Updated Nov 16, 2026· 14 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare refillable propane tanks for grills on capacity, valve, material and weight, from a 1 pound refillable cylinder to a 40 pound aluminum tank, specs only.

Propane itself is a commodity, so the lasting money decision is the cylinder you own and refill. This guide compares six refillable tanks behind the best prices for propane gas for grills on capacity, valve, material, dimensions, and weight, from the standard 20 pound grill tank to a refillable 1 pound cylinder for portable grills.

Quick verdict

The standard 20 pound steel tank with an OPD valve is the default grill cylinder for a reason. Add the built-in gauge version if running dry mid-cook is your frustration, choose aluminum to cut lifting weight or beat corrosion, step up to 40 pounds to halve refill trips, and keep the refillable 1 pound cylinder for portable grills.

All six tanks share the ownership pattern: buy a certified cylinder once, refill it for years, and let capacity, material, and the gauge decide the rest. The entries below give the full specification for each one, including the two dimensions that most often surprise buyers, the aluminum tank’s extra height and the 40 pound tank’s cabinet problem.

Product Capacity Material Weight Standout
Flame King 20 lb with OPD 5 gallons Steel 17 lb The standard grill tank
Flame King 20 lb with OPD and Gauge 5 gallons Steel 17 lb Built-in fuel gauge
Flame King 20 lb Aluminum with OPD and Gauge 5 gallons Aluminum 13 lb Lightest 20 lb carry
Flame King 40 lb Aluminum with OPD 10 gallons Aluminum 20 lb Double capacity
Flame King 20 lb Horizontal with Valve and Gauge 5 gallons Steel 20 lb Low-profile fit
Flame King Refillable 1 lb Cylinder 1 lb Steel 1.9 lb Refills at home

How we selected

Selection started with the manufacturer’s own product pages, because a cylinder is a specification product: capacity, valve type, material, dimensions, and empty weight decide whether it fits your grill cabinet and your refill routine. Every tank here is refillable, currently listed by its maker, and sized for grill or portable-grill use.

One maker dominates this set, and that is honest rather than lazy: Flame King publishes full specifications for a complete refillable range, from its 1 pound cylinder to its 40 pound aluminum tank, which makes a like-for-like comparison possible. Where the maker’s pages state a fact, such as the 80 percent fill limit, it is used; where they do not, nothing is assumed. Weights in this guide are the maker’s listed empty weights, the figure that decides the lift at the fill station.

Because this is a prices keyword, one boundary matters: tank and propane prices move by region and by week, so this guide compares the durable specifications that decide what you pay over years of refills, and leaves the day’s numbers to the listing you buy from. The comparison below is specifications only, by design.

Six tanks behind prices for propane gas for grills in detail

Four of the six share the same maker and the same testing: every Flame King cylinder on this page is x-ray and hydrostatic tested, arrives empty and pre-purged, and carries DOT certification. The real differences are capacity, material, height, and whether a gauge is built in, and those four differences are what the entries below weigh.

Flame King 20 lb Propane Tank with OPD

This is the standard grill cylinder: the maker lists a capacity of 5 gallons, an empty weight of 17 pounds, and dimensions of 12 x 12 x 17.8 inches. It is built from high-grade welded steel with a powder-coated finish, and it arrives empty and pre-purged, so the first fill needs no separate purging step or fee at the fill station.

The valve is a premium OPD assembly, the overfill prevention device that refill stations require on a tank this size. The maker states the tank is DOT-compliant and x-ray and hydrostatic tested. For a grill cabinet, the 17.8 inch height is the fit number to check, because it is the standard the cabinet was probably designed around.

There is no gauge, so judging the remaining fuel means lifting, weighing, or keeping a spare. That is the only real gap in an otherwise complete specification, and it is exactly the gap the next model fills. If your grill lives at home and refills are a short trip, this is the cylinder the whole category is priced against.

