Key takeaways
- Five beginner BBQ smokers for first time smokers compared on fuel, cooking space, temperature control, burn time, cleaning design and printed warranty terms.
This guide covers BBQ smokers for first time smokers in the cooking sense: five beginner BBQ smokers for people smoking meat for the first time, all charcoal fueled, checked on maker and listing pages and compared on control style, cooking space, burn time, cleaning and warranty terms, from fan-guided to fully manual.
Quick verdict
The Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600 is the most guided start, holding a set temperature with a digital fan and an app. The Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-Inch is the classic manual teacher, and the two drum smokers, from Oklahoma Joe’s and Pit Barrel Cooker, cut fire management down to a single intake or none at all.
The five picks teach temperature control in different ways. The Gravity Series 600 does the adjusting for you. The Smokey Mountain and the Char-Griller AKORN make you work dampers, which builds skill. The Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco adds a fuel door so a first long cook is not interrupted, and the Pit Barrel Cooker removes the temperature dial entirely, running at its own settled heat while you learn timing and doneness instead.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600 | Digital charcoal smoker and grill | Guided first cooks | 600 sq in, up to 18 hours at 225 degrees F | Needs power for the fan and controls |
| Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-Inch | Bullet water smoker | Learning damper control | Two 18-1/2-inch grates, 39.1 lb | No digital control or probe system listed |
| Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Drum Smoker and Grill | Drum smoker and grill | Hanging ribs, long cooks | 284 sq in, 14+ hours per load | Heaviest pick here at 136.5 lb |
| Pit Barrel Cooker 18.5-Inch Classic Premiere | Drum cooker | Fewest decisions per cook | 8 hooks, 2 hanging rods, no dial | No built-in temperature gauge listed |
| Char-Griller AKORN Kamado E16620 | Kamado grill and smoker | Smoking and grilling in one | 445 sq in, 200 to 700 degrees F | 1-year warranty is the shortest here |
How we selected
Each smoker below was read on a maker page or a listing page showing it in stock, and only printed figures are used: cooking space, fuel capacity, burn time, temperature range, dimensions, weight and warranty. A model a page showed out of stock, such as the Gravity Series 560 on its bundle page, was left out.
Beginner fit was judged on printed design, not on reputation. The traits that earned a place here are a controller or fan that holds temperature for you, a water pan or insulated walls that slow temperature swings, a fuel door or hopper that avoids mid-cook rebuilding, and a parts list short enough that a first assembly is an afternoon job. Every pick burns charcoal, because that is where the currently listed entry-level models with full printed specs were found.
Five smokers for first time smokers, by fuel and format
All five picks burn charcoal, but they ask different amounts of you. One holds temperature with a fan and an app, two teach damper control on insulated bodies, and two are drums that trade fine adjustment for a fire that mostly runs itself once it is lit and loaded the maker’s way.
Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600
The Gravity Series 600 gives 600 square inches of cooking space and feeds charcoal from a GravityFed hopper that holds up to 12 pounds of lump charcoal or 18 pounds of briquettes. The maker lists up to 18 hours of cooking at 225 degrees F, and burn times of up to 18 hours at 225 degrees F against up to 3 hours at 700 degrees F.
Who it is for: a first-time cook who wants charcoal flavor without learning vent control on day one. Why it fits the keyword: a DigitalFan holds the set temperature for you, the maker lists reaching 225 degrees F in 7 minutes or 700 degrees F in 10, and temperature can be set and watched on the digital control panel or in the Masterbuilt app, with tracking for up to 4 meat probes. The body has dual-wall insulation with a porcelain interior, reversible cast iron grates, porcelain-coated warming racks, and a removable ash bucket and grease tray. A pizza oven, rotisserie and flat-top griddle are listed as accessory-ready and sold separately. Warranty is listed at 1 year. The maker calls the insulated build its FuelSaver design and lists US-based support.
