Table of Contents

8 sections 23 min read
Updated Nov 15, 2026· 20 min read

Key takeaways

  • Pool pillows for above ground pool winter closing compared on maker-stated size, material, valve, and ice rating, with sizing, inflation and centering guidance.

Closing an above ground pool for winter means giving the cover a raised center and giving expanding ice somewhere to press besides the walls. This guide looks at seven best rsted pool pillows for above ground pool winter closur picks, all inflatable air pillows that sit under a winter cover, compared on maker-stated size, material, and valve.

Quick verdict: the best rsted pool pillows for above ground pool winter closur

A pool pillow is a simple tool with one job, which is to hold a pocket of air under the winter cover while ice forms. The seven picks below cover the common sizes for round and oval pools, from a 4 by 4 foot square for small round pools to an 8 by 8 foot square for large round pools.

The POOLHACKER 4 by 4 foot pillow leads for small round pools because its maker-stated 0.5 mm PVC, double-layer dual valve, four reinforced grommets, and 50 foot rope cover the three weak points of this category in one box. The In The Swim 4 by 8 foot pillow leads for mid-size round pools because its 16-gauge vinyl and 4 by 8 foot footprint match the size that sizing guides list for 18 to 24 foot round pools. The Yankee 4 by 4 foot pillow is the pick for owners who want a stated cold rating, since its maker manual gives minus 10 F, while the GOOX 8 by 8 foot pillow is the pick for large round pools that need one big central cushion instead of several small ones. Swimline HydroTools, Blue Wave, and Robelle fill the remaining sizes, and none of the seven is a bed pillow, a float, or a safety device.

Quick comparison table

The table below puts the seven picks side by side on the facts that decide fit: inflated size, material as the maker states it, valve type, cold rating, and the pool size each size is commonly matched to. Where a maker publishes no figure, the cell says Not stated instead of borrowing a number from a retailer listing.

Product Size Material Valve Ice Rating Use
In The Swim Winter Pool Cover Air Pillow 4 x 8 ft 4 x 8 ft 16-gauge vinyl Not stated Not stated Round pools 18 to 24 ft
Swimline HydroTools Air Pillow 4 x 4 ft 4 x 4 ft Heavy-duty vinyl Large-opening valve Not stated Round pools up to 15 ft
Blue Wave Air Pillow 4 x 4 ft 4 x 4 ft 16-gauge vinyl Not stated Not stated Round pools up to 15 ft
Robelle Pool Pillow 4 x 8 ft 4 x 8 ft 0.22 mm vinyl Not stated Not stated Round pools 18 to 24 ft
Yankee Pool Pillow 4 x 4 ft 4 x 4 ft 0.4 mm PVC Dual Boston valve Minus 10 F Round pools up to 15 ft
POOLHACKER Winter Pool Pillow 4 x 4 ft 4 x 4 ft 0.5 mm PVC Double-layer dual valve Not stated Round pools up to 15 ft
GOOX Pool Pillow 8 x 8 ft 8 x 8 ft 0.4 mm PVC Sealed valve Not stated Round pools 21 to 30 ft

The seven pool pillows in detail

Each pick below gets the same treatment: inflated size, material, valve, cold rating, tie-down gear, and the pool shape it suits best. Read size first, because a pillow that is too small leaves the cover flat in the middle, while one that is too large crowds the water.

In The Swim Winter Pool Cover Air Pillow 4 x 8 ft: 16-gauge vinyl for mid-size round pools

The In The Swim Winter Pool Cover Air Pillow in the 4 by 8 foot size is a rectangular vinyl pillow built for the middle of the above ground pool market. Its maker manual lists the model as W2365, the inflated size as 48 inches by 96 inches, and the material as heavy-duty 16-gauge vinyl.

The maker describes the pillow as an air pocket under the winter cover that takes pressure from freezing water so the walls carry less of it, and the raised center lets rain and snow slide toward the edges instead of pooling in the middle. The manual states that the pillow should only be inflated halfway, which matches the general guidance to leave room for the pillow to squeeze as ice forms. No valve type or cold rating is published in the maker manual read for this guide, so both cells say Not stated. Buy this pick if the pool is a mid-size round pool and a single 4 by 8 foot pillow matches the sizing guide. Skip it for a small 12 foot round pool, where a 4 by 4 foot pillow covers the center with less crowding, or a 30 foot round pool, where one 4 by 8 foot pillow covers too little.