  • Pros: standard size and height, pre-purged, OPD valve fitted
  • Cons: no fuel gauge, steel weight to lift when full
  • Buy if: you want the default grill tank every station fills
  • Skip if: running out mid-cook is your recurring problem

Flame King 20 lb Propane Tank with OPD and Gauge

The gauge version shares the steel specification sheet with the standard tank: 5 gallons of capacity, 17 pounds empty, and dimensions of 12 x 12 x 17.8 inches, in high-grade welded steel with a powder-coated finish. The maker lists the same x-ray and hydrostatic testing and the same pre-purged, ready-to-fill delivery.

The difference is the built-in gauge. The maker’s documentation explains the mechanism: a float connected to the valve inside the tank carries a magnet, and the magnet moves the dial on the outside, so the reading tracks the liquid level rather than pressure. That makes the gauge a level reading, which is the number a griller actually wants before a long cook.

Everything else matches the standard tank, including the OPD valve and the cabinet-friendly height. The choice between the two is therefore simple: pay the difference once for the gauge, or weigh the tank by hand for its whole service life. For grills without a cabinet scale routine, the gauge earns its place.

  • Pros: true level gauge, same standard dimensions as the base tank
  • Cons: same 17 pound steel carry, gauge is one more part to protect
  • Buy if: you grill often and hate mid-cook surprises
  • Skip if: you already weigh your tank or keep a full spare

Flame King Lightweight 20 lb Aluminum Tank with OPD and Gauge

The aluminum 20 pound tank keeps the 5 gallon capacity and adds the built-in gauge, but the maker lists an empty weight of 13 pounds against the steel tank’s 17. That four pound saving is on the empty tank you carry to the fill station and lift back into the cabinet, which is the lift that happens every single refill.

Aluminum also changes the corrosion story: the maker describes the tank as rust-free and resistant to saltwater corrosion, aimed at marine use as much as grills. It is x-ray and hydrostatic tested and certified by both DOT and TC, per the maker, and it arrives empty and vacuum-purged like the steel models.

One dimension needs attention: the maker lists 12 x 12 x 21.25 inches, so this tank stands about 3.5 inches taller than the steel 20 pound models. Measure your grill cabinet before choosing it, because a tank that does not fit under the doors is a problem no weight saving fixes. Where it fits, it is the easiest 20 pound carry here.

  • Pros: 13 pound empty weight, built-in gauge, no rust
  • Cons: taller than the steel standard, aluminum costs more to buy
  • Buy if: you refill often, carry far, or grill near salt air
  • Skip if: your cabinet height is already tight for a steel tank

Flame King Lightweight 40 lb Aluminum Tank with OPD

The 40 pound aluminum tank doubles capacity to 10 gallons while the maker lists an empty weight of just 20 pounds, lighter than many steel 20 pound tanks are when empty and far lighter than a steel 40. For a heavy griller, doubling capacity halves the refill trips, which is where the long-term saving on any per-trip comparison comes from.

The specification is marine-grade aluminum with an OPD valve, x-ray and hydrostatic tested, and certified by DOT and TC per the maker. The dimensions are the catch: 12 x 12 x 32.5 inches. At nearly 33 inches tall this tank does not go inside a grill cabinet; it stands beside the grill or feeds a built-in setup from a pad or compartment with real height.

Judge it as infrastructure rather than as a grill accessory. A household that grills weekly, runs a patio heater from the same supply, or hates the refill run will feel the benefit every month. A casual griller will simply own a tall tank that is full for a very long time.

  • Pros: 10 gallons at 20 pounds empty, half the refill trips
  • Cons: 32.5 inches tall, no built-in gauge on this model
  • Buy if: you grill weekly and can stand it beside the grill
  • Skip if: the tank must live inside a standard grill cabinet

Flame King 20 lb Horizontal Propane Cylinder with Valve and Gauge

The horizontal tank solves a shape problem: it holds the same 5 gallons (20 pounds of propane, per the maker) lying down, with dimensions listed as 17 x 13 x 12. It is built for low-clearance spaces, from camper compartments to outdoor kitchen cabinets where a vertical 20 pound tank is simply too tall to stand.

The specification includes a Type 1 OPD valve and an integrated fuel gauge, an EZ-Handle collar for carrying, and a stable base so the cylinder sits securely on its side. The body is high-grade welded steel with a durabond powder coat, x-ray and hydrostatic tested, and DOT and TC approved per the maker, arriving pre-purged and ready to fill.

