Key takeaways
- Six bottled waters matched to BUNN's own brewing guidance: Saratoga and Essentia in the ideal mineral band, FIJI and Mountain Valley above it, VOSS just below.
BUNN prints its own water bands in its Coffee Basics brochure: dissolved minerals ideally at 50 to 100 ppm, acceptable below 300 ppm, and never artificially softened. The six bottled water for bunn coffee makers picks below are matched against those bands with figures from each maker’s own published analysis.
Quick verdict
Two of the six land inside BUNN’s ideal mineral band on their makers’ own figures: Saratoga Spring Water at 53 to 94 mg/L of total dissolved solids and Essentia at 61.33 mg/L. FIJI and Mountain Valley sit higher, VOSS sits just under the band, and Smartwater’s maker publishes no TDS figure at all.
| Water | Type | TDS (mg/L) | pH | Against BUNN bands | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Saratoga Spring Water | Spring | 53 to 94 | 5.8 to 6.0 | Inside the ideal band | Figures given as ranges across four springs |
| Essentia Water | Purified, minerals added | 61.33 | 9.92 in the 2025 report | Inside the ideal band | Highest pH here by a wide margin |
| VOSS Still | Artesian | 44 | 5.9 | Just below the ideal band | Very little mineral content for extraction |
| FIJI Natural Artesian Water | Artesian | 222 | 7.7 | Above ideal, inside acceptable | Silica-heavy profile at 93 mg/L |
| Mountain Valley Spring Water | Spring | 210 | 7.3 to 8.1 | Above ideal, inside acceptable | Highest hardness here at 190 to 200 mg/L |
| Smartwater | Vapor distilled purified | Not stated by the maker | Not stated by the maker | Cannot be placed from published figures | No TDS number or pH in the maker’s analysis |
What BUNN says about brewing water
BUNN’s Coffee Basics brochure puts water first among the elements of proper brewing, ahead of time, temperature, filtration and turbulence. It states that fresh, good-tasting water is essential because water makes up more than 98 percent of a cup of coffee, and it prints numbers for the mineral content it wants.
The mineral band BUNN publishes
The brochure states that mineral content can affect taste, that water should never be artificially softened, and that dissolved minerals should not exceed an ideal of 50 to 100 ppm, given as 50 to 100 mg/L, or 3 to 6 grains of hardness. Its acceptable ceiling is below 300 ppm, or 18 grains of hardness.
Those two bands are the yardstick for this whole comparison, and they are BUNN’s own, printed for its brewing equipment. The brochure also notes that BUNN offers a complete line of commercial water-filtration systems for use with BUNN commercial brewing equipment, which tells you the maker expects many supplies to need adjustment before they reach a brewer. A bottled water is simply a supply whose adjustment has already been done by geology or by a bottling plant, and whose numbers can be read before a single cup is brewed.
One thing the brochure does not publish is a pH figure. Its water guidance is written in terms of dissolved minerals and hardness, so the pH figures in this article are reported for each water as printed by its maker, without a BUNN band to rank them against.
Temperature, contact time and holding
The same brochure sets an ideal water temperature of 195 to 205 degrees F during brewing, states that contact or brew time should never exceed 8 minutes, and puts the ideal depth of the coffee bed in the brew basket at 1 to 2 inches regardless of the volume being brewed.
For the finished cup, the brochure sets a strength of 1.15 percent to 1.35 percent coffee flavoring material and an extraction of 18 percent to 22 percent of the solubles, the balance it calls the Golden Cup standard from the Specialty Coffee Association chart it reproduces. Water sits underneath all of those numbers: the dissolved material the water already carries is part of what ends up measured in the cup.
Holding guidance matters to anyone filling a BUNN carafe for a room of drinkers. The brochure gives an ideal holding temperature of 175 to 185 degrees F, an ideal serving temperature of 155 to 175 degrees F, and an ideal holding time of 20 minutes in an open top decanter or 60 minutes in a closed container. Its cleanliness section also tells users to keep the sprayhead, funnel, servers and water reservoir free from lime and hard water deposits, which is where a water’s hardness figure stops being abstract.