Swimline HydroTools Air Pillow 4 x 4 ft: the legacy ice compensator in a small square

The Swimline HydroTools Air Pillow in the 4 by 4 foot size is the long-running name in this category, and Swimline calls its pillows ice compensators. The maker describes them as absorbing pressure from freezing and expanding water, and as keeping water and debris from collecting in the center of the pool.

The 4 by 4 foot size suits round pools up to about 15 feet across. Swimline states that the pillow is made from heavy-duty, puncture-resistant material, and it does not publish a gauge or millimeter thickness, so the table lists the material as heavy-duty vinyl and gives no thickness figure. The valve is described by the maker as a large-opening valve for easy inflation, which suits a standard air pump or a blower. Owner reports collected by independent roundups describe Swimline pillows going flat after two months, three months, or a year, even when filled to about 70 percent with the valve facing up. That pattern is common across this category, and it is why closing guidance treats a pool pillow as a consumable. Buy this pick if a familiar brand name and a large valve opening matter more than a stated material thickness. Skip it if the pool needs a thick PVC body with a stated cold rating, because the Yankee and POOLHACKER picks publish those figures and this one does not.

Blue Wave Air Pillow 4 x 4 ft: 16-gauge vinyl at the entry tier

The Blue Wave Air Pillow in the 4 by 4 foot size is the most widely sold pillow in this category, and its maker-stated facts are simple and easy to check. The model number is NW150, the inflated size is 48 inches by 48 inches by 21 inches, and the material is 16-gauge vinyl with heat-sealed seams.

The maker states that the rugged vinyl pillow absorbs pressure from freezing water and helps protect pool walls, and that it reduces excess rain, snow, and leaves on the winter cover by raising the center. The valve type is not published by the maker in the sources read for this guide, so the table says Not stated for the valve, and no cold temperature rating is published, so the ice rating cell also says Not stated. Independent roundups place this pillow at the low end of the group on air retention, with owner reports naming the valve as the cause when air escapes after the pump is removed. Inflate it to about 60 to 70 percent, close the valve firmly, and face it upward. Buy this pick if the pool is a small round pool and a 16-gauge vinyl body with heat-sealed seams is enough. Skip it if the pool is large or the winter is long and cold, because the POOLHACKER pick covers the double-layer valve and included rope.

Robelle Pool Pillow 4 x 8 ft: 0.22 mm vinyl with reinforced grommets

The Robelle Pool Pillow in the 4 by 8 foot size, model 3748A, is a rectangular vinyl pillow for mid-size round pools and shorter oval pools. Its maker-stated material is vinyl at 0.22 mm thick, its shape is rectangular, its size is 8 feet by 4 feet, and its listed item weight is 2.7 pounds.

Robelle describes this pillow as an ice equalizer that takes stress from the pool walls caused by ice, and as a way to reduce the build-up of rain water, leaves, and snow on the winter cover. No valve type is published for this model in the sources read for this guide, so the table says Not stated for the valve, and no cold temperature rating is published, so the ice rating cell says Not stated. The 0.22 mm thickness is thinner than the 0.4 mm and 0.5 mm PVC figures published for the Yankee, POOLHACKER, and GOOX picks. Thickness alone does not decide how long a pillow holds air, because seams, valve design, and handling matter as much as the sheet. Buy this pick if the pool is a mid-size round pool and reinforced grommets matter for centering. Skip it if the winter brings months of hard freezing and a thicker PVC body with a stated cold rating is the priority, because the Yankee pick publishes both.

Yankee Pool Pillow 4 x 4 ft: 0.4 mm PVC with a stated minus 10 F rating

The Yankee Pool Pillow in the 4 by 4 foot size is the pick in this group with the clearest cold rating. Its maker manual states that the pillow is made from 0.4 mm PVC with double-sealing technology, that it can cope with cold as bad as minus 10 F, and that it uses a dual Boston valve that works with any blower.

The manual instructs owners to inflate the pillow to about 60 to 70 percent of its full capacity, to tie the rope to the reinforced grommets, and to place the pillow at the center of the pool. A stated cold rating is not a promise that the pillow will stay inflated all winter. The manual still warns against inflating to full capacity, because the pillow needs room inside to absorb the pressure of expanding ice. Buy this pick if the pool is a small round pool in a cold climate and a stated minus 10 F rating with a dual Boston valve matters. Skip it if the pool is a large round pool or a long oval pool, where a single 4 by 4 foot pillow covers too little.

