Key takeaways
- Compare six food grade greases for KitchenAid mixer gearboxes, from the Whirlpool OEM part to NSF H1 synthetics, with NLGI grades, heat limits and pack sizes.
A KitchenAid stand mixer that grinds, whines, or weeps oil around the planetary usually needs fresh gear grease, not a new motor. This guide compares the best grease for KitchenAid mixers now on sale, from the factory Whirlpool part to NSF H1 food grade synthetics, judged on the ratings each maker prints.
Quick verdict
Start with the factory part if your mixer is a KitchenAid: the Whirlpool W11200218 grease is made for its planetary gears and fits 667 models. Owners who want a printed food grade rating on the tub should look at Super Lube or Lubriplate FGL-1, both NSF H1 registered.
The short answer splits by owner. If your mixer is under a service plan or you want zero guesswork, order the Whirlpool part and be done. If you service several machines, or you already keep food machinery grease on the shelf, a tub of Super Lube or a cartridge of Lubriplate FGL-1 covers the same gearbox and prints its food contact rating on the label. Petrol-Gel and Haynes Lubri-Film Plus are the long-running food plant names, sold in small tubes that suit a single refill. Bel-Ray is the heavy-duty outlier, built for loaded bearings and gears in food and beverage plants.
Every grease below prints either an NSF H1 rating, the FDA rule for lubricants with incidental food contact, or a factory fit for the mixer itself. That rating is the whole ballgame here, because the gearbox sits directly above the bowl. A general shop grease with no food contact rating does not belong in this housing, whatever its load numbers say.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whirlpool W11200218 Stand Mixer Planetary Gear Grease | Factory OEM grease | Owners who want the exact factory fill | Fits 667 stand mixer models | Maker prints no NLGI grade or heat range |
| Super Lube Multi-Purpose Synthetic Grease (NLGI 2) with Syncolon | Synthetic grease with PTFE | One tub for mixer and shop duty | NSF H1 registered, NLGI grade 2 | Maker page gives no pack size guidance for mixers |
| Lubriplate FGL-1 | Aluminum complex food machinery grease | Plants and heavy home use | Dropping point 460 degrees F, NSF H-1 No. 043534 | Sold in plant-size packs, smallest is a 14 oz can |
| Petrol-Gel Sanitary Lubricant | Aluminum complex grease on USP mineral oil | A mid-firm grade for small gearboxes | NLGI grade 1.5, range -4 to 302 degrees F | Maker data sheet prints no container sizes |
| Haynes Lubri-Film Plus | Extended wear sanitary grease | Single-mixer refills from a small tube | Maker lists mixers among its applications | Maker prints no NLGI grade or heat range |
| Bel-Ray Food Grade Synthetic Extreme Pressure Grease | Synthetic EP grease | Loaded gears and bearings in food plants | 4-ball weld load 500 kgf, ISO 21469 certified | Built for plant duty far beyond one mixer |
How we selected
Every pick below earned its place from a page published by its maker or from the maker’s own data sheet. A grease had to print an NSF H1 rating or the FDA incidental contact rule, or be the factory part for the mixer, and it had to name food machinery, mixers, gears, or bearings among its uses.
That screen is stricter than it sounds. Plenty of greases call themselves food grade in a headline and then print no registration number, no regulation, and no application list. Those were left out. Each pick here lets you read the actual claim: an NSF registration, a line citing Title 21 CFR 178.3570, an ISO 21469 certificate, or a factory part number with a model fit list. Where a maker does not print a figure, such as an NLGI grade or a temperature range, the article says so instead of filling the gap.
One more screen mattered: current sale. Each product below was listed in stock or in active maker packaging when its page was read, in sizes a home or small-shop buyer can actually order. Plant-only drum programs with no smaller pack still appear where the maker sells a can or cartridge size, because a 14 oz can is a fair one-time buy for a mixer that takes ounces per refill.
Grease for KitchenAid mixers, compared one by one
The six greases below split into two camps: one factory part blended for this exact gearbox, and five food machinery greases with printed H1 ratings and published test data. Read the limit line on each one before you order, because pack sizes and temperature ranges differ a lot.
