the technique is the classic Vitamix one: start low, climb through the speeds, and use the tamper rather than stopping to shake the container. Cleanup is built in, since the maker states the container self-cleans with a drop of dish soap and warm water in 30 to 60 seconds. The box holds the motor base, the 1.4-litre container and the mini-tamper, and cover runs to a five-year full warranty. Wattage is not the maker’s chosen figure here; the 2 HP rating is the number Vitamix publishes for this model.
Pros
- Ten variable speeds plus pulse for full manual control
- 2 HP motor with a tamper included for frozen loads
- Self-cleaning cycle stated at 30 to 60 seconds
- Five-year full warranty
Cons
- No preset smoothie program
- 1.4-litre container is the smallest pitcher in this group
Blendtec Classic 575
The Classic 575 is the one-touch answer from Blendtec: a 1560 watt motor, preprogrammed cycles that include a smoothie cycle and a clean cycle, and five incremental speeds plus a pulse for manual work. An illuminated LCD shows a time countdown, and the interface is a flat touchpad rather than a dial.
The jar is Blendtec’s WildSide+ design, which the maker shapes to pull ingredients into the blade path, a detail that matters when ice needs to keep circulating instead of riding on top of the blend. Timed 60-second and 90-second cycles round out the program list for jobs beyond smoothies. Cover is a two-year warranty, the shortest in this group, which is worth weighing against the strong program set. For a household that wants the smoothie to run itself, this is the simplest route in the Blendtec line.
Pros
- Dedicated smoothie cycle on a 1560 watt motor
- Five speeds plus pulse beside the programs
- WildSide+ jar shaped to keep ingredients moving
- LCD timer shows the countdown as it blends
Cons
- Two-year warranty is the shortest here
- No separate named ice crush cycle
Breville the Super Q (BBL920)
The Super Q is the heavyweight of this group: Breville rates its motor at 1800 watts, describes it as the highest possible motor rating, and quotes a blade tip speed of 186 mph under load. The jug holds 68 oz, and five one-touch programs include two separate smoothie programs alongside pulse and ice crush, frozen desserts and soup.
Twelve speed settings sit under the programs for manual work. A personal blender attachment with its own blade system is included, and the base recognizes which vessel is fitted, which lets one machine cover a 68 oz batch and a single serving. Breville also builds noise suppression into the design, a rare published detail in this class. The body is brushed stainless steel, the footprint measures 10.5 by 8.1 by 18 inches, and the box adds a recipe book, tamper and spatula. It is the most complete package here, and the largest.
Pros
- 1800 watt motor, the highest rating in this group
- Two smoothie programs plus a pulse and ice crush program
- 68 oz jug and a personal attachment with its own blades
- Noise suppression design and 12 speed settings
Cons
- Largest footprint in this group at 18 inches tall
- Personal attachment cup size not stated by the maker
KitchenAid K400
The K400 organizes its work as three preset recipe programs, ice crush, icy drinks and smoothie, over a five-speed variable dial. That pairing suits icy smoothies directly: the smoothie program runs the recipe, while the ice crush program handles the cubes when a drink needs them broken first.
KitchenAid rates the motor at 1.5 peak horsepower, and its comparison data lists 1200 watts and a cleaning cycle for this model. The asymmetric blade blends at four distinct angles, and the ribbed jar design works with that blade to fold ingredients back down. Soft Start begins gently before the motor reaches the set speed, and Intelli-Speed Motor Control adjusts power as the load changes. Of the six machines here, this is the one whose program names map most literally onto the keyword: ice first, smoothie second, both on the dial.
Pros
- Ice crush, icy drinks and smoothie preset programs
- Five-speed dial for manual control beside the presets
- Asymmetric blade blending at four angles
- Soft Start and Intelli-Speed Motor Control fitted
Cons
- Power quoted as peak horsepower rather than plain watts
- Jar capacity not stated in ounces in the maker’s figures
Blendtec Designer 650
The Designer 650 is Blendtec’s fuller-featured answer: the same 1560 watt motor rating as the Classic 575, but six preprogrammed cycles, batters, ice crush, smoothie, ice cream, whole juice and hot soup, over eight manual speeds plus a pulse. An illuminated LCD shows the remaining time as the cycle runs.
