Updated Nov 16, 2026· 13 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare griddles for gas grills by material, thickness, fit and grease flow, with six verified picks from Little Griddle, Weber, Steelmade, Lodge and Napoleon.

A gas grill already has the burners, the lid and the fuel supply; what it lacks is a flat surface that keeps eggs, onions and smash burgers out of the grates. This guide compares griddles for gas grills on material, thickness, fit and grease handling, so the plate you buy matches the grill you own and the food you cook.

Quick verdict

The Little Griddle Sizzle-Q SQ180 is the easiest recommendation: 14-gauge stainless steel, a full-width grease well and a universal 17.75 x 13 inch footprint. Weber owners with a 2016 or newer Genesis 300 get more from the full-size Weber Rust-Resistant insert, while the Steelmade Flat Top brings the thickest steel at 3/16 inch.

Product Type Best for Key spec Main limit
Little Griddle Sizzle-Q SQ180 Universal stainless plate Most gas grills 14-gauge stainless, 17.75 x 13 inches Hand wash only
Weber Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert Full-size fitted insert Genesis 300 owners Pre-seasoned carbon steel, full conversion Weber families only
Steelmade Flat Top for Outdoor Grill On-grate steel plate Heat retention 3/16 inch American steel Needs 17 inches of grate depth
Lodge Double Play Reversible Grill/Griddle LDP3 Reversible cast iron pan Grill and griddle in one 16.75 x 9.5 inches, pre-seasoned Narrower than full inserts
Napoleon Reversible Cast Iron Griddle 56041 Fitted reversible plate Napoleon owners Porcelain-enameled cast iron, 13 x 17.75 inches Napoleon series only
onlyfire Stainless Steel BBQ Griddle 25 x 16 Large universal plate Big grills, big batches 25 x 16 inch stainless surface Too wide for compact grills

How we selected

Every pick is a plate, insert or pan designed to sit on or in a gas grill, verified from its maker’s or listing page with the material, dimensions and fit stated in plain terms. Full-size fitted inserts had to name the grill families they match; universal plates had to publish their footprint so a buyer can measure before ordering.

The list splits by approach. Fitted inserts from Weber and Napoleon replace the cooking surface of one brand’s grills. Universal plates from Little Griddle, Steelmade and onlyfire ride on top of the grates of almost any grill. The Lodge pan takes a third path, a reversible cast iron piece that also works on a stove or campfire between grill sessions.

Two filters cut the long list down. First, any plate whose maker could not state a material and a footprint was dropped, because both numbers decide whether the plate cooks evenly and whether it fits at all. Second, discontinued and special-order pieces were excluded, since a griddle guide is only useful if a reader can actually order the plate this season. What survived those filters is a group with no weak material and no mystery dimensions.

The six griddles for gas grills, compared in detail

Each entry states who the griddle suits, the published figures behind the pick, and the limit that should send some buyers to another row of the table. Dimensions are the makers’ stated footprints, and fit claims are the makers’ own, because an insert that misses your grill by half an inch is a return trip, not a griddle.

Little Griddle Sizzle-Q SQ180

The Sizzle-Q is the universal answer: a 17.75 x 13 x 3 inch plate built from 100 percent 14-gauge stainless steel, sized by the maker to fit almost any gas grill on the market. Tall sidewalls keep onions and diced peppers on the cooking surface instead of in the firebox, which is where loose food goes on open grates.

Underneath, a patented vented cross-bracing system stiffens the plate and promotes even heating across the burners. A full-width grease well runs along the front to catch drips before they reach the burners. The plate weighs 9 pounds, has no nonstick coating to protect, and also works over charcoal. The maker lists hand washing only, and the steel can be scraped clean on the grill while it is still warm.

  • Pros: universal fit with a published footprint, so measuring takes a minute
  • Pros: stainless steel shrugs off metal spatulas and weather between cooks
  • Cons: hand wash only, and it is not listed for dishwasher cleaning
  • Cons: one fixed size, so very small grills may not close the lid over it

Buy if: you want one plate that works on the grill you own today and the one you buy next. Skip if: you want a full-surface conversion, because this plate shares the grill with the grates around it.