- Pro: fan-held temperature and app control remove the hardest beginner skill
- Pro: hopper feeding means no mid-cook charcoal rebuild on long smokes
- Con: the fan and controls need household power to run
- Con: 1-year warranty, matched only by the AKORN in this group
Buy if you want your first smoker to behave like an oven that happens to burn charcoal. Skip if you want to learn fire management itself, because the Smokey Mountain below teaches that directly and costs you nothing in electronics.
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-Inch
The Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-Inch, model 721001, is a porcelain-enameled steel water smoker with 2 nickel-plated cooking grates measuring 18-1/2 inches wide. The listing states it can hold a whole turkey and an entire ham at the same time, and the assembled size is 19 by 21 by 41 inches at 39.1 lb.
Who it is for: a beginner who wants the widely taught bullet-smoker method, with a water pan between the coals and the food. Why it fits the keyword: heat is managed with easily adjustable dampers, in the listing’s wording, and the water pan is the part sellers recommend keeping in place, since running without it exposes meat to direct heat and the smoker runs warmer. The cooking surface measures 17.5 inches in diameter. Warranty coverage is printed in tiers: the bowl, lid and center ring are covered for ten years against rust through or burn through, plastic components for five years, and all other parts for two years.
- Pro: longest warranty coverage in this group on the bowl, lid and center ring
- Pro: lightest pick here at 39.1 lb, and the smallest footprint
- Con: temperature is read and adjusted by hand; no fan or app is listed
- Con: two full racks of ribs are too long for the grate unless cut into half-racks
Buy if you want the smoker that teaches the standard water-smoker routine and carries the longest parts coverage here. Skip if you know you will not tend dampers during a cook, because nothing on this model adjusts the fire for you.
Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco Drum Smoker and Grill
The Bronco, model 25203120, is a drum smoker and grill with 284 square inches of cooking space on porcelain-coated steel grates. The maker lists a charcoal capacity of up to 8 lb of charcoal and wood supporting over 14 hours of smoking, a temperature gauge, and a 2-year warranty on all parts.
Who it is for: a beginner who likes the idea of hanging meat and wants a smoker that also grills. Why it fits the keyword: the maker’s own guide text calls drum smokers beginner friendly because they need less supervision, and describes this model as an especially good choice for beginners since it smokes and grills. The fuel access door lets you add charcoal or wood without removing food or grates, premium gaskets seal the lid, and the rib hanging kit includes 9 meat hooks and 3 hangers for vertical cooking. Assembled size is 26.6 by 44.4 by 43.4 inches at 136.5 lb, with dual side shelves, a removable ash pan, a grease tray and steel-core rubber-tread wheels. There is no water pan. Assembly is required, and the maker’s spec table lists manual ignition, no battery, a storage rack and no side burner.
- Pro: fuel door ends the mid-cook lid lift that unsettles a first long smoke
- Pro: hanging kit included, with hooks and hangers for ribs and large cuts
- Con: 284 square inches of grate space is the least in this group
- Con: 136.5 lb makes it the heaviest pick here despite the compact drum shape
Buy if hanging ribs appeals to you and you want one drum that grills on weeknights. Skip if most of your cooking is laid flat on a grate, because its grate area is small and its capacity lives in the hanging space.
Pit Barrel Cooker 18.5-Inch Classic Premiere
The 18.5-Inch Classic Pit Barrel Cooker Premiere is a drum cooker built around hanging: the box includes 8 stainless steel hooks, 2 steel hanging rods, a charcoal basket, a standard grill grate, an attachable ash pan and a dual-tier heat shield. Assembled size is listed at 36 inches tall by 25 inches wide.
Who it is for: a first-time cook who wants the fewest possible decisions during the cook itself. Why it fits the keyword: the maker describes this model as one of the most popular first smokers for new BBQ enthusiasts, pointing to a set-and-forget design with no temperature dial and everything needed for the first cook in the box. Capacity is listed in food rather than area: it feeds 10 to 20 people, holds up to 8 racks of ribs, two whole pork shoulders, two whole turkeys, or two full packer briskets, and handles packer briskets of approximately 14 to 16 pounds hung vertically. The Premier version adds a lid handle the maker describes as designed to reduce heat transfer, a detachable dual-tier heat shield, and the maker’s hook tool as standard parts.
