Updated Nov 16, 2026· 16 min read

Key takeaways

  • Propane tanks for grills compared by capacity, weight, valve type and material: 20 lb steel and aluminum, exchange tanks, two 5 lb models and a refillable 1 lb.

The tank under a grill decides how often you refill, how much you lift, and whether a portable grill can travel at all. This guide compares six propane tanks for grills on the figures their makers publish: propane capacity, empty weight, dimensions, valve type, shell material and the certification wording printed on each page.

Quick verdict

Most backyard grills belong on a 20 lb tank, and the Flame King steel model adds a built-in gauge to that standard size. The aluminum 20 lb cuts the lifting weight for boat and RV owners. Blue Rhino exchange trades a 15 lb fill for zero maintenance. The two 5 lb tanks and the 1 lb refillable cylinder serve portable grills.

The split that matters is ownership versus exchange. An owned tank is filled by weight at a refill station and can take a fuller fill; an exchanged tank arrives filled, inspected and ready, with a lower net weight. Size is the second split: 20 lb for the patio, 5 lb for travel, 1 lb for the smallest grills that take a screw-on cylinder.

Product Type Best for Key spec Main limit
Flame King 20 lb Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge Refillable steel cylinder The standard patio grill 5 gal capacity, 17 lb empty, built-in gauge Steel shell can rust if left uncovered
Flame King 20 lb Aluminum Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge Refillable aluminum cylinder Boats, RVs, frequent lifting 5 gal capacity, 13 lb empty Taller body at 21.25 inches
Blue Rhino Propane Tank Exchange Pre-filled exchange Zero-maintenance refills 15 lb net weight of propane Less propane per swap than a full refill
Flame King 5 lb Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge Refillable steel cylinder Portable grills at home and camp 1 gal capacity, 10 lb empty, built-in gauge Small reserve for multi-burner grills
Ignik Gas Growler 5.0 Deluxe Refillable steel cylinder kit Camp and tailgate grills on 1 lb fittings 1.2 gal capacity, 4 ft hose and case included No built-in gauge
Flame King 1 lb Refillable Propane Cylinder Refillable small cylinder Tabletop and portable grills 16.4 oz capacity, about 1.6 lb empty Short cook time per fill

How we selected

Each entry rests on pages read in full: manufacturer product pages for the Flame King and Ignik cylinders, and the exchange operator’s own FAQ and how-to pages for Blue Rhino. Capacities, empty weights, dimensions and valve types are the figures those pages print. Certification lines are reported as the makers state them.

The six picks cover the ways grill owners actually buy propane. Three are own-and-refill cylinders in the standard 20 lb size class and the portable 5 lb class. One is the exchange model, where the cylinder itself is swapped rather than filled. One is a kit built around a hose and case for camp cooking. One is a refillable version of the small cylinder that portable grills use, included because its maker states a certification that disposable cylinders do not carry. No tank appears twice in different dress: the two 20 lb Flame King models differ in shell material and weight, and the two 5 lb models differ in gauge, hose and case.

Six propane tanks for grills, from patio standard to pocket size

The sections below take the six options in size order. Each one states the capacity and empty weight its maker publishes, the valve and material, how it is filled or swapped, and the limits that follow from those figures. Certification claims are attributed to the maker or operator in every case, exactly as their pages present them.

Flame King 20 lb Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge

This is the standard grill tank, bought empty and filled at a refill station. The maker lists a capacity of 5 gallons, an empty weight of 17 lb and dimensions of 12 x 12 x 17.8 inches. The shell is high-grade welded steel with a powder-coated finish, and a built-in gauge on the valve shows the propane level without lifting or shaking the tank.

The valve is a premium OPD assembly, the overfill prevention design the maker fits across its range. Inside the tank, a float on the valve carries a magnet that drives the gauge dial on the outside, as the maker’s FAQ explains. The maker states that every tank is x-ray and hydrostatic tested and DOT approved, and that its portable cylinders meet DOT and Transport Canada standards. Tanks ship empty and vacuum purged, ready for a first fill with no purging step. The maker’s FAQ adds two ownership facts: cylinders fill to about 80 percent to leave room for expansion, and the manufacture date is stamped on the collar or foot of the tank.

Pros and cons:

  • Pro: built-in gauge ends the lift-and-guess routine
  • Pro: standard 20 lb size fits the tray or cabinet of most patio grills
  • Pro: arrives pre-purged, so the first fill is a fill only
  • Con: steel needs a cover or shelter to keep the finish intact
  • Con: 17 lb empty means a full tank is a two-hand lift into a car
  • Con: no hose or adapter in the box; it is a bare cylinder

Buy if: you own a patio grill and want one tank that reads its own level. Skip if: your grill lives on a boat or the tank rides in a vehicle often, where the aluminum model below makes more sense.

