Key takeaways
- Compare six charcoal grills for 120 on cooking area, grate material, fire control and ash handling, from a 147 square inch kettle to a 686 square inch barrel.
Shoppers comparing charcoal grills for 120 are looking at the starter end of each maker’s line, where the spec sheets differ more than the shapes suggest. Cooking area here runs from 147 to 686 square inches, grates come in cast iron, plated steel and chrome-plated steel, and ash handling ranges from a catcher to a crank-raised charcoal tray.
Quick verdict
The Char-Griller Patio Pro is the balanced pick for a small patio: 250 square inches of cast iron grate, a side shelf for platters, and an ash pan that dumps without lifting the grate. Cooks feeding a crowd should look instead at the Dyna-Glo barrel, at 686 square inches with a crank tray.
The two kettles bookend the group on size and hardware. The Napoleon NK18 brings a lid gauge and a hinged grid to 240 square inches, while the Weber Smokey Joe trims the kettle idea down to 147 square inches and 10 pounds for carrying. The Cuisinart CCG-190 is the lightest grill here at 4.2 pounds, a tabletop model with three lid locks for transport. The Old Smokey No. 18 is the traditional pick, an 18-inch aluminized steel grill whose design dates to 1953, with dampers above and below the coals and a 2-year warranty printed in its manual. Each entry below is ordered by the job the grill does, and every figure comes from the maker or listing page for that model.
How we selected
This roundup covers starter charcoal models from five makers: two kettles, two tabletop grills, a compact cart grill, and one full-size barrel. A model earned its place when its maker or listing page published cooking area, grate material, fire control hardware, ash handling, and dimensions or weight.
Where a page left a field blank, the gap is stated rather than filled in. The Char-Griller listing does not print a warranty term, the Napoleon manual points to the maker’s site for warranty terms, and the Old Smokey pages give no square inch figure for the 18-inch grate, so none is claimed for it here. Comparison throughout sticks to published numbers and named parts, and no figure from one model was borrowed to complete another model’s row.
| Grill | Cooking area | Grate | Key hardware | Ash handling |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Char-Griller Patio Pro (E1515) | 250 sq in | Cast iron | Side shelf, storage rack | Easy Dump Ash Pan |
| Weber Smokey Joe 14-Inch (10020) | 147 sq in | Plated steel | Holds up to 5 burgers | Aluminum ash catcher |
| Cuisinart CCG-190 | 196 sq in | Chrome-plated steel | Three lid locks, dual venting | Ash base under the firebox |
| Old Smokey No. 18 | 18-inch diameter | Not stated by the maker | Top and bottom dampers | Not stated by the maker |
| Dyna-Glo DGN486DNC-D | 686 sq in total | Porcelain-enameled cast iron | Crank tray, front door | Removable ash pan |
| Napoleon NK18 (NK18K-LEG) | 240 sq in | Chrome-plated steel, hinged | ACCU-PROBE gauge, lid hanger | Ash bucket assembly |
Six charcoal grills for 120, from tabletop to barrel
The six models split by shape and by how the fire is managed. The tabletops carry to a picnic table or a tailgate, the kettles stay simple with dampers alone, the Patio Pro adds a shelf and a dump pan to a compact cart, and the Dyna-Glo barrel runs the largest fire with a crank and a front door.
Read each entry for who the grill suits, the specs behind that call, and the limits the published figures show. Warranty terms are quoted only where a maker or listing page actually prints them, and dimensions and weights are the figures those pages give for each model.
Char-Griller Patio Pro Charcoal Grill (E1515)
The Patio Pro is the cart grill of this group: 250 square inches of cast iron cooking grate in a heavy steel body with a powder-coated finish. It stands on wheels with a side shelf for platters and a storage rack underneath sized for charcoal and tools.
Fire control is a set of side air-vent dampers, and ash drops into the maker’s Easy Dump Ash Pan, so cleanup does not mean lifting the grate or tipping the body over. A stay-cool wood handle covers the lid grip, and the wheels and legs give it a cart stance that suits a small patio corner. The listing gives the size at 31 inches deep, 21 inches wide, and 44 inches high, and the weight at 50 pounds, which settles it as a stay-on-the-patio grill rather than a carry model. The listing does not print a warranty term, so coverage is a point to confirm on the maker page for this model.