The maker lists the weight at 20 pounds, heavier than the vertical steel tank, which is the trade for the shape and the gauge. The maker’s transport guidance also singles horizontal tanks out as the exception to its upright-transport rule. If your space is short rather than narrow, this is the 20 pound answer, and for an outdoor kitchen with a low cabinet it is often the only full-size option that fits at all.

  • Pros: fits low spaces, integrated gauge, stable base
  • Cons: 20 pounds empty, made for horizontal mounting only
  • Buy if: your compartment or cabinet cannot stand a vertical tank
  • Skip if: a standard vertical tank already fits your space

Flame King Refillable 1 lb Propane Cylinder

Portable grills run on 1 pound cylinders, and this is the refillable one: the maker lists a weight of 1.9 pounds and dimensions of 3.75 x 3.75 x 8.25 inches, in high-grade steel with a powder-coated exterior. It is DOT-certified for refilling and transport, with a UL1769-listed valve, per the maker.

The economics are the point of the product. Instead of buying disposable cylinders repeatedly, this one refills at home from a standard 20 pound tank using the maker’s refill adapter or kit, sold separately. The box includes the empty cylinder, a protective cap, and a 2 mm Allen key. The maker’s FAQ puts the empty cylinder at about 1.6 pounds and a filled one at 2.3 to 2.5 pounds at the 80 percent fill limit.

Two limits from the maker’s own documentation matter: the refill adapter is designed to be used only with a standard 20 pound tank, and larger tanks must be filled by a licensed refill station. Within those rules, a pair of these cylinders plus the home 20 pound tank covers a portable grill indefinitely.

  • Pros: refills at home, replaces disposable cylinders, certified for refill
  • Cons: adapter or kit sold separately, small capacity by design
  • Buy if: your portable grill eats disposable cylinders
  • Skip if: your grill already runs on a 20 pound tank and hose

Prices for propane gas for grills compared by capacity and material

Read across the six, two patterns decide long-term cost. Capacity decides how often you pay the refill trip, and material decides what the tank itself costs and how it ages. Steel is the standard the category is priced against; aluminum charges more up front and gives back weight and corrosion resistance on every refill after.

Tank Capacity Empty weight Height Gauge Valve
20 lb steel OPD 5 gal 17 lb 17.8 in No OPD
20 lb steel OPD and Gauge 5 gal 17 lb 17.8 in Yes OPD
20 lb aluminum OPD and Gauge 5 gal 13 lb 21.25 in Yes OPD
40 lb aluminum OPD 10 gal 20 lb 32.5 in No OPD
20 lb horizontal 5 gal 20 lb 12 in lying down Yes Type 1 OPD
Refillable 1 lb 1 lb 1.9 lb listed 8.25 in No UL1769 listed

What actually drives the total you pay

Beyond the tank’s shelf price, four facts shape what propane costs you over its life: how full a fill really is, whether the tank arrives purged, how long its certification runs, and whether you can see the level. Each is stated on the maker’s pages for these tanks, and each is worth more than a small gap in the day’s per-gallon number.

The 80 percent fill and the OPD

The maker’s FAQ states that tanks fill to about 80 percent of capacity, leaving room for the gas to expand with temperature. A 5 gallon tank therefore takes about 4 gallons at a proper fill, and comparing refill prices without that fact misleads anywhere.

The OPD is the backstop: the maker notes it is a secondary measure, and that filling is done by weight or by the bleeder screw, not by filling until the OPD stops the flow.

Pre-purged delivery and certification life

Every tank here arrives empty and pre-purged, which removes the purge fee a new unpurged cylinder can attract at its first fill. The longer saving is certification: the maker states DOT cylinders require re-certification after 12 years from the manufacture date, and its FAQ gives a 10 to 12 year window.

The date is stamped on the collar or foot of the tank as the month, the letter A, and the year, so a used tank’s remaining life is readable before you pay for it.

Gauges, spares, and the exchange question

Three of the six tanks carry a built-in gauge, and the gauge changes spending behavior: a level you can read ends both the emergency exchange run and the habit of exchanging a half-full tank. It also ends the guesswork of lifting a steel tank to judge what is left by feel.