Flame King 20 lb Aluminum Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge

The aluminum 20 lb holds the same 5 gallons as the steel model but weighs 13 lb empty instead of 17 lb, a difference your back notices at every refill trip. The maker builds it for marine environments and states that the high-grade aluminum shell is fully resistant to rust and saltwater corrosion, where a steel tank degrades over time.

Dimensions are 12 x 12 x 21.25 inches, so the aluminum cylinder stands about 3.5 inches taller than its steel sibling; check the cabinet height of a built-in grill before swapping. It carries the same equipment: an OPD valve, a built-in gas gauge, and a pre-purged arrival ready to fill. The maker states the tank is x-ray and hydrostatic tested and DOT and TC certified. For a grill on a dock, a boat or an RV that moves between sites, the lighter lift and the corrosion-resistant shell are the whole argument, and both come straight from the maker’s specification block.

Pros and cons:

  • Pro: 13 lb empty, the lightest 20 lb class cylinder here
  • Pro: aluminum shell will not rust in salt air
  • Pro: same gauge and OPD valve as the steel model
  • Con: 21.25 inch height may not fit low grill cabinets
  • Con: aluminum dents more easily than steel if dropped
  • Con: a specialty tank; not every filler stocks or swaps them

Buy if: the tank travels, lives near salt water, or gets carried by someone who should not lift the steel version. Skip if: your grill cabinet is height-limited or the tank will sit in one sheltered patio corner for years.

Blue Rhino Propane Tank Exchange

Exchange is the no-ownership route: bring an empty standard grill tank, leave with a filled one. Blue Rhino states in its FAQ that its propane grill tanks contain a net weight of 15 lbs of propane. That figure is the key spec of the whole model, because a refill station fills an owned 20 lb cylinder by weight, typically beyond that net figure.

The operator’s how-to pages describe the routine: drop the empty tank beside the propane display, never carry it inside, pay the cashier, and an employee brings out a fresh tank. Blue Rhino states it accepts any standard gas grill tank in acceptable condition and accepts all brands for exchange. The program also absorbs the paperwork side of tank ownership: when a cylinder’s qualification runs out, exchanging it puts a qualified tank in your hands and the operator handles the old one. For a tank you no longer want at all, the operator’s pages describe writing RECYCLE on it and leaving it at a display for collection and refurbishment or recycling.

Pros and cons:

  • Pro: no recertification errands; swapped tanks arrive qualified
  • Pro: any standard grill tank, any brand, works as the trade-in
  • Pro: fastest route back to grilling when a tank runs dry mid-cookout
  • Con: 15 lb net fill is less propane than a full refill of the same cylinder
  • Con: you give up your own tank, including a new or favorite one
  • Con: the tank you receive varies in age and condition within the program’s standards

Buy if: your tank is old, expired or rusty, or convenience beats everything. Skip if: you just bought a new cylinder with a gauge, because the swap takes it out of your hands.

Flame King 5 lb Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge

A 5 lb cylinder is the refillable middle ground for portable grills: far more fuel than a 1 lb bottle, far less to carry than a 20 lb tank. This Flame King model lists a capacity of 1 gallon, an empty weight of 10 lb and dimensions of 8.1 x 8.1 x 12.8 inches, in the same high-grade welded steel with a powder-coated finish as the larger tanks.

It keeps the two features that make the 20 lb version easy to own: a premium OPD valve and a built-in gas meter gauge, which matters more on a small tank because a 5 lb reserve can run out inside one long cook. The maker states each tank is x-ray and hydrostatic tested and DOT and Transport Canada certified, and it arrives empty and pre-purged. An easy-grip collar serves as the carry handle. The maker’s own guidance on its torch pages notes that high-output appliances drain small tanks quickly, so this size suits portable and tabletop grills rather than a four-burner patio station.

Pros and cons:

  • Pro: built-in gauge on a portable-size tank
  • Pro: 10 lb empty is a one-hand carry for most adults
  • Pro: standard OPD valve fills at any refill station
  • Con: 1 gallon is a short reserve for long, hot cooks
  • Con: most portable grills need an adapter hose to connect it
  • Con: steel shell, so the same cover advice applies outdoors

Buy if: you run a portable grill at home, camp or tailgates and dislike disposable bottles. Skip if: your portable grill only takes 1 lb cylinders and you do not want to add a hose.

