Key takeaways
- Six mixers for Old Crow whiskey compared by label: Pepsi, RC Cola, a Kentucky ginger soda, sweet tea, 7UP and a pulpy lemonade, with sugar counts per serving.
Old Crow is a Kentucky bourbon that has always been mixed more than sipped, and the mixers for old crow whiskey below are its traditional company: two colas with different tempers, a ginger soda built on real sugar, sweet tea, a lemon lime soda and a lemonade with pulp in the bottle. Every one of them is an ordinary grocery shelf product.
Quick verdict
Short on time? Pepsi is the default cola pour, a touch sweeter and sharper than its rival. RC Cola is the older-school cola, on the shelf since 1905. Ale-8-One is the ginger answer with the lowest sugar here. Gold Peak is the still pour for a pitcher, and Calypso is the lemonade with actual pulp in it.
| Mixer | Format | Sugar per serving | Style |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pepsi | 12 fl oz serving | 41 g | Cola with citric acid, 38 mg caffeine |
| RC Cola | 12 fl oz can | 40 g | Cola, Royal Crown brand since 1905 |
| Ale-8-One | 8 fl oz serving | 20 g | Ginger soda, real sugar and corn sweetener |
| Gold Peak Sweet Tea | 52 fl oz bottle | 32 g per 12 fl oz | Still brewed black tea, cane sugar |
| 7UP | 12 fl oz can | 38 g | Lemon lime soda, caffeine free |
| Calypso Original Lemonade | 8 fl oz serving | 28 g | Still lemonade with lemon fruit pulp |
This is a working drinker’s list, and it knows it. Nothing here is a craft tonic or a small-batch syrup; these are the pours that have stood next to an honest bourbon for generations, in cans, bottles and pitchers. The differences that matter are small but real: a gram or two of sugar between colas, ginger in place of cola spice, tea in place of carbonation, and one lemonade that brings pulp to the glass.
How we selected these mixers
The selection rule was tradition with label receipts: pours that belong beside a Kentucky bourbon by long custom, each verified from its own label, and each different enough from the next that choosing between them means something. Two colas, one ginger soda, one tea, one lemon lime soda, one lemonade.
A value bourbon asks something specific of its mixer. The spirit is straightforward, so the mixer supplies most of the drink’s character, and it should do so without costing more than the bottle it is lengthening. That economics point is stated as a principle rather than with figures, since prices are not this article’s business; the formats here, cans, a 52 fl oz tea bottle and single-serve lemonade, are the formats of everyday mixing.
No label consulted names Old Crow as a pairing, so the pairings are stated the way drinkers actually hold them: cola and bourbon, ginger and bourbon, tea and bourbon are general customs, and each section sticks to what the mixer’s own label proves about the mixer. Sugar is quoted per serving as labeled, and servings differ, so the serving size travels with the number.
Six mixers for Old Crow whiskey, pour by pour
The order is the order of the soda fountain: the two colas first, then the ginger soda, then the still pours, tea and lemonade, with the lemon lime soda set between the ginger and the tea as the carbonated citrus option. The labels, not the legends, decide the order below.
Pepsi
Pepsi is the cola most likely already in the house. Per 12 fl oz serving the label lists 150 calories, 41 grams of carbohydrate, 41 grams of total sugars, all of them added, and 30 milligrams of sodium. The caffeine content is printed on the package: 38 milligrams per 12 fl oz.
The ingredient list holds a small distinction worth knowing: carbonated water, high fructose corn syrup, caramel color, sugar, phosphoric acid, caffeine, citric acid and natural flavor. That citric acid, which its great rival’s classic recipe does not lean on, is part of why Pepsi reads a little sharper and more citrus-edged beside a bourbon, where the cola’s job is to sweeten and lift at the same time.
With Old Crow the build is the oldest one in American drinking: bourbon, cola, ice, in a glass big enough to hold all three generously. Pepsi’s extra gram of sugar and its citrus edge suit a spirit with no frills of its own, and the drink tastes like the sum of two honest parts. It is the pour to beat on this list, and the others are here because each beats it somewhere specific.
- Who it is for: the drinker who wants the standard bourbon and cola, done right.
- Pro: the sharpest cola profile here, with caffeine printed on the package.
