Key takeaways
- Six mixers for live music compared: touchscreen and stage-box digitals with wireless control, an analog board with vocal tuning, and monitor feeds for bands.
Live music asks more of a mixer than any other job in this batch: enough inputs for the whole band, a monitor mix for every player, processing that survives a ringing room, and settings that come back next weekend. The mixers for live music below are six boards that answer those demands in different ways.
What live music demands from a mixer
A band mixer lives a harder life than a studio desk. It gets carried in a van, set up in a room it has never seen, and asked to make five or six musicians hear themselves while a room full of people hears a balanced show. Input count, monitor outputs and feedback control decide whether that goes well, long before tone enters the discussion.
Start with inputs and monitors. A five-piece band with drums easily uses twelve channels, and every player who sings or plays quietly needs a monitor feed of their own, so aux outputs matter as much as inputs. Digital boards add recall: the mix built at soundcheck returns exactly, venue after venue, and per-channel EQ, compression and gates travel with it. Feedback control is the third demand, because live rooms ring; graphic EQ, parametric EQ and automatic feedback suppression are the tools that keep a vocal microphone open in a small club.
Recording has joined the list. Bands sell and promote themselves with live recordings, and a mixer that captures the show, even as a stereo file, saves carrying a separate recorder. The six boards below divide into a touchscreen desk, three stage boxes that live at the side of the stage and are mixed from a tablet, one rack-style digital with personal monitoring, and one analog board with physical faders for players who mix themselves.
Setup time ties all of this together. On a multi-band bill the changeover may allow twenty minutes to line-check and go, and the board that recalls last night’s show, labels its channels clearly and sets its own gains where offered turns that scramble into a routine. The boards below automate very different amounts of that work, which is why the detail sections pay as much attention to setup and control as to sound.
The six boards at a glance
The table below lines up the six boards by the numbers that shape a gig: how many mic preamps they carry, how many monitor mixes they can feed, how they are controlled, and whether they can record the show. The sections after the table explain what those numbers mean for different kinds of bands.
| Mixer | Mic preamps | Monitor / aux outputs | Control | Recording |
| Allen & Heath CQ-12T | 10 | 6 aux outputs | 7-inch touchscreen, apps | 16-channel USB and SD multitrack |
| Soundcraft Ui16 | 12 | 4 aux outputs | Browser on any device, built-in Wi-Fi | 2-channel USB |
| Mackie DL16S | 16 | 8 assignable XLR outputs | Master Fader app, built-in Wi-Fi | 16×16 USB |
| Behringer X Air XR16 | 8 | 6 aux buses, XLR and TRS outs | Tablet and computer apps, built-in Wi-Fi | Stereo USB |
| Peavey PV 14 AT | 8 | Analog aux send layout | Physical faders and knobs | USB-B stereo to a computer |
| Midas MR18 | 16 | 6 XLR aux outputs | Tablet and computer apps, built-in Wi-Fi | 18×18 USB |
Two patterns stand out. The stage boxes put every input at the stage and move the engineer into the room with a tablet, which is where the mix actually happens. The analog board does the opposite: everything stays under the player’s hands. Neither approach is better in the abstract; they suit different bands, and the detail sections take them one at a time.
The mixers in detail
Each board below is described by what it does on a real night: how the band plugs in, who controls the mix and from where, how monitors are handled, and what gets recorded. They run from the smallest touchscreen desk to the largest stage box, with the analog board placed where its hands-on layout makes the strongest contrast.
Allen & Heath CQ-12T: the touchscreen desk for small bands
The CQ-12T is an ultra-compact digital mixer with a 7-inch capacitive touchscreen and physical controls on the desk itself, so it can be mixed from the board or from the maker’s apps. Ten mic/line inputs plus a stereo line input give thirteen inputs to the mix, and six aux outputs feed monitors.
Processing runs at 96 kHz with latency under 0.7 milliseconds and a dynamic range of 110 dB. Every input channel carries a high-pass filter, gate, four-band parametric EQ and a compressor, and the preamps are fully recallable with gain from 0 to plus 60 dB. Two features aim squarely at bands who mix themselves: an automatic gain setup that detects input levels and sets preamp gain across channels, then watches for clipping during the show, and a feedback assistant that finds problem frequencies and applies notch filters. Source-optimized channel presets speed up soundcheck for less experienced operators.