Ignik Gas Growler 5.0 Deluxe

The Gas Growler is a 5 lb refillable tank sold as a kit: the cylinder, a 4 ft adapter hose and a carry case with room for the hose and a wrench. The maker lists the capacity as 5 lb, or 1.2 gallons, and states the tank is welded steel with a powder-coated finish. The hose connects the tank to heaters and stoves built for 1 lb bottles.

In its case the Deluxe stands 13.5 inches tall with an 8.8 inch diameter and weighs 11.4 lb; the bare tank version is listed at 12.3 inches, 8.2 inches and 9.3 lb. The maker states the Growler complies with DOT specifications 4BA, 4BW and 4E. Tanks ship pre-purged, and the maker’s FAQ notes a filler typically puts 1.1 to 1.3 gallons into each tank. The case carries Molle webbing for strapping the kit down in a vehicle. There is no gauge, so the level check is the lift test. The maker also states storage rules worth repeating: keep the tank upright, in a ventilated place, never in a living area or a sealed trunk.

Pros and cons:

  • Pro: hose and case included; the kit is complete in one box
  • Pro: feeds grills and stoves made for 1 lb bottles
  • Pro: case protects the valve and keeps the hose with the tank
  • Con: no level gauge; weight is the only gauge
  • Con: 11.4 lb in the case for 5 lb of propane
  • Con: the case is sized to this tank and fits few other 5 lb cylinders, per the maker

Buy if: your camp grill or tailgate setup runs on 1 lb fittings and you want one refillable kit. Skip if: a gauge matters to you, or your grill already has a standard tank connection.

Flame King 1 lb Refillable Propane Cylinder

The smallest grills take a 1 lb cylinder, and disposable bottles cannot be refilled by design. This Flame King cylinder holds 16.4 oz of propane, but the maker states it is certified by the DOT and Transport Canada as refillable and transportable. The valve is a patented design the maker lists as UL1769 listed.

The cylinder is high-grade welded steel, x-ray and hydrostatic tested, with a powder-coated finish. The maker’s FAQ puts the empty weight at about 1.6 lb and the filled weight at 2.3 to 2.5 lb at the standard 80 percent fill. It fits appliances built for a 1 lb tank and refills from a standard 20 lb tank with the maker’s refill adapter or kit, which includes a stand that holds the 20 lb tank. For a tabletop grill owner, the arithmetic is simple: one backyard tank becomes the supply for every portable cook, and the small cylinders stop being a consumable.

Pros and cons:

  • Pro: refillable at home from a 20 lb tank with the maker’s kit
  • Pro: maker states DOT and TC certification for refilling and transport
  • Pro: same 16.4 oz size as the disposable bottles it replaces
  • Con: about an hour-scale fuel supply for a hungry portable grill
  • Con: the refill adapter or kit is a separate purchase
  • Con: only this maker’s cylinders carry the refill rating; disposables stay single-use

Buy if: your tabletop or portable grill eats disposable bottles and you already own a 20 lb tank. Skip if: you grill away from home base often, where a 5 lb tank and hose carry better.

Buying guide

Tank shopping goes wrong on five points: the size class, the fill model, the valve, the dates stamped on the collar, and storage. The checks below use the figures and wording from the makers’ own pages above, so you can compare any cylinder on a shelf against the same yardsticks, including tanks that are not in this guide.

Sizing propane tanks for grills by burners and cook time

Start from the grill, not the tank shelf. A patio grill with two to four burners belongs on a 20 lb cylinder; the tank fits its tray, and the reserve covers weeks of dinners. A portable grill that travels belongs on a 5 lb cylinder with an adapter hose, or on 1 lb cylinders if it packs into a kit. Undersizing a big grill means mid-cook swaps.

Burn time follows burner demand, and the makers’ own pages make the point plainly: one maker warns that high-output appliances drain small tanks fast, and lists its 5 lb and 10 lb cylinders as workable but short-lived on such loads. Treat capacity as a reserve decision. If the grill cooks for crowds or runs a side burner and a rotisserie burner together, stay at 20 lb. If it cooks for two at a campsite, 5 lb is plenty and 1 lb cylinders keep the kit light.

Own and refill, or exchange

An owned cylinder is filled by weight at a refill station, so the fill follows the tank’s rated capacity. An exchanged cylinder arrives filled to the operator’s stated net weight, which Blue Rhino prints as 15 lbs for its grill tanks. The swap buys inspection, qualification handling and speed.

Ownership suits a tank with features worth keeping, like the gauge on the Flame King models, because an exchange takes that tank out of your hands permanently. Exchange suits a plain, aging cylinder. A common pattern is to own one good tank, refill it while it is young, and exchange it when its qualification date approaches, which keeps a current tank in service without a recertification appointment.

