Key takeaways
- Compare six audio mixers for recording music on multitrack capture, preamps, sample rates, effects and size, from analog consoles to digital recorders at home.
Recording music asks more of a mixer than mixing a show: the performance has to survive as separate tracks that can be balanced, edited and mixed again later. This guide compares six audio mixers for recording music on the capture paths, preamps and sample rates their makers publish. Track counts and monitor options are covered for every model.
Quick verdict
Start with how the tracks are captured. Two consoles here record multitrack to SD cards with no computer attached. Three send multitrack over USB to a DAW. One, the Allen & Heath ZED-24, is a classic analog desk that records only a stereo feed and earns its place on preamps and routing.
The Tascam Model 24 records 24 tracks to a card and doubles as a 24-in/22-out interface. The Zoom LiveTrak L-20 records 22 tracks at up to 96 kHz and gives six monitor mixes. The Soundcraft Signature 22 MTK sends 24 channels to a DAW and returns 22. The Mackie Onyx16 records 18 tracks over USB at 96 kHz. The Yamaha TF1 is the digital option with 34×34 USB and full scene recall.
| Product | Type | Best for | Key spec | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tascam Model 24 | Analog + SD recorder | Full-band tracking, no computer | 24-track SD, 16 mic preamps | 48 kHz recording ceiling |
| Zoom LiveTrak L-20 | Digital + SD recorder | Bands that record live takes | 22 tracks at 96 kHz, 6 monitor mixes | USB interface runs at 48 kHz |
| Mackie Onyx16 | Analog + multitrack USB | Project studios and overdubs | 18×4 USB at 96 kHz, 12 Onyx preamps | SD recording is stereo only |
| Soundcraft Signature 22 MTK | Analog + multitrack USB | DAW tracking with plug-ins | 24-in/22-out USB, Ghost preamps | No onboard recorder |
| Allen & Heath ZED-24 | Analog, 24 channels | Analog tracking to an interface | 16 DuoPre preamps, 4 aux sends | USB is stereo only, no effects |
| Yamaha TF1 | Digital console | Recallable sessions and live albums | 34×34 USB, motor faders, scenes | 48 kHz only, heaviest here |
How we selected
We chose consoles that can anchor a music recording setup: at least 12 mic preamps or a clear multitrack path, published sample rates and track counts, and monitoring that lets musicians hear themselves while tracking. Every figure in this article comes from a maker or listing page opened for that exact model.
The spread is deliberate. Card recorders (Model 24, LiveTrak L-20) capture a performance anywhere. USB multitrack consoles (Onyx16, Signature 22 MTK, TF1) assume a DAW and give it every channel. The ZED-24 covers the older studio pattern, an analog desk feeding a separate interface, with stereo USB for quick demos. Each review names the capture path and its ceiling before anything else.
Audio mixers for recording music in detail
Each review below covers the same ground in the same order: how the console captures tracks, what its preamps and EQ offer while tracking, how musicians monitor, and what limits the format sets. That order mirrors how a recording session actually fails or succeeds.
Tascam Model 24
The Model 24 is a 22-channel analog console with a 24-track recorder inside: 16 Tascam mic preamps, and every input plus the stereo mix written to an SD card at 24-bit/48 kHz. For recording a band in one pass, it is the most self-contained option here.
The recorder punches in and out on up to 8 tracks at once, and recorded tracks play back through the console for mixdown on the desk. As a USB interface it sends 24 channels in and 22 out at 48 kHz. Channels 1 to 12 carry a 3-band EQ with sweepable mid and a 100 Hz low-cut filter, one-knob compressors appear on selected channels, and the master section adds a 7-band graphic EQ and 16 preset effects. Three aux outputs feed two monitor mixes and effects, Bluetooth handles playback, and the console measures 576 x 112.5 x 513 mm at 10.2 kg with 100 mm faders.
The ceiling is 48 kHz across both card and USB recording, and at over 10 kg with the widest body here, it stays where it is installed.
- Pros: 24-track recording with no computer, 16 preamps, mixdown on the console
- Cons: 48 kHz maximum rate, large and heavy, compressors on selected channels only
Buy if you record full lineups and want the session captured even when no laptop is present. Skip if you work at 96 kHz or build songs one track at a time in a DAW.