- Pros: cast iron grates; ash pan that dumps without lifting the grate; side shelf and bottom storage rack; wheels for patio moves
- Cons: no lid thermometer on the listing; 50 pounds is heavy for a compact grill; warranty term not printed on the listing
- Buy if: you want one grill that lives on a small patio and cooks for a household
- Skip if: you need a gauge in the lid or a grill you can carry to a tailgate
Weber Smokey Joe 14-Inch Portable Charcoal Grill (10020)
The Smokey Joe is the carry kettle: a 14-inch porcelain-enameled lid and bowl over 147 square inches of plated steel grate, with glass-reinforced nylon handles and an aluminum ash catcher under the bowl. It weighs 10 pounds and stands 17 inches high.
The maker rates the grate for up to 5 burgers at a time by its own burger press measure, which frames the Smokey Joe as a grill for one or two people rather than a family cooker. Airflow runs through a rust-resistant aluminum damper, and the ash catcher pulls out for emptying. There is no built-in thermometer and no wheel set, and the listing page does not state a warranty term. What it offers instead is the kettle shape in its smallest form, with enamel on the lid and bowl where heat and weather land hardest.
- Pros: porcelain-enameled lid and bowl; 10 pounds and easy to carry; removable aluminum ash catcher; simple damper control
- Cons: 147 square inches cooks for one or two; no built-in thermometer; no wheels; warranty term not stated on the listing
- Buy if: you grill for one or two and carry the grill to where you cook
- Skip if: you cook for a family or want a temperature gauge in the lid
Cuisinart 14-Inch Portable Charcoal Grill (CCG-190)
The CCG-190 is the lightest grill in this roundup at 4.2 pounds, a tabletop model with 196 square inches of chrome-plated cooking grate over an enamel-coated firebox. Three lid locks hold the top shut, which is what makes it a genuine carry grill for the road.
A dual venting system handles airflow, with vents working the firebox and the lid, and the base under the firebox catches ash so a tabletop stays cleaner than an open bowl leaves it. The listing gives the size at 14.5 inches deep, 14.5 inches wide, and 15 inches high, and prints a 90-day limited warranty, the shortest coverage stated for any model in this group. The chrome-plated grate and the short warranty mark it as a travel grill first and a household grill second.
- Pros: 4.2 pounds, the lightest here; three lid locks for carrying; dual venting system; enamel-coated firebox
- Cons: 90-day warranty is the shortest in the group; chrome-plated grate is a wear surface; tabletop size only
- Buy if: weight matters most and the grill travels in a car trunk
- Skip if: your usual cook is bigger than a 14-inch grate
Old Smokey Charcoal Grill No. 18
The Old Smokey No. 18 is the traditional pick, an 18-inch grill in aluminized steel from a Houston maker whose design dates to 1953. The coal grate is a round disc with vent holes, and dampers sit below the coals and on the lid, so the fire is managed from both ends.
The maker describes a grill that cooks for 4 to 6 people, standing on three legs with a wood handle on the lid. No thermometer appears in the manual’s parts list, and the pages for this model give no square inch figure, so the 18-inch grate diameter is the size figure to work from. The manual prints a warranty of 2 years against defects in materials and workmanship for the original purchaser, longer backing than the barrel and tabletop listings here state. The design has stayed plain on purpose: a steel body, a disc coal grate, and two dampers.
- Pros: 2-year warranty printed in the manual; dampers above and below the coals; design in production since 1953; cooks for 4 to 6 per the maker
- Cons: no thermometer in the parts list; no published square inch figure; no shelf or wheels in the manual’s parts
- Buy if: you want a simple steel grill with a long track record
- Skip if: you want a lid gauge, a side shelf, or a published grate area figure
Dyna-Glo Heavy Duty Charcoal Grill (DGN486DNC-D)
The Dyna-Glo is the capacity pick, a barrel with 686 square inches of total cooking area on porcelain-enameled cast iron grates. A crank raises and lowers the charcoal tray, and a steel front door opens the firebox for adding fuel without lifting the grates.