POOLHACKER Winter Pool Pillow 4 x 4 ft: 0.5 mm PVC with a double-layer dual valve

The POOLHACKER Winter Pool Pillow in the 4 by 4 foot size is the most fully specified pick in this group. Its maker listing states a 0.5 mm ultra-thick, cold-resistant PVC body, a double-layer valve with two-stage caps, four reinforced grommets, and a 50 foot rope in the box.

The listing instructs owners to inflate the pillow to 50 to 70 percent of its full capacity, and it states that the pillow is designed to withstand sub-zero temperatures, but it gives no number for that rating, so the table says Not stated for the ice rating rather than turning a general cold claim into a figure. One conflict needs a plain note. Some listings for this same POOLHACKER pillow state a 0.4 mm thickness instead of 0.5 mm, and one roundup table lists 0.4 mm for the 4 by 4 foot size while the headline listing states 0.5 mm. This guide uses the 0.5 mm figure from the headline listing, because that is the figure the maker puts first, and it flags the 0.4 mm figure here so an owner who reads a different listing is not surprised. The valve, grommet count, and rope length are consistent across the listings read for this guide. The 4 by 4 foot size suits round pools up to about 15 feet across, and the same pillow is sold in 4 by 8 foot and 4 by 15 foot sizes for larger pools. Close the two-stage valve caps tightly after inflation, because a loose cap is a common air-loss path. Buy this pick if the pool is a small round pool and the owner wants the thickest stated PVC, a double-layer valve, and rope included. Skip it if the pool is a large round pool, where the larger version of the same pillow fits better.

GOOX Pool Pillow 8 x 8 ft: a single large square for large round pools

The GOOX Pool Pillow in the 8 by 8 foot size is the large-pool pick in this group, and its size is the point. A single 8 by 8 foot pillow covers 64 square feet of water surface, which is four times the area of a 4 by 4 foot pillow, so one large square can do the work of several small squares.

Sizing guides list an 8 by 8 foot pillow for round pools in the 21 to 30 foot range, either alone or paired with a 4 by 4 foot pillow. The maker-stated material is 0.4 mm PVC, and the valve is described as a sealed valve that works with a blower, which suits an owner who inflates with a shop blower rather than a small hand pump. No cold temperature rating is published for this model in the sources read for this guide, so the table says Not stated for the ice rating, and the tie-down gear is not stated in the sources read either, so an owner should check the box on arrival and supply rope if none is included. Buy this pick if the pool is a large round pool and one big central cushion is the simplest setup. Skip it if the pool is small or mid-size, where an 8 by 8 foot pillow crowds the water and pushes the cover toward the walls.

How size and shape were matched to each pool

Size is the first decision in this category, because the pillow has to cover enough of the water to raise the cover without covering so much that it crowds the pool. Sizing guides give the same pattern: small pools take a small pillow, and large pools take a large pillow or more than one.

Round pools take one pillow in the middle in most cases

Round pools are the simplest shape for this decision, because the pillow sits in the center and the cover rises in a cone shape around it. A 12 to 15 foot round pool takes a 4 by 4 foot pillow, an 18 to 24 foot round pool takes a 4 by 8 foot pillow, and a 27 to 33 foot round pool takes a 4 by 15 foot pillow or two 4 by 8 foot pillows.

The rule behind those bands is to cover about 10 percent of the water surface, so a 24 foot round pool with about 452 square feet of water needs about 45 square feet of pillow. That 10 percent rule is a planning guide, not a maker specification. A pillow that covers far less leaves the cover flat in the middle, while one that covers far more crowds the water. The seven picks cover the 4 by 4 foot, 4 by 8 foot, and 8 by 8 foot sizes, so most round pools in the 12 to 30 foot range have a matching pick.

Oval pools need a long pillow along the center line

Oval pools need a different shape of thinking, because a square pillow in the middle of a long oval leaves the ends of the cover flat. A long rectangular pillow, such as a 4 by 8 foot or 4 by 15 foot pillow, runs along the center line of the oval and raises the cover along its length, which is why sizing guides list it for oval pools.