Whirlpool W11200218 Stand Mixer Planetary Gear Grease
This is the grease Whirlpool itself supplies for the job, sold under part number W11200218 and described by the maker as the lubricant for planetary gears in stand mixers. The fit list runs to 667 models, and it covers the KitchenAid lines most home bakers own, tilt-head and bowl-lift alike.
Whirlpool owns the KitchenAid brand, so this tub is the factory fill in everything but name. The part replaces a long line of earlier numbers, including 4176597, WP4176597, 4160587, and W11102079, which means it is the current answer for older machines whose manuals name a discontinued grease number. The maker states the service triggers plainly: replace the grease when it darkens, when the mixer makes noise, or after a gear replacement. On the question every buyer asks, the listing’s expert answer states that this grease will be food-grade quality.
The trade-off is paperwork. Whirlpool prints no NLGI grade, no temperature range, and no test data for this part, so there is nothing to compare against the food machinery greases on numbers alone. You are buying fit and factory intent rather than a spec sheet. For a mixer still worth real money, that is usually the right trade.
- Pros: genuine factory part; fit confirmed for 667 models; replaces nine earlier part numbers; written for planetary gears by name
- Cons: no printed NLGI grade or temperature range; no published test data; sold as a parts item, not a labeled food grease
Buy if your mixer is a KitchenAid and you want the exact grease the factory specifies. Skip if you service many brands of food equipment and want one rated tub that covers all of them.
Super Lube Multi-Purpose Synthetic Grease (NLGI 2) with Syncolon
Super Lube builds this grease on synthetic base fluids with Syncolon, its name for PTFE solid lubricant, and registers it with NSF as a food grade lubricant rated H1 for incidental food contact. It is the most widely stocked pick here, and its NLGI grade 2 body matches gearbox duty well.
The maker’s description is direct about what the formula does: synthetic base fluids and Syncolon micro powders combine to give longer life protection against friction, wear, rust, and corrosion. The grease also meets the former USDA H1 guidelines, which is the older wording of the same incidental contact category. NLGI grade 2 is the firm, peanut-butter body most small gearboxes are packed with, so the grease stays on vertical gear teeth instead of slumping into the bottom of the housing.
Because the same tub is sold for general machinery, the maker page does not give mixer-specific fill amounts or a KitchenAid fit list. You are matching it to the job by rating and grade, not by model number. For owners who also grease a meat grinder, a slicer, or shop equipment, that generality is the point.
- Pros: NSF registered H1 rating printed by the maker; synthetic base with PTFE; NLGI grade 2 suits gearbox packing; easy to find in stock
- Cons: no mixer fit list; maker page states no temperature range; general-purpose formula rather than a mixer-specific fill
Buy if you want one rated synthetic grease that covers the mixer and other food equipment you own. Skip if you want the factory part number on the tub for a mixer under a service agreement.
Lubriplate FGL-1
Lubriplate aims the FGL series at food, beverage, and pharmaceutical plants, and FGL-1 is the NLGI grade 1 member of the family, built on an aluminum complex thickener with USP white oils. The maker calls it the most widely used lubricant in the series because it covers low and high speeds.
The published data is the deepest in this group. The maker lists a dropping point of 460 degrees F, worked penetration of 310 under ASTM D-217, and NSF International H-1 registration number 043534. The formula is manufactured with ingredients that comply with FDA regulation 21 CFR 178.3570, the incidental food contact rule, and the series carries OU Kosher Pareve and Halal certification. Lubriplate also builds its Lubri-Armour antimicrobial additive into the series and notes the thickener resists the oil bleed that plagues many food grade greases.
Packaging is plant-minded: a case of 24 cans at 14 oz each, 6 lb cans, a 35 lb pail, 14.5 oz cartridges, and an 11 oz aerosol. A single 14 oz can is the sensible buy for home service, and it will cover several mixer refills. The grade 1 body is softer than grade 2, so it pumps and spreads easily in a cold shop, a real help when you are packing a gearbox by hand.