An adjustable flue on the smoke stack works the exhaust side, and ash collects in a removable high-capacity ash pan. The listing gives the size at 55.79 inches long, 28.43 inches wide, and 50.98 inches high, and the weight at 79 pounds, so this grill gets assembled where it will live. The listing prints a 1-year limited warranty. Against the kettles the trade is plain: far more grate area and real fire hardware, in exchange for a footprint and a weight that rule out carrying it anywhere.
- Pros: 686 square inches of total area; crank-raised charcoal tray; front access door; removable ash pan
- Cons: 79 pounds; 1-year limited warranty; footprint needs real patio room
- Buy if: you cook for groups and want to adjust the fire from outside the grill
- Skip if: space is tight or the grill has to move often
Napoleon NK18 Premium Charcoal Kettle Grill (NK18K-LEG)
The NK18 is the fitted-out kettle: 240 square inches on a 17.5-inch chrome-plated cooking grid that hinges for adding charcoal, inside a porcelain-enameled lid and bowl. An ACCU-PROBE temperature gauge sits in the lid, the one factory gauge among the kettles here.
The manual describes the maker’s Vortex Heat Management System with an ash bucket assembly under the bowl, four legs with two wheels, a bottom storage rack, and a built-in lid hanger, so the lid parks on the bowl rim instead of the ground. The manual gives the size at 24.5 inches wide, 21 inches deep, and 38.5 inches high, and the weight at 20 pounds. For warranty terms, the manual points to the maker’s site rather than printing a term, so coverage is a point to confirm on the maker page for this model.
- Pros: ACCU-PROBE lid gauge; hinged cooking grid for adding charcoal; porcelain-enameled lid and bowl; ash bucket assembly
- Cons: warranty term not printed in the manual; chrome-plated grid is a wear surface; 240 square inches is mid-size only
- Buy if: you want a kettle with a gauge and a hinged grid
- Skip if: you want the warranty term in writing before you order
Buying guide
Starter charcoal grills separate on four things: how much grate area you actually fill, how the fire is adjusted, how ash leaves the grill, and what the warranty paperwork says. Work through those four points before shape or finish, because they decide how the grill cooks week after week.
Grate area and shape
Cooking area in this group runs from 147 square inches on the Smokey Joe to 686 on the Dyna-Glo, and the right figure is the one that matches your usual cook. Count the food you grill on a normal Saturday, not the biggest party of the year, and leave working room around each piece.
Shape matters alongside area. A round kettle grate centers food over the coals and suits two-zone cooking with a banked fire, while a barrel spreads food in a row and gives long items like ribs and whole fish a straight run. Tabletop grates in this group sit between 147 and 196 square inches, which covers burgers and chicken pieces for a few people and not much more.
Fire control: dampers, trays and doors
Every grill here breathes through dampers, and damper control is a skill of small moves: open to raise heat, close to settle it. Two models add hardware on top of that baseline, a crank-raised charcoal tray on the Dyna-Glo and a dual venting layout on the Cuisinart tabletop.
A crank tray changes heat without touching the food, which helps when a flare-up starts or a thick steak needs the fire pulled back. A front door, also on the Dyna-Glo, lets you add charcoal mid-cook without lifting the grate. Kettle dampers ask for patience instead: adjustments take minutes to show, and overshooting in both directions is the usual beginner pattern.
Ash handling decides cleanup
Ash is the part of charcoal cooking that shows up after every meal, and the six models handle it four different ways. The Patio Pro dumps a pan, the Dyna-Glo pulls a pan out, the Smokey Joe lifts a catcher, and the Napoleon drops ash into a bucket assembly under the bowl.
Ash left in a grill holds moisture against the steel and shortens the life of the firebox, so the handling route matters more than it looks on a spec sheet. A pan or catcher that removes without tools gets emptied; a fixed bowl that needs scooping gets skipped. Whichever system you choose, ash comes out only when the coals are fully cold, and it goes into a metal container, not a bin liner.