Zoom LiveTrak L-20
The LiveTrak L-20 is a 20-input digital mixer that records 22 tracks to an SD card at up to 24-bit/96 kHz: all 16 mono channels, the stereo channels and the master mix. It is built for bands that record their live takes and want each part separate afterward.
The 16 mic preamps reach +60 dB of gain with an EIN of -128 dBu, compression is built into channels 1 to 16, and channels 1 and 2 add Hi-Z inputs while channels 3 to 16 carry a 26 dB pad. A variable low-cut filter runs from 40 to 600 Hz, the 3-band EQ has a semi-parametric mid, and 20 effects sit on two buses. Individual tracks record without effects, so the mix can be rebuilt later. Six monitor outputs carry custom mixes, 9 scenes store setups, and a slate mic and metronome are built in. As a USB interface it runs 22-in/4-out at 48 kHz. The unit measures 445 x 388.4 x 82.6 mm and weighs 3.7 kg.
Multitrack at 96 kHz lives on the card only; the USB path to a DAW runs at 48 kHz, so high-rate DAW tracking means recording to card and transferring files.
- Pros: 22 tracks at up to 96 kHz, six monitor mixes, light at 3.7 kg, dry track recording
- Cons: USB interface capped at 48 kHz, digital menu sections, adapter power only
Buy if your band records together and edits later, especially away from a studio computer. Skip if your workflow is DAW-first at high sample rates.
Mackie Onyx16
The Onyx16 is an analog console for DAW-centered recording: 16 channels, 12 Onyx mic preamps with up to 60 dB of gain, and 18×4 multitrack USB at 24-bit/96 kHz. It suits project studios that track a small group at once, then overdub against USB returns.
The 3-band Perkins EQ sweeps its mid from 100 Hz to 8 kHz on the mono channels and includes a hard bypass switch, and every input channel has a 100 Hz high-pass filter. The DSP effects engine adds reverb, delay and chorus with a dedicated effects EQ and up to 6 user presets on a full-color display. An SD slot records the stereo mix for quick reference takes, Bluetooth streams to a channel, and the 4-track USB return is assignable per channel for overdub monitoring. The steel chassis measures 18.7 x 14 x 4.5 inches and weighs 15.2 lb, and Pro Tools | First and Waveform bundles are included.
There is no multitrack recorder on board, so a computer has to run for every multitrack session, and 12 mic inputs cap the size of a live lineup.
- Pros: 96 kHz multitrack over USB, 12 strong preamps, assignable USB returns
- Cons: No card multitrack, 12 mic inputs, stereo-only SD recording
Buy if your studio records through a DAW and you want an analog front end with real multitrack capture. Skip if you need to record a full drum kit plus a band with no computer.
Soundcraft Signature 22 MTK
The Signature 22 MTK is a 22-channel analog mixer whose centerpiece is a 24-in/22-out USB interface: every channel reaches the DAW, and 22 channels return, so plug-ins can be inserted on input channels while tracking or mixing. The MTK suffix marks the multitrack USB build of the Signature line.
Sixteen Ghost preamps feed a Sapphyre 4-band EQ with two swept mid bands, dbx limiters guard 8 inputs, and a dual-engine Lexicon processor covers reverb, delay, chorus and modulation. Five auxes switch pre or post fader, subgroups are 4 mono and 2 stereo with dedicated outputs, and the faders are 100 mm. Switchable Hi-Z inputs take instruments directly, Ableton Live 9 Lite and a Lexicon plug-in are included, and the metal console measures 490 x 660 x 109 mm and weighs 11.36 kg with an internal universal power supply.
Recording depends entirely on the computer; there is no card slot or onboard recorder, so a laptop failure ends the session’s capture as well as its playback.
- Pros: 24 channels into the DAW, 4-band EQ, subgroups with outputs, plug-in insertion
- Cons: No onboard recording, largest footprint here, computer required for capture
Buy if you track larger lineups straight into a DAW and mix with plug-ins on the way back through the desk. Skip if you want any recording to happen without a computer.