Two multi-effects engines cover reverbs and delays, outputs carry graphic or parametric EQ with delay, and recording is unusually complete for the size: sixteen channels over USB or to an SD card, plus stereo recording to a USB drive and Bluetooth playback for break music. At 291 by 242 by 89 millimeters and 2.4 kilograms, with an optional rack kit, it suits a gigging band that wants a real control surface in a carry-on footprint. Wireless control runs through a router on its network socket rather than a built-in radio.
Soundcraft Ui16: the stage box any browser can drive
The Ui16 is a stage-box digital mixer with no control surface at all: it sits by the drums, and the band mixes from any phone, tablet or computer browser over its integrated Wi-Fi, with up to ten control devices connected at once, and nobody is tied to a desk at the side of the room.
Twelve mic preamps, eight on combo sockets and four on XLR, plus two instrument inputs and a stereo RCA line input cover a full band with a playback source. Mic gain and phantom power are fully recallable and remote-controlled, and every input channel carries four-band parametric EQ, a high-pass filter, compressor, de-esser and noise gate. Outputs get a 31-band graphic EQ, noise gate and compressor, with a real-time frequency analyzer on inputs and outputs. Three dedicated Lexicon effects buses provide reverb, delay and chorus, and the Harman processing family contributes dbx AFS2 automatic feedback suppression and DigiTech amp modeling for a guitarist who plugs in direct.
Four balanced XLR aux outputs feed monitor mixes, two headphone outputs serve the stage, and shows and snapshots recall with channel safes and a security lockout that can limit a device to one mix, which is how each player gets their own monitor control without touching the main mix. A two-channel USB media player handles break music and two-channel USB recording captures the stereo mix. The box is rackmountable at 19 inches wide and 7.9 pounds.
Mackie DL16S: sixteen preamps mixed from the room
The DL16S is a stage-box mixer with sixteen Onyx+ recallable mic preamps and eight fully assignable XLR outputs, controlled by the Master Fader app over built-in Wi-Fi from iOS, Android, Mac or PC, with up to twenty devices at once. The mixer itself lives on stage with the cables, within reach of the drum kit.
That device count matters for bands: the engineer mixes the room while each musician adjusts a personal monitor mix from a phone. Every input channel carries four-band parametric EQ, a high-pass filter, gate, compression and a real-time analyzer with spectrograph. Thirteen output buses offer four-band EQ, high and low-pass filters, a 31-band graphic EQ, compressor/limiter and alignment delay, and the routing includes six stereo-linkable aux sends, six subgroups, six VCAs and six mute groups. Four stereo effects processors supply reverbs, delays, choruses and flangers with dedicated sends and returns, and full I/O routing with A/B sources per channel lets one channel serve two purposes across a set.
Recording is a full sixteen-by-sixteen USB interface: the show can be captured multitrack for a later mixdown, and those same recordings play back into each channel for a virtual soundcheck in an empty room, which is the fastest way to improve a mix between gigs. Full recall of every setting, offline app operation and access limiting round out a board aimed at working bands who play the same show in different rooms.
Behringer X Air XR16: the X32 effects rack in a stage box
The XR16 is a sixteen-input stage-box mixer built around eight Midas-designed, fully programmable mic preamps on combo sockets and eight balanced line inputs, a layout that suits bands where keyboards and playback rigs arrive at line level. Eight mic inputs is the trade for that line-level capacity.
Its built-in tri-mode Wi-Fi router works as an access point, joins an existing network as a client, or connects by Ethernet, so no external router is needed. The processing is 40-bit floating point with 24-bit conversion at 44.1 or 48 kHz and a 114 dB dynamic range, and analog input-to-output latency is 0.8 milliseconds. The effects come from the X32 rack: four stereo slots with simulations of studio hardware including the Lexicon 480L and PCM70 reverbs, the EMT250 and the Quantec QRS. Six aux buses and the main LR carry inserts, full dynamics and a choice of six-band parametric or 31-band graphic EQ, watched over by a 100-band real-time analyzer on channel and bus EQs.
