Key takeaways
- Switch between your back and your side at night? Compare seven pillows for back sleepers and side sleepers by loft, fill and care, plus a buying guide and FAQ.
Many people start the night on their back and end it on their side, which means one pillow has to do two jobs. These best pillows for back sleepers and side sleepers either adjust, come in two heights or hold a middle loft that serves both positions well, and each is backed by maker-stated specs and plain trade-offs.
Quick verdict: best pillows for back sleepers and side sleepers
Back sleepers usually want a medium loft and side sleepers a higher one, so the best compromise is a pillow you can adjust or a design with a contoured shape. Fixed pillows work if you spend most of the night in one position and rarely change, and they are simpler to live with than loose fill.
- Best simple foam at 5 inches: Serta Nightstar Pillow.
- Best contoured foam: Original Groove Pillow.
- Best fixed latex with two heights: Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow.
- Best shaped adjustable pillow: Eli & Elm Cotton Side-Sleeper Pillow.
- Best for warm combination sleepers: Helix ComfortAdjust Cooling Pillow.
- Best for rearranging layers: Luxome LAYR Customizable Pillow.
- Best soft fiber pillow for back sleeping: Sweet Zzz Plant-Based Pillow.
These are shopping suggestions, not medical advice. If you have persistent neck or back pain, check with your doctor or physical therapist before changing your setup.
Comparison table
The table lists each pillow with its fill, the positions it suits, and the key spec makers or reviewers give. Missing numbers are noted as not stated, because it is better to leave a gap than to guess a loft that you might then buy by mistake, so confirm any missing figure with the seller.
| Model | Fill | Best for | Key spec | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Serta Nightstar Pillow | Solid open-cell polyfoam | Side and back sleepers | 5-inch height, medium feel | Fixed height |
| Original Groove Pillow | Solid bamboo charcoal memory foam | Side, back and combination sleepers | Medium firm, shaped | Height not stated |
| Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow | Solid Talalay latex | 4-inch for back, 5-inch for side | Medium firm, two heights | You must choose one height |
| Eli & Elm Cotton Side-Sleeper Pillow | Shredded latex or memory foam plus polyester fiber | Side sleepers, with some back sleepers comfortable | Adjustable fill, oblong shape | Loft not listed in inches |
| Helix ComfortAdjust Cooling Pillow | Shredded memory foam and down alternative | Combination sleepers | Side zippers, cooling cover | Spot clean only per review |
| Luxome LAYR Customizable Pillow | Inserts of down alternative and gel-infused memory foam | Side, back and stomach by insert count | Two to three inserts for back, three to four for side | Takes setup time |
| Sweet Zzz Plant-Based Pillow | Plant-based down alternative fibers | Back sleepers | Medium firmness, machine washable | Loft not listed in inches |
How we selected pillows for back sleepers and side sleepers
The challenge with a dual-position pillow is height, because the same pillow has to fill the shoulder gap when you roll onto your side and avoid pushing the head forward when you lie on your back. So we looked for adjustability, two-height options or a shaped design.
Each model had to be currently sold, with its fill, feel and care described on a maker or review page that we read. We included a mix of foam, latex, shredded and fiber fills so that you can choose by feel, and we noted which covers are washable.
We did not rank by price or review score, and we left out anything we could not trace to a source. Where a height was not stated, we say so. This is shopping help, and it is not medical advice.
The pillows we picked
Each pillow below lists its stated fill, how it handles back and side positions, and its limits. Treat the descriptions as the words of makers and reviewers, and expect to test any pillow for a few nights before deciding it is right, since position habits are hard to judge in a store.
Serta Nightstar Pillow
The Serta Nightstar is a solid polyfoam pillow with a stated 5-inch height, described by one review as a fit for side and back sleepers. It is a straightforward choice if you want a single fixed pillow for both positions and do not want to adjust fill or inserts.
A published review lists solid open-cell polyfoam, queen and king sizes, a medium feel, and a removable poly-nylon cover that is machine washable. There is no adjustable fill, so the height is fixed. No certifications were stated on the page we read, and the review does not name any other features.
- Pros: stated 5-inch height, washable cover, no assembly.
- Cons: fixed height may be high for back sleepers or low for broad shoulders.
- Buy if: you want a simple foam pillow for two positions.
- Skip if: you want to adjust height.
Original Groove Pillow
The Original Groove is a single block of dense memory foam with a shaped design, and it is described as suited to side, back and combination sleepers. It appeals to people who want a firmer, contoured pillow with no loose fill to chase around, and who like the same shape every night.
A published review lists solid bamboo charcoal memory foam with bamboo-derived gel, a medium-firm feel, and a removable scuba-knit cover that is machine washable, though reattaching it can be difficult. Height and size were not stated. The review notes it is less suited to stomach sleepers.
- Pros: contoured shape, firm feel, washable cover.