Allen & Heath ZED-24
The ZED-24 is the analog purist: 24 channels, 16 DuoPre mic preamps and no effects section at all. In a recording setup it works as the front end in front of a separate interface, or as a live desk that captures a stereo mix of the show over USB. It is also the largest purely analog surface in this group.
The 16 mono channels pair Neutrik XLR mic inputs with separate line inputs, channel inserts for outboard compressors or gates, and a 3-band EQ with a swept mid; the 4 stereo channels carry 2-band EQ. Four aux sends feed monitors and external effects, 23 sources reach the mix, and 10 outputs leave the desk, including balanced XLR mains. The USB connection is a configurable stereo send and return for recording a mix or playing back from a computer. The steel chassis runs on an internal universal supply, and the faders are 100 mm long-throw.
For multitrack recording you must add an interface, because the built-in USB path is stereo only, and there are no onboard effects for tracking comfort.
- Pros: 16 clean preamps with inserts, deep routing, 10 outputs, durable build
- Cons: Stereo USB only, no built-in effects, needs a separate interface for multitrack
Buy if you already own an interface and want an analog desk with strong preamps for tracking and live work. Skip if the mixer itself has to record every track.
Yamaha TF1
The TF1 is the digital console: 16 combo mic/line inputs, 40 input mixing channels, motorized faders and full scene recall. For recording music it pairs with a computer over a 34×34 USB interface, with Steinberg Nuendo Live included for multitrack capture.
The touchscreen surface runs 17 motor faders of 100 mm, 20 aux buses, 8 DCA groups and 16 XLR outputs. Onboard DSP provides 8 effects and 10 graphic EQs, and channel presets plus scene memories store whole setups for repeat sessions. A USB storage device records a 2-track mix directly, and the TF apps extend control to other devices. An expansion slot accepts an NY64-D card for networked audio. The console measures 510 x 225 x 599 mm, weighs 13.5 kg, draws 100 W, and its typical EIN is -128 dBu.
Everything runs at 48 kHz, the multitrack path needs a computer, and at 13.5 kg it is the heaviest console here by a wide margin.
- Pros: 34×34 USB recording, scene recall, motor faders, 20 aux buses for monitors
- Cons: 48 kHz only, 13.5 kg, multitrack requires a computer
Buy if you record recurring sessions or live shows and want every setting recalled at a touch. Skip if you want analog simplicity or high sample rates.
Buying guide
Recording puts the capture path first. Count the tracks you need at once, decide whether a computer is part of the session, then look at preamps, EQ and monitoring. The sections below follow that order, because a console that cannot capture the take cannot be rescued by a good EQ section.
Track count: how many simultaneous tracks do you need?
Count the sources that play at the same time, not the size of the band on paper. A four-piece with a miked drum kit can need 12 or more inputs at once. Overdubbing one part at a time needs far fewer, but then the return path and monitoring matter more than the raw input count.
The Model 24 captures 24 tracks to a card and the L-20 captures 22, so a full lineup is covered with room to spare. The Signature 22 MTK sends 24 channels to a DAW and the TF1 sends 34. The Onyx16 sends 18. The ZED-24 sends a stereo mix only. Match the number to your largest simultaneous lineup, then check the sample rate that number runs at.
What matters most in audio mixers for recording music
Three specs decide most recording sessions: the sample rate of the multitrack path, whether tracks record dry or with processing, and how many separate monitor mixes the musicians get. Everything else, effects lists included, matters less than those three on the day of the session.
On rates, the Onyx16 runs multitrack USB at 96 kHz and the L-20 records 96 kHz to card; the Model 24, Signature 22 MTK’s class of USB path and the TF1 work at 48 kHz. On dry capture, the L-20 records tracks without effects by design, and the analog desks send their preamp and EQ to tape unless you bypass the EQ where a bypass is fitted. On monitoring, the TF1’s 20 aux buses and the L-20’s six monitor outputs lead this group.