Exchanging also swaps your owned cylinder for a stranger’s, with an unknown date stamp. Owning a tank with years of certification left, and refilling it, is the pattern these six products are built around.

A spare tank changes the math

The simplest refill pattern in this guide uses two tanks: one on the grill and one full in reserve under cover. When the working tank empties, the spare goes on and the empty goes for a refill on a normal trip, so the emergency exchange run never happens.

The maker’s range supports the pattern directly, because the same 20 pound tank that feeds the grill also feeds the refill adapter for the 1 pound cylinders. A spare also protects the certification you paid for. An exchange hands back a cylinder of unknown age, while a refill keeps your stamped date and your known valve. Over a 10 to 12 year certification window, that difference is the whole ownership argument, and it costs nothing beyond the second tank itself. It also spreads the lifting: a full spare waits by the grill instead of riding in the car on a special trip.

Buying checklist

Before buying any cylinder, measure the space it must live in, height first, then check the valve and the date logic on the listing. Confirm the tank is refillable and DOT certified, that it arrives pre-purged, and that your grill’s connector matches the valve type. For a used tank, read the stamped manufacture date before anything else.

  • Measure cabinet or compartment height against the tank’s listed height
  • Choose capacity by refill tolerance: 5 gallons standard, 10 for fewer trips
  • Pick steel for the standard fit, aluminum for weight or salt air
  • Take the gauge version if you will not weigh the tank
  • Confirm pre-purged delivery so the first fill carries no purge step
  • For portable grills, price the refillable 1 pound cylinder plus its adapter

Common mistakes

The commonest mistake is comparing refill prices per gallon while ignoring the 80 percent fill, which makes a low fill smaller than it looks. The second is buying the tall aluminum 20 pound tank for a cabinet measured for the steel one. The third is exchanging an owned tank with years of certification left and getting an older one back.

A handling mistake matters too: the maker’s guidance is that these cylinders are vapor draw and cannot be mounted upside down, and that vertical tanks travel upright, with horizontal tanks the stated exception. Storage follows the same documentation: a well-ventilated covered area, and never indoors. Treat the tank as the maker specifies and the specification you paid for is the one you keep.

Frequently asked questions

Short answers on capacity, gauges, certification, and the refillable small cylinder, drawn from the maker specifications above. If you are choosing between owning and exchanging, or between steel and aluminum, the answers below cover the facts that actually change the total you pay over the tank’s working life.

How much propane does a 20 pound tank really hold?

The maker lists the 20 pound cylinders at 5 gallons of capacity, and its FAQ states tanks fill to about 80 percent, so a proper fill is about 4 gallons. The 20 pound name refers to the propane weight class, not the tank’s weight: the steel tank itself weighs 17 pounds empty, and the aluminum one 13 pounds, per the maker’s specification lists.

Is owning a tank better than exchanging?

Owning lets you refill the same certified cylinder for years and read its date stamp yourself. The maker’s range is built for that pattern: pre-purged delivery, OPD valves refill stations accept, and a 10 to 12 year certification window. Exchanging trades that known cylinder for an unknown one, which is why owners value the gauge and a spare.

Does the built-in gauge read pressure or level?

Level, per the maker’s documentation. A float inside the tank is connected to the valve and carries a magnet, and the magnet moves the dial on the outside of the tank. Because the float rides on the liquid, the dial tracks how much propane remains rather than the pressure in the headspace, which is the more useful reading before a long cook.

Can the 1 pound cylinder really be refilled at home?

Yes, within the maker’s stated rules. The cylinder is DOT-certified for refilling and transport, and it refills from a standard 20 pound tank with the maker’s refill adapter or kit, sold separately. The maker is explicit that the adapter is designed only for a standard 20 pound tank, and that larger tanks go to a licensed refill station instead.

Conclusion

Start with the standard: the 20 pound steel OPD tank, or its gauge version if you grill often. Choose the aluminum 20 pound for the lighter carry where its extra height fits, the 40 pound aluminum to halve refill trips, the horizontal tank for low spaces, and the refillable 1 pound cylinder to end disposable-cylinder spending for good.

A
admin88
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.