Key takeaways
- Flat, lumpy inserts ruin good covers. Compare seven down alternative inserts and insert-included sets for throw pillows, with sizes, fills, shells and care.
A beautiful cover can still look sad when the insert inside it is thin, lumpy or the wrong size. The best down alternative pillow insert for throw pillows is soft, holds its shape, fits the cover snugly and has a shell that keeps the fill from poking through. Here are the buying rules first, then seven real options.
Best down alternative pillow insert for throw pillows: quick verdict
Choose an insert that is one or two inches larger than your cover, with a tightly woven shell and a fill that is full but not stiff. Cotton sateen shells feel refined, while microfiber shells suit everyday sofas. Washable inserts are easier to keep fresh.
If you want the most polished feel, look at the cotton sateen options from Lincove and Bokser Home. If you want a straightforward everyday set, the Utopia Bedding and Bare Home packs are simple choices. If you also need covers, two listed sets here include both.
Match size before anything else. A 20 inch cover wants a 20 or 21 inch insert, and a size that is too small leaves empty corners. Read the closure, shell fabric, fill and care lines on each listing before ordering.
| Insert | Shell and fill | Best for | Key listed spec | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company Store Down Alternative Square Insert | Polyester shell, recycled polyester fiber fill | Choosing among many sizes | Machine washable, GRS and OEKO-TEX listed | Certification wording conflicts in Q&A |
| Utopia Bedding 20×20 2-Pack Insert | Microfiber shell, siliconized polyester fill | Everyday sofas and chairs | Two pillows, soft density | Arrives vacuum compressed |
| Bokser Home 2 Pack Down Alternative Insert, 20×20 | Cotton sateen shell, microfiber fill | Smooth cotton feel | OEKO-TEX listed, medium density | Indoor use only |
| Lincove Classic Insert, 2-Pack | Cotton sateen shell, recycled fill | Wide size range | Double-stitched edges, OEKO-TEX listed | Care wording varies by listing |
| Bare Home Inserts, Set of 2, 20×20 | Microfiber shell, polyester hollow fiber | Indoor and outdoor covers | Indoor and outdoor use listed | Plain white only |
| Cheer Collection Faux Fur Set of 2, 20×20 | Faux fur covers, down alternative fill | Cover and insert in one set | Covers and inserts included | Indoor only |
| Becky Cameron Cotton Slub 2-Pack, 20×20 | Cotton slub covers, polyester fill | Cover and insert in one set | Inserts 21×21, hidden zipper | Covers are spot clean |
How we selected these inserts
Every insert here is a real, currently sold model, and its details come from a retailer product page read for this guide. We looked for inserts that state their fill, shell fabric, size and care, since those four details decide how an insert behaves inside a cover.
The keyword is down alternative, so we favored fills the page describes as polyester, microfiber, recycled fiber or hollow fiber. Where a page did not say the word hypoallergenic, we did not use it, and we repeat any certification only as the listing states it.
We also included two sets that come with covers, because many shoppers searching for inserts need both. For those, we describe the insert part first and the cover second.
We left out real down and feather inserts, and we skipped listings that did not describe their fill or shell. The goal is a useful shortlist of fillings that stay soft, wash well and look good in a cover.
Best down alternative inserts for throw pillows, product by product
Each section lists the size, shell, fill and care exactly as the product page states them, then explains who it suits. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so, because shoppers should follow the label that arrives with the insert. Insert-included sets are marked clearly, so you can see what ships.
Company Essentials Down Alternative Square Pillow Insert
This insert is for shoppers who want to choose from a long list of sizes and prefer recycled content. The page describes a down alternative square insert with a blended polyester fill, a lofty recycled polyester fiber with 100% GRS-certified recycled content. The size selector lists 16, 18, 20, 22, 24 and 26 inches.
The shell is listed as 100% polyester. Care is machine wash cold on a gentle cycle, separately, non-chlorine bleach only if needed, tumble dry low and do not iron. The page lists Global Recycled Standard and OEKO-TEX Standard 100, but a customer answer says it is not currently OEKO-TEX certified, so check the label.
- Pros: large size range, recycled fill, washable.
- Cons: conflicting certification information; one color listed.
Buy if you need a specific size, including large sizes. Skip if OEKO-TEX status matters to you and you cannot confirm it.
How to use it: pick the same size as the cover for a snug look, or go up one size for a fuller pillow.