The WildSide+ jar carries the maker’s strongest frozen-ingredient wording in this group: Blendtec credits the jar design with a 25 percent increase in blending efficiency for frozen ingredients, and describes the blade as 80 percent thicker and ten times stronger than its standard design, with a blunt profile. The machine measures 7 by 15.5 by 9.25 inches, weighs 9.8 lbs, draws 15 amps on 110 or 120 volts, and carries an eight-year warranty, the longest cover in this group by a wide margin.
Pros
- Six cycles including both smoothie and ice crush
- Eight manual speeds plus pulse
- Maker credits the jar with 25 percent better frozen blending efficiency
- Eight-year warranty, the longest here
Cons
- Touch controls instead of a physical dial
- 15 amp draw is the highest stated in this group
Cleanblend Commercial Blender
The Cleanblend takes the simplest route in this group: a 3 HP, 1800 watt motor, a 64 oz BPA-free container and stainless steel blades, with the listing naming ice crush among its recommended uses alongside protein drinks and juices. There are no program names to learn; the pitch is power and capacity in a commercial-style frame.
The box holds the blender, container, lid, tamper and warranty booklet, and cover runs to five years. The unit measures 8 by 8 by 19 inches, weighs 12 lb and runs on 120 volts. One practical note from the listing: the container is not listed for dishwasher cleaning, so this is a rinse-and-wash machine rather than a dishwasher one. For a buyer who wants the strongest simple specification in the group and no interface to manage, it makes a clear case.
Pros
- 3 HP and 1800 watts, joint highest power figures here
- 64 oz BPA-free container with a tamper included
- Ice crush named among the maker’s recommended uses
- Five-year warranty
Cons
- No preset smoothie or ice programs
- Container not listed for dishwasher cleaning
Buying guide
Full-size icy smoothie machines look similar on a shelf, so this guide separates them on the details that change the result in the jug: how the smoothie and ice work is organized, what the motor figures really say, jar design, capacity, and the warranty and cleaning facts that decide long-term satisfaction.
How blenders for making smoothies with ice handle frozen loads
A frozen load fights back in two ways: cubes bridge above the blades, and thick mixtures stop circulating. The makers here answer with hardware and software. On the hardware side, tampers on the E310 and Cleanblend push the load down, while the WildSide+ jar shape and the K400 ribbed jar are designed to fold ingredients back into the blade path.
On the software side, a smoothie cycle varies speed and pulsing so the load keeps dropping, which is the Classic 575 and Designer 650 approach, and the Super Q dedicates two of its five programs to smoothies alone. Manual machines ask you to work the dial from low to high instead. Neither route is wrong, but they suit different mornings: programs for routine, dials for control.
Programs against dials for a daily smoothie
Count the automation before you buy. The Designer 650 offers six cycles, the Classic 575 a smoothie cycle plus timed cycles, the Super Q five one-touch programs, and the K400 three recipe programs over its dial. The E310 and the Cleanblend offer none, relying on speeds and the tamper.
The trade is repeatability against flexibility. A program makes Tuesday’s smoothie match Monday’s with one press, and it stops by itself. A dial lets you rescue a blend mid-cycle, slow down for a thick mixture, or finish a sauce at a texture no program names. Households blending the same drink daily gain more from programs; varied cooks gain more from the dial.
Reading horsepower and wattage together
This group quotes power three ways: watts, at 1560 for both Blendtec models and 1800 for the Super Q and Cleanblend; horsepower, at 2 HP for the E310 and 3 HP for the Cleanblend; and peak horsepower, at 1.5 for the K400, whose maker also lists 1200 watts in comparison data.
Peak figures describe a ceiling, not a cruising speed, so the honest comparisons are inside each dialect: the two 1560 watt Blendtec machines against each other, the 1800 watt pair against each other. Across dialects, treat blade design, jar shape and programs as part of the power story, because the makers present them together and a strong motor behind a poor jar still leaves ice riding on top.
Jar design is part of the ice story
Three jar philosophies appear here. Blendtec shapes the WildSide+ jar to drive ingredients into the blades and credits it with a 25 percent blending efficiency gain for frozen ingredients on the Designer 650. KitchenAid ribs the K400 jar and angles its blade four ways. Vitamix and Cleanblend keep the jar simpler and hand the job to a tamper.
None of these approaches removes the need for liquid with ice, which every maker’s guidance assumes. What jar design changes is how often you intervene: a well-shaped jar on a program can run untouched, while a tamper jar asks for ten seconds of attention and returns control of the texture. Choose based on whether you want to watch the blend or leave it.