Matching charcoal grills for 120 to your space
Measure the spot before the grill. The Dyna-Glo needs a footprint near 56 inches long and weighs 79 pounds, the Patio Pro stands 44 inches high on a 31 by 21 inch base, and the two tabletops need a table or a stand rather than floor space at all in the yard.
Weight decides whether the grill travels. At 4.2 pounds the Cuisinart goes in a car trunk without thought, the Smokey Joe at 10 pounds carries by its handles, and the Napoleon at 20 pounds rolls on two wheels for short moves. Cart and barrel models are patio furniture: they move for cleaning and winter storage, not for outings.
Warranty terms vary more than the grills
The printed terms in this group run from 90 days on the Cuisinart listing to 2 years in the Old Smokey manual, with the Dyna-Glo listing at 1 year between them. Two pages print no term at all, and a missing term is worth one check on the maker page before you order.
Read what a term covers, not just its length. Charcoal grills fail at the firebox, the grate, and the ash parts first, and those are exactly the parts short terms tend to leave out. Keep the manual and the receipt together, and register the grill if the maker offers registration, since proof of purchase is what a claim runs on.
FAQ
The questions below cover the points that separate these six models on paper: size, fire control, carrying weight, gauges, and what the published pages do and do not state. Every answer sticks to the figures and parts lists the makers and listing pages print for each grill.
What size are charcoal grills for 120?
They run from true tabletops to a full barrel. The Smokey Joe and the Cuisinart cook on 147 and 196 square inches, the Patio Pro and the Napoleon sit at 250 and 240 square inches, the Old Smokey cooks on an 18-inch round grate, and the Dyna-Glo reaches 686 square inches in total.
For one or two people the tabletops are enough. Households of three to five usually land on the 240 to 250 square inch models, and the barrel earns its footprint when gatherings are the normal cook rather than the exception.
Which of these grills is easiest to carry?
The Cuisinart CCG-190, at 4.2 pounds with three lid locks holding the top shut over the firebox. The Smokey Joe is next at 10 pounds with handles on the bowl, and the Napoleon rolls at 20 pounds but is a patio grill that moves, not a grill that travels.
Lid locks matter as much as weight: a locked lid keeps ash and the grate inside the grill in a car trunk. Neither tabletop has wheels, and the cart and barrel models, at 50 and 79 pounds, stay where they are assembled.
Do any of these grills have a lid thermometer?
One does as published here. The Napoleon NK18 carries the maker’s ACCU-PROBE temperature gauge in the lid, and the other five pages list no built-in gauge, so their cooks read temperature at the grate with a separate probe thermometer of their own instead.
A lid gauge reads the air near the lid, not the grate, so it guides vent moves rather than reporting food temperature. For thick cuts, a probe at grate level is the reading that decides when food moves or comes off.
How is ash handled on a starter charcoal grill?
Four ways in this group: a dump pan on the Patio Pro, a removable pan on the Dyna-Glo, an aluminum catcher under the Smokey Joe bowl, and a bucket assembly under the Napoleon. The Cuisinart catches ash in the base under its enamel-coated firebox, and the Old Smokey pages do not describe an ash system.
Empty ash after every few cooks, and only when it is fully cold. A deep ash bed under the coal grate chokes airflow and makes the next fire sluggish, so ash handling is a cooking issue, not just a cleaning one.
What warranty should I expect at this level?
Short terms are normal in this group. The printed figures are 90 days on the Cuisinart listing, 1 year on the Dyna-Glo listing, and 2 years in the Old Smokey manual, while the Char-Griller and Weber listings and the Napoleon manual print no term at all.
A short term puts the weight on build: enamel on the bowl and lid, grate material, and grate material, and how ash is handled around the firebox. If a term matters to you, confirm it on the maker page for the exact model number before ordering.
Conclusion
For most first-time charcoal buyers, the Patio Pro is the balanced pick, with cast iron grates and a dump ash pan on a compact cart. Kettle buyers should take the NK18 for its gauge and hinged grid, carriers should take the Smokey Joe or the CCG-190, and cooks feeding a crowd should take the Dyna-Glo.