- Pros: full published test data; NSF H-1 registration number printed; grade 1 body spreads and pumps easily; long plant track record
- Cons: smallest pack is a 14 oz can; softer grade may suit high-heat gearboxes less than grade 2; aerosol version is a different registration
Buy if you read spec sheets before you buy and want the numbers in print. Skip if you only need a single small tube and do not want a can on the shelf afterward.
Petrol-Gel Sanitary Lubricant
Petrol-Gel is the old name in food machinery grease: an aluminum complex grease on USP mineral oil from McGlaughlin Oil, NSF H1 listed and Kosher certified. Its printed grade, NLGI 1.5, sits between the softer grade 1 and firmer grade 2 tubs, which suits a small gearbox that flings grease.
The maker’s data sheet reads like a lab report. Base oil viscosity is 100 cSt at 40 degrees C, worked penetration runs 300 to 330, and the dropping point sits above 260 degrees C. The printed temperature range is -4 to 302 degrees F, far beyond anything a mixer gearbox reaches in a kitchen. Water washout is listed at 1.0 percent loss, and the maker claims good mechanical stability, which is the property that keeps a grease from thinning out under constant gear shear.
McGlaughlin writes the application list for food plants: meat processing plants, canneries, dairies, breweries, and bottling plants where incidental food contact is a possibility. The data sheet does not print container sizes, so check the pack on the listing page before ordering. For a home mixer, the grade 1.5 body is a sensible middle path: firm enough to stay on the gears, soft enough to pack without warming the tub.
- Pros: mid-firm NLGI 1.5 grade; full test data on the maker sheet; 1.0 percent water washout; long history in food plants
- Cons: data sheet prints no pack sizes; mineral oil base rather than synthetic; plant wording rather than home wording
Buy if you want a middle grade with published numbers and a food plant pedigree. Skip if you want a synthetic formula or a factory part number.
Haynes Lubri-Film Plus
Haynes prints the word mixers in its own application list for Lubri-Film Plus, alongside bearings, pumps, slicers, and soft-serve machines. The grease is an extended wear sanitary lubricant rated NSF H1 for incidental food contact, and it comes in small tubes that fit a one-mixer job.
That application list matters more than it might seem. Most food grade greases name food plants in general; Haynes names the machine class this article is about. The maker describes Lubri-Film Plus as a heavy duty sanitary lubricant with extended performance and low friction properties, designed for longer lubrication intervals. It states the grease wears evenly on moving parts, will not dry or gum on equipment, and is highly resistant to separation or bleed, the failure that leaves oil weeping from a mixer head. The maker also states that all of its ingredients comply with FDA food contact rules.
Packaging is the home-friendly part of the line: tubes of 7 g, 1 oz, and 4 oz, plus pails and drums for plants. A 4 oz tube is about one gearbox refill, so little is left over to age on a shelf. The data sheet prints no NLGI grade and no temperature range, so buyers who shop by numbers should look at Lubriplate or Bel-Ray instead.
- Pros: maker lists mixers as an application; small tubes match a single refill; resists separation and bleed; NSF H1 rated
- Cons: no printed NLGI grade; no printed temperature range; thin published test data next to plant brands
Buy if you want a small, rated tube from a maker that names mixers on its own sheet. Skip if you need a printed grade and dropping point before you open a gearbox.
Bel-Ray Food Grade Synthetic Extreme Pressure Grease
Bel-Ray builds this synthetic grease for the heavy-duty end of food plant work, with extreme pressure and anti-wear additives plus polymers that add tack. It carries NSF H1 registration and ISO 21469 certification, and it comes in NLGI grade 1 and grade 2, so pick the grade your service notes name.
The numbers are the strongest here. The maker lists a 4-ball weld load of 500 kgf, a dropping point of 450 degrees F for grade 1 and 500 degrees F for grade 2, and a useful temperature range of -40 to 400 degrees F for grade 1. Water washout at 79 degrees C is 2.5 percent for grade 2. The formula is Kosher and Pareve approved and Halal certified, and the maker adds bacteriological protection that inhibits the growth of certain bacteria, yeast, and mold in the lubricant itself.