- Con: 41 grams of sugar is the highest count on the list.
- Buy if: one cola has to cover every bourbon drink in the house.
- Skip if: a drier or caffeine free glass is the goal.
RC Cola
RC is the cola with the longer memory. The brand line on the listing reads Royal Crown Cola, established 1905, and the can’s label lists, per 12 fl oz, 150 calories, 41 grams of carbohydrate, 40 grams of total sugars, all added, and 40 milligrams of sodium. The listing also flags the drink as low sodium.
The recipe is the classic cola build with one signature item: carbonated water, high fructose corn syrup, caramel color, phosphoric acid, caffeine, natural flavors and acacia gum. Caffeine is in the ingredient list, though this label does not print a milligram figure, so none is claimed here. The acacia gum is an old soda-fountain ingredient, there for body and foam, and it is part of the reason RC pours with a slightly rounder feel than the sharper Pepsi.
Beside Old Crow, RC is the nostalgic glass: a Southern cola and a Kentucky bourbon with more than two centuries of shelf history between the two brands. The flavor case matches the story, since RC’s rounder sweetness flatters a plainspoken spirit. Availability is the practical catch; RC is a regional pleasure in much of the country, stocked deep in the South and thinner elsewhere.
- Who it is for: the drinker who likes the old brands and the rounder cola.
- Pro: a century-old cola with a soft, full pour and low sodium by label.
- Con: distribution is regional, and no caffeine figure is printed.
- Buy if: it is on the local shelf and bourbon and cola is a house ritual.
- Skip if: the drink must be built from nationally stocked cans.
Ale-8-One
Ale-8-One is the ginger pour, and the lightest sweet thing on this list. The label record lists, per 8 fl oz serving, 80 calories, 20 grams of carbohydrate and 20 grams of sugars. The record’s own title gives the name away: it is sold as the “A Late One” soft drink.
The ingredients explain the profile: carbonated water, real sugar, corn sweetener, glycerin, ginger, natural and artificial flavorings, citric acid, sodium benzoate, phosphoric acid, caramel coloring and caffeine. Real ginger is a named ingredient, not a flavor note, and the sweetening is split between real sugar and corn sweetener. Caffeine is in the recipe; the record does not print a milligram count, so none is claimed.
With a bourbon, a ginger soda does what cola cannot: it adds a warm spice note that reads as if it belonged to the whiskey all along. Ale-8-One’s version is gentler than a ginger beer’s, closer to a ginger ale with citrus around it, and at 20 grams of sugar per serving it lengthens a pour of Old Crow without turning the glass into dessert. It is the connoisseur’s pick on a list that does not use the word lightly.
- Who it is for: the drinker who wants ginger character at a modest sugar count.
- Pro: real ginger in the ingredients and the lowest sugar per serving here.
- Con: a regional soda, and its serving is 8 fl oz, smaller than the colas’.
- Buy if: a whiskey ginger is the house drink and sweetness is watched.
- Skip if: it cannot be found locally, or a bold ginger beer heat is wanted.
Gold Peak Sweet Tea
The tea is the still pour, and the pitcher drink. The 52 fl oz bottle lists, per 12 fl oz serving, 120 calories, 32 grams of carbohydrate, 32 grams of total sugars, all added, and 5 milligrams of sodium. The label rates its sweetness at level 4 and calls the tea real brewed.
The ingredient list is the shortest on this page: brewed tea from filtered water and black tea leaves, cane sugar, and phosphoric acid. Three lines. The maker copy adds that the black tea leaves are harvested at their flavor peak and that the tea is brewed for a homemade sweet tea taste. Cane sugar, not corn syrup, does the sweetening, which tea drinkers claim they can taste, and the label gives them the fact to stand on.
Bourbon and sweet tea is a Southern table drink, built long in a tall glass or batched in a pitcher with lemon if the house likes it. The tea’s tannin gives the drink a structure the sodas do not have, and the still pour never goes flat while a group works through it. For an Old Crow drinker hosting more than two people, this is the practical bottle on the list.
- Who it is for: the drinker mixing for a table, or who prefers a still drink.
- Pro: three-ingredient label, cane sugar, and a 52 fl oz pitcher format.