- Pro: no temperature dial to manage; the cooker runs at its settled heat
- Pro: hooks, rods, basket, grate and rubs are all in the box for a first cook
- Con: no built-in temperature gauge is listed, so doneness checks are on you
- Con: hanging is the main method; flat grate cooking is the secondary one
Buy if you want to light one basket of charcoal and spend the cook learning meat, not vents. Skip if you want to hold a precise low temperature for a specific recipe, because this design does not offer a dial to set one with.
Char-Griller AKORN Kamado E16620
The AKORN Kamado, model E16620, lists 445 square inches of cooking capacity on cast iron grates with a removable stainless steel warming rack, and a cooking range from 200 to 700 degrees F. The body is triple-wall insulated steel, the cooking diameter is 20 inches, and the assembled size is 45 by 31 by 47 inches at 97 lb.
Who it is for: a beginner who wants one cooker that smokes at the low end and grills hot at the top end. Why it fits the keyword: temperature is worked with indexed dual adjustable dampers, which give a new cook repeatable settings to return to, and a built-in temperature gauge reads the chamber. The listing includes foldable carbon steel side shelves with tool hooks, a bottom storage shelf, an EasyDump ash pan, a grill grate lifter, and 8-inch locking caster wheels. The AKORN Smokin’ Stone is listed as sold separately. Warranty coverage is printed as repair or replace for a period of 1 year. The listing names the color as Graphite and the body material as alloy steel.
- Pro: 200 to 700 degrees F range covers smoking and high-heat grilling
- Pro: insulated triple-wall steel body and an ash pan that dumps cleanly
- Con: 1-year warranty is the shortest coverage in this group
- Con: the smoking stone for indirect cooking is a separate purchase
Buy if your first smoker also has to be your grill, and you like damper settings you can write down and repeat. Skip if warranty length is a deciding factor, because the Weber above covers its bowl, lid and center ring for ten years.
Buying guide
A first smoker should make temperature boring. Judge these five on how the temperature is held, how fuel is added during a long cook, how ash comes out afterward, and how much food the maker rates the cooking space for, because those four things decide your first three cooks.
Controls that help smokers for first time smokers most
There are three levels of help in this group. The Gravity Series 600 holds a set temperature with a digital fan and reports through an app. The Smokey Mountain and AKORN ask you to work dampers, one with a water pan steadying the chamber and the other with indexed damper settings and insulated walls.
The drums sit at the far end: the Bronco gives you an airflow system and a gauge, and the Pit Barrel Cooker gives you no dial at all. None of these is the wrong answer. Pick the level of involvement you will still enjoy on your tenth cook, not just your first, because a smoker you find tedious is a smoker that stays in the garage.
Fuel handling during a long cook
Long cooks are where beginners get caught out, so compare how fuel is added. The Gravity Series 600 feeds itself from a hopper holding up to 12 pounds of lump charcoal or 18 pounds of briquettes. The Bronco opens a fuel door. The bullet and kamado designs ask you to add charcoal through their access points.
Burn time figures tell the same story in numbers: up to 18 hours at 225 degrees F for the Gravity Series 600, and over 14 hours from an 8-lb load for the Bronco. A first brisket or pork shoulder can run past ten hours, so a smoker whose printed burn time clears that mark on one load removes the most stressful refill of your early cooks.
Size, capacity and footprint
Cooking space here runs from 284 square inches of grate on the Bronco to 600 square inches on the Gravity Series 600, but the drum smokers add hanging capacity that area figures miss: the Pit Barrel Cooker is rated for up to 8 racks of ribs hung from its rods, and the Bronco’s kit hangs ribs and large cuts too.