Capacity, footprint and noise
Capacities cluster: 64 oz on the Cleanblend container, 68 oz on the Super Q jug, and 1.4 litres on the E310, which is the smallest pitcher here and the one aimed at medium batches and small family meals. The Blendtec models do not headline a jar ounce figure in their published summaries, so this guide records those jars by name instead.
Footprint and height matter under cabinets: the Designer 650 stands 15.5 inches tall, the Super Q 18 inches, and the Cleanblend 19 inches. Noise is the least published figure in the class; the Super Q is the exception, with noise suppression built into its design according to Breville. If a quiet morning matters, that published detail is worth more than a guess.
Warranty length and cleaning effort
Warranty spread in this group is wide enough to be a deciding factor: two years on the Classic 575, five years on the E310 and the Cleanblend, and eight years on the Designer 650. A daily icy smoothie is hard, repetitive work for a motor and a jar seal, so the length of cover says something about how the maker rates its own machine for this job.
Cleaning splits the group too. The E310 self-cleans with soap and warm water in 30 to 60 seconds by the maker’s account, the K400 lists a cleaning cycle, and the Classic 575 includes a clean cycle among its programs. The Cleanblend container is not listed for dishwasher cleaning. Match the cleaning story to your patience, because a machine that is annoying to wash gets used less.
FAQ
Questions about icy smoothie machines tend to circle the same points: liquid, frozen fruit against cubes, program or dial, and how big a batch one run should be. The answers below rest on the makers’ published figures and descriptions for the six models in this guide, not on general folklore.
Do blenders for making smoothies with ice need liquid first?
Every maker’s guidance in this area assumes liquid in the jar with the ice. The reason is mechanical: liquid gives the blades something to move, and the moving liquid drags cubes down into the blade path. A jar of dry cubes alone tends to bridge and rattle rather than blend, whatever the motor rating says.
The machines here are built around that assumption, from the tamper jars that expect a mixture to push down, to the programmed cycles that pulse to drop the load. If a blend stalls, the makers’ shared fix is more liquid or a pause to let the load settle, and the max line on the jar is the ceiling for how much you add.
Is frozen fruit harder to blend than ice cubes?
The makers treat them as sibling jobs. Blendtec credits the Designer 650 jar with better efficiency for frozen ingredients generally, the Super Q runs a frozen desserts program beside its ice crush program, and the K400 separates ice crush from icy drinks as two of its three recipe programs.
In practice the published distinction is about programs rather than difficulty: a model with both a smoothie cycle and an ice route, like the Designer 650 or the K400, gives you a named path for each. A manual model like the E310 handles both with the same technique, low speed first, then high, with the tamper keeping frozen pieces in the blades.
Does a smoothie program beat manual speeds?
A program wins on repeatability: the Classic 575 smoothie cycle, the Super Q smoothie programs and the K400 smoothie preset all run a fixed pattern and stop on their own, so the drink comes out the same each day. That is worth a great deal at breakfast time.
Manual speeds win on judgment. The E310 ten-speed dial lets you slow down when a mixture thickens or stop the moment the texture looks right, and the pulse on every machine here gives you a hand-operated way to drop ice into the blades. Several models in this group offer both, which is why control style appears here as a preference, not a ranking.
How many servings does one icy smoothie batch make?
Work from the container figures the makers publish. The Cleanblend container holds 64 oz and the Super Q jug 68 oz, which is family-batch territory for smoothies. The E310 1.4-litre container is described by Vitamix as suited to medium batches and small family meals, a piece of honesty in a class that usually only quotes the biggest number.
Remember that ice and frozen fruit take volume before they take liquid form, so a full container at the start blends down to less than its headline size. For a household, the practical split is between the 64 to 68 oz machines for one shared batch and the E310 size for a couple of servings at a time.
Can these blenders handle hot soup as well?
Some publish it directly. The Designer 650 includes a hot soup cycle among its six programs, and the Super Q includes a soup program among its five one-touch programs. Those two carry the claim in their own program lists, in the same place they list their smoothie and ice work.
For the E310, K400, Classic 575 and Cleanblend, the pages behind this guide do not headline a soup program, so the honest answer is to read them as smoothie-first machines and check the maker’s full documentation before hot use. A guide should not lend a model a capability its maker has not stated for it, and this one does not.
Conclusion
For icy smoothies, pick the control style first: a program for the same drink every day, or a dial for texture you steer yourself. Then let jar design and warranty length settle the choice. On the makers’ own published figures, each of these six machines makes smoothies with ice a headline job, not an afterthought.