Valve types: OPD and the Type 1 connection

Every refillable tank in this guide carries an OPD valve, the overfill prevention design. The Flame King FAQ explains the behavior that matters day to day: on tanks of 40 lb and under, the OPD valve releases propane only when connected to a hose or appliance, and a checking feature can pause flow if the tank is opened too fast at startup.

The connection a grill sees is the Type 1 fitting, which Flame King also labels QCC in its FAQ. It hand-tightens onto the tank valve, which is why modern grills need no wrench at the tank. When a tank will not flow, the maker’s advice is procedural, not mechanical: close everything, reconnect, and open the tank valve slowly, lighting one burner at a time. Knowing that saves a new tank from being blamed for a tripped check valve.

Dates, recertification and the collar stamps

A steel cylinder carries its biography on its collar. Flame King’s FAQ states the manufacture date is stamped on the collar or foot in a month, letter A, year format, and that DOT certified tanks require recertification after 12 years from that date. A filler can refuse an out-of-date tank, and no amount of remaining shine changes the stamp.

That date is the strongest argument for the exchange model late in a tank’s life, and for reading the collar before buying any used cylinder. The same FAQ notes the requirement can change over time and advises checking the current DOT position as the date nears. When you buy a new tank, note its stamp month; a tank that sat in a warehouse for two years starts its service life with two years already gone.

Storage and transport rules that come from the makers

Both makers in this guide print the same storage rules. Flame King: store the tank in a well ventilated covered area such as a patio, shed or garage, and never store tanks indoors. Ignik: store upright and ventilated, never in a living area or an attached storage space, and never in a sealed trunk; a vented vehicle locker is the stated exception.

Transport follows the same logic. Flame King states its tanks must travel upright, because they draw vapor from the top and cannot be mounted upside down. Upright, ventilated, outdoors or in a detached covered space: those three habits, all printed by the makers, are the whole storage system.

FAQ

Questions about grill tanks repeat across every size class: how long a fill lasts, whether a 5 lb tank can run a big grill, what the gauge actually reads, when a tank expires, and whether disposable 1 lb bottles can be refilled. The answers below come from the maker and operator pages behind this guide.

How long do propane tanks for grills last between fills?

It depends on burner demand, which is why makers rate tanks in pounds and gallons rather than hours. A 20 lb cylinder holds 5 gallons by the Flame King specification and feeds a patio grill through a long run of weekend cooks. A 5 lb cylinder holds 1 to 1.2 gallons, and a 1 lb cylinder holds 16.4 oz, so each step down shortens the interval.

Can a 5 lb tank run a full-size patio grill?

It can connect and burn, but the reserve is the problem. Flame King’s own guidance warns that high-output appliances drain small tanks quickly, while confirming its 5 lb and 10 lb cylinders still work on them. For an occasional cook it is a workable backup.

As the main supply for a four-burner grill, a 1 gallon reserve means frequent refill trips, so the 20 lb class stays the right default.

What does the gauge on a propane tank actually read?

On the Flame King tanks, the maker’s FAQ explains the mechanism: a float connected to the valve inside the tank carries a magnet, and the magnet moves the needle of the dial on the outside. The dial reads the liquid level in the tank, not pressure. That makes it a level gauge, most useful near the end of a fill, as the float drops.

When does a propane tank expire, and what happens then?

Flame King’s FAQ states that DOT certified tanks require recertification after 12 years from the date of manufacture stamped on the collar. At that point a refill station can decline to fill the cylinder. The date is stamped in a month, letter A, year format, on the collar or the foot of the tank.

The owner has three routes: pay for recertification by a qualified service, retire the tank through a recycling route, or exchange it, since Blue Rhino states it handles qualification for tanks taken in exchange.

Can disposable 1 lb propane bottles be refilled?

No, they cannot. Flame King states its 1 lb cylinders are the only 1 lb propane tanks certified by the DOT and Transport Canada as refillable and transportable, and that disposable cylinders are not designed or approved for refilling and transport after use.

The refillable cylinder exists precisely because the disposable bottle lacks that rating. If a portable grill runs on 1 lb bottles, the lawful refill route is a certified cylinder like the one above, or a 5 lb tank on a hose.

Conclusion

Buy the tank that matches the grill and the way you refill. A gauged 20 lb steel cylinder serves most patios, aluminum serves boats and backs, exchange serves anyone with an old tank, the 5 lb pair serves portable grills, and the refillable 1 lb cylinder ends the disposable bottle habit for good. Check the collar date before any of them.

A
admin88
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.