- Cons: no height stated, cover can be hard to refit.
- Buy if: you roll between back and side and like firm foam.
- Skip if: you sleep on your stomach.
Brooklyn Bedding Talalay Latex Pillow
Brooklyn Bedding sells this latex pillow in 4-inch and 5-inch heights, and reviewers suggest the 4-inch for back sleepers and the 5-inch for side sleepers. If you mostly stay in one position, that choice is easy to make, and the removable cover makes upkeep simple.
The listing describes solid Talalay latex with a medium-firm feel, in queen and king, with a removable Tencel cover that is machine washable. The latex should only be spot cleaned, and one review notes small holes for airflow. If you switch positions a lot, you may find one height fits only part of the night.
- Pros: two heights, resilient latex, washable cover.
- Cons: no adjustable fill, spot clean core.
- Buy if: you stay mostly in one position.
- Skip if: you flip often and want flexibility.
Eli & Elm Cotton Side-Sleeper Pillow
Eli & Elm shapes its pillow for side sleeping, and one review notes that back sleepers also reported comfort. Because you can add or remove fill, it is a reasonable bet for people who split the night between the two, as long as side sleeping is the larger share.
Published specs describe 75 percent shredded latex or shredded memory foam and 25 percent polyester fiber, with the latex version including gel infusions. It has an oblong, ergonomic shape and comes in one size listed as suitable for queen or king mattresses. The cover is a cotton, polyester and spandex blend that can be machine washed after removing the fill.
- Pros: adjustable, shaped for side sleeping, washable cover.
- Cons: loft not in inches, and extra fill is sold separately according to one review.
- Buy if: you want a side-leaning pillow that back sleepers can tolerate.
- Skip if: you want a solid block of foam.
Helix ComfortAdjust Cooling Pillow
Helix describes this pillow for combination sleepers, and it uses side zippers so you can change the fill without opening the whole pillow. The cooling cover makes it relevant for people who sleep warm, and the zippers let you tweak the fill from night to night without a fuss.
A published review lists shredded memory foam and down-alternative fiber in an inner pouch, adjustable firmness and loft, and a GlacioTex cooling fabric cover. Care guidance says to spot clean, and one review warns that machine washing can cause permanent damage. Sizes and heights in inches were not stated. The cooling language is a maker feature, not a promise about temperature.
- Pros: adjustable, aimed at combination sleepers, cooling cover.
- Cons: spot clean only, sizes not stated.
- Buy if: you shift positions and run warm.
- Skip if: you want to machine wash.
Luxome LAYR Customizable Pillow
The LAYR is made of inserts, so you can use more of them on side nights and fewer on back nights, or find one setting that works for both, which suits anyone who enjoys fine-tuning a bed over a few weeks. Insert counts are only a starting point, because every body is different.
A published review lists down alternative, shredded gel-infused memory foam and solid gel-infused memory foam inserts, in standard and king sizes. Side sleepers in that review used three to four inserts, and back sleepers used two to three at most. The cover is bamboo-derived viscose with side vents, and the inserts and cover are washed separately, while the fill should not be laundered.
- Pros: highly adjustable, mixed fill, vented cover.
- Cons: setup takes time.
- Buy if: you like to experiment with height.
- Skip if: you want a no-fuss pillow.
Sweet Zzz Plant-Based Pillow
Sweet Zzz uses two layers of plant-based down alternative fibers and is described as a pillow for back sleepers, which gives it a role if you mostly lie on your back and sometimes roll. Its feel is softer than foam or latex, so it suits sleepers who dislike a firm, springy surface under the head.
A published review lists a medium firmness, a natural cotton shell and a mid-range loft with no height in inches. It can be machine washed on a gentle cycle in cold water and tumble dried on low, and it should not be ironed or dry cleaned. Sizes are listed differently between sources, so check the seller.
- Pros: machine washable, medium feel, plant-based fill.
- Cons: no loft number, size listings differ.
- Buy if: you mostly back sleep and like soft fiber.
- Skip if: you are mostly a side sleeper who needs height.
Buying guide: pillows for back sleepers and side sleepers
A dual-position pillow works when height, fill and shape fit both postures. These sections explain how to judge each factor, and how to decide between an adjustable pillow and one fixed height, which is the biggest choice for anyone who changes position at night.
Understand the loft difference
Common guidance says side sleepers usually need a higher loft to fill the shoulder-to-neck gap, while back sleepers do better with a medium loft. A single pillow has to land between those needs unless it can change, which is why adjustable designs get so much attention among combination sleepers.
That is why adjustable pillows and two-height families are popular for combination sleepers. If you favor one position, buy for it. If you truly split the night, choose a pillow you can fine-tune and expect to tweak it after a week or two.
Look for contour and shape
Some pillows are shaped, with a lower center and raised edges, so the neck is supported on the back and the shoulder gap is covered on the side, and that makes a good fit for people who switch. The Original Groove and the Eli & Elm pillow lean on shape in different ways.