For one KitchenAid this is more grease than the job demands, and the maker aims it at bearings, bushings, cams, and sliding surfaces in food and beverage plants. It earns its place for owners who run a mixer hard, knead dense dough weekly, or keep one rated grease for a whole bench of equipment. Lighter-duty owners will be just as well served by Super Lube or Haynes.
- Pros: highest load numbers in this group; ISO 21469 certified on top of NSF H1; two NLGI grades; tacky film resists washout
- Cons: plant-grade overkill for a single home mixer; data sheet prints no pack sizes; firm grades need care when packing by hand
Buy if your mixer works hard every week and you want the strongest printed film in the group. Skip if the mixer sees holiday duty only.
Buying guide
A mixer gearbox is a small, slow, sealed box of gears, so the grease decision is simpler than most lubricant choices. Four things decide it: the food contact rating, the NLGI grade, the temperature range printed on the sheet, and the pack size you will actually use up before it ages.
Start with the food contact rating
The rating to look for is NSF H1, the category for lubricants that may touch food by accident. Every grease in this guide prints that rating, the FDA rule behind it, or a factory fit for the mixer, and that printed claim is what separates these picks from general shop grease.
H1 does not mean the grease is an ingredient or that it belongs in food. It means the formula is built from ingredients the FDA allows for lubricants with incidental contact, under Title 21 CFR 178.3570, and registered or certified by a body such as NSF or under ISO 21469. If a tub prints none of those marks, treat the words food grade on its front label as marketing and move on. The factory Whirlpool part is the one exception here: Whirlpool answers the food grade question directly on its listing instead of printing a registration.
Match the NLGI grade to the gearbox
NLGI grade is a firmness scale, and the gearbox cares about it more than any other number on the tub. Grade 1 is soft and spreads easily, grade 2 is the firm body most small gearboxes ship with, and Petrol-Gel splits the difference at grade 1.5 for owners who cannot decide.
A grease that is too firm can channel, leaving a tunnel around the gear path while the teeth run dry. A grease that is too soft can slump off vertical teeth and pool in the bottom of the housing, which is how a mixer ends up weeping oil at the planetary. When a maker’s sheet offers two grades, as Bel-Ray and Lubriplate do, match the grade your service manual names. When the manual names none, grade 2 is the common factory choice for this class of gearbox, and grade 1 or 1.5 is the easier hand-packing option.
Check the temperature range on the sheet
Mixer gearboxes run near room temperature, so heat range is rarely the deciding factor, but the printed range still tells you how the maker rates the formula. Petrol-Gel prints -4 to 302 degrees F, and Bel-Ray prints a useful range up to 400 degrees F for its grade 1 grease.
Dropping point is the other heat number worth reading: it is the temperature where the grease turns fluid enough to drip. Lubriplate prints 460 degrees F for FGL-1, and Bel-Ray prints 450 degrees F for grade 1 and 500 degrees F for grade 2. A high dropping point will not change how your mixer kneads, yet it does signal a stable thickener that resists the slow separation owners find as dark oil around the head joint. Where a maker prints no heat figures at all, as Whirlpool and Haynes do not, judge those picks on fit and rating instead.
Reading the label on grease for KitchenAid mixers
The label on any grease for KitchenAid mixers should give you four things in print: the rating mark, the NLGI grade, the thickener type, and the maker’s name for the application. If one of those four is missing, the sections above show which picks print it and which leave it unstated.
Thickener type is the quiet detail that matters during a refill. Aluminum complex thickeners, used by Lubriplate, Petrol-Gel, and Bel-Ray here, are known in maker literature for water resistance and stability under shear. PTFE-loaded synthetics like Super Lube take a different route, leaning on solid lubricant particles. Mixing two greases with different thickeners in one housing can soften the blend, so a full clean-out of the old fill is the right move whenever you change brands, whatever the labels say.
Buy the pack size that matches one refill
A stand mixer gearbox takes ounces, not pounds, so pack size is a freshness decision as much as a money one. Haynes sells tubes as small as 7 g and 1 oz, Lubriplate starts at a 14 oz can, and plant pails make sense only when several machines share the shelf.