Recording to a card, a computer, or both
Card recording removes the computer from the session. The Model 24 and L-20 capture everything to SD media, which suits rehearsals, live rooms and any place a laptop is one more thing to manage. The trade is file handling afterward and, on the Model 24, a 48 kHz ceiling.
Computer recording gives you the DAW’s editing from the first take. The Onyx16, Signature 22 MTK and TF1 all assume that workflow, and the TF1 even bundles Nuendo Live for the capture side. The ZED-24 sits outside both camps: its stereo USB suits demos and show archives, while real multitrack work goes through a separate interface you supply.
Preamps, EQ and processing for tracking
Preamps set the noise floor of every track. Look at the gain range and the published EIN where a maker states one: the L-20 and TF1 both publish -128 dBu figures, and the Onyx preamps reach 60 dB of gain. Phantom power, pads and Hi-Z inputs decide which microphones and instruments plug straight in.
EQ while tracking is a taste call. The Signature 22 MTK’s 4-band EQ with two swept mids shapes the most on the way in; the Onyx16’s EQ has a bypass switch for recording flat; swept mids on the Model 24, L-20 and ZED-24 sit between those poles. Limiters on the Signature’s 8 inputs and compression on the L-20’s channels can protect a take from clipping, at the cost of printing the processing.
Mixing down: on the console or in the DAW
Decide where the mix will happen before choosing the console. The Model 24 plays its card tracks back through the desk for an analog mixdown, and the Signature 22 MTK returns 22 channels from the DAW so plug-ins and faders work together. The L-20 returns only 4 USB channels, so its mixes are usually finished in the DAW from the card files.
The TF1 recalls its own mixes with scenes, which suits engineers who mix the same act repeatedly. The ZED-24 mixes whatever reaches it live, and the recording side is handled elsewhere. None of these is wrong; they are different studios wearing the same product name.
FAQ
These are the questions that decide most recording mixer purchases: whether one console can carry a whole album, whether 48 kHz is enough, how these desks relate to a separate interface, and whether analog or digital serves a recording room better. Short answers come first, then the reasoning behind each one.
Can audio mixers for recording music handle a full album project?
Yes, if the capture path matches the way the album is made. A band that tracks live can cut a whole record on the Model 24 or L-20 without a computer in the room, and a DAW-based project can run start to finish through the Onyx16, Signature 22 MTK or TF1.
The limits show up at the edges: input count for large lineups, the 48 kHz ceiling on several of these desks, and monitoring for singers who need their own mix. Albums built from overdubs forgive all three; albums tracked live forgive none of them.
Is 48 kHz enough for recording music?
For most releases, yes. 48 kHz at 24-bit is the standard rate for video work and a common album rate, and every console here records at that rate or better. The desks differ in whether their higher rate, where offered, applies to the path you actually use.
The L-20’s 96 kHz applies to card recording, not its USB interface. The Onyx16 runs 96 kHz over USB directly. If high rates matter to your productions, check which path carries them rather than the headline number.
Do I still need an audio interface with one of these mixers?
With five of the six, no: the Model 24, L-20, Onyx16, Signature 22 MTK and TF1 all include a USB interface that moves multitrack audio to and from a computer. Their channel counts and rates differ, but the interface function is built in. The distinction matters when you budget the rest of the studio around the desk.
The ZED-24 is the exception. Its USB connection carries a stereo mix for demos and archives, so multitrack recording with that desk means adding a separate interface behind its direct outputs and inserts.
Analog or digital for recording music?
Analog desks here (Model 24, Onyx16, Signature 22 MTK, ZED-24) give one control per function and a fixed signal path; what you set is what records. Digital desks (L-20, TF1) add scene recall, more monitor mixes and processing on more channels, at the cost of menus.
For a studio that hosts different engineers, analog’s visible state is an advantage. For one engineer repeating similar sessions, recall wins. The recording quality itself is set by preamps and converters on both sides, and the published figures here are close.
Conclusion
Choose by capture path first. The Model 24 and LiveTrak L-20 record the whole band with no computer; the Onyx16, Signature 22 MTK and TF1 feed a DAW every channel; the ZED-24 fronts a separate interface. Match that path to how your sessions actually run, and the rest follows. Pick the format that fits the room you record in.