Water for bunn coffee makers: the six bottles compared
The six waters below are ordered by where their published total dissolved solids land against BUNN’s bands, not by taste. Two are spring waters, two are artesian, one is a purified water with minerals added back, and one is vapor distilled. Every figure comes from the maker’s own analysis or label copy.
Saratoga Spring Water
Saratoga’s own 2025 water analysis report gives its spring water a total dissolved solids range of 53 to 94 mg/L, which sits entirely inside BUNN’s ideal band of 50 to 100 ppm. The same report lists pH at 5.8 to 6.0, calcium at 8 to 17 mg/L, magnesium at 1.3 to 5.8 mg/L and total hardness at 25 to 67 mg/L as CaCO3.
The figures are ranges rather than single numbers because the brand bottles from four named springs: White Cedar Spring in Maine, Greenwaltz Spring in Bangor, Pennsylvania, Nature’s Way Springs in Foster Township, Pennsylvania, and Sweet Water Spring in Saratoga Springs, New York. Sodium runs 2.2 to 10 mg/L, potassium 0.37 to 0.71 mg/L and chloride 10 to 18 mg/L across those sources. The report’s factory process is a storage silo, microfiltration, ultraviolet and/or ozone disinfection, then bottling, with no step that strips minerals out.
For a BUNN brewer, this is the closest published match to the maker’s own band: the whole TDS range falls inside the ideal band, and the hardness range is low next to the other spring water in this list. The trade-off is the pH, the smallest reading here alongside VOSS, and the fact that the exact bottle in hand comes from one of four springs, so its figure sits somewhere inside the printed range rather than at a single point.
- Pros: entire TDS range inside BUNN’s ideal band, low hardness, four named springs in the report
- Cons: pH of 5.8 to 6.0 is the joint smallest here, figures are ranges rather than one fixed analysis
Essentia Water
Essentia’s own 2025 water analysis report lists total dissolved solids at 61.33 mg/L, inside BUNN’s ideal band, with total hardness of only 5.88 mg/L as CaCO3. The same report measured pH at 9.92, while the brand rates the water at 9.5 or higher, making it the highest-pH bottle in this comparison by a wide margin.
The rest of the report reads like a purified water with a small mineral addition: magnesium 1.42 mg/L, potassium 7.30 mg/L, sodium 15.0 mg/L, bicarb alkalinity 33.55 mg/L as HCO3, sulfate 3.17 mg/L, and calcium and chloride both reported as not detected. That profile is the opposite route to the same band as Saratoga: instead of spring water that happens to land at 53 to 94 mg/L, this is water built to a figure.
BUNN’s brochure ranks water by dissolved minerals and hardness and prints no pH figure, so the 9.92 reading neither helps nor hurts this water against the maker’s stated bands. What counts for the brewer is the 61.33 mg/L of dissolved solids and the very low hardness, and on those two published numbers Essentia matches the ideal band with the least mineral weight of any water that lands inside it.
- Pros: TDS of 61.33 mg/L inside the ideal band, very low hardness at 5.88 mg/L, full analysis published
- Cons: pH of 9.92 is far from every other water here, calcium reported as not detected
VOSS Still
The VOSS quality report lists its still artesian water at 44 mg/L of total dissolved solids, just below the bottom of BUNN’s ideal band, with a pH of 5.9. Calcium is 3 mg/L, magnesium under 1 mg/L, sodium 4 mg/L and bicarbonate under 20 mg/L, the lightest mineral profile in this comparison.
The brand states that the water is bottled at an artesian source in Southern Norway and describes it as unprocessed, naturally filtered and protected from pollutants beneath the ground. Chloride is 5 mg/L, sulfate under 5 mg/L, potassium under 1 mg/L and fluoride 0.1 mg/L in the same report. Only the still water is counted here; the brand’s sparkling version carries a separate analysis with a much higher TDS of 300 mg/L.
Against BUNN’s bands, VOSS is the near miss: 6 mg/L short of the ideal window on the low side. A brewer fed with it is working with very little dissolved material, which puts the burden of extraction almost entirely on the coffee itself. Drinkers who find mineral-heavy water masks a delicate coffee may prefer exactly that, but it is a preference, not a match to the printed band.