Dugan-style auto-mixing manages gain sharing between open microphones, useful when several singers share backing vocals. Outputs are four XLR and two TRS aux connectors plus XLR mains and a phones output, a front USB socket records uncompressed stereo WAV of the show and plays back break music, and free apps cover iPad, Android and PC, Mac and Linux. Rack ears and protection bumpers are included; the box measures 333 by 149 by 140 millimeters and weighs 3 kilograms.
Peavey PV 14 AT: the analog board with tuned vocals
The PV 14 AT is the analog entry in this group: a mixer with faders and knobs, eight low-noise mic preamps on combo inputs, stereo quarter-inch and RCA inputs, and no tablet in the chain. For a band that mixes from the stage, that directness is the feature.
Every control is visible at a glance and nothing needs a network. Its signature is built-in Antares Auto-Tune pitch correction, which tidies vocal tuning in real time during the performance rather than in a studio afterwards. Four channels of built-in compression smooth out singers who move around the microphone, three-band EQ with bypass switches shapes each channel, and a selectable high-impedance preamp takes an electric guitar direct. Kosmos-C bass and treble enhancement adds weight to the main mix, and an LCD display handles the effects and media sections.
Bluetooth streams break music from a phone, a USB-A socket plays MP3 files, and USB-B connects to a computer for stereo recording. Phantom power covers condenser microphones. This is the board for a covers or function band that wants its vocals polished, its tracks a button-press away, and its mix where its hands are, and it doubles as a rehearsal-room and small-venue desk the rest of the week.
Midas MR18: sixteen Midas PRO preamps and personal monitoring
The MR18 is an eighteen-input stage-box mixer whose sixteen Midas PRO mic preamps, on locking Neutrik combo connectors, come from the same design family as the maker’s M32 consoles, with two line inputs bringing the total to eighteen inputs. It carries the largest channel count in this group of six boards.
A built-in tri-mode Wi-Fi router gives direct tablet control with no external router, and free apps cover iOS, Android and PC, Mac and Linux. Four effects engines run simulations drawn from the M32 library, channels carry low-cut filters, de-essers, noise gates and parametric EQ, and buses offer six-band parametric or 31-band graphic EQ under a 100-band real-time analyzer. Dugan-style auto-mixing manages multiple open microphones, and the 40-bit processing runs at a 48 kHz sample rate. Six XLR aux outputs and XLR mains, plus a headphone output with its own volume control, cover the physical feeds.
What separates the MR18 is monitoring and recording depth. An ULTRANET port connects the P-16 personal monitoring system, sending sixteen channels down one Cat5 cable so each player can mix their own ears from a personal mixer. The USB interface is a full eighteen-by-eighteen bidirectional connection, enough to multitrack the whole band. At 333 by 149 by 140 millimeters and 3.9 kilograms, with rackmounts and bumpers included, it is the choice for a band that has outgrown wedge mixes and wants studio-style control of a live show.
How to choose mixers for live music for your band
The right choice starts with two counts: how many inputs your largest lineup actually uses, drum microphones included, and how many separate monitor mixes the players need. Those two numbers eliminate most boards at once. What remains is a question of control style and recording, and the sections below take them in that order.
Count inputs and monitor mixes first
Write down the fullest version of the band: every drum microphone, both guitar sources, keyboards in stereo, every vocal. A five-piece rock band typically lands between twelve and sixteen inputs, which is why the DL16S and MR18 carry sixteen preamps.
An acoustic trio fits the CQ-12T or Ui16 with room to spare. Count monitors the same way: each singer and each quiet instrument wants a feed, and aux outputs, six on the CQ-12T, XR16 and MR18, four on the Ui16, set the ceiling. Personal monitoring changes the arithmetic. With the MR18 and its P-16 system, players mix their own ears from a shared feed, so the aux ceiling matters less. With the app-controlled boards, musicians adjust their own monitor mixes from phones, which does not add outputs but removes the engineer as a bottleneck. If neither appeals and the band mixes from the stage, the PV 14 AT keeps the whole show on physical controls within arm’s reach.
Faders, touchscreen or tablet: pick the control style
Control style decides who can rescue a mix mid-song. A touchscreen desk like the CQ-12T keeps control on the hardware and still offers apps when wanted, while a stage box puts the mixer at the stage and the engineer in the audience, where balance problems are audible.