Weber Rust-Resistant Griddle Insert

Weber’s insert takes the opposite approach to the Sizzle-Q: instead of riding on the grates, it converts the entire grilling surface of a compatible grill into a flat top. The plate is pre-seasoned carbon steel, so it cooks from day one without a seasoning session, and its surface builds the same dark finish as a cast iron pan with use.

Fit is the whole decision here. This full-size version matches Genesis and Genesis II 300 Series gas grills from 2016 and newer, plus Summit gas grills from 2024 and newer. Rimmed edges keep food, oil and seasonings on the surface, and the grease management is designed to work with the grill’s existing collection system rather than a separate cup. A storage bag is sold separately, so plan a dry shelf for the plate.

  • Pros: the largest cooking area of any pick, the full grill surface
  • Pros: pre-seasoned carbon steel with the grill’s own grease path underneath
  • Cons: fits only the named Weber families, nothing else
  • Cons: carbon steel needs drying and a light oil coat after cleaning

Buy if: your Genesis 300 or newer Summit is the grill you cook on most and breakfast crowds are common. Skip if: your grill is any other brand or an older Weber generation, because the insert will not seat correctly.

Steelmade Flat Top for Outdoor Grill

Steelmade builds its case on thickness: 3/16 inch American steel, which the maker notes is 50 percent thicker than most dedicated griddles. That mass absorbs heat from the burners and radiates it back evenly, so a pile of cold hash browns does not collapse the surface temperature the way it does on thin pans.

The plate sits on top of your existing grates, and the maker is blunt about it: do not remove the grates. Three sizes cover most grills, the FT20 at 19-3/4 x 16-13/64 inches, the FT24 at 23-29/32 inches wide and the FT30 at 28-25/32 inches wide, each needing a grate area at least 17 inches deep. Large 1/2 inch front drain slots send grease through to the grill’s own flavorizer bars or trap. The steel seasons with use, and Steelmade backs it with a lifetime warranty.

  • Pros: the thickest steel here, with three sizes matched to grill width
  • Pros: lifts off in seconds when you want open-flame grilling back
  • Cons: needs 17 inches of grate depth, which rules out shallow grill boxes
  • Cons: raw steel must be seasoned and kept oiled, like cast iron

Buy if: even heat across a big batch matters more to you than brand-matched fit. Skip if: your grill’s grate area is under 17 inches deep, because none of the three sizes will sit correctly.

Lodge Double Play Reversible Grill/Griddle LDP3

The Double Play is the small-footprint traditionalist: seasoned cast iron, one smooth griddle side for pancakes and eggs, one ribbed grill side for burgers and steaks. At 16.75 x 9.5 inches it spans two burners on a stove, and on a gas grill it drops onto the grates as a half-surface griddle that leaves room for grates beside it.

Lodge pre-seasons the iron with 100 percent natural vegetable oil, so the surface is ready to cook and improves with use. The pan weighs 9.38 pounds, measures 0.75 inch thick, and is listed for use in the oven, on the stove, on the grill or over a campfire, which makes it the only pick here that travels to a campsite. It is not listed for dishwasher cleaning; cast iron care is a hand wash, a dry and a light coat of oil.

  • Pros: two cooking surfaces in one piece, with grill ridges on the reverse
  • Pros: works on the grill, the stove, the oven and a campfire
  • Cons: 9.5 inches wide is a breakfast for two, not a crowd surface
  • Cons: cast iron weight and care routine are part of ownership

Buy if: you want a griddle that earns its keep indoors all winter and on the grill all summer. Skip if: you need to cook for six at once on a single surface, because the surface is the smallest in this group.