- Pros: smallest TDS figure here at 44 mg/L, bottled at the source, full mineral table published by the brand
- Cons: sits below BUNN’s ideal band rather than inside it, magnesium and potassium both under 1 mg/L
FIJI Natural Artesian Water
FIJI’s label analysis, printed on its grocery listing, gives total dissolved solids of 222 mg/L and a pH of 7.7. That TDS figure is above BUNN’s ideal band and comfortably inside the maker’s acceptable ceiling of below 300 ppm, and the profile is defined by silica at 93 mg/L, the highest single mineral figure in this list.
The same analysis lists calcium at 18 mg/L, magnesium at 15 mg/L and bicarbonates at 152 mg/L. The brand states that tropical rain filters through ancient volcanic rock and collects in a natural artesian aquifer at Yaqara in the Fiji Islands, gathering naturally occurring electrolytes on the way, and that the water is bottled at the source. The listing carrying the analysis showed the water in stock.
For a BUNN brewer, FIJI is the acceptable-band option with the most mineral character: more dissolved material than the ideal window asks for, well under the ceiling BUNN prints. The silica-led profile is also the one most likely to be tasted in the cup, for better or worse, since 222 mg/L is more than four times the load of the lightest spring water here.
- Pros: inside BUNN’s acceptable band, pH of 7.7 near neutral, analysis printed on the label copy
- Cons: TDS of 222 mg/L is above the ideal band, silica at 93 mg/L gives a pronounced profile
Mountain Valley Spring Water
Mountain Valley’s official 2025 water analysis report lists its spring water at 210 mg/L of total dissolved solids, above BUNN’s ideal band and inside the acceptable ceiling, with pH ranging from 7.3 to 8.1. Calcium is the headline figure at 65 to 70 mg/L, the highest calcium reading in this comparison.
The report gives magnesium at 6.1 to 7.2 mg/L, sodium at 1.7 to 2.5 mg/L, alkalinity at 190 as CaCO3 and total hardness at 190 to 200 mg/L as CaCO3, by far the highest hardness here. The source is stated as Mountain Valley Springs in Garland County, Arkansas, and the factory process is microfiltration with ultraviolet and/or ozone disinfection, with no mineral removal step listed.
That hardness figure is the one to weigh against BUNN’s own cleanliness guidance, which tells users to keep the sprayhead, funnel, servers and reservoir free from lime and hard water deposits. A water at 190 to 200 mg/L of hardness will leave more of those deposits than one at 25 to 67 mg/L. The TDS passes BUNN’s acceptable test; the hardness asks for more frequent attention to the machine.
- Pros: inside the acceptable band, highest calcium here at 65 to 70 mg/L, full official report published
- Cons: hardness of 190 to 200 mg/L is the highest here, TDS well above the ideal band
Smartwater
Smartwater is vapor distilled purified water, and its maker’s 2025 annual analysis reports total dissolved solids only as a pass against the 500 mg/L standard of quality. The Coca-Cola Company analysis states no TDS number and no pH value for the water, so it cannot be placed inside or outside BUNN’s bands from published figures.
What the analysis does state is the process. Most bottling facilities draw water from municipal systems and a few from protected groundwater sources. The water passes through granular activated carbon filtration, then reverse osmosis, then interim ultraviolet light disinfection, and is then re-mineralized with small amounts of magnesium sulfate and potassium chloride to assure consistent taste before a final ozonation step.
That makes Smartwater the control case in this list: a water built to be nearly mineral-free, then given back a small, fixed mineral addition. Anyone choosing it for a BUNN brewer is choosing the purified profile on purpose, and should know that the maker does not publish the one figure, a TDS number, that BUNN’s guidance is written around.
- Pros: fully documented purification process, re-mineralized for consistent taste, annual independent analysis
- Cons: maker publishes no TDS figure or pH, so it cannot be checked against BUNN’s bands
How the six compare as water for bunn coffee makers
Read against BUNN’s two printed bands, the six waters split into three pairs: two inside the ideal 50 to 100 ppm window, two above it but under the 300 ppm acceptable ceiling, and two that fall outside the ranking altogether, one just below the window and one with no published figure to rank.