- Con: no carbonation, and 32 grams of sugar per serving is a full count.
- Buy if: bourbon tea is served by the pitcher in warm weather.
- Skip if: fizz is non-negotiable in a mixed drink.
7UP
7UP is the lemon lime pour, verified for the deep eddy lemon list in this same batch and poured here for a different spirit. Per 12 fl oz can the label lists 140 calories, 39 grams of carbohydrate, 38 grams of total sugars, all added, and 40 milligrams of sodium, and the drink is caffeine free.
The recipe is the familiar one: carbonated water, high fructose corn syrup, citric acid, natural flavors, potassium citrate and calcium disodium EDTA. It is low sodium by its label’s own description. There is no juice in the can; the lemon lime is flavor, delivered clean and sweet with strong carbonation.
Bourbon and lemon lime soda is the simplest highball on this list: spirit, soda, ice, nothing to measure and nothing to garnish unless a lemon wedge is at hand. The citrus brightens the bourbon the way it brightened the lemon vodka in its own article, and the caffeine free label makes it the evening pour for drinkers who are done with caffeine for the day. It is also the easiest bottle here to find absolutely anywhere.
- Who it is for: the drinker who wants the simplest possible bourbon highball.
- Pro: caffeine free, nationally stocked, and dead simple to build with.
- Con: lemon lime flavor only; it brings no spice, tannin or depth.
- Buy if: a no-thought evening pour is the requirement.
- Skip if: the mixer is expected to give the drink its character.
Calypso Original Lemonade
Calypso is the lemonade with something in it. The nutrition record lists, per 8 fl oz serving, 121 calories, 29 grams of carbohydrate, 28 grams of total sugars and 2 milligrams of sodium. The maker of record is King Juice Company of Wisconsin. It pours like a lemonade stand drink, only bottled.
The ingredient list runs filtered water, sugar, lemon juice from concentrate, citric acid, lemon fruit pulp, canola oil, modified food starch, natural flavors, beta carotene and EDTA to preserve freshness. The lemon fruit pulp is the detail that matters: most bottled lemonades are clear, and this one carries pulp, which gives the drink a homemade texture that stands up in a mixed glass instead of vanishing.
With Old Crow it builds the whiskey lemonade, the summer pour that needs no shaker and no syrup: bourbon over ice, lemonade to the top, and the pulp doing the work of a garnish. The sugar is real but not the list’s highest, the sodium is nearly nothing, and the drink tastes like lemonade first and bourbon second, which for many drinkers on a hot day is the correct order.
- Who it is for: the drinker who wants a whiskey lemonade with texture.
- Pro: real lemon pulp in the bottle and a very low sodium line.
- Con: still and sweet, and the serving is 8 fl oz, so a glass takes two.
- Buy if: lemonade drinks are a summer habit in the house.
- Skip if: a clear, pulp free lemonade is the preference.
Buying guide
Every pour here is an everyday product, so the buying decisions are about habit rather than occasion: which cola temper suits the house, whether ginger or tea should join the shelf, and how the sugar and caffeine lines fit the drinkers. This guide takes them in that order.
Sugar counts across mixers for Old Crow whiskey
The colas top the list at 41 and 40 grams per 12 fl oz. The tea follows at 32 grams per 12 fl oz, then the Calypso at 28 grams per 8 fl oz, the 7UP at 38 grams per can, and the Ale-8-One lowest at 20 grams per 8 fl oz. Serving sizes differ, so the honest comparison is per finished glass, where a tall cola build uses a full can.
None of these numbers is hidden; all six labels print them plainly. The practical habit is to pick the house pour by the number the household can live with nightly, and keep the fullest-sugar cola for the nights it is specifically wanted. A bourbon this plainspoken tastes good with all of them, which is exactly why the label has to make the decision.
Two colas, two tempers
Pepsi and RC are not duplicates. Pepsi’s recipe adds citric acid and sugar beside its corn syrup, and it drinks sharper, with a citrus edge and 38 milligrams of printed caffeine. RC’s recipe includes acacia gum, drinks rounder, prints no caffeine figure, and carries a brand history back to 1905 that matches the bourbon’s own old-soul appeal.