Napoleon Reversible Cast Iron Griddle 56041

Napoleon owners get a fitted version of the Lodge idea: a reversible cast iron griddle with a porcelain coating, sized at 13 x 17.75 inches for the Prestige and PRO 500 series and the LEX 485, 605 and 730 grills. One side is a flat griddle for breakfast; the reverse is ridged for sandwiches the maker describes as panini style.

The porcelain-enameled iron seasons like a plain cast iron pan and, in the maker’s words, gets better every time you use it. Small holes in the surface let grease drain away from the food, which the maker credits for crispier bacon. The maker’s own serving picture is onions caramelizing beside burgers, exactly the mixed load a half-surface plate exists for. Because it is proportioned for specific Napoleon series, the fit check is simply your grill’s model line, and the listing page showed the griddle in stock.

  • Pros: brand-matched fit for the named Napoleon series, no measuring gamble
  • Pros: porcelain coating over cast iron pairs easy cleanup with heat retention
  • Cons: useless on any other brand of grill
  • Cons: one griddle covers part of the grill, not the full surface

Buy if: you own a Prestige, PRO 500 or LEX grill and want the accessory Napoleon sized for it this season. Skip if: your grill is another brand, or you want the whole surface converted at once.

onlyfire Stainless Steel BBQ Griddle 25 x 16

The onlyfire plate is the big universal: 25 x 16 inches of stainless steel, the widest surface in this group, with a grease groove and handles at the sides. It is built for large grills where a standard 17 inch plate leaves half the burners idle, and the listing rates it for gas and charcoal grills alike.

The spec table lists a height of about 2.8 inches and a weight of 6.7 kg, so it is a substantial piece that wants two hands and its handles to move. The grease groove gives drips a channel instead of a path to the burners. The listing page was light on further detail, so buyers should treat this as a simple, large stainless plate rather than a feature-led design.

  • Pros: the largest universal footprint here, for full-size grills
  • Pros: handles and a grease groove on a stainless, coating-free surface
  • Cons: 25 inches wide will not fit compact or two-burner grills
  • Cons: published detail is thin, so measure carefully before ordering

Buy if: your grill is wide and your batches are big, and the mid-size plates look lost on it. Skip if: your grill is compact, because this plate needs a wide grate area to sit flat.

Buying guide

Griddles fail in predictable ways: they do not fit, they warp, they rust in the off season, or they turn grease management into a fire drill. The checks below follow the order a buyer should run them, from the tape measure to the sink, using the figures published for the six models above.

Measure first: fitting griddles for gas grills to your grate area

Fit decides everything, and the makers publish the numbers to check it. Universal plates list a footprint: 17.75 x 13 inches for the Sizzle-Q, 25 x 16 for the onlyfire. On-grate plates like the Steelmade list a minimum grate area, 17 inches of depth in every size. Fitted inserts skip dimensions and name grill families instead.

Measure the grate area with the lid closed in mind: the plate must sit flat and the lid must shut over it, sidewalls included. A plate that fits the grates but props the lid open leaks heat and invites flare-ups around the edges. When a maker names your exact grill series, as Weber and Napoleon do, that match beats any universal claim.

Material decides heat, care and lifespan

Three materials cover this group. Stainless steel, in the Sizzle-Q and the onlyfire, needs no seasoning and tolerates metal tools and weather. Carbon steel, in the Weber insert and the Steelmade, seasons like cast iron and holds heat harder, but it must be dried and oiled. Cast iron, in the Lodge and Napoleon, is the heaviest and the most forgiving of high heat.

Thickness is the quiet spec inside each material. Steelmade publishes 3/16 inch and builds its whole case on it; Little Griddle publishes 14-gauge stainless with cross-bracing to keep the thinner sheet flat. A braced thin plate and a thick plain plate can both cook evenly, but only one of them shrugs off a warp if it is overheated empty.

Grease handling is a design, not an afterthought

Every design here routes fat differently. The Sizzle-Q catches it in a full-width front well. The Steelmade drains it through 1/2 inch slots into the grill’s own trap. The Weber insert works with the grill’s existing collection system. The Napoleon lets it escape through holes in the surface, away from the food.