Utopia Bedding 20×20 2-Pack Throw Pillow Insert
This pack is for everyday sofas that need soft, simple inserts without fuss. The Target listing describes two white inserts at 20 by 20 inches, about 7 inches thick, weighing 3.1 pounds in total. The brand also lists other sizes, including 12 by 20 pairs, on its Target pages.
The outer fabric is listed as 100% microfiber, 120 GSM brushed fabric, and the fill is 100% polyester siliconized fiber with a soft density. Care is machine wash and tumble dry on low heat, with no ironing, dry cleaning or bleach. The listing says the pillows are vacuum compressed and may look like one large pillow when unpacked.
- Pros: pair, soft density, machine washable.
- Cons: vacuum compressed; soft fill may feel less structured.
Buy if you want a soft, basic pair. Skip if you want a firm, structured pillow.
How to use it: unpack early so the pillows can expand, then fluff before placing them in covers.
Bokser Home 2 Pack Down Alternative Insert, 20×20
This pack is for people who prefer a cotton shell. The listing describes a pack of two inserts at 20 by 20 inches, about 7 inches thick, with a 100% cotton shell in plain weave with a sateen finish. The fill is 100% polyester microfiber in a medium density.
Care is machine washable and tumble dry safe. The page lists OEKO-TEX Standard 100 and says the inserts are for indoor use. There is no closure, since the inserts are sewn shut. Bokser Home also lists a single 20 by 20 insert where its answers describe medium firmness.
- Pros: cotton shell, medium density, pack of two.
- Cons: indoor only; not a plush fill.
Buy if you want a smooth shell and medium feel. Skip if you want a very plump look.
How to use it: use a cover one size smaller for a fuller shape.
Lincove Classic Throw Pillow Insert, 2-Pack
This insert is for shoppers who want a polished shell and a wide choice of sizes. The listing offers sizes from 12 by 12 to 26 by 26 inches, including lumbar shapes, and describes a 100% cotton sateen shell at 240 thread count. The fill is recycled down alternative fiber made from post-consumer plastic bottles.
The page lists cold machine wash and tumble dry low, double-stitched edges and re-fluffing after washing. It also lists OEKO-TEX certification and describes the inserts as vegan and hypoallergenic, for indoor use, with a sewn seam closure. A 4-pack listing for the same brand shows conflicting care wording, so follow the label.
- Pros: many sizes, cotton shell, recycled fill.
- Cons: care wording varies by listing; sold as pairs or packs.
Buy if you need unusual or large sizes. Skip if you want a very soft, loose feel.
How to use it: choose a size one inch larger than the cover for a plump look.
Bare Home Throw Pillow Inserts, Set of 2, 20×20
This set is for covers that may go indoors or out. The listing describes two white inserts at 20 by 20 inches, about 7 inches thick, with a 100% microfiber shell and 100% polyester hollow fiber fill. The page lists indoor and outdoor use. That makes it a handy choice for covers that move between a living room and a covered patio.
Care is machine washable and tumble dry, and the description suggests a mild detergent and wool dryer balls. The page lists OEKO-TEX Standard 100 and describes the inserts as hypoallergenic. There is no closure. They are suited to sofas, chairs and beds, according to the listing.
- Pros: indoor and outdoor use listed, washable, pair.
- Cons: plain white only; not a plush look.
Buy if you swap covers between a living room and patio. Skip if you want a cotton shell.
How to use it: dry fully before storing, and fluff after washing.
Cheer Collection Luxurious Faux Fur Throw Pillows, Set of 2, 20×20
This set is for people who need covers and inserts together. The listing says the set includes both, sized 20 by 20 inches and about 4 inches thick. The fill is described as 100% down alternative hollow fiber, and the closure is a hidden zipper. Because the covers zip off, the inserts can be washed or reused later.
The outer is 100% polyester, reversible with faux fur on one side and microplush on the other. Listed colors include black, blue, chocolate, gray, maroon, purple, rust, sand and white. The page lists OEKO-TEX Standard 100, calls the pillows hypoallergenic, lists the cover as machine washable and notes indoor use only.
- Pros: covers and inserts included, reversible, washable cover.
- Cons: indoor only; cover style is fixed.
Buy if you want one box with everything. Skip if you want to reuse your own covers.
How to use it: remove the insert before washing the cover.
Becky Cameron 2-Pack Cotton Slub Solid Pillows and Inserts, Mustard and Navy, 20×20
This set is for shoppers who want covers and inserts in two colors. The listing says it includes two covers and two inserts, with 20 by 20 inch covers and 21 by 21 inch inserts, about 4 inches thick overall. The insert has a cotton cover with polyester fill.