Sizing guides list a 4 by 8 foot pillow for oval pools from 12 by 18 feet to 16 by 32 feet, and a 4 by 15 foot pillow for oval pools from 18 by 33 feet to 21 by 43 feet. Two smaller pillows spaced along the center line can do the same job, and they give a backup if one goes flat. The two 4 by 8 foot picks, In The Swim and Robelle, suit oval pools best, because their length fits the center line of a short or mid-size oval. Measure the length as well as the width before choosing, because a pillow that matches the width but not the length leaves the ends of the cover unsupported.

What rsted and closur mean in this keyword

The keyword for this article reads best rsted pool pillows for above ground pool winter closur, and two words in it need a plain note. The word rsted is kept verbatim from the source list, and its intended reading is not confirmed, so this article does not guess a completion for it and does not change it in the heading or the file name.

The word closur is also kept verbatim, and it is read here as a truncated form of closure, because the article is about winter closing, but that reading is unconfirmed and the truncated form stays in the heading as written. Keeping those words verbatim matters for two reasons. First, correcting a typo in a keyword can create a duplicate of another article that already uses the corrected form. Second, the reader who searches with the keyword as written should land on the article that matches it. The rest of this article uses the standard words winter closing and winter closure in the body, while the heading keeps the keyword exactly as listed.

How to install a pool pillow at winter closing

Installing a pool pillow is a short job, but the order matters, because the pillow goes in before the cover, and the cover cannot be adjusted easily once it is cabled down. The steps below follow the maker instructions read for this guide, and they assume the water has already been lowered to the closing level.

Inflate the pillow only partway and face the valve up

Inflate the pillow to about 50 to 70 percent of its full capacity, and never fill it tight. The maker guidance is consistent on this point: In The Swim says halfway, Yankee says 60 to 70 percent, POOLHACKER says 50 to 70 percent, and Swim University gives a range of 50 to 80 percent.

The pillow needs room inside to squeeze as ice forms around it, and a pillow filled tight has no room to give, so it splits at a seam or pops its valve. Face the valve upward when the pillow goes in the water, and close the valve firmly before the pillow is placed. A valve that faces down sits in the water all winter, and a cap that is left loose lets air escape slowly. If the pillow has a two-stage valve, close both stages, and if it has a Boston valve, screw the cap down by hand until it stops.

Center the pillow and tie it loosely in place

Place the pillow at the center of the pool, and tie it loosely so it stays near the middle without being pulled tight. The rope goes through the reinforced grommets or eyelets on the pillow and out to the pool walls or to the cover cable, with enough slack that the pillow can shift a little as ice forms and as the cover moves.

A rope pulled tight pulls on the grommets all winter, and a grommet that tears leaves the pillow free to drift. The POOLHACKER and Yankee picks include a 50 foot rope in the box, which is enough to cross a mid-size pool, while the Blue Wave and Swimline picks include no rope, so an owner needs to supply it. Measure the pool across the center before closing day. If two pillows are used, space them evenly along the center line rather than stacking them together.

Fit the winter cover over the pillow and check the water level

Fit the winter cover over the pillow so the pillow raises the center and the cover slopes down toward the edges. The cover should sit on the pillow without stretching tight over it, because a cover pulled tight over a full pillow presses the pillow flat and pulls on the cable.

Let the cover drape, then pull the cable snug around the pool wall, and check that the pillow still has give when pressed through the cover. If the cover is drum tight, let out a little cable. Check the water level before the cover goes on, because the level sets how much the cover can sag. Most closing guides lower the water below the skimmer, so follow the pool maker guidance for that figure. A cover pump helps through the winter, because rain and snow melt collect on the cover even with a pillow underneath. Do not walk on the cover, and do not use the pillow as a float, because it is not built for that load.

Choosing the best rsted pool pillows for above ground pool winter closur for large pools

Large pools change the choice, because one small pillow cannot raise the cover across a wide span. Sizing guides give two answers: one large pillow, such as an 8 by 8 foot square, or two or more smaller pillows spaced across the center. Both work, and the choice comes down to handling and backup.

Best rsted pool pillows for above ground pool winter closur for large pools

For a large round pool, the GOOX 8 by 8 foot pillow is the simplest pick from the table, because one large square covers 64 square feet and fits the sizing guides for round pools from 21 to 30 feet. Its maker-stated material is 0.4 mm PVC, and its sealed valve works with a blower, which suits the larger volume of air that a big pillow needs.

The alternative is two 4 by 8 foot pillows, the In The Swim or the Robelle, spaced across the center, which spreads the lift and gives a backup if one pillow goes flat mid-winter. Two smaller pillows keep part of the cover raised if one fails, and they are easier to carry and store when deflated. An owner with a 30 foot or 33 foot round pool should also look at a 4 by 15 foot pillow, which is the size the guides list for those diameters, even though no 4 by 15 foot pillow is in the table in this guide.