The price of the stage-box approach is dependence on a tablet, a charged battery and a wireless link. Browser control, the Ui16’s approach, removes app compatibility from the equation entirely, since any device with a browser works. App ecosystems, like Mackie’s Master Fader or the X AIR and M AIR apps, go deeper, with offline preparation and show files that travel between venues. Analog control on the PV 14 AT removes the question: the mix is whatever the faders say it is, every time, with no recall and no software between the band and the sound.
Running mixers for live music on the night
A good live mix is mostly decided before the first song: in how the soundcheck is run, how monitors are set, and how the board is prepared for the room. The boards above automate different parts of that work, and knowing which parts yours handles tells you where to spend your own attention on the night.
Soundcheck habits that hold up
Set gains first, monitors second, front of house third. The CQ-12T’s automatic gain setup and the auto-mixing on the XR16 and MR18 shorten the first step, but the order stays the same, and it is the order that makes the rest of the check predictable.
Ring out the monitors with the graphic EQ on the outputs; the 31-band sections on the Ui16, DL16S, XR16 and MR18 exist for exactly this. Let automatic feedback suppression, dbx AFS2 on the Ui16 or the CQ-12T’s feedback assistant, catch what the room does when it fills with people and warms up. Save the show. Every digital board here recalls, and the band that saves each venue’s mix starts the next visit from a working setup instead of a blank one. Label channels for the actual lineup, set the vocal effects once, and resist re-engineering the show between songs; live mixing rewards small corrections on a stable base far more than constant rebuilding.
Recording the show without extra gear
Every board here can capture the night, at different depths. The PV 14 AT and Ui16 record the stereo mix, the XR16 records stereo WAV to a USB stick with no computer at the gig, and the CQ-12T, DL16S and MR18 record multitrack for a later mixdown, with every channel kept separate.
A stereo recording is enough for reviewing the performance and posting a live track. Multitrack goes further: it turns the gig into raw material for a properly mixed live release. Multitrack playback doubles as a virtual soundcheck, since yesterday’s recording plays through today’s empty room and the mix improves without the band present. That workflow, built into the DL16S and available through the USB interfaces of the CQ-12T and MR18, is the strongest argument for a recording-capable board in a band that plays the same rooms repeatedly.
Questions bands ask before buying
Three questions decide most band mixer purchases, and all three are really about the future size of the band rather than its present one. Answering them honestly, with the fullest lineup in mind, prevents the common outcome of buying a board that the band outgrows within a year.
How many aux sends do we actually need?
One per distinct monitor mix, not one per player. Players who stand together and play similar parts can share a mix; singers and the drummer usually cannot, so a four-piece band often needs three or four mixes and a six-piece with backing singers needs five or six.
The Ui16’s four aux outputs fit the first case, the six-aux boards fit the second, and personal monitoring systems remove the ceiling by giving each player a mixer of their own. Count again whenever the lineup changes: an added backing singer or a keyboard player who sings is a new mix, and boards are most often outgrown at the aux outputs rather than the inputs.
Can one mixer handle monitors and front of house together?
Yes; that is the normal arrangement at this level, and every board here is built for it. The main LR feeds the audience speakers while the aux buses feed monitors, each with its own EQ, and the discipline is in the setup, not the hardware. The setup order matters more than the feature list here.
Monitors are rung out first and left alone, and the main mix is built on top. Boards with per-output graphic EQ and feedback tools, which is most of this group, exist precisely because one mixer doing both jobs has to tame two different rooms: the stage and the house. When a band grows to a dedicated monitor engineer, the same boards hand monitor control to phones or personal mixers without replacing the main unit.
Should a first band mixer be analog or digital?
Analog, like the PV 14 AT, teaches the signal path with nothing hidden and never needs an update, and its built-in vocal tuning and compression cover a working band’s needs. Digital buys recall, per-channel processing on every input, feedback tools and recording.
That is why five of the six boards here are digital. The honest dividing line is the operator: a band with a dedicated engineer, or a player willing to learn an app, gets more from digital; a band that mixes itself between songs often gets a better night from faders it can grab. Neither answer is permanent, and many bands start analog for the rehearsal room and move the same show to a digital board as the gigs grow.
Conclusion
The best live mixer is the one whose input count, monitor feeds and control style match the band you actually field. These six boards cover that ground from a self-mixed analog desk to eighteen-input stage boxes with personal monitoring, so the decision rests on your lineup, your rooms and who holds the mix.