The covers are 100% cotton slub with a hidden zipper and are listed as indoor and fade resistant, with OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certified fabric. The insert is described as machine washable and tumble dry, while the cover wording is mixed, so follow the label. The covers and inserts may ship separately.
- Pros: oversized inserts for fullness, covers included, hidden zipper.
- Cons: mixed care wording; polyester fill is not labeled down alternative.
Buy if you want a full set. Skip if you only need loose inserts.
How to use it: keep the inserts for reuse in other covers later.
Buying guide: best down alternative inserts for throw pillows
The right insert changes how a pillow looks, feels and lasts. These sections explain how to choose size, shell, fill and firmness, how to compare down alternative with other fills in general terms, and how to care for inserts so they keep their shape.
How to choose a down alternative pillow insert for throw pillows
Start with the cover size. For a plump, designer look, pick an insert one to two inches larger than the cover. For a flatter, tailored look, match the sizes exactly. Next, think about firmness, shell fabric, fill and care, in that order, because size mistakes are the hardest to fix later.
Choose a medium fill for sofas where people lean on the pillows, and a softer fill for decorative corners. Zippered covers make it easy to swap inserts later.
Down alternative versus real down, in general terms
Down alternative is a synthetic fill, usually polyester fiber, microfiber or recycled fiber. It tends to be easier to wash and replace. Real down and feather feel different and need different care. Pick down alternative when you want machine washing and an animal-free fill.
Makers sometimes call their fills hypoallergenic. Only trust that wording where the listing states it for that insert.
Shell fabric: cotton, microfiber and polyester
A tightly woven shell keeps fibers inside and stops stray fill from poking through the cover. Cotton sateen feels smooth and tidy, microfiber feels soft and brushed, and polyester is light and durable. If you often wash inserts, a shell that tolerates machine washing is helpful.
Check for double stitching and a closed seam. Inserts with no closure are sealed, which keeps the fill from escaping.
Size and fullness
Standard sizes are 16, 18, 20, 22 and 24 inches, and several listings here go up to 26. Larger sizes suit sofas with deep seats and make the back row look generous. If your cover has a flange, match the size more closely so the flange sits flat and neat.
Vacuum compressed inserts need time to expand. Let them rest and fluff them by hand.
Care and common mistakes
Wash inserts according to the listing, using a gentle cycle and low heat when stated, and never guess if a listing is silent. Dry fully, and fluff during drying with a clean dryer ball if the label allows. Care decides how long an insert keeps its loft.
Common mistakes include buying an insert smaller than the cover, using an old flat insert in a new cover and ignoring care labels. Each mistake shortens the life of the pillow.
Frequently asked questions
These answers cover common questions about down alternative inserts for throw pillows. They are general guidance, so follow the care and use lines on the listing for each product, and adapt the size advice to your own covers and sofa before you order a set.
What size insert should I buy for a throw pillow cover?
Pick an insert one to two inches larger than the cover for a full, plump pillow, or match the size exactly for a flatter look. A flange cover is better matched exactly. Measure the cover seam to seam, not just the label, since printed sizes can differ.
Can I wash a down alternative insert?
Many can be machine washed, but only if the listing says so, and only the way the listing says. The inserts here describe machine washing with low heat drying, though wording varies, so follow each label. Dry fully before using the insert again, because damp fill can clump.
Is down alternative hypoallergenic?
Only where the maker says so. Some listings here describe their insert as hypoallergenic, while others do not mention it at all. A synthetic fill is not a guarantee against allergies, so rely on the listing wording and ask a doctor about specific concerns.
How long do inserts last before they go flat?
It depends on fill, use and care. Washing and fluffing can restore loft for a time, but any insert eventually thins out with use and weight. Replace it when it stays flat after fluffing, the shell wears through or the fill clumps and no longer recovers.
Should I buy inserts with covers or separately?
Buy a full set if you want a coordinated look quickly. Buy inserts separately if you already own covers or want a particular shell and size. Sets that include covers are convenient but fix your fill and shell choice, and the covers may ship separately.
Conclusion
For most shoppers, a cotton sateen or microfiber insert one size larger than the cover gives the best-looking throw pillow. Lincove and Bokser Home suit a smooth shell, Utopia and Bare Home suit everyday use, and the sets with covers save a step. Check size, shell, fill and care on the listing before you order any insert.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!