Footprint and weight decide where the smoker lives. The Smokey Mountain is 39.1 lb on a 19 by 21 inch base, the AKORN is 97 lb on locking casters, and the Bronco is 136.5 lb with side shelves spread across 44.4 inches of width. Measure the patio corner and the storage spot before choosing, and count the shelves in the width, not just the barrel.
Cleaning and ash handling
Ash is the chore that decides whether a smoker gets used weekly. The AKORN lists an EasyDump ash pan, the Gravity Series 600 a removable ash bucket and grease tray, the Bronco a removable ash pan and grease tray, and the Pit Barrel Cooker an attachable ash pan, all designs that empty without tipping the cooker.
Grease handling matters on fatty cuts. A listed grease tray or bucket, as on the Masterbuilt and the Bronco, catches drippings in one removable part. On the Smokey Mountain, the water pan sits between the fire and the food and collects much of what drips, which is one more reason sellers advise keeping it in place during a cook.
Warranty and parts support
Warranty terms in this group are printed plainly and they differ a lot. Weber covers the Smokey Mountain’s bowl, lid and center ring for ten years against rust through or burn through, with five years on plastic components and two years on other parts. Oklahoma Joe’s lists 2 years on all Bronco parts.
At the other end, the Masterbuilt Gravity Series 600 lists a 1-year warranty and the AKORN lists repair or replace for 1 year. The Pit Barrel page does not print a warranty term in the sections read for this guide, so treat that as a question to settle on the maker page before ordering. For a first smoker, longer coverage on the fire-facing parts is worth real weight in the decision.
FAQ
First-time buyers usually ask the same four things: how much space is enough, whether a fan is worth it, what a water pan does, and how long a first cook takes. The answers below stick to the figures and features printed for the five smokers in this guide.
How much cooking space do smokers for first time smokers need
Enough for one large cut plus a second dish is a practical start. In this group that means the 445 square inches of the AKORN or the 600 of the Gravity Series 600 for flat cooking, while the Smokey Mountain’s two 18-1/2-inch grates are rated to hold a whole turkey and an entire ham at the same time.
Is a digital fan worth it on a first smoker
It is worth it if your goal is food first and fire skills later. The Gravity Series 600’s DigitalFan holds the set temperature, reaches 225 degrees F in 7 minutes by the maker’s listing, and reports through an app with tracking for up to 4 probes. The trade is dependence on household power and a 1-year warranty.
What does the water pan do in a bullet smoker
On the Smokey Mountain it sits between the charcoal and the grates. The seller guidance read for this guide recommends always using it: without the pan, meat is exposed to direct heat and the smoker runs warmer. With it in place, the cook stays indirect, which is the gentler setup while you learn damper control.
Is hanging meat harder than cooking on a grate
The makers of both drum smokers here present hanging as the simpler routine, not the advanced one. The Pit Barrel Cooker includes 8 hooks and 2 rods and is described by its maker as a popular first smoker, and the Bronco’s kit adds 9 hooks and 3 hangers. The food hangs over the coals and cooks on all sides at once.
How long does a first long cook take
Plan around the printed burn times rather than the recipe alone. The Gravity Series 600 lists up to 18 hours at 225 degrees F on a hopper load and the Bronco over 14 hours on up to 8 lb of charcoal and wood, so both can carry an overnight pork shoulder on one load.
Start with a shorter cook, such as ribs, while you learn your smoker’s habits. The bullet, kamado and Pit Barrel pages read for this guide do not print a burn time, so plan their first long cook for a day when you can check the fire from time to time.
Conclusion
For a guided start, choose the Gravity Series 600 and let its fan hold temperature while you learn the food. For skills that transfer to any charcoal smoker, choose the Smokey Mountain Cooker 18-Inch. The Bronco, Pit Barrel Cooker and AKORN suit beginners who want hanging drums or a kamado that also grills.