Stocking both is not excess for a cola-drinking house, because they answer different moods: Pepsi when the drink should taste bright, RC when it should taste mellow. Stocking one is fine too, and the tie-breaker is availability, since RC’s regional distribution means many households will meet it as a treat rather than a staple.
Caffeine, stated and unstated
The caffeine facts on this list come in three kinds. Pepsi prints its figure, 38 milligrams per 12 fl oz. RC and Ale-8-One list caffeine among their ingredients without a printed milligram count on the labels consulted, so they are caffeinated pours of unstated strength. The 7UP is labeled caffeine free.
The tea’s label does not state a caffeine figure either, and black tea as a category is a caffeinated drink, but this article claims only what labels print. The practical rule follows: for a late drink, the 7UP is the one pour here whose caffeine status is printed as zero, and the rest should be treated as caffeinated unless the bottle in hand says otherwise.
Formats for one drinker or a table
The colas and the 7UP come in cans that portion themselves. The tea comes in a 52 fl oz bottle built for a pitcher and a fridge shelf. The Ale-8-One pours from bottles in its home region, and the Calypso serving is 8 fl oz, so a mixed drink uses a generous part of a bottle each time.
Match format to company. A single drinker is best served by the cans, which wait in the pantry without a fridge clock. A household that mixes for a porch full of people should keep the tea and the lemonade, which are built to be finished the day they are opened and taste best exactly then.
The bourbon and cola build, done carefully
The classic build rewards two small disciplines. Fill the glass with ice before anything else goes in, so the drink is cold from the first sip and dilutes slowly. Pour the bourbon over the ice, then the cola down the side of the glass, which keeps more of the carbonation alive than a splash from height.
For the still pours the same care applies in reverse: tea and lemonade should be cold before they meet the spirit, since a still drink has no carbonation to hide a warm start. Taste the first glass of a batch before serving it around, and adjust with mixer, not with more bourbon, when the balance is off.
FAQ
Short answers on caffeine, sugar and the two-cola question, drawn from the labels above, for the drinker who keeps an honest bourbon on the shelf and wants its company chosen with the same plain dealing the spirit itself is known for. Most of them turn on caffeine and sugar.
Which mixers for Old Crow whiskey are caffeine free?
Only the 7UP carries a caffeine free label among the six. Pepsi prints 38 milligrams of caffeine per 12 fl oz. RC Cola and Ale-8-One both list caffeine as an ingredient without a printed milligram figure on the labels consulted. The Gold Peak label states no caffeine figure, and the Calypso lemonade lists no caffeine among its ingredients.
Why are there two colas on one list?
Because cola is the default bourbon mixer and the two classics genuinely differ: Pepsi is sharper, with citric acid in the recipe and the higher sugar count by a gram, while RC is rounder, built with acacia gum, and older as a brand, established 1905. A list that picked only one would be hiding the actual choice drinkers make at the shelf.
What is Ale-8-One, exactly?
A ginger soda sold under a name that plays on the phrase “a late one”, per the label record’s own title. Its ingredients name real ginger, real sugar and corn sweetener, glycerin and caffeine. Per 8 fl oz serving it lists 80 calories and 20 grams of sugars, the lowest sugar line on this list, and its distribution is regional rather than national.
Can the sweet tea be batched with the bourbon?
Yes; a still mixer is the easiest kind to batch. Combine the tea and the bourbon in a pitcher in the proportion the house prefers, chill it, and pour over ice at serving time. The tea will not go flat, because it was never carbonated, and the 52 fl oz bottle is sized for exactly this use. Add lemon at the glass if it is wanted.
Which pour is best for a group?
The Gold Peak Sweet Tea, on format alone: one 52 fl oz bottle, a pitcher, and a drink that stays consistent from first glass to last. The colas serve a group well too if cans are plentiful, since each drinker can be handed a can and a glass. The Calypso is the least group-friendly format here, at 8 fl oz servings.
Conclusion
Keep it simple and keep it cold: Pepsi or RC over ice for the classic glass, Ale-8-One when ginger sounds right, Gold Peak for the pitcher, 7UP for the caffeine free evening, and Calypso when lemonade weather arrives. Old Crow has never asked for fancy company, and these six pours prove it does not need any.