A shaped pillow can feel odd at first because it differs from a flat rectangle. Give it a few nights. If you tend to hug your pillow or tuck an arm under it, make sure the shape allows that, or you may fight it all night.
Pick a fill that holds up when you roll
Solid foam and latex hold their shape through turns, shredded fills shift and may need re-fluffing, and fiber fill is soft but can flatten. Each is a trade-off between stability and ease of adjustment, so choose the behavior that matches how restless you are.
If you switch positions many times a night, steadiness matters, so a solid pillow can be reassuring. If you like to mold your pillow, shredded or fiber options suit you. Read each maker’s firmness description against how your current pillow behaves.
Weigh care and temperature
Care varies widely: the Serta and Brooklyn covers wash, the Sweet Zzz is fully washable, and the Helix is spot clean only. A cover you can wash keeps the pillow fresher, which matters over months of use, especially if you sleep warm or tend to sweat at night.
If you sleep warm, look at what makers say about cooling covers or ventilated designs, and treat those as features rather than guarantees. Cotton and bamboo-derived covers are described as breathable by some makers, but personal comfort differs widely and no cover can promise a temperature outcome.
Test the pillow with your mattress
Your mattress changes how much height you need. A soft bed lets your shoulder sink, so a slightly lower pillow can work, while a firm bed keeps the shoulder up and may need more height. If you change mattresses, expect to change your pillow setting too.
Try the pillow for several nights, and note how you wake. Check the seller’s return terms, since we did not verify them for these models, and keep your old pillow until you are sure. If pain persists, see a doctor or physical therapist.
Avoid the usual mistakes
The usual mistake is choosing a pillow for one position and forcing it to do both. A very tall pillow can leave the back sleeper looking at their toes, while a very flat one can leave a side sleeper tilted toward the mattress. Pick for the position you spend the most hours in.
Another mistake is judging a pillow in a single night. Muscles adapt, and a first night can feel odd even when the height is correct. Give an adjustable model a fair run, change one thing at a time, and write down what you did so you can undo a change that makes things worse.
Frequently asked questions
These answers are general guidance for people who switch between their back and their side during the night, and they apply to most adult sleepers. They are not medical advice, and anyone with ongoing neck or back pain should ask a doctor or physical therapist for personal advice that fits their body.
Can one pillow work for both back and side sleeping?
Yes, if it is adjustable, shaped or sits in a middle loft that you find comfortable in both positions, as long as the fill holds up. Many combination sleepers use adjustable fill or inserts to find that midpoint, and some people accept a small compromise in one position.
If your pillow works on your side but pushes your head forward on your back, remove some fill or try a lower height. If the opposite is true, add height. Small changes over several nights are better than big ones, because your neck needs time to adapt to each adjustment.
What loft should a combination sleeper choose?
There is no exact number, but a medium to medium-high loft often suits combination sleepers. Adjustable pillows help you find it, and fixed options such as the 5-inch Serta or Brooklyn show how high some models go, so compare those figures with your own shoulder width.
Alignment is the test. On your side, your head should stay level with your spine. On your back, the head should not tilt forward. If both feel comfortable for a few nights in a row, you have likely found a workable height for your body.
Is memory foam or latex better for people who switch positions?
Neither wins outright, and the right pick comes down to feel and to how often you turn over in a night or move around. Latex is springier and may feel easier to move on, while memory foam contours more slowly and can feel warmer, though cooling versions exist.
If you roll a lot, a responsive surface might feel better, and if you like to sink in slightly, memory foam might. Shredded blends like the Eli & Elm let you decide by changing fill, which can be a safe starting point if you are unsure which feel you prefer.
Do I need a knee pillow too?
Many side sleepers use a pillow between the knees, and many back sleepers use one under the knees. Common sleep guidance suggests these can help keep hips and the lower back comfortable, but they are optional, and plenty of people sleep well without one.
If you switch positions, a single slim pillow may be easy to move around in the night. Try it for a week and see whether it helps. If you have hip, knee or back concerns, ask a doctor or physical therapist what suits you.
How do I know when to replace my pillow?
Replace it when it stays flat, has lumps that will not fluff out, smells after washing or no longer holds the height you need. Different fills age at different speeds, and a pillow that still feels soft is not always one that still holds the height you need.
Follow the maker’s care steps to extend its life, such as washing removable covers and spot cleaning solid cores. If you notice new neck stiffness after your pillow has aged, a replacement may help, and a clinician can advise if it continues.
Conclusion
If you switch between back and side, choose a pillow you can adjust or one in a middle loft, such as Eli & Elm, Luxome LAYR or Helix ComfortAdjust. If you mostly stay put, pick Brooklyn Bedding by position, test any new pillow for a few nights, and see a doctor or physical therapist if neck or back pain lingers.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!