Inside the ideal band
Saratoga and Essentia are the two waters whose published TDS lands inside BUNN’s ideal band, and they get there by opposite routes. Saratoga is spring water bottled from four named springs with a range of 53 to 94 mg/L, while Essentia is a purified water with minerals added back, measured at 61.33 mg/L in its maker’s 2025 report.
Their secondary figures differ more than their TDS. Saratoga’s hardness runs 25 to 67 mg/L as CaCO3 with a pH of 5.8 to 6.0, while Essentia’s hardness is 5.88 mg/L with a measured pH of 9.92. BUNN’s brochure gives no pH figure, so the choice between them turns on the figures BUNN does print, and on both of those, dissolved solids and hardness, each water sits where the maker asks.
Above ideal, inside acceptable
FIJI at 222 mg/L and Mountain Valley at 210 mg/L both clear BUNN’s acceptable ceiling of below 300 ppm with room to spare, and both carry the mineral weight to show for it. FIJI’s analysis is led by silica at 93 mg/L and bicarbonates at 152 mg/L, while Mountain Valley’s is led by calcium at 65 to 70 mg/L.
The practical difference between the pair is hardness. Mountain Valley reports total hardness of 190 to 200 mg/L as CaCO3, the highest in this list, while FIJI’s label analysis prints no hardness figure at all. Set against BUNN’s cleanliness guidance about lime and hard water deposits in the sprayhead and reservoir, Mountain Valley is the water that asks the most of the machine’s cleaning routine.
Below the band, and the bottle with no figure
VOSS Still, at 44 mg/L, misses the bottom of BUNN’s ideal band by 6 mg/L, and Smartwater cannot be scored at all because its maker reports TDS only as a pass against the 500 mg/L standard. Neither fact makes either water a poor drink; it makes them the two picks that stand apart from the maker’s printed bands.
The honest way to hold both is this: VOSS is a known quantity that lands just under the window, with every mineral figure published, while Smartwater is an unknown quantity by design, a purified water whose small mineral addition is described in words rather than numbers. A buyer following BUNN’s guidance literally can verify VOSS against it and cannot verify Smartwater.
Buying guide: choosing water for bunn coffee makers
Start with the number BUNN prints, not with the story on the bottle. A water’s total dissolved solids, read from the maker’s own analysis, tells you which of BUNN’s bands it lands in before you buy a case of it, and the hardness figure tells you what it will ask of the brewer over months of use.
Start from the water you already have
Bottled water earns its place when the supply on hand cannot be brought into BUNN’s bands, or when its mineral content swings enough that the cup keeps changing. BUNN itself sells commercial water-filtration systems for its commercial brewers, which is the maker’s own answer for a plumbed supply that needs adjusting.
For a home or small office brewer filled by hand, a bottled water with a published analysis is the simpler control: the figure is printed, the figure is stable, and the figure can be checked against the 50 to 100 ppm ideal and the below 300 ppm ceiling in seconds. That is the whole case for the six waters above, and it is also their limit, since a bottle habit costs more effort per brew than a filter on a line.
Match the bottle to how the brewer is used
A brewer that runs all day and holds coffee for a room should be fed with deposits in mind: BUNN’s holding guidance of 20 minutes in an open decanter and 60 minutes in a closed container, at 175 to 185 degrees F, assumes a machine kept free of lime and hard water deposits, and low-hardness water makes that routine easier to keep.
A brewer used for one careful pot at a time can afford to choose on TDS alone, which points to the two in-band waters, Saratoga and Essentia. A drinker who prefers a pronounced mineral character and accepts the cleaning that comes with it has FIJI and Mountain Valley inside the acceptable band. The choice is mechanical once the figures are on the table: band first, hardness second, taste preference last.
One last check before the first pot: BUNN ties its water bands to the rest of the brew, holding an ideal water temperature of 195 to 205 degrees F and a finished strength of 1.15 percent to 1.35 percent, so a water inside the mineral band still has to meet a brewer set to those figures.
BUNN’s own bands do the ranking here: Saratoga and Essentia land inside the maker’s ideal 50 to 100 ppm window, FIJI and Mountain Valley sit in the acceptable zone below 300 ppm, VOSS falls just under the window, and Smartwater publishes no figure to rank. Choose by the number on the maker’s analysis.