Valve types and why a double valve holds air longer

Valve design is the weak point of most pool pillows, because a valve that leaks slowly empties the pillow over months, and the owner cannot reach it under the cover. The Yankee dual Boston valve and the POOLHACKER double-layer dual valve both give two stages of sealing, while the Swimline large-opening valve gives fast inflation.

The In The Swim, Blue Wave, and Robelle picks publish no valve type, so an owner should inspect the valve on arrival and check that it closes firmly. A double valve helps in two ways. The inner valve stops air from escaping while the pump is removed, and the outer cap gives a second seal that stays closed through the winter. A single valve with a loose cap has only one seal. Whatever valve the pillow has, close it firmly, face it upward, and do not overfill the pillow. If a pillow has gone flat in a past winter, the valve is the first part to check, and a pick with a double-layer valve is the natural next choice.

When a pool pillow is the wrong tool for the job

A pool pillow is the wrong tool when the pool does not freeze, when the pool is an in-ground pool, or when the cover is a mesh leaf net rather than a solid winter cover. In a warm climate with no hard freeze, the pillow adds little, because there is no expanding ice to absorb.

In-ground pools do not use air pillows in the same way, because their covers and water levels work differently. A mesh leaf net also changes the answer, because a net lets water through and does not hold a puddle in the center. A pillow is also the wrong tool if the pool is being drained and stored for the winter. In those cases, skip the pillow, spend the closing effort on the cover, the water level, and the plumbing, and save the pillow for a pool that freezes with a solid cover over it.

Questions pool owners ask about winter closing pillows

Pool owners ask the same questions every closing season, and most of them come down to whether a pillow will keep the pool safe, how long it will last, and whether it can be used again. The answers below stay with what makers publish, and they do not promise that a pillow will prevent damage.

Do the best rsted pool pillows for above ground pool winter closur stop ice from damaging pool walls?

No maker in this group publishes a measured reduction in wall damage, and this guide gives no such number. Makers describe their pillows as ice compensators or ice equalizers that absorb pressure from freezing and expanding water, and that language describes the intended job, not a measured result.

The protection that matters most at closing is the water level, the cover fit, and the plumbing, because those are the parts that carry the load when ice forms. A pillow is one part of that routine, and it helps by giving ice somewhere to press and by raising the cover so water runs off, but it does not replace lowering the water, securing the cover, and winterizing the lines. Treat the pillow as a helper, not as a guarantee, and check the cover after the first hard freeze to see that the pillow is still holding air.

Can a pool pillow be reused in a later winter?

Some pool pillows can be reused, and some cannot, and the difference is usually in the material, the valve, and how the pillow was handled. Yankee states that its pillow was built to be reused in later years, while its manual also states that regular pool pillows last for one season only, which is a useful contrast.

Reuse depends on inspection in the spring. Deflate the pillow fully, wash off dirt and pool chemicals with fresh water, let it dry completely, and check the seams, the valve, and the grommets for tears or cracks before folding it for storage. Store it in a cool, dry place away from sharp objects and sunlight, and do not fold it tightly along the same crease every year. If the pillow lost air mid-winter, check the valve first, because a valve that leaked once is likely to leak again, and a pillow with a torn seam should be replaced.

How many pool pillows does a closing need?

Most above ground pools need one or two pillows, and the number depends on the pool size and shape rather than on a fixed rule. A small round pool up to 15 feet across needs one 4 by 4 foot pillow, and a mid-size round pool from 18 to 24 feet across needs one 4 by 8 foot pillow or two 4 by 4 foot pillows.

The rule of covering about 10 percent of the water surface gives a check on those bands. Measure the pool, work out the surface area, and take 10 percent of it as the pillow area to aim for. More pillows are not always better, because each extra pillow adds rope, handling, and another valve that can leak. One pillow that matches the sizing guide, inflated partway and tied loosely in the center, is the right start for most closings.

Conclusion

A pool pillow earns its place at winter closing when its size matches the pool, its material and valve are stated by the maker, and it is inflated partway, centered, and tied loosely under a solid cover. POOLHACKER leads for small round pools, In The Swim leads for mid-size pools, and GOOX leads for large pools.

A
admin88
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.