Match the route to your grill. A plate that drains into the firebox of a grill with a weak grease system invites flare-ups under the food. A well or groove that holds grease on the plate keeps it visible and scrapeable, but it must be emptied before it overflows. Either way, plan the scrape path before the first cook, not during it.

Full conversion, half surface or reversible pan

Decide how much of the grill the griddle should claim. A full conversion like the Weber insert turns the whole grill into a flat top, ideal for a breakfast crowd and useless for simultaneous grilling. A half-surface plate like the Lodge or Napoleon leaves grates free for burgers while eggs cook beside them.

Reversible pans add a second decision: the flip side is a ribbed grill surface, handy for sandwiches and steaks, but the pan must cool or be handled with mitts to flip mid-session. If your griddle work is one big batch of one food, take the full conversion. If it is mixed cooking, take the half surface and keep the grates.

Weight, handles and moving a hot plate

A griddle is at its heaviest when it is hot, greasy and full of food, which is exactly when it needs to move. Published weights in this group run from 9 pounds for the Sizzle-Q and 9.38 pounds for the Lodge to 6.7 kg for the onlyfire, and the full-size Weber insert is a two-hand lift by design even though its maker does not headline a weight.

Handles change the handling picture. The onlyfire builds them in, the Lodge casts loop handles into the pan, and the Steelmade lifts by its edges once it cools. A plate with no handles and no rim, cooking at full temperature, should be treated as a fixture for the whole session: set it before preheating, cook, scrape it clean in place, and lift it only when it is cool enough to carry without rushing.

FAQ

The answers below use the makers’ published figures for these six models and general griddle practice. Where a brand does not publish a number, the answer works with the numbers that do exist rather than estimating one.

Can I leave a griddle plate on my gas grill all season?

You can, but material decides how it ages. Stainless plates like the Sizzle-Q tolerate storage on the grill best. Carbon steel and cast iron plates, the Weber, Steelmade, Lodge and Napoleon, need a dry surface and a light coat of oil before they sit, and the Weber’s storage bag is sold separately for exactly this job.

Do griddles for gas grills need seasoning?

Only the steel and iron ones. The Weber insert arrives pre-seasoned, and the Lodge is pre-seasoned with vegetable oil at the foundry. The Steelmade seasons with use, like cast iron. Stainless plates, the Sizzle-Q and the onlyfire, need no seasoning at all, which is their main convenience advantage over the rest of this group.

Will a universal griddle fit my two-burner grill?

Check the published footprint against your grate area. The Sizzle-Q at 17.75 x 13 inches suits many compact grills, and the Lodge at 16.75 x 9.5 inches suits even more. The Steelmade needs 17 inches of grate depth in every size, and the onlyfire at 25 inches wide is a large-grill plate, so small two-burner boxes should start with the two smaller options.

Can I use metal spatulas on these griddles?

On the uncoated surfaces, yes. Stainless steel, carbon steel and seasoned cast iron all tolerate metal tools, and Little Griddle’s own cleaning guidance uses a stainless steel scraper on the warm plate. The Napoleon is the careful case: its porcelain coating over cast iron rewards nylon or wood tools that will not chip the enamel over time.

How do I clean a griddle plate after a greasy cook?

Start hot and simple: scrape residue toward the grease well, groove or drain while the plate is warm, as Little Griddle directs, then wipe and dry. None of the six makers here list their plate for dishwasher cleaning; the Sizzle-Q and the Lodge state hand washing plainly. Steel and iron plates finish with a thin film of oil once they are dry and cool.

Conclusion

Start with the Sizzle-Q SQ180 if your grill is unlisted or mixed-brand: it fits almost anything and asks very little. Take the Weber insert for a full-surface conversion on a matching Genesis or Summit, the Steelmade for the thickest steel, and the Lodge when the same pan must also work over a campfire.

A
admin88
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.