Grease does not spoil quickly, yet a tub opened for years gathers dust every time the lid lifts, and dust is grit inside a gearbox. If you service one mixer every few years, buy the small tube and use it up. If you run a bakery bench or a repair shelf, the can or cartridge sizes from Lubriplate or the pail programs in this guide keep the cost per refill down without leaving a drum in the corner. Match the pack to the count of machines, not to the size of your ambition.
FAQ
Most grease questions come down to timing, quantity, and what the ratings really allow. The answers below stick to what the makers print on the pages and sheets behind this guide, and they flag the places where a maker simply does not state a figure.
How often should grease for KitchenAid mixers be replaced?
Whirlpool gives condition-based triggers rather than a calendar: replace the grease when it darkens, when the mixer makes noise, or after a gear replacement. Dark grease has picked up wear metal, and noise means the film on the gears has thinned or moved off the teeth.
In practice, a mixer that kneads weekly earns a look inside far sooner than one that whips cream at holidays. If you open the housing for any other repair, a stripped gear, a worn worm follower, a cracked housing, the grease decision makes itself: clean the old fill out fully and pack fresh grease while the box is open. Reusing dark grease after a gear swap puts the old wear particles straight back onto new teeth.
Can I use a general food grade grease instead of the factory part?
Yes, provided the tub prints a real rating. Super Lube, Lubriplate, Petrol-Gel, Haynes, and Bel-Ray all print NSF H1 status or the FDA incidental contact rule on their maker pages, which is the same food contact category a mixer gearbox needs above the bowl.
What changes is fit assurance. The Whirlpool part carries a model fit list of 667 mixers and a factory description written for planetary gears. A general food grade grease asks you to match NLGI grade and rating yourself. Both routes are sound; the first removes the matching work, the second gives you published test data and pack choices. What neither route allows is a shop grease with no food contact rating, however strong its load numbers look.
What does the NSF H1 rating actually allow?
H1 is the category for lubricants that may touch food by accident, in small amounts, during normal running. The formulas are built from ingredients listed under FDA Title 21 CFR 178.3570, and NSF registers the finished product for use in and around food processing areas.
The rating is about the lubricant’s ingredient list and registration, not about eating it. Grease still belongs inside the gearbox, and any fill that migrates into the bowl area should be cleaned out and replaced, because migration means the housing is overfilled or a seal has aged. Lubriplate’s sheet puts the plain version well: the registration covers equipment where there may be incidental contact between the lubricated part and the edible product. Treat H1 as the minimum bar for this job, not as permission to be careless with quantity.
How much grease does one stand mixer take?
Answers on the factory part’s own listing put the working figure at a minimum of about 6 ounces for one mixer, and the tub is sized to cover at least one full repack. Pack the housing so every gear tooth carries a coat, then turn the gears by hand to spread the fill before closing.
More is not better past that point. An overpacked housing churns the excess, builds heat, and pushes grease past the gasket toward the planetary, which is where the drips owners complain about start. If old grease has separated into oil and thickener, scoop and wipe the whole fill out rather than topping it off; mixing fresh grease into a separated fill gives you an unknown blend with an unknown grade. A kitchen scale makes the 6 ounce measure easy to hit before the housing closes.
Why did the old grease turn dark or start to separate?
Dark color is wear metal suspended in the fill, ground from gear teeth over years of loads. Separation is the thickener letting go of its oil, which then migrates to seams and drips, while the grease left on the gears runs thinner than its printed grade.
Heat cycles, long storage, and heavy dough loads all speed both processes. This is why makers such as Lubriplate call out resistance to oil bleed in their thickener design, and why Haynes prints that its grease will not dry or gum and resists separation. None of that makes a grease permanent. When the fill you find is dark, runny, or pooled at the bottom of the housing, the service answer is a full clean-out and a fresh pack at the grade the maker specifies, not a top-up.
Conclusion
For most owners the factory tub ends the debate: Whirlpool W11200218 is the grease KitchenAid mixers were filled with, and its fit list proves the match. Owners who want printed ratings and test data should buy Super Lube for the shelf or Lubriplate FGL-1 for the numbers, and size the pack to one refill.